|
I kind of always scum read TW until he makes a "this reads post is so off that it must be town" post that he did earlier in the game.
But yea, he could still be mafia.
The only people playing this game are me, disformation, chez, vivax, ruX, and btdt sometimes. It's really frustrating and not that fun, regardless of my alignment. I thought there was gonna be a ton of activity, but this game is more dead at 17 alive than a 13 person D1 mini lol
|
Palmar is wildcardy but I can see him as town more easily than rayn even. I can see why he plays with that attitude at least. I've read rayn's big post but it lacks direction. Hope that he posts more and adresses my old issue with his read on Palmar that he hasn't picked up on yet.
BTDT I actually still think is town cause of his actions around Koshi D1. They felt pushy and townie and he was on a wavelength with a bunch of other townies on Koshi. Also the dick posts earn him some town points imo. I really don't think he's mafia right now.
If I ignore ruxxar I'm currently operating under Grack/ES/VA/rayn mafia.
|
VA almost solely cause he came out of the blue with the fefe case on someone I'm very confident to be town and laid out reasons for, and rayn cause he lacks townie aggression almost entirely.
Person I didn't read much into lately is ES but I still kind of think mafia from D1 stuff.
|
On June 19 2017 23:34 Vivax wrote: Palmar is wildcardy but I can see him as town more easily than rayn even. I can see why he plays with that attitude at least. I've read rayn's big post but it lacks direction. Hope that he posts more and adresses my old issue with his read on Palmar that he hasn't picked up on yet.
BTDT I actually still think is town cause of his actions around Koshi D1. They felt pushy and townie and he was on a wavelength with a bunch of other townies on Koshi. Also the dick posts earn him some town points imo. I really don't think he's mafia right now.
If I ignore ruxxar I'm currently operating under Grack/ES/VA/rayn mafia. Can you explain the VA read?
|
I see. I don't think I agree with that kind of reasoning.
|
On June 19 2017 23:35 Vivax wrote: VA almost solely cause he came out of the blue with the fefe case on someone I'm very confident to be town and laid out reasons for, and rayn cause he lacks townie aggression almost entirely.
Person I didn't read much into lately is ES but I still kind of think mafia from D1 stuff.
So you don't think there's anything weird about how FF did that bait thing that disformation pointed out? What's the town agenda behind that?
|
On June 19 2017 23:36 Chezitwo wrote:Show nested quote +On June 19 2017 23:34 Vivax wrote: Palmar is wildcardy but I can see him as town more easily than rayn even. I can see why he plays with that attitude at least. I've read rayn's big post but it lacks direction. Hope that he posts more and adresses my old issue with his read on Palmar that he hasn't picked up on yet.
BTDT I actually still think is town cause of his actions around Koshi D1. They felt pushy and townie and he was on a wavelength with a bunch of other townies on Koshi. Also the dick posts earn him some town points imo. I really don't think he's mafia right now.
If I ignore ruxxar I'm currently operating under Grack/ES/VA/rayn mafia. Can you explain the VA read?
With the little in his filter it's these two reasons atm:
- he pinged ES post as scummiest in the thread D1 among the first and did nothing with it, not even explained why. - His case on FF came across as opportunistic when ppl were calling Rels/Grack/ES mafiaish at the time, IIRC. Grossly from memory but at the time it felt out of place and on the wrong person on top of it.
|
Chezi what's your opinion on the other guys I mentioend?
|
Yes, rayn is extremely worrying to me at this point. He's promised to start playing ~3 times and only does these huge reads posts
|
On June 19 2017 23:39 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On June 19 2017 23:36 Chezitwo wrote:On June 19 2017 23:34 Vivax wrote: Palmar is wildcardy but I can see him as town more easily than rayn even. I can see why he plays with that attitude at least. I've read rayn's big post but it lacks direction. Hope that he posts more and adresses my old issue with his read on Palmar that he hasn't picked up on yet.
BTDT I actually still think is town cause of his actions around Koshi D1. They felt pushy and townie and he was on a wavelength with a bunch of other townies on Koshi. Also the dick posts earn him some town points imo. I really don't think he's mafia right now.
If I ignore ruxxar I'm currently operating under Grack/ES/VA/rayn mafia. Can you explain the VA read? With the little in his filter it's these two reasons atm: - he pinged ES post as scummiest in the thread D1 among the first and did nothing with it, not even explained why. - His case on FF came across as opportunistic when ppl were calling Rels/Grack/ES mafiaish at the time, IIRC. Grossly from memory but at the time it felt out of place and on the wrong person on top of it. Ok, when you put it this way your second point is not that bad providing FF is actually town. The first point seems like standard town!VA to me.
|
On June 19 2017 23:40 Vivax wrote: Chezi what's your opinion on the other guys I mentioend? The other 3 can easily be mafia in my opinion.
|
It's just that there are so many people who can easily be mafia. Besides TW BH also comes to mind with his unnecessary Xata push and btdt bashing yesterday.
|
I believe at this point mafia has big difficulties just coming into the thread and trying to push townies without feeling like they're looking awful.
I predict an easy game
There's just to hope that it will remain this way after the NKs. But I volunteer to carry on your legacies if I'm not the kill.
My legacy if I die is
- lynch grack and ES, grack first if possible. - never lynch FF - consider that Rels can be town - force SL to play more - keep an eye on ruxxar if he keeps on surviving while he keeps posting as much as he did D2. I still kind of respect annuls D1 read on him along with my points. - And last but not least, never forget what happened in previous days or D1 for that matter when previously lurky people start to try and look more active as the game progresses.
I'm being pretty ballsy here but I think Skynx and TW are town. Skynx had good D1 and his list of 5 people for postgame cred is so wrong that I think he can't be mafia.
Sl/ruxxar/tw/btdt/HF for postgame cred
Same for TW who as mafia is prone to the mistake of trying to be too right in his reads and ends up posting correct reads on most people . When he doesn't care too much about being in sync with rest of town and openly looks bad in his voting patterns, he's probably town..
|
has anyone ever actually gotten postgame cred for putting a bunch of random names in a post? I don't understand why thats such a common thing.
oh man remember when that guy threw out a bunch of random names in the middle of the game? -snip- look at this fucking sick post bro
never happens.
|
unless the person quotes their own post, I do see that a lot
|
On my way home from work, so I'll get some more thoughts out later, but just to leave you with my preferred lynch order:
Grack. Rels. Maybe ES.
It's just super obvious to lynch people on the town train before people on the scum train.
If you try to convince me or town that there was only 1 mafia on the annul train I'll be nominating you for the Darwin Award.
|
On June 20 2017 00:06 ruXxar wrote: On my way home from work, so I'll get some more thoughts out later, but just to leave you with my preferred lynch order:
Grack. Rels. Maybe ES.
It's just super obvious to lynch people on the town train before people on the scum train.
If you try to convince me or town that there was only 1 mafia on the annul train I'll be nominating you for the Darwin Award.
you or town?
fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck
|
On June 20 2017 00:08 darthfoley wrote:Show nested quote +On June 20 2017 00:06 ruXxar wrote: On my way home from work, so I'll get some more thoughts out later, but just to leave you with my preferred lynch order:
Grack. Rels. Maybe ES.
It's just super obvious to lynch people on the town train before people on the scum train.
If you try to convince me or town that there was only 1 mafia on the annul train I'll be nominating you for the Darwin Award. you or town? fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck
Is this the part where I post the baby seals?
|
A simple "I concede :/" will suffice
|
On June 20 2017 00:01 VayneAuthority wrote: has anyone ever actually gotten postgame cred for putting a bunch of random names in a post? I don't understand why thats such a common thing.
oh man remember when that guy threw out a bunch of random names in the middle of the game? -snip- look at this fucking sick post bro
never happens.
Sometimes people get postgame cred, sometimes they get townreads for their reads being too wrong to come from mafia
|
|
|
|