EPT[M][N]A Wonderful Normal Game of Mafia - Page 12
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Tubesock
United States2726 Posts
| ||
|
RiceyKins
Canada106 Posts
I'm null on Marv and JAT as well although the way they both entered the game bothers me. It seemed rehearsed and the timing was too good. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
Do you really think if I was mafia with marv we would make such a stupid and completely unnecessary play? Why? I never lie about rl stuff regardless of my alignment. I think I agree that thrawn looks the worst from the list I gave based on solely on the fact that Mig didn't post at all while he was clearly around at some point. But saying "slam did more" is like saying homeopathic medicine does more than placebo pills. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
|
RiceyKins
Canada106 Posts
And yeah I think it looks rehearsed. 18 hours into the game where neither of you have shown up "Oh man JAT hasn't posted yet he must be sick!" 5 minutes later "Ha Ha oh Marv I just came back from the doctor cause I'm sick". If you don't think that's some oddly good timing and an insane coincidence idk Considering there's almost nothing else to mention about the two of you to this point yeah its suspect. You also don't have to be lying about coming back from the doctor, it's very possible Marv knew and just waited for you to be around to put on a show. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
On May 04 2016 09:12 Tubesock wrote: Slam the man: 3 people saw your trap and mentioned something showing they understood it. Does this bother you? Are you goign to follow up on this? Nah. It didn't actually do anything as it was largely ignored since it was always only half serious to begin with. Glad there are fewer postings this game. Not gonna ruin it any further with my usual behaviour behavior. Welcome the Saitama. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
| ||
|
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On May 04 2016 14:45 RiceyKins wrote: Mig hasn't said a word since the game started where Dr.P has said one thing and hasn't come back. If the discussion is about which inactive player we believe should be lynched I'll go with Dr.P because he's clearly been here and made a decision not to continue but Mig is a ? and I can deal with waiting to see. It's not a great situation either way but if we're picking between the two I'd lynch Dr.P. And yeah I think it looks rehearsed. 18 hours into the game where neither of you have shown up "Oh man JAT hasn't posted yet he must be sick!" 5 minutes later "Ha Ha oh Marv I just came back from the doctor cause I'm sick". If you don't think that's some oddly good timing and an insane coincidence idk Considering there's almost nothing else to mention about the two of you to this point yeah its suspect. You also don't have to be lying about coming back from the doctor, it's very possible Marv knew and just waited for you to be around to put on a show. Why? Why on earth would we put on a show like that? It doesn't make any sense. What does a supposed mafia team of marv and me gain from doing that? Explain this to me. Of course it is an insane coincidence. That's why I found it so funny. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On May 04 2016 14:52 Alakaslam wrote: Nah. It didn't actually do anything as it was largely ignored since it was always only half serious to begin with. Glad there are fewer postings this game. Not gonna ruin it any further with my usual behaviour behavior. Welcome the Saitama. I would gladly welcome the saitama. Didn't the saitama post quite a bit though? | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
On May 04 2016 13:44 Etellex wrote: I'm familiar with casualized forms of Mafia like Town of Salem where there's a lot less reading into what people say and more logic/evidence. I've been quiet because I'm at a loss for what to go off of for suspicion. I can understand and empathize with this. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
On May 04 2016 13:54 Tubesock wrote: Well...guess you better start reading some of the guides that are stickied on this very forum. ... That are also largely wifom now  But they say that too so hey. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
On May 04 2016 14:02 Tubesock wrote: I'd be down for Mig although he's on track for being mod killed. Dr Thrawn would be my pick of the 4 you listed. I don't think he was buddying Kush at all, but he did not produce any content and had a great chance to and it would have been pretty easy to do. Slam only because an obsolete metric I used was how much effort he placed in his fishing expeditions. When he was town he would fish till he got something. As mafia he well gave a couple casts and gave up. Kinda like here. But this is a year old at least and he constantly changes his play. Soooo....yeah. Etellex...I don't even know. Well, we will see. | ||
|
RiceyKins
Canada106 Posts
| ||
|
Tubesock
United States2726 Posts
Do you think anyone is town? It sounded like Saitama was super intense effort. Maybe there is a happy medium somewhere. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
On May 04 2016 14:30 justanothertownie wrote: Rehearsed? lol Do you really think if I was mafia with marv we would make such a stupid and completely unnecessary play? Why? I never lie about rl stuff regardless of my alignment. I think I agree that thrawn looks the worst from the list I gave based on solely on the fact that Mig didn't post at all while he was clearly around at some point. But saying "slam did more" is like saying homeopathic medicine does more than placebo pills. This is epic Bro-fist on the seeing through homeopathic stuff "lemonade will cure your cancer!" Lol. Riiiiiiiight so my cousin's UCLA grad level research in the matter is pointless because lemons. That literally insults her work. Yet it is like my posting, I post half-ass jokes and that gets me a town pass? Isn't half the joke based on the fact that this usually happens? I have set the bar for myself so low that I can cruise through 90% of my games suspicion free. So I find we are a bit too inactive here and will probably need to start voting video people to get them to start talking. Fear of talking is a factor, but when you are already up for lunch you have nothing to lose and start talking. So let's do that. ##Vote: Etellex Get my vote off you sir. Why aren't you just lurking scum? You can't get a read; fine. But nothing at all to say? Scum is a lot scarier then town, sir, so... New or not I am inclined to actually lean scum on you. Prove me wrong. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
On May 04 2016 15:02 Tubesock wrote: Slam do you want anyone lynched? Or do you have a shortlist you'd be ok lynching? Do you think anyone is town? It sounded like Saitama was super intense effort. Maybe there is a happy medium somewhere. I am totally fine with intensity where it is legitimately called for. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
On May 04 2016 14:54 justanothertownie wrote: I would gladly welcome the saitama. Didn't the saitama post quite a bit though? Well, and I am on now. | ||
|
Tubesock
United States2726 Posts
##Vote: Etellex | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17322 Posts
On May 04 2016 15:02 Tubesock wrote: Slam do you want anyone lynched? Or do you have a shortlist you'd be ok lynching? Do you think anyone is town? It sounded like Saitama was super intense effort. Maybe there is a happy medium somewhere. Why make a list with so little info? I don't like lists in this scenario. Why open up ml opportunities for Mafia to plan around? I don't want them knowing my sentiment, and I can contribute in ways that don't inform them while informing the lot of us on specific players. Others can use this sort of contribution for PoE. However I will confirm that Etellex is not the only person I currently suspect. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On May 04 2016 15:00 RiceyKins wrote: It gets way too WIFOM if I try to base everything on that JAT, and as I said you're still Null imo it just didn't look right and it's the only thing that's even worth mentioning about you so far. Although tbh you didn't seem to find it "so funny" either which is also why I found the whole thing kind of odd. It's not even WIFOM. There is 0 reason to assume we would do that as mafia if you think about if even for a split second. Your supposed line of thought is "this is unusual so it is scummy" without critically evaluating if that makes sense or not. | ||
| ||
