On November 03 2014 08:10 kushm4sta wrote:
ok i actually read the op. this setup is broken.
non doctor role should claim. then doctor role will just protect the non doctor as he checks everyone.

This from the only decent player to sign up man are we in trouble.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 02 2014 23:21 GMT

#174

On November 03 2014 08:19 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

Show nested quote +

Did you just call kush a decent player?

Was referring to his pre game list in which he refers to himself as a decent player.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 00:12 GMT

#183

On November 03 2014 09:11 KelsierSC wrote:
Ff is my first town.. Firstly explaining to sentinal about the bh being rng king. And secondly he went back and checked the possible set ups after kush made his pronouncement then he asked kush to explain himself. That is a guy putting in the effort to catch scum.

How does either of the two things you said he did help towards catching scum?

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 00:19 GMT

#185

Are you saying mafia doesn't put in any effort?

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 00:56 GMT

#194

On November 03 2014 09:47 KelsierSC wrote:
Bats you know he has about 4 posts and 2 of them are pregame nonsense

Compared to ff who you have a town read on for two posts both of which i wouldn't consider to be alignment indicative.

Im not trying to be that serious but my last 2 games i seem to just sheep all of day one and i want to change that.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 01:09 GMT

#208

On November 03 2014 09:57 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

Show nested quote +

Who do you see as at least somewhat town/scum right now and why?

I have Gack as leaning town for this post here.

On November 03 2014 08:54 Grackaroni wrote:
Now, let's talk Kush. What's your leaning? Devious scummer or incompetent townie?
The answer incompetent mafia could also be acceptable.

He seems to be trying to lead the conversation away from the initial joking/trolling phase into serious discussion which i see as townie.

Also i have you has also lean town because i don't think mafia makes that post about having 1 from the newbie pile and two from the veteran pile. I don't think mafia would make this post as you would know your team setup and it would be weird for you to come up with that as mafia. This is a weak read.

Don't have much else at the moment.

Also im confused why everyone is jumping on batsnacks but not kelsier? Do people agree with kelsiers read on ff? How is explaining game mechanics hunting scum? How is pushing kush for not getting the setup right hunting scum when if he is mafia he is given the setup?

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 01:21 GMT

#211

On November 03 2014 10:16 KelsierSC wrote:

Show nested quote +

point is if ff was mafia he could just say "look kysh id trying to get roles out omfg" instead he went back to the op, looked at the setups and was like "a logical inconsistency, mafia make logical inconsistincies, kush your story doesn't make sense, explain" to me that is incredibly town.

also his question to hs was also excellent,

So what do you think of kush then? Do you think he is mafia for his "logical inconsistency". Also when he comes back to the thread and just says he read the OP wrong what then?

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 01:22 GMT

#213

No i don't actually have a scum read on you at the moment but i don't see why people are jumping on batsnacks for calling me town without much reason when i think you have done the same with ff.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 01:28 GMT

#218

Kelsier here is where im confused about your logic. If you are unsure about kushes alignment why isn't it possible that ff is mafia trying to make kush look bad for a mistake he has made as town. Town makes mistakes, they are more likely to do so they don't have perfect information. This is why i don't think ff's question makes him townbecause he could easily be mafia trying to make a town kush look bad.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 01:50 GMT

#228

FF do you have any town/scum at the moment

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 01:52 GMT

#229

On November 03 2014 10:49 batsnacks wrote:
It's not a trap, I'm voting Superbia because I think he is the scummiest player and deserves to be voted.

(So do you)

Show nested quote +

Even if it is a trap people who fall for bat traps are usually town.

I disagree but i want to see what superbia brings to the table before i say why if that makes sense.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 01:57 GMT

#232

yeah explain the super read because im reading him town at the moment

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 02:12 GMT

#244

So superbia has been in both of my two games on TL and in both he has been sure of his reads and willing to push lynches day 1. Given the second game he was bulletproof so he could be fearless that opening statement from him is on par with what I expect from him. I havn't seen a game where he is mafia though so i don't know what he is like as mafia.

Although i agree deliberately tunneling someone is anti town but im intrested to see how serious he is about it.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 02:14 GMT

#245

Kelsier what about his very last game in which he pushed the day 1 lynch i would consider that a tunnel but im not sure of the exact definition.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 02:26 GMT

#256

Lightningstrike what's your thoughts on people in the thread who is your town/mafia?

Batsnacks do you agree with kelsier that superbia has to bleed town not to be lynched today?

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

November 03 2014 02:27 GMT

#258

Also don't edit your posts its against the rules just fyi just make another post correcting yourself.