|
On August 11 2013 02:54 monk wrote:Show nested quote +On August 11 2013 02:52 BronzeKnee wrote:On August 11 2013 02:39 monk wrote:On August 10 2013 23:01 BronzeKnee wrote:A lot of you owe Maru an apology. He became #1 when he defeated Innovation and had a solid July. He defended it when he defeated the #2. There is no doubt who the best play SC2 player on the planet is.
It is Maru, the man who just won the most difficult individual tournament in the world. At tournament which both Innovation and Rain played in! And he defeated them both, the Power Rank #1 and #2 on his way to victory!On August 10 2013 20:06 Fionn wrote: thing is none of these regional finals matter cause we're just going to use the seasonal finals to determine who goes where.
watch innovation just 4-0 in the finals again. No bias from the TL writers huh? Honestly, you guys shouldn't do a Power Rank with this kind of bias. You can't possibly be unbiased when you're already calling the score of the finals 4-0 in favor of Innovation, and telling us that Maru's achievement don't matter. This is why that WCG qualifier performance and a few best of one wins in Proleague for Innovation overcame Maru's stomp into the OSL Finals over Symbol and a 4-0 Innovation huh? Just go ahead his discount his achievements... Why slap Maru in the face like that? lol, way to completely misinterpret Fionn's post in so so many ways. How is that Power Rank doing Monk? pretty good, thanks ^^
I know it doesn't predict, unless you're trying to justify Innovation:
On July 04 2013 04:47 TeamLiquid ESPORTS wrote: Think of it this way: you have to bet your life on either Soulkey or Innovation in a bo1 against an arbitrary player. Who would you choose?
But man...
|
East Gorteau22261 Posts
I would like to summarise this thread
On August 09 2013 03:36 Zealously wrote: This power rank is bad because my subjective critera is better than your subjective critera
|
On August 11 2013 03:35 BronzeKnee wrote:Show nested quote +On August 11 2013 02:54 monk wrote:On August 11 2013 02:52 BronzeKnee wrote:On August 11 2013 02:39 monk wrote:On August 10 2013 23:01 BronzeKnee wrote:A lot of you owe Maru an apology. He became #1 when he defeated Innovation and had a solid July. He defended it when he defeated the #2. There is no doubt who the best play SC2 player on the planet is.
It is Maru, the man who just won the most difficult individual tournament in the world. At tournament which both Innovation and Rain played in! And he defeated them both, the Power Rank #1 and #2 on his way to victory!On August 10 2013 20:06 Fionn wrote: thing is none of these regional finals matter cause we're just going to use the seasonal finals to determine who goes where.
watch innovation just 4-0 in the finals again. No bias from the TL writers huh? Honestly, you guys shouldn't do a Power Rank with this kind of bias. You can't possibly be unbiased when you're already calling the score of the finals 4-0 in favor of Innovation, and telling us that Maru's achievement don't matter. This is why that WCG qualifier performance and a few best of one wins in Proleague for Innovation overcame Maru's stomp into the OSL Finals over Symbol and a 4-0 Innovation huh? Just go ahead his discount his achievements... Why slap Maru in the face like that? lol, way to completely misinterpret Fionn's post in so so many ways. How is that Power Rank doing Monk? pretty good, thanks ^^ I know it doesn't predict, unless you're trying to justify Innovation: Show nested quote +On July 04 2013 04:47 TeamLiquid ESPORTS wrote: Think of it this way: you have to bet your life on either Soulkey or Innovation in a bo1 against an arbitrary player. Who would you choose?
But man...
You really need to figure out the difference between prediction and handicapped odds based on past results.
edit: You should totally do your own power rank.
|
I agree that Maru is not the absolute best player on planet the best RTS player ever etc etc, but what really annoys me is that people consider Maru as bad and cheesy scrub.
Even though winning Innovation and Rain does not make him best player on planet it should fucking mean something. Give that boy some credit, for gods sake, he destroyed two of the best player (Also he was really close to beat Soulkey too and his worst matchup is TvZ) This kid is crazy good.
Also this makes me giggle a bit: Game 1 - Rain beats Maru who does not yet have ghosts really and is not ready for warp prism drop. = Rain genius Game 4 - Basically same scenario at same time with same amount of economy etc but maru made some defense at his base and made ghosts bit earlier = Really bad move from Rain he gave that game (((
GG Maru have been hoping for him to win championship for really long time! Also great finals in general
|
On August 11 2013 03:07 vthree wrote:Show nested quote +On August 11 2013 01:17 FuRong wrote: You don't automatically become the #1 player in the world by winning one tournament. Is Maru underappreciated? Yes. But can we definitively say he is the best player in the world right now? I don't think so.
Innovation's results from the last few GSLs:
Semifinals (January GSL) Finals (WCS1) Champion (WCS global finals) Semifinals (WCS2)
That's consistency. On top of that he carried his team to a PL victory and was the second winningest player across the PL season. If Maru can show results like that over his next few tournaments then maybe he does deserve the #1 spot, but it's too early to call at this stage. We need to see what happens at the global finals before making any judgment imo. To be fair, the rankings specifically state that the results within that month matter most. So if Maru does will in globals, he should get the top spot.
yeah this. this ranking is more like a flavor of the month kind of thing rather than a serious attempt to determine the current best player
|
United States15275 Posts
On August 11 2013 10:11 theMagus wrote:Show nested quote +On August 11 2013 03:07 vthree wrote:On August 11 2013 01:17 FuRong wrote: You don't automatically become the #1 player in the world by winning one tournament. Is Maru underappreciated? Yes. But can we definitively say he is the best player in the world right now? I don't think so.
Innovation's results from the last few GSLs:
Semifinals (January GSL) Finals (WCS1) Champion (WCS global finals) Semifinals (WCS2)
That's consistency. On top of that he carried his team to a PL victory and was the second winningest player across the PL season. If Maru can show results like that over his next few tournaments then maybe he does deserve the #1 spot, but it's too early to call at this stage. We need to see what happens at the global finals before making any judgment imo. To be fair, the rankings specifically state that the results within that month matter most. So if Maru does will in globals, he should get the top spot. yeah this. this ranking is more like a flavor of the month kind of thing rather than a serious attempt to determine the current best player data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt=""
Determining the "best player" in this field, where the skill level is so high that absolute dominance is at best streaky and just as dependent on luck as skill, would take so long that the results would be irrelevant by the time they were produced.
Anyway Maru played amazingly and no one can say he did not deserve to win OSL.
|
On August 11 2013 10:24 CosmicSpiral wrote:Show nested quote +On August 11 2013 10:11 theMagus wrote:On August 11 2013 03:07 vthree wrote:On August 11 2013 01:17 FuRong wrote: You don't automatically become the #1 player in the world by winning one tournament. Is Maru underappreciated? Yes. But can we definitively say he is the best player in the world right now? I don't think so.
Innovation's results from the last few GSLs:
Semifinals (January GSL) Finals (WCS1) Champion (WCS global finals) Semifinals (WCS2)
That's consistency. On top of that he carried his team to a PL victory and was the second winningest player across the PL season. If Maru can show results like that over his next few tournaments then maybe he does deserve the #1 spot, but it's too early to call at this stage. We need to see what happens at the global finals before making any judgment imo. To be fair, the rankings specifically state that the results within that month matter most. So if Maru does will in globals, he should get the top spot. yeah this. this ranking is more like a flavor of the month kind of thing rather than a serious attempt to determine the current best player data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Determining the "best player" in this field, where the skill level is so high that absolute dominance is at best streaky and just as dependent on luck as skill, would take so long that the results would be irrelevant by the time they were produced. Anyway Maru played amazingly and no one can say he did not deserve to win OSL.
by best player, i meant in terms of results within reasonably relevant periods. what i was saying was that this is much more focused on a player's achievements within a month, hence flavor of the month. oh and i'm not out to get maru. i happen to think anyone who wins a championship deserves to win it, regardless of who it is data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt=""
|
United States15275 Posts
On August 11 2013 10:39 theMagus wrote:Show nested quote +On August 11 2013 10:24 CosmicSpiral wrote:On August 11 2013 10:11 theMagus wrote:On August 11 2013 03:07 vthree wrote:On August 11 2013 01:17 FuRong wrote: You don't automatically become the #1 player in the world by winning one tournament. Is Maru underappreciated? Yes. But can we definitively say he is the best player in the world right now? I don't think so.
Innovation's results from the last few GSLs:
Semifinals (January GSL) Finals (WCS1) Champion (WCS global finals) Semifinals (WCS2)
That's consistency. On top of that he carried his team to a PL victory and was the second winningest player across the PL season. If Maru can show results like that over his next few tournaments then maybe he does deserve the #1 spot, but it's too early to call at this stage. We need to see what happens at the global finals before making any judgment imo. To be fair, the rankings specifically state that the results within that month matter most. So if Maru does will in globals, he should get the top spot. yeah this. this ranking is more like a flavor of the month kind of thing rather than a serious attempt to determine the current best player data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Determining the "best player" in this field, where the skill level is so high that absolute dominance is at best streaky and just as dependent on luck as skill, would take so long that the results would be irrelevant by the time they were produced. Anyway Maru played amazingly and no one can say he did not deserve to win OSL. by best player, i meant in terms of results within reasonably relevant periods. what i was saying was that this is much more focused on a player's achievements within a month, hence flavor of the month. oh and i'm not out to get maru. i happen to think anyone who wins a championship deserves to win it, regardless of who it is data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt=""
Which brings up all the problems people have with ranking players in the first place: unintentionally avoiding players in brackets, getting their tournament runs cut short against top players, winning games despite playing poorly, losing games despite playing fundamentally well, inflation due to crushing clearly inferior opponents, opportunities to go out to tournaments, arguments over time frames, arguments over viability of play in the long run, arguments over the influence of the metagame instead of 'pure skill', etc.
|
On August 11 2013 10:49 CosmicSpiral wrote:Show nested quote +On August 11 2013 10:39 theMagus wrote:On August 11 2013 10:24 CosmicSpiral wrote:On August 11 2013 10:11 theMagus wrote:On August 11 2013 03:07 vthree wrote:On August 11 2013 01:17 FuRong wrote: You don't automatically become the #1 player in the world by winning one tournament. Is Maru underappreciated? Yes. But can we definitively say he is the best player in the world right now? I don't think so.
Innovation's results from the last few GSLs:
Semifinals (January GSL) Finals (WCS1) Champion (WCS global finals) Semifinals (WCS2)
That's consistency. On top of that he carried his team to a PL victory and was the second winningest player across the PL season. If Maru can show results like that over his next few tournaments then maybe he does deserve the #1 spot, but it's too early to call at this stage. We need to see what happens at the global finals before making any judgment imo. To be fair, the rankings specifically state that the results within that month matter most. So if Maru does will in globals, he should get the top spot. yeah this. this ranking is more like a flavor of the month kind of thing rather than a serious attempt to determine the current best player data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Determining the "best player" in this field, where the skill level is so high that absolute dominance is at best streaky and just as dependent on luck as skill, would take so long that the results would be irrelevant by the time they were produced. Anyway Maru played amazingly and no one can say he did not deserve to win OSL. by best player, i meant in terms of results within reasonably relevant periods. what i was saying was that this is much more focused on a player's achievements within a month, hence flavor of the month. oh and i'm not out to get maru. i happen to think anyone who wins a championship deserves to win it, regardless of who it is data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" Which brings up all the problems people have with ranking players in the first place: unintentionally avoiding players in brackets, getting their tournament runs cut short against top players, winning games despite playing poorly, losing games despite playing fundamentally well, inflation due to crushing clearly inferior opponents, opportunities to go out to tournaments, arguments over time frames, arguments over viability of play in the long run, arguments over the influence of the metagame instead of 'pure skill', etc.
a lot of the variables you mentioned are very subjective and don't belong in an objective list. only actual results are of concern to me. trying to make something objective out of subjective elements, you will surely run into problems
|
|
doesn't seem like a power rank. just feels like best tournament showings in recent days
|
lol. innovation only won 1 championship when hellbat was super op and he was abusing it to death or cheese all the time. I just can't understand people calling him the best in the world. If that logic applies, it is absolutely ok for maru to be the best in the world right now. He beat all the top players alone the way this season and he should be #1 in the world and power rank #1.
If innovation should be considered #1 in the world, he's gotta at least win few championships not just 1 championship with patch terran manner. He's good in tvz I give him that but other than that, he's nothing special but patch terran champ. Need prove? As soon as hellbat nerf came, bomber 3-0 him, maru 4-0 him. Bomber didn't even cheese him and still destroyed innovation. Maru 1 based all in him 3 times in a row but that hardly matters coz innovation couldn't adopt at all. That surely doesn't suit #1 in the world. Innovation's tvt was 100% based on cheese or hellbat drop abuse to mech push and with that gone, his seemingly invincible tvt record was bound to fall(though I bet nobody expected his tvt was that bad without hellbat). Innovation should feel lucky that hellbat nerf came after he made it to round of 4. In wings of liberty, inno wasn't even code S round of 8 material and only reason he won season 1 final was most of his important matchese were tvt where he could abuse hellbat drop and cheese to death. If Innovation still plays solid and win another championship, I will consider him as one of the best in the world but as it is now, he's mere patch terran champ in my book.
So there you go. All you people calling Maru garbage, you should have look at innovation's record first. By people who calling innovation #1 in the world's logic, Maru prime is NEW #1 in the world. He beat the best in the world innovation 4-0, so Maru is the #1. There's no excuse for innovation losing 4 games in a row whether he cheesed or not. His tvt was never impressive from the beginning and with hellbat drop gone, he will never be able to win tvt the way he did up till now. I bet flash, mvp etc will have sweet revenge times against innovation if they ever meet him again.
|
^ it's easy. He is the best in the world, because he lost only 16 out of 69 offline matches in HotS. That makes it 77% winrate. Against Korean only opponents (besides 1 match vs Huk). There is none other, who has such stats.
|
On August 11 2013 18:56 shin_toss wrote: where's Polt This was published the morning of August 8th in America... Meaning this was published before his WCS Ro16 group. If he can get a decent placement at the WCS Season 2 finals he might make the list for September.
|
Just realised there was absolutely no mention of Polt and now he's WCS Americas Champion D= Didn't he also win MLG or something not too long back? I'm guessing the writers and editors missed it.
|
They forgot polt... even before WCS he deserved AT LEAST a mention... he won MLG late june, and wos 2 zotac cups in july beating some good players like mma and hyun that is #8 in this rank. He lost to revival a close series on IEM but that was it.
Polt deserved to be listed in the top10 (i would put him somewhere 6-8), but at least should be mentioned.
|
On August 12 2013 06:18 shin777 wrote:lol. innovation only won 1 championship when hellbat was super op and he was abusing it to death or cheese all the time. I just can't understand people calling him the best in the world. If that logic applies, it is absolutely ok for maru to be the best in the world right now. He beat all the top players alone the way this season and he should be #1 in the world and power rank #1. If innovation should be considered #1 in the world, he's gotta at least win few championships not just 1 championship with patch terran manner. He's good in tvz I give him that but other than that, he's nothing special but patch terran champ. Need prove? As soon as hellbat nerf came, bomber 3-0 him, maru 4-0 him. Bomber didn't even cheese him and still destroyed innovation. Maru 1 based all in him 3 times in a row but that hardly matters coz innovation couldn't adopt at all. That surely doesn't suit #1 in the world. Innovation's tvt was 100% based on cheese or hellbat drop abuse to mech push and with that gone, his seemingly invincible tvt record was bound to fall(though I bet nobody expected his tvt was that bad without hellbat). Innovation should feel lucky that hellbat nerf came after he made it to round of 4. In wings of liberty, inno wasn't even code S round of 8 material and only reason he won season 1 final was most of his important matchese were tvt where he could abuse hellbat drop and cheese to death. If Innovation still plays solid and win another championship, I will consider him as one of the best in the world but as it is now, he's mere patch terran champ in my book. So there you go. All you people calling Maru garbage, you should have look at innovation's record first. By people who calling innovation #1 in the world's logic, Maru prime is NEW #1 in the world. He beat the best in the world innovation 4-0, so Maru is the #1. There's no excuse for innovation losing 4 games in a row whether he cheesed or not. His tvt was never impressive from the beginning and with hellbat drop gone, he will never be able to win tvt the way he did up till now. I bet flash, mvp etc will have sweet revenge times against innovation if they ever meet him again. data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt=""
I'm not an Innovation fan but he would have won the last two GSLs in WoL if ZvT weren't ridiculously Z favored. Have you watched his TvZ in WoL? Without mines and booster his medivac harass still looked fucking insane. And he didn't lose any Bo3 TvT in WoL so I don't know wtf you're talking about.
|
|
United States8476 Posts
Polt didn't do anything in July except lose in IEM. Winning 2 Zotac cups doesn't count.
|
On August 12 2013 06:18 shin777 wrote:lol. innovation only won 1 championship when hellbat was super op and he was abusing it to death or cheese all the time. I just can't understand people calling him the best in the world. If that logic applies, it is absolutely ok for maru to be the best in the world right now. He beat all the top players alone the way this season and he should be #1 in the world and power rank #1. If innovation should be considered #1 in the world, he's gotta at least win few championships not just 1 championship with patch terran manner. He's good in tvz I give him that but other than that, he's nothing special but patch terran champ. Need prove? As soon as hellbat nerf came, bomber 3-0 him, maru 4-0 him. Bomber didn't even cheese him and still destroyed innovation. Maru 1 based all in him 3 times in a row but that hardly matters coz innovation couldn't adopt at all. That surely doesn't suit #1 in the world. Innovation's tvt was 100% based on cheese or hellbat drop abuse to mech push and with that gone, his seemingly invincible tvt record was bound to fall(though I bet nobody expected his tvt was that bad without hellbat). Innovation should feel lucky that hellbat nerf came after he made it to round of 4. In wings of liberty, inno wasn't even code S round of 8 material and only reason he won season 1 final was most of his important matchese were tvt where he could abuse hellbat drop and cheese to death. If Innovation still plays solid and win another championship, I will consider him as one of the best in the world but as it is now, he's mere patch terran champ in my book. So there you go. All you people calling Maru garbage, you should have look at innovation's record first. By people who calling innovation #1 in the world's logic, Maru prime is NEW #1 in the world. He beat the best in the world innovation 4-0, so Maru is the #1. There's no excuse for innovation losing 4 games in a row whether he cheesed or not. His tvt was never impressive from the beginning and with hellbat drop gone, he will never be able to win tvt the way he did up till now. I bet flash, mvp etc will have sweet revenge times against innovation if they ever meet him again. data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt=""
are you serious ? have you ever seen his game against soulkey when soulkey did an early 3 hatch before pool and got away with it ? soulkey played extremely good yet he lost convincingly against innovation .. innovation makes tvz look really broken ..
|
|
|
|