EPTSome good, a lot of nostalgia, watched it till end.
the Pimpest Plays of 2010, 2011 and 2012 - Page 3
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
ejozl
Denmark3372 Posts
Some good, a lot of nostalgia, watched it till end. | ||
|
Pres1990
Poland14 Posts
| ||
|
sAxiS
Canada10 Posts
Still, thanks for the effort in putting these clips together. Next time use your own eye when you're editing clips, sit down and judge whether or not what you're trying to show off is enhanced or distracted by the effects you've chosen. | ||
|
Ravensong170
United States858 Posts
when he did that. you knew Nerchio was just on a different level than younghwa. (at least back then) | ||
|
BretZ
United States1510 Posts
A lot of people are pointing out the darkness filter, which I agree isn't really needed. Music choice, you aren't always going to win and I feel that type of metal fits with the "pimpest plays" theme. The text was kinda meh, but the transitions were pretty good. You can always redo it if you feel the need to | ||
|
MekTypro
France360 Posts
Good job | ||
|
Maltos
Germany6 Posts
About the Dark Templer scene (Nerchio vs YoungHwa): I planed to put this one in too and as you can see its in the replaypack i uploaded, but at the end i totally forgot that game - i could beat myself for that -.- >.< AGAIN: Thanks for all the good and bad feedback, it really helps me alot! | ||
|
renaissanceMAN
United States1840 Posts
| ||
|
MisterTea
United Kingdom1047 Posts
| ||
lookfirewood
1212 Posts
I believe you had more focus on making the video awesome with effects rather than content. Which is missing the point. But dont get me wrong, I am not pooping on your production, I am trying to give you tips for the future! Things to think about next time (because I really hope you keep this up, the idea is awesome, but you need to polish it): 1: Too much material to cover: 3 years is waaaaay to much material to cover in one video, you should have done one for each year at tops. You missed some of the pimpest plays over the years (in my oppinion ofcourse, but I believe may would agree). 2: Keep awesome looking effects where they belong: Some effects (and screen cutouts), even though they are beautiful, it makes it hard to appreciate the pimpness of the plays at almost every occation in the video. Place video effects and unrelated awesomness in between the clips that show pimpness. That way the effects are more lovable and the pimpest plays more lovable. 3: Keep it to the original speed: It's hard to understand what happens when you speed up the gamespeed in a video, and again, it's hard to appreciate the pimpness unless you relive the play at the original speed. 4: Music sync: Who doesn't love music sync! It's awesome! You have done that really well in this video, but again, keep it where it belongs. Do not edit the actual video to match the sound by cutting out important stuff, speeding the clip or slowing the clip. You gotta match it by using longer/shorter clips (where it is possible, so you don't cut out important scenes) or do not audio-sync at all. Priority number one must always be the pimpest play! All this comes from me with good intent and I really hope you can take it constructivly. I love this kind of videos and I really hope you dig deeper into this and perfect your already good skills! best Kim | ||
|
j4vz
Canada976 Posts
that was really epic cant remember who it was, but i think it was prolly 2-3month ago. | ||
|
Maltos
Germany6 Posts
On April 09 2013 03:29 lookfirewood wrote: This is cool. I really love the ambition and the general idea. But the ambition is your downfall though. I believe you had more focus on making the video awesome with effects rather than content. Which is missing the point. But dont get me wrong, I am not pooping on your production, I am trying to give you tips for the future! Things to think about next time (because I really hope you keep this up, the idea is awesome, but you need to polish it): 1: Too much material to cover: 3 years is waaaaay to much material to cover in one video, you should have done one for each year at tops. You missed some of the pimpest plays over the years (in my oppinion ofcourse, but I believe may would agree). 2: Keep awesome looking effects where they belong: Some effects (and screen cutouts), even though they are beautiful, it makes it hard to appreciate the pimpness of the plays at almost every occation in the video. Place video effects and unrelated awesomness in between the clips that show pimpness. That way the effects are more lovable and the pimpest plays more lovable. 3: Keep it to the original speed: It's hard to understand what happens when you speed up the gamespeed in a video, and again, it's hard to appreciate the pimpness unless you relive the play at the original speed. 4: Music sync: Who doesn't love music sync! It's awesome! You have done that really well in this video, but again, keep it where it belongs. Do not edit the actual video to match the sound by cutting out important stuff, speeding the clip or slowing the clip. You gotta match it by using longer/shorter clips (where it is possible, so you don't cut out important scenes) or do not audio-sync at all. Priority number one must always be the pimpest play! All this comes from me with good intent and I really hope you can take it constructivly. I love this kind of videos and I really hope you dig deeper into this and perfect your already good skills! best Kim WoW this is the kind of feedback i love to see :D It will really help me thanks! And to your "hope": Yes i will keep doing it and hopefully will get better in that kind of stuff, posts like yours make me get motivated (because thats all you need) even more :D | ||
|
LeeDawg
United States1306 Posts
| ||
|
triforks
United States370 Posts
edit: but nice video theres not enough of this stuff for sc2 | ||
|
lookfirewood
1212 Posts
On April 09 2013 03:58 Maltos wrote: WoW this is the kind of feedback i love to see :D It will really help me thanks! And to your "hope": Yes i will keep doing it and hopefully will get better in that kind of stuff, posts like yours make me get motivated (because thats all you need) even more :D Glad I could help!  I also forgot to mention cropping. Dont do it! Mini-map is a vital part in understanding what happens in the game, even if there's a crazy ass micro bit that's going on, because questions always arise "is it a base-race? is it 5? 10? or even 25minutes into the game?" etc. best Kim | ||
|
chocopaw
2072 Posts
On April 09 2013 01:10 boxerfred wrote: Go for the dailymotion link. gotta hate gema. All germans need to know about https://proxtube.com/ (Gema has to die!) | ||
|
nface
106 Posts
| ||
|
N.geNuity
United States5112 Posts
You don't see the brood war ones say "good marine control". You don't see soccer (aka football) highlight videos label plays. You don't see NBA basketball best plays label stuff. *edit: this is a little unfair, some of the brood war pimpest plays give names. But try to be a little better than "biggest air battle" or overuse of "epic". A lot of the brood war videos that name stuff go for like "boxer's ninja proxy" or "willpower hold lurkers" or something to that end). basically don't label the play or "huge air battle", just label the game ("X vs Y 2011"). Keep it as simple as possible. The play is supposed to speak for itself stopped watching at idra moment because you can't have pimp plays mixed with silly moments or stupid moments (of which there were ones earlier in the video) I think it's bad to be honest, independent of issues with darkness. Poor selection and against the spirit of pimpest play/highlight videos. | ||
|
Prplppleatr
United States1518 Posts
| ||
|
Hollandrock
United Kingdom158 Posts
| ||
| ||
