I really like the current TSL logo. I think it looks classic and professional.

I like your startale logo, but I don't like the TSL update. Too cartoony, reminds me of Kirby games for some reason. The current Startale and your TSL logo (and gamania) look like they belong in the same league.

Leetley

1796 Posts

January 14 2012 15:30 GMT

#147

ST and Quantic logos are super. Good work!

havox_

Germany442 Posts

January 14 2012 15:36 GMT

#148

Agree, ST and TSL logos are pretty ugly, but yeah, guess thats what they want

Still, tour updates look super nice, think the TSL one is the weakest of the 3, but still 100 times better than the current one (not sure how anybody can say that it looks professional?!?)

ReachTheSky

United States3294 Posts

January 14 2012 15:37 GMT

#149

the startale one is nice, the others seemed to be less appealing to me.

The KY

United Kingdom6252 Posts

January 14 2012 15:40 GMT

#150

On January 14 2012 11:51 shiroiusagi wrote:
I think that new team RS is a new addiction to ugly logos too. :< But TSL is the worst out of the 2. (Btw ever thought of those wings as eyes, cause I sure do :< and it's freaky as heck when I look at their logo every time.)

As for your redos I like the Quantic one a lot. XD

Those aren't eyes?

Well shit.

Greggle

United States1131 Posts

January 14 2012 17:30 GMT

#151

Love the ST one, was happy with the current TSL logo though.

In fact I'm not really sure why you decided to change the TSL logo when the monstrosity that is the MVP logo is still out there distributing eye cancer.

Great work though, like it a lot. Good response to criticism too, the TSL logo is much better with the new T.

mtn

729 Posts

January 14 2012 17:33 GMT

#152

On January 15 2012 00:40 The KY wrote:

Show nested quote +

Those aren't eyes?

Well shit.

HAHA

Exactly. Same thing happened to me when I read his post ^^

scruffeh

England196 Posts

January 14 2012 17:35 GMT

#153

I like them all, but the new ST one is particularly good. I don't know what it is with the fuzziness of some of the original logos. The official TSL one would look so much better if I was crisper. Nice work! Would be interesting to see what the teams themselves think...

Xeris

Iran17695 Posts

January 14 2012 17:37 GMT

#154

Your Quantic concept is by far better than the other two.

Both your logos are IMO not as good as the actual ones. They're really clunky, rigid, and I don't think the fonts do very well (especially the TSL one)

Shuffleus

Australia764 Posts

January 14 2012 17:37 GMT

#155

The Startale and Quantic ones are actually really nice, I love em. Time to go bother my manager :D

The Final Boss

United States1839 Posts

January 14 2012 17:37 GMT

#156

I like the StarTale one, but as it has been mentioned, bad logos is an important tradition

As far as TSL goes I don't think that the current one is that bad, and I personally like the old one more than your variant. That being said, TSL--while I don't think a change is necessary--I think that you certainly have the talent that you could come up with something better ^^ (Quantic one is cool imo)

Swilvan

113 Posts

January 14 2012 17:39 GMT

#157

Nice work, I'm not such a big fan of the tsl one but I really like the st one!

kaplOw

Canada27 Posts

January 14 2012 19:59 GMT

#158

Thanks for the feedback guys! I tweeted the logos to the teams, we'll see if they like

HaXXspetten

Sweden15718 Posts

January 14 2012 20:05 GMT

#159

The old StarTale happy face logo was by far the best, their new one is sort of bland. Your version is easily better than their current one, although the original is still undoubtably the best

mark05

Canada807 Posts

January 14 2012 20:07 GMT

#160

quantic one is my favourite