Idra will never be a winner until he stops quitting games early.
Winners and people who succeed in life will claw their way to the top and fight tooth and nail even if they are losing, especially when they are losing. In sports it is all about when you are down and out do you rally, do you elevate your game, do you go into some god mode and just destroy your opponent after you slipped or he got lucky.
This is why MMA will always beat Idra at the moment. Everyone makes mistakes, it is how you recover from them that makes you great.
On June 06 2011 20:29 Lutto wrote: If idra wasnt so popular he would probably be kicked from EG, his preformance and rage quitting is just bad and the fact that he still states that zerg sucks vs protoss after the last results (even losria vs mc) is just sad...
are you joking? Idras performances are bad? hes only lost like 3 BO x's in major tounaments in the last few months
plus he fact that he finished as 4th against arguably players in the top 3 for their race in korea and the best foreigner WITH all the early gging and senseless rage quitting.
If anything it really shows to EG how good of a player he could really be if he just changed his attitude.
+ the fact that IdrA is a benefit to any team as a practice partner and an ACE player i would put removing IdrA from EG as one of the stupidest things an 'professional' team could ever do.
thorzain looked like the best foreigner tbh. argruably he would have finished highest foreigner if he didn't have to play his group matches after exhausting open bracket marathon and beating MC...
naniwa and idra both surrender to MC before the match even starts.
Thorzain would have won against MC if there was no extended series rule aswell. I think they need to reconsider that shit, its silly and everyone knows it.
You assume MC would have played the same with or without the 2-0 lead. That's a pretty stupid assumption.
On June 06 2011 20:29 Lutto wrote: If idra wasnt so popular he would probably be kicked from EG, his preformance and rage quitting is just bad and the fact that he still states that zerg sucks vs protoss after the last results (even losria vs mc) is just sad...
are you joking? Idras performances are bad? hes only lost like 3 BO x's in major tounaments in the last few months
plus he fact that he finished as 4th against arguably players in the top 3 for their race in korea and the best foreigner WITH all the early gging and senseless rage quitting.
If anything it really shows to EG how good of a player he could really be if he just changed his attitude.
+ the fact that IdrA is a benefit to any team as a practice partner and an ACE player i would put removing IdrA from EG as one of the stupidest things an 'professional' team could ever do.
thorzain looked like the best foreigner tbh. argruably he would have finished highest foreigner if he didn't have to play his group matches after exhausting open bracket marathon and almost* beating MC...
naniwa and idra both surrender to MC before the match even starts.
pretty much this, thorzain performed better than any other foreigner on mlg
Thorzain and Idra performed as well as each other. Idra might have embaressed himself in the end but he was still the only foreigner to beat a Korean in a series.
On June 06 2011 13:50 Reborn8u wrote: Idra has been known for this for a long time. In TSL 2 (BW) he accidentally canceled his command center building at his natural while it was getting harassed by a probe. He instantly gg'd. In the GSL against Jinro's bunker rush ramp block close positions on metalopolis, he GG's, didn't even try to break it. Against huk he had the game won and GG'd because of a bunch of hallucinated void rays. In this very MLG he GG'd against MC's cannon rush, he had his nat up and was able to make lings to counter mc's base but he just gg'd. These are major events, these are not games anyone should just be giving away.
Idra has no heart, no resilience, he rolls over and quits at the first sign of an uphill battle. If he were MMA he would have GG'd when he killed his own OC. I was a fan for a while, but I feel like Idra has become more of a spectacle than a competitor. He's good, but he acts like a 10 year old sometimes. He gives up when things get tough, he goes on tilt and whines when he looses, he gives people the finger, and that is why he is so popular. The most disappointing thing is he has so much skill and talent.
If Idra had a never say die attitude, was full of determination 100% of the time. Accepted his losses with dignity, he would probably be the most feared opponent in starcraft. But his attitude, approach to the game, and mental state are holding him back from dominating. I would love to see him change and reach his full potential, but after a few years of seeing this I think it may be deeply ingrained in who he is.
On June 06 2011 14:24 BaronFel wrote: For koreans, "cool" means something along the lines of "I don't really care" attitude. Like if you get blown off and you go "whatever" and act like is no big deal, that's being cool.
yup and along that line I would like to correct the mistranslation from the event
MMA never said anything about 'being positive'
This is what MMA actually said but lost in translation 'From this game, I hope Idra is able to learn some perseverance/fortitude'
On June 06 2011 20:29 Lutto wrote: If idra wasnt so popular he would probably be kicked from EG, his preformance and rage quitting is just bad and the fact that he still states that zerg sucks vs protoss after the last results (even losria vs mc) is just sad...
are you joking? Idras performances are bad? hes only lost like 3 BO x's in major tounaments in the last few months
plus he fact that he finished as 4th against arguably players in the top 3 for their race in korea and the best foreigner WITH all the early gging and senseless rage quitting.
If anything it really shows to EG how good of a player he could really be if he just changed his attitude.
+ the fact that IdrA is a benefit to any team as a practice partner and an ACE player i would put removing IdrA from EG as one of the stupidest things an 'professional' team could ever do.
thorzain looked like the best foreigner tbh. argruably he would have finished highest foreigner if he didn't have to play his group matches after exhausting open bracket marathon and almost* beating MC...
naniwa and idra both surrender to MC before the match even starts.
pretty much this, thorzain performed better than any other foreigner on mlg
Thorzain and Idra performed as well as each other. Idra might have embaressed himself in the end but he was still the only foreigner to beat a Korean in a series.
Hmm how did the Moon vs Naniwa series end ?
Forgot about that, fair enough. Most people don't rate Moon too highly but you're right Naniwa did beat him.
I think the extendet series rule is the worst thing for the matches.. The players who have beaten their opponents once should be able to defeat them a second time. If not their first win was probably just luck. And on the other hand if there are such intense matches like Idra vs. MC (sunday match) no player will go into the series with something like "lol 2:0 already; no chance to lose" in their minds.
On June 06 2011 22:55 sicQ wrote: I think the extendet series rule is the worst thing for the matches.. The players who have beaten their opponents once should be able to defeat them a second time. If not their first win was probably just luck. And on the other hand if there are such intense matches like Idra vs. MC (sunday match) no player will go into the series with something like "lol 2:0 already; no chance to lose" in their minds.
They should change to series to Bo5 later on in the tournament. A final should not be a Bo3.
On June 06 2011 13:59 Zhyq wrote: Really guys? You really argue that it was lack of mental strength that led IdrA to those loses? I would strongly suggest it was that exact mental strength that shined. It is remarkable to see a player who is able to foresee 5-6 moves ahead and -know- whether (under perfect play from both sides) he will win or lose.
As said earlier, if MMA had the OC at the gold base up and running, he'd have another round of reinforcements which would defeat IdrA. In a scenario that MMA plays perfect and IdrA plays perfect as well, after that last battle, IdrA loses. Why wait it out when you know the outcome?
As far as the MC games are concerned, again IdrA would lose 3 out of 4 of them eventually (again given no mistakes from MC). However, IdrA could have easily won game 4 if he had teched a bit better, rather than remaining stuck with hydra/roach/corruptor forever. That you can fault him on.
Now, one can say that IdrA was tired and didn't make proper decisions as far as his STRATEGY was concerned, and indeed I believe that this was the case. Still, I feel IdrA is not being appreciated for his greatest strength, that is, his ability to read the game flow.
It is a feat of extremely high intelligence to be able to know if you've lost 10 minutes before you do, and that should be recognized rather than criticized.
Mental strength is believing you can outplay your opponent to the end. IdrA assumed MMA was playing perfectly but he was not. IdrA isn't psychic and should have stuck around to see what was really happening in the game instead of assuming he'd lost.
On June 06 2011 13:59 Zhyq wrote: Really guys? You really argue that it was lack of mental strength that led IdrA to those loses? I would strongly suggest it was that exact mental strength that shined. It is remarkable to see a player who is able to foresee 5-6 moves ahead and -know- whether (under perfect play from both sides) he will win or lose.
As said earlier, if MMA had the OC at the gold base up and running, he'd have another round of reinforcements which would defeat IdrA. In a scenario that MMA plays perfect and IdrA plays perfect as well, after that last battle, IdrA loses. Why wait it out when you know the outcome?
As far as the MC games are concerned, again IdrA would lose 3 out of 4 of them eventually (again given no mistakes from MC). However, IdrA could have easily won game 4 if he had teched a bit better, rather than remaining stuck with hydra/roach/corruptor forever. That you can fault him on.
Now, one can say that IdrA was tired and didn't make proper decisions as far as his STRATEGY was concerned, and indeed I believe that this was the case. Still, I feel IdrA is not being appreciated for his greatest strength, that is, his ability to read the game flow.
It is a feat of extremely high intelligence to be able to know if you've lost 10 minutes before you do, and that should be recognized rather than criticized.
Mental strength is believing you can outplay your opponent to the end. IdrA assumed MMA was playing perfectly but he was not. IdrA isn't psychic and should have stuck around to see what was really happening in the game instead of assuming he'd lost.
Perfect response imo. Would like a reply to this argument.
The comment by Zhyq is ridiculous. Who plays absolutely perfect? And if Idra bases his decisions on that assumption, I would question his mental strength even more. I would wonder if he's fucking retarded.
The truth is, the problem is psychological, not computational. Which makes me wonder... are there any participants in e-sports who employ sports psychologists? I think Idra could benefit a lot from a good one.
The Idralings in this thread are mind boggling. He will never be a champion if he keeps giving up so easily with his self defeating attitude. You're die hard defence of him will only hinder his ability to grow as a player.
IdrA's attitude about starcraft 2 hurts his performance. I do not like his attitude one bit and I am saying this because he is the best non korean in the world and he can't prove it. Even the koreans look at idra and know this guy is good. Whats that old addage? Football is 80% physical and 20% mental? This is exactly the same thing here.
IdrA! You need to work on your 20% man. Your attitude is losing you games now. This is not just because of GG timings either. The whole 2nd MC series IdrA played terrible. MC was completely in his head. Roach rushing 3 times when MC just stopped a roach rush from Moon. Then you get to the last game and think, zerg isnt supposed to beat protoss.
It is a feat of extremely high intelligence to be able to know if you've lost 10 minutes before you do, and that should be recognized rather than criticized.
Ya, leaving games early is a feat of extremely high intelligence...
I realize IdrA is smart, but you're really pushing the definition of ultra-fanboy right now =/
I actually dislike IdrA on the whole, but I do admire his ability to know whether he has an advantage or not. So not a fanboy, I'd say.
Well you shouldn't admire it that much, because facts seem to suggest it's quite a bit off.
IdrA has what Zig Ziglar called a "loser's limp. It's holding him back.
Characteristically, when a person falls victim to Garbage-Dump Thinking he develops an assortment of "Loser's Limps." You know what the Loser's Limp is if you've ever attended a football game or watched one on television. (Incidentally, the last time I saw the local team play I knew they were in trouble when the punter signaled for a fair catch on the snap from center.) The offensive player slips behind the defensive player, reaches up, pulls in a pass,and heads for the end zone. The defensive player quickly recovers and takes out in hot pursuit. When the offensive player gets about 20 yards from the end zone, the defensive player realizes he's not going to catch the man with the ball. Everybody in the stands knows it too. So, the defensive player frequently pulls up limping and the people in the stands say, "Well, no wonder the poor guy couldn't catch him. Look, he's crippled." Now that is Loser's Limp.
Psychologically, giving up with some ego-soothing excuse like "Zerg can't win against Protoss" is better than admitting to yourself that the other player might just be better, or that maybe you just need to practice harder.
If he took the energy he wastes on balance-whining and trashing other players and focused it on honestly improving his own play, I think he'd be a much better player. He's entertaining to watch, but as other players get better he has to keep up with hard practice instead of ego-saving antics.
Idra should just GG at the beginning of every game if he believes his opponent will execute perfect play. Logic that stupid is the antithesis of the competitive mindset.
If MMA hadn't suicided his gold, he's probably got quite a few more marines, and likely wins that final encounter. But Idra needed only hang around a few seconds more, and he would have seen, definitively and with his own eyes, that no such marines existed. Blunders of this kind are the worst, because they simultaneously reveal both Idra's genius and foolishness.
I was so disappointed to see Idra go out of the tournament this like this. After his first match with MC I was really hoping that he would show inspiring games throughout the tournament, but his series against MMA and MC were just painful to watch. Everybody knows that he could have done so much better. It is so sad. If Idra would work on his mindset, maybe even with the help of a sport psychologist, I feel that he could do way better than he already is. Tbh I cant think of any athlete/gamer as successful as Idra with such a bad mindset. It is really scary that hes doing so well nonetheless. As pointed out many times before in this thread, his approach to the game is not healthy for esports. People watch to see players compete, and against MC, Idra was not competing and even claimed that there is nothing like competition in PvZ. The MLG stage is not the place for such remarks.
Hopefully he will grow with the experience so we can all enjoy watching him trying his best. ZvP might be imbalanced but that does not mean that Idra vs MC is imbalanced as well.