|
On May 02 2012 19:28 Tobberoth wrote: Using mouse buttons is actually faster (you can click a mouse button with one hand and press the keyboard with the other faster than doing both actions on just the keyboard) so I think it's misguided to try to make the case that this is more effective than darkgrid because this doesn't use the mouse, when it's technically the other way around.
I agree, macro is faster when using mouse buttons. In addition is saves space on the keyboard which is fucking awesome. However, using mouse buttons sacrifices mouse accuracy; I am not down with sacrificing mouse accuracy. Also, although tournaments allow extra buttons on mouses? (need to verify, not 100% sure that all of them do) Who's to say that they choose not to in the future.
Darkgrid is a very efficient custom hotkey layout for people who want to use extra mouse buttons. Chameleon is a very efficient custom hotkey layout for people who don't want to use extra mouse buttons.
EDITED for name change
|
On May 02 2012 20:16 c_kAelle wrote:what do you think about jakatak, about the grid layout like stephano uses? data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt=""
I think grid and standard are not nearly as efficient as Chameleon. I will be writing up a review of the inefficiencies of darkgrid, grid and standard very soon and will add it to the OP :D
I also think every one in the world should watch Day 9 Daily 400 at least once in their lives. It has helped me improve so much.
http://blip.tv/day9tv/day-9-daily-400-p1-special-episode-eliminating-assumptions-5888689
Thanks :D
EDITED for name change
|
On May 02 2012 20:46 Mesha wrote: I see you put a lot of effort in this and you believe its something great. I respect you for that and wish all the best. But i am little confused. How is this better from for example grid hotkey setup? It's still ton of effort to learn (get used to it) everything, especially if i understood well, you plan on helping noobs. They can go either way to learn their hotkeys - it's still massive amount of time needed to get used to it. I think Stephano uses grid, and its efficient as hell, if i were starting all over again i would defenitely start with grid hotkey setup. Also i have to be honest, i don't really understand the whole thing about customizing hotkeys and just how efficient it is and how much it's better from regular hotkey setups. So i won't claim this is nonsense just because i don't get it. ^_^
GL with your project.
Did you read the whole post? I would at least check out the part about guiding principles because that gives my basic explanation on why it is better to have a custom hotkey layout.
I will be writing a critique on the inefficiencies of grid and adding to the OP soon. Look for it :D
|
On May 02 2012 20:56 niks2 wrote: I've been playing with grid but have been looking for an easier way to control group my army. I will definitely play around with this for a couple of weeks, looks like great work, will return if i run into problems/have questions. Thanks in advance though!
Awesome. If you wouldn't mind PMing me when you know how many games it took you to get used to the setup so I can post that up it would be great :D
|
On May 02 2012 21:30 Akinokaze wrote: This looks really nice, gonna give it a go with some slight changes (mouse side button for base cam, caps for idle worker and F1-F6 for screen locations).
sweet man. let me know how that works out for you :D
|
I see what you're doing here, but honestly why would anyone who's been practicing their mechanics a certain way for over two years now want to change to something like this?
I have never felt "Damn I'm not fast enough at hitting that key"
Not to mention the 10 years of broodwar with standard hotkey placement and 1a/ctrl clicking as normal
|
On May 02 2012 23:11 leo23 wrote: jakatak i would like to congratulate you for making this wonderful post. i am a high masters zerg and as reach the higher levels of the ladder i realize that my hotkeys are not as efficient as they could be.
as of now my setup is 1. ground 2. infestors 3. bl 4. queens 5. hatches
and the backspace inject trick (change base camera to space)
it doesn't give me much harass options or control groups to deal with drops so i find myself defending these manually which ultimately loses me some precious time like you mentioned.
when i see your guide and see 8 controls group for army that are easily accessible i drool because that would open so many options.
i have one problem though and it may be because im fucking stupid but... how do i start editing everything? i mean i get the gist of the process but i would appreciate it if you could send me a pm of what keys do i change exactly to what.
thanks a lot man and i appreciate your effort
edit: oh and i also use f1-f4 keys for camera
downloading the doc whoops
Glad you found the doc :D Thank you so much. I want feedback from all levels of play, but its nice to see that masters of Sc2 like yourself are agreeing that they can benefit from this layout. I look forward to your feedback :D
|
On May 03 2012 02:51 098799 wrote:Go go man, we're looking forward to your big project data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt=""
TheJaKaTaK is LIVE at 18:00 PDT 21:00 EDT 02:00 CET and 10:00 KST every day! You can find it at
http://www.twitch.tv/thejakatak
Day 1 was yesterday! It was sort of on a whim, but I had a really fun time :D I have to figure out how to get skype to go through the stream via xsplit though...
Thanks for your support!! :D :D :D
|
This is a really, really good idea. the problem for existing players is re-learning the muscle memory, but you have a good idea with coaching new people. What you need is like a 15 year old who has gaming experience and a really strong drive, then you teach him like Mr miyagi.
Good luck
|
On May 03 2012 03:22 Pabs wrote: Wow, grats on working hard saving money to work on a life goal. I as well plan to live off of savings soon so I can dedicate as much time as I like to gaming. So far I bought a house and rented out the extra rooms. I got less than a year left of 70 hour work weeks. Soon I'll install the solar panels for free power and refinance so the renters cover my expenses. I will look up your show. I apreciate dedicated people with good attitudes.
Woah! That's awesome man!!! You going pro? Or do you have something else in mind?
|
On May 03 2012 04:17 Th1rdEye wrote: I see what you're doing here, but honestly why would anyone who's been practicing their mechanics a certain way for over two years now want to change to something like this?
I have never felt "Damn I'm not fast enough at hitting that key"
Not to mention the 10 years of broodwar with standard hotkey placement and 1a/ctrl clicking as normal
I see where you're coming from. It wasn't really my intention to try and "convert" people. I just thought that since the hotkeys are now customizable it would be better to have a more efficient layout available for people who think the change is worth it. Did you used broodwar hotkeys when sc2 came out? Or do you use the new Sc2 standard hotkeys?
|
On May 03 2012 04:21 TheFish7 wrote: This is a really, really good idea. the problem for existing players is re-learning the muscle memory, but you have a good idea with coaching new people. What you need is like a 15 year old who has gaming experience and a really strong drive, then you teach him like Mr miyagi.
Good luck
I think you may be overestimating the time it takes to relearn the muscle memory. So far I've heard its taken a week to get used to darkgrid, (which is similarly a very different layout from standard). I am compiling a list of # of games it takes for people to switch and hopefully I'll have a better answer for you soon. I do believe that it is worth it for anyone to make the switch, the more games you play, the faster you'll learn, but the more muscle memory you have to overwrite. The fewer games you play, the longer it will take, but the less muscle memory you have to overwrite. My guess is that it comes out to a week of playing.
User was warned for not using the edit button.
EDIT: I was not trying to get extra posts, It would just be really annoying to respond to everyone in the same post, because the quote button takes you right to posting stuff. Sorry
|
On May 03 2012 03:25 JaKaTaK wrote:Show nested quote +On May 02 2012 15:35 Akamu wrote:On May 02 2012 12:45 JaKaTaK wrote:On May 02 2012 12:43 Akamu wrote: Hey high/mid masters T here. I'm giving this a shot over the next couple weeks. But im having trouble finding how to select all idle workers? Maybe im just herp derping but how do i do that?
I have never used that, or found a use for that? What do you use it for if you're high/mid masters?? (forgive my ignorance, i really thought it was a useless key) wow really?! I'm quite surprised. I use it often, if i forget to shift click any workers back to minerals after building things or if a base mines out. I would normally just hit CTRL+ F1 and have them all selected and tell them where i want them to go. Couldn't i in theory just keep it like that since i'm not using F1 in this current set up? Shift clicking scvs and probes back to mine is deep in my blood, It almost never happens that I forget it because its such a habit for me. I am sure that i forget sometimes, but I can't think of a time off the top of my head. You could keep it at F1, I'm working on incorporating it now that I know it is useful. I think N or H might be better options. But then again, I'm working on a big issue with zergs accidentally making extra queens and getting upgrades they don't want to get. (Zerg is definitely the biggest pain in the ass for hotkeys) and may want to use N, H and 6 to solve that. What do you think is faster F1 or N or H?
I changed it back to F1 because that's what i'm used to. And considering this is only my second day playing with it i've already gotten very very used to it. It just makes sense (to me) the way all the hotkeys flow together. I especially like the reusing of the A key. So easy to hit.
I feel like given another week ill be 100% comfortable. I would say i'm 85% right now but given i've mostly played diamond to gold opponents i haven't really felt pressured. If i were to play someone of similiar skill i think i may get a little overwhelmed. I'm gonna keep grinding games and post back later. But right now i give this a big thumbs up and can definitely see the benefits of this setup.
|
On May 03 2012 10:29 Akamu wrote:Show nested quote +On May 03 2012 03:25 JaKaTaK wrote:On May 02 2012 15:35 Akamu wrote:On May 02 2012 12:45 JaKaTaK wrote:On May 02 2012 12:43 Akamu wrote: Hey high/mid masters T here. I'm giving this a shot over the next couple weeks. But im having trouble finding how to select all idle workers? Maybe im just herp derping but how do i do that?
I have never used that, or found a use for that? What do you use it for if you're high/mid masters?? (forgive my ignorance, i really thought it was a useless key) wow really?! I'm quite surprised. I use it often, if i forget to shift click any workers back to minerals after building things or if a base mines out. I would normally just hit CTRL+ F1 and have them all selected and tell them where i want them to go. Couldn't i in theory just keep it like that since i'm not using F1 in this current set up? Shift clicking scvs and probes back to mine is deep in my blood, It almost never happens that I forget it because its such a habit for me. I am sure that i forget sometimes, but I can't think of a time off the top of my head. You could keep it at F1, I'm working on incorporating it now that I know it is useful. I think N or H might be better options. But then again, I'm working on a big issue with zergs accidentally making extra queens and getting upgrades they don't want to get. (Zerg is definitely the biggest pain in the ass for hotkeys) and may want to use N, H and 6 to solve that. What do you think is faster F1 or N or H? I changed it back to F1 because that's what i'm used to. And considering this is only my second day playing with it i've already gotten very very used to it. It just makes sense (to me) the way all the hotkeys flow together. I especially like the reusing of the A key. So easy to hit. I feel like given another week ill be 100% comfortable. I would say i'm 85% right now but given i've mostly played diamond to gold opponents i haven't really felt pressured. If i were to play someone of similiar skill i think i may get a little overwhelmed. I'm gonna keep grinding games and post back later. But right now i give this a big thumbs up and can definitely see the benefits of this setup.
Thanks man, that's awesome! 85% after 2 days is much better than I expected :D lemme know when you feel 100% comfy with it :D
|
On May 02 2012 14:02 NrGmonk wrote: Tagged and changed title.
Hey man, I don't mean to take up too much of your time, but I looked for what the title tags mean on a search and didn't find anything definitive... is there a post that explains them all? what does [G] mean?
|
G - Guide L - Low Level H - Help D - Discussion Q - Question among others
also, to avoid future warnings for excessive posts (lol), I suggest while editing a particular post, right click the 'quote' link of the post you want to quote so it opens in another window, and copy / paste it into your working post. Repeat as necessary, until TL gets a multiple quote feature up in here.
edit:
Also, I wanted to point out that you can use the side mouse buttons without using drivers or third party software. Starcraft 2 sees them as Mouse Forward Button and Mouse Back Button.
|
United States8476 Posts
|
On May 02 2012 07:29 achristes wrote: Idk mang, looks really hard to get used to so I'll stick with my modified Standard setup.
I am in the same boat with you. I've also got my modified setup that works kinda well for me but has its drawbacks. But I just don't ever have the incentive to switch over to better control scheme. That being said, I love looking over new and different hotkey setups like Darkgrid and this.
|
On May 03 2012 11:53 Epishade wrote:Show nested quote +On May 02 2012 07:29 achristes wrote: Idk mang, looks really hard to get used to so I'll stick with my modified Standard setup. I am in the same boat with you. I've also got my modified setup that works kinda well for me but has its drawbacks. But I just don't ever have the incentive to switch over to better control scheme. That being said, I love looking over new and different hotkey setups like Darkgrid and this.
I definitely think its worth it, and may take you much less time than you think. Thanks for the interest :D
|
|
|
|
|