On May 26 2011 22:37 L0thar wrote: Sorry, but If you can't tell the difference between "being MSL finalist" and "won a game, still get eliminated form the MSL" by yourself, I probably won't be able to explain it either way.
You can explain it by being in a group with the 2 best players in the world. Not getting further into the MSL is not a negative on Bisu's list because it's entirely possible Flash or Jaedong couldn't have got through
Wait, so you are saying that since Flash and Jaedong could have theoretically lost to Bisu they should be below him?
No, I never said that. My point is that Bisu not making past the group stages is not something to hold against him
On May 26 2011 22:37 L0thar wrote: Sorry, but If you can't tell the difference between "being MSL finalist" and "won a game, still get eliminated form the MSL" by yourself, I probably won't be able to explain it either way.
You can explain it by being in a group with the 2 best players in the world. Not getting further into the MSL is not a negative on Bisu's list because it's entirely possible Flash or Jaedong couldn't have got through
Wait, so you are saying that since Flash and Jaedong could have theoretically lost to Bisu they should be below him?
No, I never said that. My point is that Bisu not making past the group stages is not something to hold against him
It is if you're comparing him to Flash.
I'm not because I can reasonably state that Flash should be above Bisu
On May 27 2011 11:01 Xiphos wrote: At this point, the ranking would be 1/2. ZerO/Flash 3/4 Bisu/Flash and then 5 being Hydra and then other players who have a good reccord this month.
You mean 1/2. Zero/Flash and 2/3. Bisu/Flash ?? Otherwise 1-4 are just three players ^^, I think this months PR is hard to rank. If Flash beats Hydra we might see 1 Flash 2 Zero 3 Bisu
If he loses to Hydra 1 Zero/Hydra 2 Hydra/Zero 3 Bisu
On May 27 2011 11:01 Xiphos wrote: At this point, the ranking would be 1/2. ZerO/Flash 3/4 Bisu/Flash and then 5 being Hydra and then other players who have a good reccord this month.
You mean 1/2. Zero/Flash and 2/3. Bisu/Flash ?? Otherwise 1-4 are just three players ^^, I think this months PR is hard to rank. If Flash beats Hydra we might see 1 Flash 2 Zero 3 Bisu
If he loses to Hydra 1 Zero/Hydra 2 Hydra/Zero 3 Bisu
Why would Flash be below Bisu if he loses to Hydra? For May Flash is 6-2 and Bisu is 7-2 in PL i.e. similar results, if we count since last PR Flash is 4-0 vs Bisu's 4-1 in PL. On top of that I think semifinals MSL trumps ro32 MSL. Unless Hydra trounces Flash I really don't see why Bisu should be above him in that case.
On May 27 2011 11:01 Xiphos wrote: At this point, the ranking would be 1/2. ZerO/Flash 3/4 Bisu/Flash and then 5 being Hydra and then other players who have a good reccord this month.
You mean 1/2. Zero/Flash and 2/3. Bisu/Flash ?? Otherwise 1-4 are just three players ^^, I think this months PR is hard to rank. If Flash beats Hydra we might see 1 Flash 2 Zero 3 Bisu
If he loses to Hydra 1 Zero/Hydra 2 Hydra/Zero 3 Bisu
Why would Flash be below Bisu if he loses to Hydra? For May Flash is 6-2 and Bisu is 7-2 in PL i.e. similar results, if we count since last PR Flash is 4-0 vs Bisu's 4-1 in PL. On top of that I think semifinals MSL trumps ro32 MSL. Unless Hydra trounces Flash I really don't see why Bisu should be above him in that case.
As for the same reason why this month Bisu was above Flash, by counting results only, this month Flash should be 2 and Bisu 3, but as you know, it isn't. But I won't be confused if Flash is above Bisu, I was more focusing on 1/2. spot in my post.
flash bisu zero jaedong/hydra if hydra > flash then hydra hydra/jaedong if flash < hydra then hydra soulkey
?? ??
bisu just seems more scary than zero because of zero's inconsistency and stuff (lose to jaehoon) jaedong is not looking that scary apart from his vT soulkey is below jaedong because he is still new
Honestly, unless Flash shows some serious weakness in the MSL, he should be above Bisu. Bisu hasn't really shown any weakness this month, and as I said the only thing Flash has on him is the MSL. If he wins against Hydra or at least does really well, I'd say he belongs above Bisu this time around. The only way I'd drop him is if he crashes and burns.
On May 27 2011 21:37 vishrut wrote: i think it should be:
flash bisu zero jaedong/hydra if hydra > flash then hydra hydra/jaedong if flash < hydra then hydra soulkey
?? ??
bisu just seems more scary than zero because of zero's inconsistency and stuff (lose to jaehoon) jaedong is not looking that scary apart from his vT soulkey is below jaedong because he is still new
How is soulkey still considered a new player? he's been an A-teamer for more then a year already and this is not even his first time on the power rank, there's no way you can put Jaedong above soulkey considering their month
On May 29 2011 05:33 Rtran10 wrote: what's the likelihood jaedong drops out of the top 5
Unfortunately it's a realistic possibility, but given his skill, given the run he was having just a month ago, given that he made it to the semifinal before flopping... a part of me doesn't want to see it happen. Another part thinks... you drop the ball, you're bound to get punished.