Power Rank 09/14/2010 - Page 12
Forum Index > Polls & Liquibet |
pronesc
United States31 Posts
| ||
Crisium
United States1618 Posts
On September 18 2010 22:07 SubtleArt wrote: It's a new writer with a more neutral tone. Rather than heap praise in decorated language he says it factually and with little emotion....it's just his style. Right. But many people here are saying they prefer a more excited and hyped style that the PR has had in the past. There are plenty of complaints here. But there's also constructive criticism. That post comparing when Jaedong won the Golden Mouse to Flash this month is called constructive criticism. Waxangle doesn't have to reinvent himself, but he would be wise to listen and consider new ideas for the next PR. | ||
aupstar
Australia912 Posts
On September 14 2010 15:04 Waxangel wrote: For the first 23 minutes of Leta and Flash’s first OSL game, we were in some bizarre alternate reality where Leta was abusing Flash like Flash abuses Hiya. For 23 minutes, Leta constantly attacked Flash at a frenetic pace, with his attacks suffering no dullness despite their incredible speed. Even the turtle-king was bewildered, and soon gave up at a 6 to 3 base advantage. . However, Leta then made a possibly career defining error, one so costly that it defeated his spirit and allowed Flash to slowly but surely grind out a win. Waxangle writes a great unbiased article with no hype..=_='' Turtle king grinding a win + another reference to how flash beat hiya in the proleague finals and in doing so made a "small" contribution to KT's victory. Ofc, KT would be where they are now without Flash because they're just so damn good without him. Gosh I'm not looking forward to future PR. | ||
SubtleArt
2710 Posts
On September 18 2010 23:42 Crisium wrote: Right. But many people here are saying they prefer a more excited and hyped style that the PR has had in the past. There are plenty of complaints here. But there's also constructive criticism. That post comparing when Jaedong won the Golden Mouse to Flash this month is called constructive criticism. Waxangle doesn't have to reinvent himself, but he would be wise to listen and consider new ideas for the next PR. Then "please write with more enthusiasm" is a much more valid complaint than "Waxangel stop trying to belittle Flash's accomplishments" | ||
Tempest[OEC]
United States417 Posts
Good write-up Waxangel. It was a good read. | ||
InRaged
1047 Posts
On September 19 2010 01:16 SubtleArt wrote: Then "please write with more enthusiasm" is a much more valid complaint than "Waxangel stop trying to belittle Flash's accomplishments" No it's not more valid, cause it's only Flash's write-up that lacks a good deal of enthusiasm. Others get so much more enthusiastic writing style in comparison to their accomplishment last months (none). Leta's write-up quoted above is a good example. | ||
SubtleArt
2710 Posts
On September 19 2010 02:51 InRaged wrote: No it's not more valid, cause it's only Flash's write-up that lacks a good deal of enthusiasm. Others get so much more enthusiastic writing style in comparison to their accomplishment last months (none). Leta's write-up quoted above is a good example. It was another solid month for Jaedong, where his play was consistently in the great to awesome range. It was marked with a variety of tough TvZ tests, where Jaedong faced capable opponents in Light and Flash. Jaedong played well in all of these series, with some spectacular play in drawn out games against Light and Flash. Unfortunately, he was unable to keep Flash out of his head and complicated mind-games caused him to lose some one-sided but intriguing matches. In addition, Fantasy had the boost of playing well in the Proleague post-season. He won his match at Kwang-an-ri for the second year running, although this time it could not help his team win a championship. Even so, winning at such an important event counts for a lot. Combined with some solid wins over a variety of decent players such Calm, Shuttle, and Kal, Fantasy showed that he’s the best of the rest. Free was on a OSL joyride, going undefeated on his royal road tour before Flash gave him a heavy dose of reality. Besides his win with a slightly lucky (but still well executed) proxy gate rush, Free suffered a terrible thrashing at Flash’s hands. There was a clear gulf in class on display, as Free failed to put up any meaningful resistance. Even besides the 1-3 score, his skill level never suggested the threat of an upset like the above three players. With solid statistical production but no realistic capacity to challenge for a championship, Free provides a solid buffer between the real contenders above him and the murky depths of inconsistency below. Sea’s two surprise wins against Jaedong and dual top eight finish secures him a respectable #7. Just teeming with emotion | ||
kamizushi
Canada52 Posts
On September 17 2010 08:13 Crisium wrote: Actually I can. And you want an even more shocking number? Distinct player winner's per race, last 6 seasons (2 years) 1 Terran: Flash 2 Protoss: Stork Bisu 4 Zerg: Jaedong EffOrt Calm Luxury You seem to forgot that success is measured by winning. No Terran has been capable of winning for YEARS besides Flash. If you push it back to 11 seasons, or 3.67 years, only 3 unique Terran have won compared to 7 unique Zerg. The highest stage is what matters. Only, and I mean only, if you use this most recent season can you claim Terran have dominated at the highest stage. You have to go back to when Oov and NaDa were winning to see non-Flash Terran winning the majority of tournaments. You remember why he is called the Ultimate Weapon? He transformed himself into the winning method; not his race. You know I have to agree with you. I remember on the Round of 8 of the Ever OSL reading someone's comment. It was saying Terran are dominating. For those of you with sort memory, out of 8 players there was 4 zergs, 3 Protoss and Flash. If it wasn't for Flash's success Terran would do pretty bad. Beside Flash and Fantasy is there any Terran worth mentioning in the past 2 years? | ||
Mortality
United States4790 Posts
On September 19 2010 10:02 kamizushi wrote: You know I have to agree with you. I remember on the Round of 8 of the Ever OSL reading someone's comment. It was saying Terran are dominating. For those of you with sort memory, out of 8 players there was 4 zergs, 3 Protoss and Flash. If it wasn't for Flash's success Terran would do pretty bad. Beside Flash and Fantasy is there any Terran worth mentioning in the past 2 years? Certainly Terran hasn't been as strong as in the past. After Savior's 5-0 over Oov in Cyon(?) MSL, Terran dominance hasn't been the same. Late 2008/early 2009 was probably the all time low point. Probably because it was the all time high point for Protoss and historically the game balance has been P > T > Z > P. But so what? Terran has traditionally been the strong race in Starcraft history. If we go all the way back to the EVER 2005 season, only 6 distinct Terrans have won a finals. By the above argument, Terran was weak back then too. But at this time, even though Terran did not win either final in the EVER 05/Uzoo MSL season, Terran was pretty much unanimously considered the strongest race by everyone paying attention to progaming even though both OSL and MSL were won by Zerg (July and Savior). In fact, looking at distinct SL winners: Terran (9): Boxer, NaDa, Oov, Mind, ForGG, Flash, Sync, Xellos, Casy Zerg (10): Gorush, Savior, Chojja, Jaedong, Luxury, Calm, Freemura, July, GGplay, Effort Protoss (8): Nal_ra, Bisu, Giyom, Garimto, Reach, Kingdom, Anytime, Stork So by your argument... in the long run, all races have been equal? Gold Count: Terran: 22 Zerg: 19 Protoss: 12 Paints a different picture? [Edit: I may have forgot to count this season, which would make it 24 gold for Terran. Too tired to bother checking my numbers.] What made Terran dominance special was really just the presence of the bonjwas and nothing more than that. Sure there were other very strong S-class Terrans over the years, but other races have also had their lists of S-class players. Protoss is probably unique in this in that the lists of S-class gamers tended to be smaller. Pre-LYH/LYH era, it was sometimes said that if you weren't Giyom, Garimto or IntoTheRain, you didn't have a chance. And then post LYH it was Ra, Reach, Kingdom for a long time. Then Anytime, Pusan and Stork arose, although Pusan never went all the way and Stork had terribad PvZ back then (adequate vs schmucks, painful to watch vs toss killers like Chojja and Savior), but it wasn't until the Six Dragons that we ever had such a strong line-up for Protoss. This naturally changed everything. Many strong Protoss. No Terran bonjwa. So things were bad. 2010? Even without Flash, I'd say Terran is doing better than Protoss, although I cannot say the same for Zerg if you remove Jaedong from the picture. | ||
![]()
]343[
United States10328 Posts
On September 19 2010 12:34 Mortality wrote:Protoss is probably unique in this in that the lists of S-class gamers tended to be smaller. Pre-LYH/LYH era, it was sometimes said that if you weren't Giyom, Garimto or IntoTheRain, you didn't have a chance. And then post LYH it was Ra, Reach, Kingdom for a long time. Then Anytime, Pusan and Stork arose, although Pusan never went all the way and Stork had terribad PvZ back then (adequate vs schmucks, painful to watch vs toss killers like Chojja and Savior), but it wasn't until the Six Dragons that we ever had such a strong line-up for Protoss. Whoa I just realized that Lim Yo Hwan and Lee Young Ho have the same initials T_____T | ||
kamizushi
Canada52 Posts
Don't ask me what it means, if it means anything. | ||
aupstar
Australia912 Posts
On September 14 2010 15:04 Waxangel wrote: In addition, Fantasy had the boost of playing well in the Proleague post-season. He won his match at Kwang-an-ri for the second year running, although this time it could not help his team win a championship. Even so, winning at such an important event counts for a lot. . He beat HOEJJA! Yes, regardless winning at such an important event counts for a lot...That is unless you are Flash in which case it is a "small" contribution. | ||
TwoToneTerran
United States8841 Posts
| ||
moopie
12605 Posts
On September 16 2010 06:02 Grobyc wrote: Glad to see some protoss moving up and effort finally move down. i like effort personally, but he doesn't deserve the rank he had before. Don't worry, next month he won't be ranked at all :/ | ||
Lebesgue
4542 Posts
Edit: Damn, I just saw Effort announced that he retires ![]() | ||
bluetrolls
United States139 Posts
| ||
bluetrolls
United States139 Posts
| ||
![]()
Waxangel
United States33429 Posts
On September 20 2010 08:50 aupstar wrote: He beat HOEJJA! Yes, regardless winning at such an important event counts for a lot...That is unless you are Flash in which case it is a "small" contribution. Bad wording on my part, I did consider them almost equally (slight edge for Flash for having been on the winning side). But Flash didn't even need the PL win to take #1 by a mile. | ||
Navi
5286 Posts
![]() I think that the PR is fine, waxangel's writing style is much more matter-of-fact than previous writers', which lets me compare my personal PR to his, step by step. Not saying that previous PR's didn't have this quality, but it is, in my opinion, a great RANKING. | ||
Reggiegigas
234 Posts
Either way, I think y'all should stop complaining just cause a new writer has a different style than the old one. It's still the same type of power ranking as before, is it not? Don't nitpick so much and be grateful someone put so much effort (ack, that word hurts to type now) into making this. Thanks! | ||
| ||