|
Next level mafia play..
Leave ES alive after catching one. D2 be real easy.
|
On September 19 2020 12:34 Monadel wrote:Show nested quote +On September 19 2020 12:31 Number 4 wrote:On September 19 2020 12:30 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 12:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 19 2020 11:47 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 11:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 10:11 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 08:13 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 06:50 Number 4 wrote:
I think is better for town to focus this night which cop is “the best” or the “real” cop and decide who is the other mafia after the flip.
I think we have enough information and it's arguably productive to milk it even more. What town should do on the other hand is trying to find the second mafia WITHOUT making associative reads. I get why you say this but if we end up lynching shockey working out who the second mafia is is irrelevant because power roles solve the game. Id prefer to continue to discuss who we are lynching between the two cop claim. Can both cop claims go into as much detail ad they can on how they chose their checks? Let me think about this. If we lynch correctly today: N1 4v1, 2 confirmed townies D2 3v1, probably 2 confirmed townies with another check. If we mislynch, then: N2 2v1, GG. So not really, the cop is very important but won’t determine our win. This is wrong it would be 3 confirmed towns the cop and his 2 checks (this only works if shockey is fakeclaim) No... We had one check. That makes 3 if doctor claims. Which I think is silly. I dont really follow you. There is 6 people left. If we were to lynch shockey and then there is a NK there is 4 people left. It will be 3 town and 1 mafia in the number 4 is town cop world Currently in that world there is two confirmed towns yourself and GB. Who should both survive the night because they will be killing the docter dadred. That leaves myself and vivax and you will have a check on one of us. Which means the game is solved That leaves It's day. Yah D1 4 v 2 N0 4 v 1 D2 3 v 1 by this stage you have yourself GB and 1 more check which is 3 confirmed in your eyes. Am I making sense?
You’re assuming they will kill Damdred.
And to be fair, if we believe Damdred is really the doctor then we lynch outside the claims.
|
But I hardly believe shockey isn’t mafia at this point
|
On September 19 2020 13:19 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On September 19 2020 12:34 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 12:31 Number 4 wrote:On September 19 2020 12:30 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 12:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 19 2020 11:47 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 11:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 10:11 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 08:13 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 06:50 Number 4 wrote:
I think is better for town to focus this night which cop is “the best” or the “real” cop and decide who is the other mafia after the flip.
I think we have enough information and it's arguably productive to milk it even more. What town should do on the other hand is trying to find the second mafia WITHOUT making associative reads. I get why you say this but if we end up lynching shockey working out who the second mafia is is irrelevant because power roles solve the game. Id prefer to continue to discuss who we are lynching between the two cop claim. Can both cop claims go into as much detail ad they can on how they chose their checks? Let me think about this. If we lynch correctly today: N1 4v1, 2 confirmed townies D2 3v1, probably 2 confirmed townies with another check. If we mislynch, then: N2 2v1, GG. So not really, the cop is very important but won’t determine our win. This is wrong it would be 3 confirmed towns the cop and his 2 checks (this only works if shockey is fakeclaim) No... We had one check. That makes 3 if doctor claims. Which I think is silly. I dont really follow you. There is 6 people left. If we were to lynch shockey and then there is a NK there is 4 people left. It will be 3 town and 1 mafia in the number 4 is town cop world Currently in that world there is two confirmed towns yourself and GB. Who should both survive the night because they will be killing the docter dadred. That leaves myself and vivax and you will have a check on one of us. Which means the game is solved That leaves It's day. Yah D1 4 v 2 N0 4 v 1 D2 3 v 1 by this stage you have yourself GB and 1 more check which is 3 confirmed in your eyes. Am I making sense? You’re assuming they will kill Damdred. And to be fair, if we believe Damdred is really the doctor then we lynch outside the claims.
If they don't kill damdred then its an extra confirmed?
Why would we lynch outside of the claims if we lynch wrong we lose
|
p On September 19 2020 13:39 Monadel wrote:Show nested quote +On September 19 2020 13:19 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 12:34 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 12:31 Number 4 wrote:On September 19 2020 12:30 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 12:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 19 2020 11:47 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 11:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 10:11 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 08:13 GlowingBear wrote:
[quote]
I think we have enough information and it's arguably productive to milk it even more.
What town should do on the other hand is trying to find the second mafia WITHOUT making associative reads. I get why you say this but if we end up lynching shockey working out who the second mafia is is irrelevant because power roles solve the game. Id prefer to continue to discuss who we are lynching between the two cop claim. Can both cop claims go into as much detail ad they can on how they chose their checks? Let me think about this. If we lynch correctly today: N1 4v1, 2 confirmed townies D2 3v1, probably 2 confirmed townies with another check. If we mislynch, then: N2 2v1, GG. So not really, the cop is very important but won’t determine our win. This is wrong it would be 3 confirmed towns the cop and his 2 checks (this only works if shockey is fakeclaim) No... We had one check. That makes 3 if doctor claims. Which I think is silly. I dont really follow you. There is 6 people left. If we were to lynch shockey and then there is a NK there is 4 people left. It will be 3 town and 1 mafia in the number 4 is town cop world Currently in that world there is two confirmed towns yourself and GB. Who should both survive the night because they will be killing the docter dadred. That leaves myself and vivax and you will have a check on one of us. Which means the game is solved That leaves It's day. Yah D1 4 v 2 N0 4 v 1 D2 3 v 1 by this stage you have yourself GB and 1 more check which is 3 confirmed in your eyes. Am I making sense? You’re assuming they will kill Damdred. And to be fair, if we believe Damdred is really the doctor then we lynch outside the claims. If they don't kill damdred then its an extra confirmed? Why would we lynch outside of the claims if we lynch wrong we lose
Is he an extra confirmed?
If someone claims doctor later, we will have to decide again between two claims. That’s my point.
You’re right. We lose if we mislynch today. I was thinking we would still have day2
|
On September 19 2020 13:46 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On September 19 2020 13:39 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 13:19 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 12:34 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 12:31 Number 4 wrote:On September 19 2020 12:30 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 12:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 19 2020 11:47 Monadel wrote:On September 19 2020 11:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 10:11 Monadel wrote:
[quote]
I get why you say this but if we end up lynching shockey working out who the second mafia is is irrelevant because power roles solve the game.
Id prefer to continue to discuss who we are lynching between the two cop claim.
Can both cop claims go into as much detail ad they can on how they chose their checks? Let me think about this. If we lynch correctly today: N1 4v1, 2 confirmed townies D2 3v1, probably 2 confirmed townies with another check. If we mislynch, then: N2 2v1, GG. So not really, the cop is very important but won’t determine our win. This is wrong it would be 3 confirmed towns the cop and his 2 checks (this only works if shockey is fakeclaim) No... We had one check. That makes 3 if doctor claims. Which I think is silly. I dont really follow you. There is 6 people left. If we were to lynch shockey and then there is a NK there is 4 people left. It will be 3 town and 1 mafia in the number 4 is town cop world Currently in that world there is two confirmed towns yourself and GB. Who should both survive the night because they will be killing the docter dadred. That leaves myself and vivax and you will have a check on one of us. Which means the game is solved That leaves It's day. Yah D1 4 v 2 N0 4 v 1 D2 3 v 1 by this stage you have yourself GB and 1 more check which is 3 confirmed in your eyes. Am I making sense? You’re assuming they will kill Damdred. And to be fair, if we believe Damdred is really the doctor then we lynch outside the claims. If they don't kill damdred then its an extra confirmed? Why would we lynch outside of the claims if we lynch wrong we lose Is he an extra confirmed? If someone claims doctor later, we will have to decide again between two claims. That’s my point. You’re right. We lose if we mislynch today. I was thinking we would still have day2
Only mafia thinks like this.
On September 19 2020 05:03 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On September 19 2020 04:57 GlowingBear wrote:On September 19 2020 04:54 ShoCkeyy wrote:
I literally can picture GB and Number 4's QT
"Don't kill shockeyy N0, he's a easy push for D1" Why would myself and N4, as mafia, decide to kill you, just to see you flipping cop, and have her lynched right after? ROFL That's even why I asked the doctor to not save inside the claims, because mafia would shoot outside it to kill the doctor and that if they even decide to shoot the real cop, we have a confirmed mafia on the other side. It's basically a win-win. But then I realized that if we lose the cop, we are a bit screwed later on. Cause you're mafia, and she's willing to die late game to win. It's not hard math. I die today, that's -1 town, leaving three town, and two mafia. Mafia kills one more town at night, and that's essentially BG.
|
On September 19 2020 11:37 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On September 19 2020 06:24 Monadel wrote:
if shockey is mafia then vivax is his partner I’m not mafia, the town is my partner. Notice how it’s only two people that are constantly against me. Rayn was at least trying to speak to me. GB basically said he would always think I’m mafia. That’s not town mentality.
This is a lie, GB was the only one trying to think of you as town while rayn was always it is Shockey + Damred.
Anyone can read Rayns filter and see is true.
- cop
|
On September 19 2020 12:39 ShoCkeyy wrote:Monadel think of it this way, N4 and GB are both willing to vote you out if necessary. I’m typically always on the chopping block in every game we play together, and they’re using that to the advantage of the game to kill a blue during D1.
Vote you out what?
I am voting the shit out of you because you are mafia.
|
No, the lynch today MUST be between the cop claims (obviously Shockey).
What the last mafia does at night we don’t care becsuse there is still a chance Damred is lying. (Don’t get mad if you are the real doctor, but idk if you are lying and as town I have to be wary)
Also I want to point out that if town misslynches today the game is over and mafia wins.
To answer you Monadel I believed GB was mafia, have said that several times. And even tho I didnt get a mafia I think at the end is a good check because he is a very vocal player.
|
@Monadel
Shockey’s personality in this game doesnt fit, I have said that before, GB too and even Rayn has said that.
The only thing I am surprised tho is that Vivax hasnt said a thing about it but focused on GB.
|
I woke up when everyone is mia  I think I will go and prepare hot dogs.
|
Reading some of rayns filter and because im still not really sure what way to go with the cop claims I think we should no lynch today.
GB/Number 4 I'd appreciate your comments on this and if you could unvote if you agree so there can be no tom foolery with instant majority.
|
I am sorry, no matter the circumstances but I am voting shockey always and forever because it is my duty as town who has knowledge.
- cop
Btw have you asked yourself why shockey hasnt voted me? 
|
On September 19 2020 16:53 Monadel wrote:
Reading some of rayns filter and because im still not really sure what way to go with the cop claims I think we should no lynch today.
GB/Number 4 I'd appreciate your comments on this and if you could unvote if you agree so there can be no tom foolery with instant majority.
Can you also elaborate on what are the things you like or dislike of each cop?
I am going to think more about your suggestion.
|
There is no lynch
We are at 4 vs 2
Someone dies (more likely a vanilla townie or maybe even the doc if they are lucky)
So 3 vs 2
Obviously they are going to keep GB and the hydra alive vs the two mafia.
1 vanilla townie, second one with no info is going to be alive (or doc)
Sounds a bit dangerous to me, better scenario than 2 vs 2 but that day is going to be a shit fest.
|
Would someone want to discuss the game?
|
I'm annoyed cause people don't even read my posts I guess.
The doc can save the same target for multiple nights.
|
On September 19 2020 20:58 Dadred wrote:
I'm annoyed cause people don't even read my posts I guess.
The doc can save the same target for multiple nights.
Who are the several persons?
So far all I know is Ever who asked that.
|
On September 19 2020 20:58 Dadred wrote:
I'm annoyed cause people don't even read my posts I guess.
The doc can save the same target for multiple nights.
This is fantastic knowledge! I'm sorry I missed your post . I need to catch up again but it shouldn't take me long.
I really need a shower though so standby friends!
|
On September 20 2020 01:23 Number 4 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 19 2020 20:58 Dadred wrote:
I'm annoyed cause people don't even read my posts I guess.
The doc can save the same target for multiple nights. This is fantastic knowledge! I'm sorry I missed your post . I need to catch up again but it shouldn't take me long. I really need a shower though so standby friends!
Ebwop
-es
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
