|
Sorry guys 
I played pretty terribly. Definitely felt pretty lost most of the game and even when I thought I was sure I was wrong LOL. Probably shouldn't have signed up. I didn't have enough time to play to my standards especially with the amount of posts this game. Probably won't play mafia again at least while the spam is this high. It's just not my thing and I don't like playing with that many posts. I also didn't like pms, but I never played with them so it was something different to try.
As for why I did what I did during the last day. I really thought town was in a 4-5-2 situation and that VA was 3rd party and really had to kill bats. I figured town had to take a risk and not lynch bats because if not they would lose due to the amount of KP. I actually thought HtS was mafia and was super sure of that. Obviously, I was wrong. And it was pretty much only hubris that caused me to stick with HtS over Sep who I also agreed was mafia. That was dumb.
Even playing terribly, I still had fun. Thanks for hosting GreY! I know it is difficult work and you do a great job!
Random fact: During day 3 I death framed VA to get a list of the actions performed on him, so we could figure out once and for all whether or not he was scum. I thought I would get the results immediately, but I misunderstood and would only get results if he was targeted by scum which never happened, so it ended up being for naught. GG everybody.
|
On April 08 2015 10:17 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +Original Message From kitaman27:
From the moment we laid eyes on each other this game, I knew you were the one for me. It's clear that you're the one I'm meant to spend the rest of the day with.
*gets down to one knee*
Will you accept my rose? Show nested quote +Original Message From kitaman27:
So I really think that this is the time in the game where you try to busdrive a mafia kp from a townie player into a scummy looking player.
Unless LS's towncheck on you was manipulated by night actions.
Then you can go back to being my mail order bride. I'm willing to accept you for who you are. For anyone wondering about the most relevant part of the game, this guy was our lucky Bachelor winner. I meant what I said baby. Love you always.
I LOVE YOU BATMAN.
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
On April 08 2015 10:59 Crossfire99 wrote:
As for why I did what I did during the last day. I really thought town was in a 4-5-2 situation and that VA was 3rd party and really had to kill bats. I figured town had to take a risk and not lynch bats because if not they would lose due to the amount of KP. I actually thought HtS was mafia and was super sure of that. Obviously, I was wrong. And it was pretty much only hubris that caused me to stick with HtS over Sep who I also agreed was mafia. That was dumb.
If you believed HTS/Sep were both mafia it then lynching outside of batsnacks with the hopes of 3p VA assistance was the right call. Nothing wrong with pushing something you believe in.
Did we get an explanation with where that poison ended up?
|
On April 08 2015 11:07 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 08 2015 10:59 Crossfire99 wrote:
As for why I did what I did during the last day. I really thought town was in a 4-5-2 situation and that VA was 3rd party and really had to kill bats. I figured town had to take a risk and not lynch bats because if not they would lose due to the amount of KP. I actually thought HtS was mafia and was super sure of that. Obviously, I was wrong. And it was pretty much only hubris that caused me to stick with HtS over Sep who I also agreed was mafia. That was dumb. If you believed HTS/Sep were both mafia it then lynching outside of batsnacks with the hopes of 3p VA assistance was the right call. Nothing wrong with pushing something you believe in. Did we get an explanation with where that poison ended up?
I looked at the spreadsheet. HF poisoned Blazinghand, but he was bussed with JAT who was healed, so the poison was negated.
Edit: Or I think that's what happened. Now I'm not sure when looking at it. Or GreY just explained it.
|
Holyfare targeted BH, who was bussed with JAT who was bussed with Koshi, thus koshi was poisioned.
|
So just wondering why majoras mask ha abilities for everyone else who got it but not me. I really wanted to write Who Let the Dogs Out is Confirmed Town!
|
On April 08 2015 11:14 GreYMisT wrote:
Holyfare targeted BH, who was bussed with JAT who was bussed with Koshi, thus koshi was poisioned.
So stupid.
|
JAT you told me to trust OwS so he was the only one I shared everything with . Also I tried to play town leader last night I kept everything as close to the vest as I could except with Obi, while getting as much info as I could from everyone else. I started to trust HtS toward the end but couldn't PM directed OwS to bus me and sepulchre.
|
So I replaced into a like 300 page thread after a >6 month hiatus, played for 48 hours during which we lynched scum, and then was worth a hit with a scum NK while giving my strongest power to a townie. I consider this a successful replacement game even though my team ended up losing. I think I did as much as I could do here.
Yes, I pushed town Kita pretty hard, but I don't think my reasoning there was terrible, and I did see my way past that (mostly due to Kita pm'ing me a very detailed and reasonable explanation for everything), and I refocused onto the actually-scum bh. I vote me for Most Valuable Replacement of this game.
|
I think people may have relied too much on "confirmations" using roles/PMs/etc.
Obi was basically assumed confirmed town because of a town check from someone
BH was basically assumed town the last phases because of some PM thing with Onegu (that I still don't understand)
HTS was basically assumed mafia for a while because of some weird night action stuff with Damdred and kita or whatever.
Just ignore all that shit, specially in a Greymist game. I mean, obviously dwell on that stuff and have all the fun you can get with 5th party House Chezinu and sleeper cell and self-redirecting magic-bus-driver and whatever. But for lynching and figuring out alignments....yeah, leave it out.
|
On April 08 2015 11:34 Onegu wrote:JAT you told me to trust OwS so he was the only one I shared everything with . Also I tried to play town leader last night I kept everything as close to the vest as I could except with Obi, while getting as much info as I could from everyone else. I started to trust HtS toward the end but couldn't PM directed OwS to bus me and sepulchre.
Did you tell him I was doctor or did they guess that?
|
On April 08 2015 12:07 gonzaw wrote:
I think people may have relied too much on "confirmations" using roles/PMs/etc.
Obi was basically assumed confirmed town because of a town check from someone
BH was basically assumed town the last phases because of some PM thing with Onegu (that I still don't understand)
HTS was basically assumed mafia for a while because of some weird night action stuff with Damdred and kita or whatever.
Just ignore all that shit, specially in a Greymist game. I mean, obviously dwell on that stuff and have all the fun you can get with 5th party House Chezinu and sleeper cell and self-redirecting magic-bus-driver and whatever. But for lynching and figuring out alignments....yeah, leave it out.
I agree. Still fun though haha
|
On April 08 2015 10:59 Crossfire99 wrote:Sorry guys I played pretty terribly. Definitely felt pretty lost most of the game and even when I thought I was sure I was wrong LOL. Probably shouldn't have signed up. I didn't have enough time to play to my standards especially with the amount of posts this game. Probably won't play mafia again at least while the spam is this high. It's just not my thing and I don't like playing with that many posts. I also didn't like pms, but I never played with them so it was something different to try. As for why I did what I did during the last day. I really thought town was in a 4-5-2 situation and that VA was 3rd party and really had to kill bats. I figured town had to take a risk and not lynch bats because if not they would lose due to the amount of KP. I actually thought HtS was mafia and was super sure of that. Obviously, I was wrong. And it was pretty much only hubris that caused me to stick with HtS over Sep who I also agreed was mafia. That was dumb. Even playing terribly, I still had fun. Thanks for hosting GreY! I know it is difficult work and you do a great job! Random fact: During day 3 I death framed VA to get a list of the actions performed on him, so we could figure out once and for all whether or not he was scum. I thought I would get the results immediately, but I misunderstood and would only get results if he was targeted by scum which never happened, so it ended up being for naught. GG everybody.
You did enough for most of us to assume you were town right up until the last post so I'd say that's a good enough job.
|
On April 08 2015 12:13 Snarfs wrote:Show nested quote +On April 08 2015 11:34 Onegu wrote:JAT you told me to trust OwS so he was the only one I shared everything with . Also I tried to play town leader last night I kept everything as close to the vest as I could except with Obi, while getting as much info as I could from everyone else. I started to trust HtS toward the end but couldn't PM directed OwS to bus me and sepulchre. Did you tell him I was doctor or did they guess that?
He told me.
|
On April 08 2015 12:15 Snarfs wrote:Show nested quote +On April 08 2015 10:59 Crossfire99 wrote:Sorry guys I played pretty terribly. Definitely felt pretty lost most of the game and even when I thought I was sure I was wrong LOL. Probably shouldn't have signed up. I didn't have enough time to play to my standards especially with the amount of posts this game. Probably won't play mafia again at least while the spam is this high. It's just not my thing and I don't like playing with that many posts. I also didn't like pms, but I never played with them so it was something different to try. As for why I did what I did during the last day. I really thought town was in a 4-5-2 situation and that VA was 3rd party and really had to kill bats. I figured town had to take a risk and not lynch bats because if not they would lose due to the amount of KP. I actually thought HtS was mafia and was super sure of that. Obviously, I was wrong. And it was pretty much only hubris that caused me to stick with HtS over Sep who I also agreed was mafia. That was dumb. Even playing terribly, I still had fun. Thanks for hosting GreY! I know it is difficult work and you do a great job! Random fact: During day 3 I death framed VA to get a list of the actions performed on him, so we could figure out once and for all whether or not he was scum. I thought I would get the results immediately, but I misunderstood and would only get results if he was targeted by scum which never happened, so it ended up being for naught. GG everybody. You did enough for most of us to assume you were town right up until the last post so I'd say that's a good enough job.
I just resay what I said in my pm to onegu during the night.
The problem is I can't do anything. That whole post was mostly just a charade. I did actually lie about stuff, but I can't use any of my abilities because they are all passive. I am pissed that we lynched HF because he couldn't do anything on his own and could have continued voting with town to kill mafia players until the end. We could have held him hostage until we had the game under town's control. And lynching him doesn't reduce mafia's kp at all which we really needed.
The best I can hope for is drawing mafia's attention to myself and getting them to try to kill me or rb or something. Anyways, hopefully you have crazy plans that can actually do something good tonight. I'm hoping for the best.
|
+ Show Spoiler +Original Message From Trfel: Hi batsnacks  Unfortunately, I've only skimmed the first 80 pages, so I have to read those more carefully, and of course there's another 45 or so pages after that. Nice to play with you again. I don't think we've played since Carol? Original Message From Holyflare: :D:D:D wanna cyber? <3 <3 <3 Original Message From Keirathi: omghi Original Message From LightningStrike: Hey what you think of HF? Original Message From Crossfire99: I don't know you, so I will not respond with hugs and kisses, but maybe if I got to know you better that could change. Who knows? Original Message From Chezitwo: oh my. Hello there. Original Message From Sepulchre: such town much communication Original Message From ObiWanShinobi: ilu2 :D Original Message From rsoultin: o.0 Original Message From WaveofShadow: No I'm mad at you. Original Message From justanothertownie: yawn Original Message From Alakaslam: :D Original Message From Snarfs: Sup! I think I'm on page 103... Started at 50 or so Jesus. Original Message From Blazinghand: ilu Original Message From Koshi: Damn... I thought you were town. Original Message From Half the Sky: LOL Bats, just getting on TL and this is the first thing I see. Original Message From kitaman27: Hi Hi. Holyflare spoke as if you were undoubtedly town. Is this a reasonable stance for him to take?
|
On April 04 2015 02:01 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On April 04 2015 01:45 justanothertownie wrote:On April 02 2015 22:56 VisceraEyes wrote:
Hi boys. I'll get to this game this phase sometime. Pinky swear. What happened to this? I got to it. I wanna lynch VA/BH.
Oh look. VE solves the game and gets shot for it again.
|
On April 08 2015 12:40 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On April 04 2015 02:01 VisceraEyes wrote:On April 04 2015 01:45 justanothertownie wrote:On April 02 2015 22:56 VisceraEyes wrote:
Hi boys. I'll get to this game this phase sometime. Pinky swear. What happened to this? I got to it. I wanna lynch VA/BH. Oh look. VE solves the game and gets shot for it again.
Isn't that kind of mafia's job!?
|
Oh yea, THAT's why I had Cav down as town and just ignored looking again. LS's check had him as town.
Even though I knew it wasn't 100% accurate, it seemed not worth it to think about him until the end game.
Also, random insanely good luck that bats framed OWS night 2, or did you guys know that's who he was checking beforehand?
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
On April 08 2015 12:07 gonzaw wrote:
I think people may have relied too much on "confirmations" using roles/PMs/etc.
Obi was basically assumed confirmed town because of a town check from someone
BH was basically assumed town the last phases because of some PM thing with Onegu (that I still don't understand)
HTS was basically assumed mafia for a while because of some weird night action stuff with Damdred and kita or whatever.
I actually thought the role speculation wasn't all that bad this game.
Damdred was lynched because of his role claim failing to make sense, VA came up as mafia after it was pointed out that his fake claim was missing information, sep and batnsacks were process of elimination reads for never claiming when the rest of the town was, BH would have been dealt with instantly if his third party counter-part ever came forward. Obi was really the only outlier with the green dt check, but that kind of stuff is hard to get around before endgame anyways. I think the HTS stuff was more based on her posts/activity than a role claim, but I could be wrong.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
