|
On February 15 2015 07:23 Fecalfeast wrote:
Gobble as GF actually explains sicklucker's play D2 pretty well but how do you explain SL voting gobble over keir D1? Sicklucker isn't stupid enough to risk a mafia lynch over a free ML is he?
What would you take a bet on, Rayn beign able to push his lynch through without me here pushing my lynch. Or gobble going through without someone vocal pushing?
|
And I mean SL hammering the godfather who was dead in the water if gobble is the gf, would give him town cred till end game
|
Its difficult to look at the context of the thread its possible gobble is town. So much wifom in sls filter
|
On February 15 2015 07:27 Fecalfeast wrote:
I hear you. Are you saying SL rode the gobble wagon and when it came to crunch time realized he couldn't switch to keir at that point? Ok, fine. I'll vote gobble for now.
He made it impossible to switch to keir, and he switched over when rayn was picking his wagon up. He was afking his vote on ows also, so not sure if that means anything.
|
On February 15 2015 07:17 LightningStrike wrote:
Okay I'm back and we got LM claiming Vet and FF claiming Gunsmith so that means we got 2 more blues more than I thought for such a small game o.o I still okay with lynching Gobble since he did waste his vote on me Day 1 and wasn't trying to talk to us except attacking LM. I still feel like 1 of the blues is lieing but idk which one.
##Unvote
##Vote: Gobble
If you are so sure one of the blues is lying though why do you automatically go for gobble instead of trying to figure outw hich one is lying?
|
On February 15 2015 07:51 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On February 15 2015 07:41 Damdred wrote:On February 15 2015 07:17 LightningStrike wrote:
Okay I'm back and we got LM claiming Vet and FF claiming Gunsmith so that means we got 2 more blues more than I thought for such a small game o.o I still okay with lynching Gobble since he did waste his vote on me Day 1 and wasn't trying to talk to us except attacking LM. I still feel like 1 of the blues is lieing but idk which one.
##Unvote
##Vote: Gobble If you are so sure one of the blues is lying though why do you automatically go for gobble instead of trying to figure outw hich one is lying? I buying your thing on why we might really have 4 blues seeing how that game you told me did have a lot blues.so it's possible but I don't like it for balance reasons.
This isn't an aswer though LS, I understand now that's your answer. But at the time of that post why didn't you go after them instead of gobble
|
LS who is the second scum now that we have so much information?
|
What about geript or slam ls are they town?
|
FF if you ever play weaker than this again I will policy lynch you.
|
Why don't you have a firm read on geript? Hes done a few things LS, what do you think about what hes done?
|
On February 15 2015 08:24 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On February 15 2015 08:21 Damdred wrote:
Why don't you have a firm read on geript? Hes done a few things LS, what do you think about what hes done? Like I said he been trying to change his playstyle as far as I remember from Student V but I do have a slight town read based on stuff like his large catch up post and trying to ask questions to people but also he did notice I didn't went full Puppy Mode for a bit and finding it odd on how some of you guys called me town very early.
What about his push on obi?
|
Then whats the conclusion?
|
Here is my thoughts on the setup speculation that's going on.
masons generally are sorta weak in the fact that it doesn't automatically help town. It helps town as two people are confirmed but they still have to use their own logical reasoning skills to figure out the mafia without relying on their powers even if they have a private chat to get things out without mafia interference which is ok but still have to convince the thread.
The kill power that town has is really limited, one it takes a whole cycle for the power to really be put into play. If blocked it takes two cycles to really be useful, if that person is killed its totally eliminated. While its a cool role it is a bit weak.
Vet is a good role as well but its limited just like the other roles are, it protects itself and not others.
I think its pretty balanced it might be a bit town sided but not much as the roles over all are on the weaker side their is no cop or tracker to gather hard evidence and still relies heavier on the logical reasoning of town rather than power usage.
So I think all of the claims make sense, and not much else to say about it.
|
OWS should be off the table today I think.
It should be between Geript, LS and Gobble. Maybe slam but his martyring and some insightful posts have me meh on a slam lynch.
|
Honestly part of the setup is thinking, what if ff gave a gun to scum... Game changes pretty fast in the opposite direction.
But it makes slam meh because he's usually a bit more involved as scum and puts survival first. Here he'd rather get lynched it feels loke
|
Its the better play to lynch into the green claims than the blue claims.
and we gain much less information and lms claim makes sense with the weakness of the other roles.
|
There have been a few setups with four blues and three mafia. Its not the furthest thing plus we still have at least one mafia on the greens which is why id rather not waste a lynch on lm especially since I think he's blue.
Gobble is an ok lynch I think.
Geeipt you just feel weird you are basically policy lynching at this point and not sure why you don't want to hunt in the greens
|
Also claiming blue is honestly a death trap, might or might not save him and it gets more attention on him. Plus the way he reacted to the cop theory adds credence to either lm+ls team or the more likely lm is vet.
|
Really quiet day we have a good 4 1/2 hours left I think. And I will be here for deadline probably.
There was a theory that the lack of push means a dealt inactive mafia at that point. Rayn thinks scum was in the late voters also on SL.
I think it somewhat eliminates slam from the lynch, some things are off about slam he dits into the more inactive but he was a decently early voter on SL and switched to kier. I'd like to not lynch him today and lynch someone else.
OWS really tried to push the thread when it was at a lull and pressed for information, I think he's probably town in all actuality and shouldn't be the lynch.
This leaves me with a gobble geript or ls by poe. I don't think ls fits into inactive mafia and he's been trying to do things. I'd rather not lynch him. It would be informative as lm+ls would be the only team that makes sense with ls in it.
Lm I believe the claim would not lynch at all today.
I think lynching gobble has a few great things to it, it gives us a lot of good information that the thread can use. Besides the information gobble still isn't trying to push his own thoughts is being somewhat noncommital, really gave himself room to move out of voting ows and only has basically mentioned ls since even though obi is a coin flip. Gobble is the best lynch today
|
Meh he tried to lynch me in titanic mafia as his partner. Now, we have to see would a bus on gobble be viable, talk with me about it gobble dead in the water is it worth a bus
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
