EPTOn March 03 2015 23:06 Mocsta wrote:
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/476732-jack-of-all-trades-mafia?user=Breshke&view=all
Bresche filter.
Conclusion: Fairly likely to be mafia
Recommend to be shot
Reasoning
Wishywashy Content
Bresche early filter focuses on the "plan" for town to control the shot after 24hrs.
This is not typically alignment indicative early on, however, it is interesting to note that Bresche has a focus on establishing "town" reads; and not questioning his "scum" reads. Even more so, given that Rayn has been quite active in the thread.
Further, note the confidence Bresche exudes when referring to Tubesock (and to a lesser degree Slam + Koshi + FecalFeast) as town. Everyone knows list collaborations are an easy tool for scum to utilising when feigning contribution. But Bresche begs to differ, offering the generic morsel that this effort is too much to be scum.
Which leads us to
Congruence
I get no focus in his filter. There is talk but none of it has proper conclusions that are reinforced within *THIS* game. His filter has no consistency in thought. Posts within a short duration jump from target to target; which when combined with the tendency to buddy people as town indicate a motive to blend in and offer meaningless contributions.
Possibly best exemplified by:
&
Couple points
Bresche goes into a lot of detail to debunk Epiphany points on Geript, however, at no point takes a stance on Geript OR EPIPHANY
This is critical.
Bresche last 2 paragraphs reads as "Im about to wreck yo", and ends miserley with ... "please post more"
Think about this.. town *WANT* to pursue their scumspects. What we get here is Bresche saying this:
(1) I want you to hang yourself; or,
(2) I want someone else to take the lead with hanging you; or,
(3) I am giving myself flexibilty to pursue or withdraw.
I havent played mafia in about a year, but to me, this has always been indicative of a mafia mentality.
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/476732-jack-of-all-trades-mafia?user=Breshke&view=all
Bresche filter.
Conclusion: Fairly likely to be mafia
Recommend to be shot
Reasoning
Wishywashy Content
Bresche early filter focuses on the "plan" for town to control the shot after 24hrs.
This is not typically alignment indicative early on, however, it is interesting to note that Bresche has a focus on establishing "town" reads; and not questioning his "scum" reads. Even more so, given that Rayn has been quite active in the thread.
Further, note the confidence Bresche exudes when referring to Tubesock (and to a lesser degree Slam + Koshi + FecalFeast) as town. Everyone knows list collaborations are an easy tool for scum to utilising when feigning contribution. But Bresche begs to differ, offering the generic morsel that this effort is too much to be scum.
Which leads us to
Congruence
I get no focus in his filter. There is talk but none of it has proper conclusions that are reinforced within *THIS* game. His filter has no consistency in thought. Posts within a short duration jump from target to target; which when combined with the tendency to buddy people as town indicate a motive to blend in and offer meaningless contributions.
Possibly best exemplified by:
&
Couple points
Bresche goes into a lot of detail to debunk Epiphany points on Geript, however, at no point takes a stance on Geript OR EPIPHANY
This is critical.
Bresche last 2 paragraphs reads as "Im about to wreck yo", and ends miserley with ... "please post more"
Think about this.. town *WANT* to pursue their scumspects. What we get here is Bresche saying this:
(1) I want you to hang yourself; or,
(2) I want someone else to take the lead with hanging you; or,
(3) I am giving myself flexibilty to pursue or withdraw.
I havent played mafia in about a year, but to me, this has always been indicative of a mafia mentality.
Since you want people to talk about this mocsta ill give me view.
First of all rayn was a scumread of mine and i did question him i asked him to explain some of his reads(You quote this post later not sure how you missed it). It was clear he wasn't around so yes i moved on. When rayn returned to the thread he did start explaining this reads which i then understood so i then town read him.
Also about tubesock i never town read him for making a list post. I town read him for trying to form a plan which i believed would turn a more scum favored lynch type into a normal lynch. Not only that but he went to the trouble of compiling everyone's reads and promised he would continue tot ally the vote. I believed this made him town because he was actively trying to make the game better for town.
Your Congruence bit is whatever I talk about what I want to and find it hard to get scum reads on D1 and often just find myself jumping around finding towns.
Onto geript and AT your right I never said what i thought of them. That was more out of frustration because Geript was seemingly not even giving AT a chance so while i was finding everything that AT was saying to be wrong I was at least going to try and give him a chance. He then continued to respond to geript and not to me which caused me to not care about the situation especially since geript still wanted to shoot koshi.
Anyway i think Geript is my top town this game partly because he was the first to go against the idea that i was scum for all the same reasons he has before. AT i have no idea i stopped caring about his alignment I would need to reread.
