TL Mafia LXIX: Carol Of The Bells

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/472628-tl-mafia-lxix-carol-of-the-bells?page=35#691 http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/472628-tl-mafia-lxix-carol-of-the-bells?page=35#699

I assume you're still going for the low-hanging-fruit play but why spoilers?

The amount of people sadly counterbalances this. ;;
setup talk/fluff

I fear the same will happen to me.
useless comment

This is a dangerous thing to assume. If he actually is scrooge then he probably dies night one.

I'm actually really annoyed. As I said earlier, I believe that Scrooge is vital to this game, as he is the primary target of four different roles. He is almost certainly in this game, even if it's not kush. Unfortunately, if Marley is in this game we are probably sunk if Kush is, in fact, Scrooge.

At the same time, if Scrooge dies, we have three useless town roles that could claim.
Everyone understands this, setup talk


Why is this so important to you?
reply to a post directed at someone else


There will almost certainly not be 6 mass murderers. MM is a mafia role, and there can only be as many MMs as mafia. Plus, the game is presumably balanced, so if there are 6 MMs, there is enough town power to compensate.
There was a scrooge claim because someone said there should be a scrooge claim.
setup talk


So, you're claiming a role. Great. Why?
He's claiming 'not named VT' which to most people means 'not joyful child' which was relevant at the time since there was speculation as to who started with presents
*yawn, yawn, skip through a bunch of useless posts around page 43*
What has the use of the other posts you commented on been?

looks like a mafia post, although this may be my intentionally-not-christmas-color tinted glasses. I don't think so. It has the same tone as the post you made before there were 9 votes on you.
"This is a mafia post because your tone is similar to before you were voted" zzz

I put myself into the role of Santa before realizing that I was probably claiming for doing so. I may or may not be Santa.
fluff, nobody would claim santa before getting a check

Joyful child isn't a named VT as far as we know. Elf could just as easily be the named VT.
setup talk


Give it to me pls ;;
useful post to comment on

Reading up on the Froggy posts.
why is this quote here?


So, I got from this that scum hunting is important, but that day 1 lynches are based on poor evidence and therefore shouldn't be done because scum will be lurking, HOWEVER lynching possible lurking scum completely prevents scum hunting. Wahaaaaaat?
misinterpreted post, lynching lurkers hinders scumhinting because you spend 0 time hunting when you lynch a lurker since the only reason is that they are lurking
However, I am OK with his read on me, despite it being one of the most negative ones in the thread. This is, of course, the only reasonable thing I have seen. It has, so far, taken him 6 hours to not come up with a read. He said he was reading through the thread and didn't really give any evidence of this.

Adding to naughty list for now.
The only read in the entire post

I'm disappointed by how much everyone is spamming too. It's like me on other areas of this site.
another comment on posting speed
My mother is leaning over my shoulder and asking why I'm spending so much time on one post. Speeding through thread...


I must have missed it, who said your posts were fluffy? I think they are pretty short but on-topic. You really need to slow down your posting though, you're going to reach the limit soon.
And yes, a lot of your posts are one-liners. Some are two lines.
zzzzzz

? I do this too. Just because you say he's town doesn't mean he has to recuperate. Stop expecting gifts from people. More coal in your stocking.
reciprocate*


Your answer on why you considered my posts towny. Other people seem to think I was restating a lot in the thread and didn't have original content. What parts of my posts do you think were thought-provoking?
decent question
Damdred/OWS: I know you seem to like to compare people to how they were in a recent game you played, but I don't consider this sufficient evidence. One game, unless it is the entirety of one's play or it's very distinctive (see S1CKLuCk3R), could, from my experience, be outdated evidence or an outlier unless it is in line with other games.
'I dislike meta reads' some people think this way

I have 34,000 posts. Would you like to guess how many games of mafia I've played on TL?
zzzzzzzzz

How has his play differed from when you read him scum?
another ok question

27ninjabunnies, Disgruntled Christmas Worker, lynched Day 1
Koshi, Disgruntled Christmas Worker, killed Night 1
kitaman27, Disgruntled Christmas Worker, killed Night 1
Damdred, Joyful Child, killed Night 1
kushm4sta, Town Scrooge, killed Night 1
LoneMeow, Town Carol Singer, killed Night 1
KelsierSC, Mafia Branch Manager, lynched Day 2
Trfel, Town Santa, killed Night 2
ObiWanShinobi, Town Arnold, killed Night 2