On May 05 2014 01:17 Yell0w wrote:So because I haven't been posting much today, ima give you my reads right now, I feel they're pretty weak, I just don't seem to be as convinced as others that Epishade is mafia so here I go.
Bunnies: Pretty convinced she's town, she seems really genuine.
Eden: I thought he was suspicious all the way through day 1, but the fact that he keeps changing his minds on things, especially on me, while he could probably have gotten an easy lynch if he pushed makes me think he's a townie trying to get information and lynch a mafia, not just lynch the easy target.
Epishade: I had him as town before when he defended me at the beginning, but then I felt like he was trying to hard to make himself known as the guy who would be town if we mislynched me day 1, and then day 2 he immediately wants to lynch me while still thinking I'm town. Not convinced he's mafia though, I can see his play making sense if he's town. I also don't buy the argument that he's mafia because he voted to lynch a town. He was one of the first, if not the first, to say Sweetfrost was suspicious, and he was suspicious, so Epishade's vote makes sense and the BW on Sweetfrost happened after his vote.
sqrt: I found him pretty suspicious since pretty early in the game, I think most people did, just the way he posts, always short with minimum info on anything, mostly just asking weird questions to people. My biggest concern is his vote, he was the last to vote on Sweetfrost and his reason was that the general consensus is that he's mafia, that's some pretty hardcore bandwagoning. And his vote saved tamburini, I think a mafia sqrt would want to save a vigi tamburini because he was going to shoot a town (me). Would be fine with lynching him right now.
Tamburini: So that guy... I really don't like the way he played this game, but I guess I believe he's vigi, it's the most likely scenario, I'm not sure why everyone believe he cannot possibly be mafia though? It seems like everyone thinks he's vigi or maybe sk, but not mafia, I think he could be mafia and not have been roleblocked at all. I don't like that he's trying to lynch me again when he can just kill me if he's vigi, and I would be dead by now if he never claimed vigi and just played a better day 1. So I'd say most likely vigi, but I'm not convinced at all.
ritoky: I guess he seems mostly town, only thing I don't like is he was the only one to vote against ahs but didn't do anything to convince others that ahs was scummy and he didn't do much to defend Sweetfrost from a lynch despite that he thought Sweetfrost was town. Even Amiko pointed out that nobody was defending Sweetfrost. Maybe 63% town
People who are flying under the radar by barely posting:dfs: No idea, hasn't posted enough, but he's the most town of the four barely active players though in my mind.
mysterymeat: He said he was going to be more active, he has barely been more active, a little at the beginning but then stopped, his read on dfs makes no sense to me, but I don't know why he would do it if he was mafia either. I kind of want to hear more from him, but would not be opposed to lynching him.
ahs: That guy's definitely fishy, I especially didn't like the post where he just shows up to make a recap of what others said without adding any kind of opinion to what was said. And then he just votes for mysterymeat, probably the easiest of targets. By not voting against one of the possible people getting lynched that day, he doesn't put himself in the crosshair.
dravernor: That guy just showed up a few time, hasn't posted yet in day 2 too btw, and everytime he makes a big post not saying anything, I mean he made a huge paragraph about me saying he was on the fence, then he wasn't, then he was, and other useless things, not saying why I was suspicious at all. This whole post is huge and lacks any kind of new information. In the end of that post, he votes against Epishade, and I have absolutely no clue why. The only thing he seems to disagree with others was Amiko and bunnies, he thought they were looking too town for him I guess. So I'd like to think he's mafia, but my concern is he doesn't seem to be with anybody at all, so if he's mafia I have no clue with whom.
So in conclusion, I don't have any strong scum reads right now, I know, I suck, I think I'm missing something or that the mafias are being inactive and letting us kill each other, I'm going to think about it all and I hope I find a strong suspect before the end of the day, but right now I'd be fine with a sqrt lynch or one of the 4 inactive people.
EPT
