Catastrophe Mafia - Page 19

On April 13 2014 04:06 austinmcc wrote:
You hear the ABBA, but you clearly do not read with the blue eyes of the swedes.

I'm not suggesting oats is townie or town. I'm trying to understand what geript is thinking when he posts these:

On April 13 2014 04:19 austinmcc wrote:
DI, i got...nothing in particular to ask about that. I generally believe it, just because you weren't looking scummy and apparently have been doing some townie stuff.

My only real question I guess is that you seem concerned with JAT throughout your filter, but not with Amiko much. I can understand "makes sense that there could be another survivor", but ... you didn't question his claim at all because of that? Or question just general play / claimed item abilities / comment about not being sure about committing himself to ABBA.

On April 13 2014 05:59 Palmar wrote:
So boring that you can't lynch people.

Like this game is pointless to play for about a week while we try to kill the claimed 3p people (amiko/oats/jat).

I'll be afk and voting.

On April 13 2014 06:06 Palmar wrote:

Fuck off, killing non-town is always the correct play and if it isn't the game is dumb and I don't care.

On April 13 2014 08:16 strongandbig wrote:


Don't forget GM has roles sometimes where people become interesting after some event (like Bruce Wayne, who became batman after his parents died)

Anyways, this is the first vt claim, right? So I like it.

On April 13 2014 08:55 strongandbig wrote:
Alright I'm staying locked on target.

On April 13 2014 16:51 geript wrote:

I agree. We should be lynching JAT instead of you. We should be shooting you in the face.

On April 14 2014 03:24 strongandbig wrote:
Come on guys we can't let the thread die like this.

The game is not solved! Our confirmed townies are dropping like flies and we still don't know for sure who the scum are.

So here's something to talk about.

Postulate: if scum could, they would have used the prince of darkness power on day 2. Either to cancel the pms, or to cancel the double lynch. The fact that they didnt suggests two things to me.

One: the chaos counter was not high enough. We have seen this game that strong town powers have changed the chaos (eg blazinghand), and it's reasonable to expect the same of strong scum powers.
Two: the scum player with that power was not present on day 2 to use it.

So I think it could have come either from djodref/geript or killing. Killing's power triggered something on lsb, and reduced the chaos counter; the day phase ended right after lsb died. On the other hand, djodref was not in the thread on the pm day, and the prince of darkness power was used immediately after geript joined the game.

So we need to be talking about those players (plus VE, who put a green check on djodref) IMO and not just waiting for oatsmaster to die.