Newbie Mini Mafia XLII - Page 66

On June 13 2013 14:01 fferyllt wrote:
I think it is possible.

And I don't think scum Xzav would have changed his vote and then changed it again five minutes later. All it did was call attention to him. He could have stayed on Gotard and been much less visible.

I think we are looking for scum in the minor wagons and on the Firere wagon. Not on the Gotard wagon.

On June 13 2013 14:05 fferyllt wrote:
yeah, I saw that.

One vote is not a big deal.

To me the bigger issue is going through the process of elimination and removing players from the lynch pool based on good reasoning. Because, the bigger the lynch pool, the more likely the final scum will win.

On June 13 2013 15:27 fferyllt wrote:
Case for iV being scum (some of these may be null)

- argued against the yavanna case
- hopped the Firere bandwagon as it started to gain steam and look inevitable. Had a list of 3 for the day 1 lynch
- Skanjab died after masoning him night 1
- Stayed off the Lonemeow wagon. Voted Xzav, then Umasi
- JK means he may have been the protected victim, may also mean he was the blocked killer
- Has floated a few names on day 3 and apparently has no plans to POE his list of 4 before wagonning.
- Is not leading, despite being perceived as town by p much all.
- warmed up to yavanna as potential scum only after day 1, when she was a modkill possibility.
- minimized possibility that kill went missing because he was blocked.*

Case against iV being scum

- Day 1 gambit got the game rolling in a good direction
- Good protown general advice on stuff not to do in mafia.
- Skanjab read him as town, masoned him, self-proclaimed track record of reading him correctly**

* could be a style thing. If I were JK'd I'd make sure that possibility was kept in mind.
** strongest reason to think he's town IMO.


I'm still working on my Onego case.

- argued against the yavanna case

- hopped the Firere bandwagon as it started to gain steam and look inevitable. Had a list of 3 for the day 1 lynch

- Skanjab died after masoning him night 1

- Stayed off the Lonemeow wagon. Voted Xzav, then Umasi

- JK means he may have been the protected victim, may also mean he was the blocked killer

- warmed up to yavanna as potential scum only after day 1, when she was a modkill possibility.

- minimized possibility that kill went missing because he was blocked.*

On June 13 2013 10:34 Umasi wrote:
okay onegu, I will try to explain why. This is literally the best I can do, to tell you why I'm town
I'm not responding to your posts, I'm responding to...I don't know what I'm responding to.
But rationalize this question:
two things, actually:


A: If I am scum, why have I drawn so much attention to myself, and

B: Why have I not been lynched yet.

What about me is towny enough that people are not voting me?

On June 13 2013 11:07 fferyllt wrote:
As scum, I would not hesitate to bus a scum partner. If I thought the wagon was going to go through, I would get on it before it was a foregone conclusion.

I have literally done this minutes before the town pile-on started and looked like I was in front and leading the way. More than once.

If I were scum, I most likelly would have been on the Firere wagon. I would have gotten on it a little bit later than when I did, but early enough not to look like I"d given up on the wagon fading away.

This stuff about nobody bussing Firere is not surefire.

Not

at

all

On June 08 2013 17:27 Onegu wrote:


I put my vote on someone I thought was scum, why is that a bad thing. I am not the only one either. I wanted to check back in before the deadline but I slept. I dont think me voteing for someone who may or maynot be lynched is such a bad thing, I didnt have strong feelings on either of the two main canidates for myself to justify puting a vote on them.

On June 13 2013 21:41 iVLosK! wrote:

Let me just point out that KP is not roleblockable. Because apparently nobody knows. If I was jailed and I had KP, my KP would still go through. KP is something that's held by the mafia faction, not any individual player.