|
I as well would like to see what Release and Mordanis have to say.
On giving Golden the benefit of the doubt..I wasn't 100% sure on him when I posted my case. He had the benefit of the doubt with me until he posted his defense. I was ready to read what he had to say to defend himself, consider it objectively, and compare it to my read. To me though, his defense was just so far off the mark. Maybe I'm not being lenient enough, but I dont think so this time.
I understand that you want to see more from him, and that's fine. So do I. Everyone will have to decide for themselves.
|
Mods, can I (humbly) ask you to line out sciberbia on page 1 player list? thank you!
|
the vote is tonight, I'm pretty sure
|
On May 25 2012 08:32 VisceraEyes wrote:Day 2![[image loading]](http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-OV5vg9LU2mE/TthjCjFlUII/AAAAAAAACmI/XFgWdXHbjoo/s1600/crime_scene_mgmt1_2405.gif) Twas the night before Friday and all through the house, not a creature was stirring…except for the two scummy bastards killing people. After a quick glance, you realize one of your member has indeed not joined you. sciberbia the Vanilla Townie has been…taken care of. You have ~48 hours from this post to decide who you wish to destroy next.
This post signaled the end of night 1 and the start of day 2. Posted on may 25th 08:32 KST.
it is now may 27th 08:26 KST. The lynch is definitely right now.
|
Ugh, I don't even know what to say. I think this puts us at LYLO after the scum night kill.
I take responsibility for driving this, but I really thought we had something here.
|
|
|
gg and good luck guys. wish i had been of more help.
|
We came sooooo close to a correct lynch on day 1. Gah. I feel I played pretty badly. What's the use of huge analytical posts if the conclusions you draw are wrong >.< We had a chance to get Milton a second time on the day I pushed hard for the Golden lynch. In the absence of that case, I think Milton would have been the favorite. Granted, Mordanis did start the suspicion on Golden...I pretty much played right into their hands by doing the grunt work on the case. In my defense though I had started working on it before Mordanis mentioned him.
I think it's funny how easy it was to scumread after I was out of the game. Without any pressure to post/read I guessed Milton/Mordanis, while in-game I was defending both of them.
GG to all, and nice job by mafia for keeping us fooled.
|
I'm curious to know what others were thinking about me tunneling shiaopi on day 1. Did this make me look scummy?
|
hegeo,
My reading of your big post just prior to death was very much affected because I was trying to consider the argument as a package deal. It became difficult to separate Mordanis from Release...I mistakenly cleared Mordanis because I was so sure Release was town. You made some good points about Mordanis; coupled with what he posted just before and after your death, it was definitely enough to pursue. The biggest moment for me was this:
On May 24 2012 08:39 Mordanis wrote:Show nested quote +On May 24 2012 08:37 ShiaoPi wrote:
Just finished reading it.
Sadly it is too late to get some discussion on that post before lynch.
Mordanis your timing is incredibly scary. Especially just that single remark in the entire post stuck you as most important to respond to?
Either you are a really fast reader or we just had a knee-jerk from you.
Anyway, really waiting for the flip now... I only read a little bit..... And I just explained why. Anyways I'm off to work. Here's hoping for some red!!
Not sure how I let myself forget this. The way you doggedly pursued the case even when your death was assured (only a townie would do this) made Mordanis 'hope for red' extremely suspect. I think it was because sciberbia said that it was weird I was so sure you were town at that point, but I really should have trusted my logic and stayed on the trail you blazed.
|
Yea I even made a conscious effort to do that after Mattchew harped on it in Holy Roman Mafia. Its a shame I let it slide at one of the key points in the game. There was definitely information to be had surrounding the event of hegeo's lynch.
That aside, I'm amazed at how small the margin of error was in this game. That's part of the territory for mini set-ups though I suppose. Our day 1 medic mislynch meant we HAD to get day 2 right, otherwise we end up at day 3 with 3 townies (1 inactive) and 2 scum. This is what happened obviously...I chuckle when I think that Milton and Mordanis could have scum-claimed on day 3 and still wouldn't have been lynched.
|
Marvel can you point out Milton's posts that made you read him as scum?
|
thank you for the analysis post sloosh, i enjoyed the read
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
