On March 07 2012 20:45 GMarshal wrote:
As a reminder, if you are playing in this game, you cannot be playing in any other games, thus if you /ined but also /ined for another game I did not add you to the player list.

Hmm ... ooops! I'm guessing you're talking about me. I'll /out the JubJub game then, since it still looks a ways off.

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

March 10 2012 02:57 GMT

#62

On March 10 2012 11:40 GMarshal wrote:
Game will start tomorrow.

Yaaaaaay!

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

March 12 2012 01:45 GMT

#123

Sup guys! My first post in this game, sorry it took so late!

It's hard to read someone based on the first half of the first day. On this whole Nova Terra/Cosine discussion, the only thing that stood out to me was Nova Terra's behavior, accusing and pushing on cosine (in a somewhat impatient manner), turning defensive when he's called out on it and then forgiving cosine after his post, seeming willing to go to the next topic. Being overly aggressive is not a usual day 1 mafia trait, but quickly turning defensive if called out some something is. Still, he is being active, so time will tell whether it was just a bit of town inexperience/carelessness or something more.

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

March 12 2012 01:46 GMT

#124

We have Koritora, Phagga, Elean and Inferno lurking as of this moment.

On March 12 2012 10:22 koritora wrote:
However, to lynch a lurker is not a bad thing. It's not helping anyone in the town. As for people against lynching on the Day 1, that's where my suspicion lies.

Sure, Koritora, we could single out Inferno (or whoever you're actually referring to) for not being dead set on lynching without cause, but I don't think this is scum behavior per se. The fact that he actually has an opinion and wrote a bit on it, though, is good for singling him out if he does have a scummy attitude later on. Your post, on the other hand, doesn't add anything to the discussion and doesn't even have enough content so that we can use it to analyse you later on. So, how about putting a little more effort?

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

March 12 2012 14:29 GMT

#143

On March 12 2012 14:58 Nova_Terra wrote:

Show nested quote +

What is your point here? I didnt accuse him, i fos'ed him. two co pletely separate things, at least in my eyes. The pyshing on him was wanting him to respond, as was the point of my fos. I also wanted other people, like yourself, to come out of their lurking and post on this. I got frustrated when they started saying Nova_Terra is extremely eager to FoS because i was like... OH Really?!?! and then they went on to use my logic to say that he was suspicious. thats why i was mad. not exactly defensive, but frustrated at the town. Then, cosine posted exactly what i had been looking for, generating intelligent discussion. if by "willing to go onto the next topic" you mean "making new ideas that help the town and dont tunnel one person" i agree.

please dont discredit my posting by calling it "inexperience/carelessness or something more" especially when this is your FIRST POST. later on i will come and explain why YOUR post seems suspicious to me.

for now, im thinking eleanthas.

You didn't accuse him? Short of actually voting for the fellow, threatening to vote for someone is as accusatory as it gets:
+ Show Spoiler +

On March 12 2012 01:57 Nova_Terra wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yeah, it was a funny coincedence that he posted that right before i woke up. i also pointed out the post before how the suspicion should also be on me. The thing is though, his post was extremely messed up and seemed very scummy. i definitely think it is worth an FOS seeing as nothing else was happening and i want him to clarify it up. its not like i voted for him yet or anything.

On March 12 2012 01:59 Nova_Terra wrote:
EBWOP: and if cosine doesnt post and we dont get any other leads i feel that he would be a good lynch candidate.

Also, why so angry? Why do you insist (once again) on explaining the motives for your change of atitude? I pointed out that you were quick to turn defensive (or frustrated, as you say) when you were called out on it and it is my opinion that this is suspicious behavior, but that this doesn't matter for now because it is not worth it to push on a talkative (potential) mafia because there will be plenty of time for you to slip up later on if you really are scum. Now your answer is to threaten me, calling me suspicious?

Anyway, question here: if the we agree to lynch a lurker, how are we gonna go about it? Bandwagon on the first non-replied accusation? At this point, besides Elean, we can consider a Inferno as a lurker. His post may not be contradictory like Elean (as in, he doesn't call himself worthless and suggests himself to be lynched), but he also hasn't contributed to the thread. Firmtofu looked like he was gonna participate but also hasn't said anything.

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

March 12 2012 19:57 GMT

#159

In terms of lack of posts, Firm and Inferno are the same, but since Firm was dead set of lynching lurkers, I suppose it is only appropriate for him to go first. I still hope both him and Inferno will show up and talk before the voting is finalized we can avoid this.

##Vote FirmTofu

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

March 13 2012 01:02 GMT

#176

Given that we're this far into the voting and Firm still hasn't showed up, I'm thinking he's simply given up on the game. Since there's a good chance he may be replaced by our host, I'm gonna change my vote to No Lynch.

I suggest somebody else who voted for him stay online until the voting deadline and change the vote at the last minute if he still hasn't given signs of life. Voting is mandatory as per OP, so not voting makes him liable to be replaced (or modkilled). If he shows up and votes at the very last minute without saying anything, we can assume it's scummy behavior and possibly lynch him tomorrow.

Of course, this assumes he is not mafia, but usually being mafia (and town PRs, for that matter) make playing more exiting, so I don't think it's a bad assumption.

##Unvote: FirmTofu
##Vote: No Lynch

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

March 13 2012 01:09 GMT

#177

On March 13 2012 10:02 Sbrubbles wrote:
Given that we're this far into the voting and Firm still hasn't showed up, I'm thinking he's simply given up on the game. Since there's a good chance he may be replaced by our host, I'm gonna change my vote to No Lynch.

I suggest somebody else who voted for him stay online until the voting deadline and change the vote at the last minute if he still hasn't given signs of life. Voting is mandatory as per OP, so not voting makes him liable to be replaced (or modkilled). If he shows up and votes at the very last minute without saying anything, we can assume it's scummy behavior and possibly lynch him tomorrow.

Of course, this assumes he is not mafia, but usually being mafia (and town PRs, for that matter) make playing more exiting, so I don't think it's a bad assumption.

##Unvote: FirmTofu
##Vote: No Lynch

Hmm, here's a vote tally:

FirmTofu:
phagga
Eleantheas
Janaan
Gossemerr
Memetoss
Infernookami
Seviro
cosine

Gossemerr:
NovaTerra

No Lynch:
Sbrubbles
koritora

I just realised that for what I said to work we would need another person to switch to No Lynch and a third person stay up to the deadline. It's up to you guys if you want to go through with this or take a chance on having him replaced.