EPTTL Mafia XLV - Page 13
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Mig
United States4714 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
On September 28 2011 20:23 jcarlsoniv wrote: The role list says not all roles are guaranteed to be in the game, but is it possible for there to be roles that aren't on the list? No, only the roles listed in the OP are present | ||
|
tnkted
United States1359 Posts
On September 28 2011 20:45 supersoft wrote: town doesn't have to know who is muted. Only scum wants to know who is muted, because amongst these people, are the snipers. therefor I'd suggest, that noone claims that he's muted anymore. I disagree, I think we SHOULD know who is muted. There are going to be enough muted players anyway that if the mafia shoots into them, they'll have a small chance of hitting someone town, and if they do, its guarrenteed to be a person who isn't being an active townie behind the scenes, pming away, with a smaller chance of someone who is useful to town. Will mafia take that gamble? No, they're going to kill the town organizer, because an organized town is much more scary than a single vig. So I'm going to PM everybody and see who responds. I'll post the results tmrw when I get back to the internet If you don't want people to know if you're mute or not, don't respond, but I encourage you to do so. More info for town = better town play. | ||
|
sinani206
United States1959 Posts
On September 28 2011 22:56 tnkted wrote: I disagree, I think we SHOULD know who is muted. There are going to be enough muted players anyway that if the mafia shoots into them, they'll have a small chance of hitting someone town, and if they do, its guarrenteed to be a person who isn't being an active townie behind the scenes, pming away, with a smaller chance of someone who is useful to town. Will mafia take that gamble? No, they're going to kill the town organizer, because an organized town is much more scary than a single vig. So I'm going to PM everybody and see who responds. I'll post the results tmrw when I get back to the internet If you don't want people to know if you're mute or not, don't respond, but I encourage you to do so. More info for town = better town play. I'm mute, so I'm not answering. | ||
|
tnkted
United States1359 Posts
Should people who are burned at night claim, so that medic can choose to protect them, or what? that tells mafia where the medic is gonna be, but mafia can just fakeclaim a burn and draw the medic too. I'm uncomfortable with introducing a town mechanic that allows mafia to manipulate the medic that way. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
On September 28 2011 22:56 tnkted wrote: I disagree, I think we SHOULD know who is muted. There are going to be enough muted players anyway that if the mafia shoots into them, they'll have a small chance of hitting someone town, and if they do, its guarrenteed to be a person who isn't being an active townie behind the scenes, pming away, with a smaller chance of someone who is useful to town. Will mafia take that gamble? No, they're going to kill the town organizer, because an organized town is much more scary than a single vig. So I'm going to PM everybody and see who responds. I'll post the results tmrw when I get back to the internet If you don't want people to know if you're mute or not, don't respond, but I encourage you to do so. More info for town = better town play. I'll save you the trouble. You and DropBear have both PMed me. I won't be responding to either. | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
Overseer is watching you... | ||
|
Curu
Canada2817 Posts
If you haven't been PMed by Mig yet, please post so in the thread. | ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
| ||
|
Curu
Canada2817 Posts
| ||
|
Erandorr
2283 Posts
On September 28 2011 22:56 tnkted wrote: I disagree, I think we SHOULD know who is muted. There are going to be enough muted players anyway that if the mafia shoots into them, they'll have a small chance of hitting someone town, and if they do, its guarrenteed to be a person who isn't being an active townie behind the scenes, pming away, with a smaller chance of someone who is useful to town. Will mafia take that gamble? No, they're going to kill the town organizer, because an organized town is much more scary than a single vig. So I'm going to PM everybody and see who responds. I'll post the results tmrw when I get back to the internet If you don't want people to know if you're mute or not, don't respond, but I encourage you to do so. More info for town = better town play. huh? Dont they have 100 percent chance of shooting town , since, you know, they know who each other is? | ||
|
tnkted
United States1359 Posts
On September 29 2011 00:22 Erandorr wrote: huh? Dont they have 100 percent chance of shooting town , since, you know, they know who each other is? Yes, they do, but it's guarrenteed to be a townie that isn't PMing. It doesn't make sense for mafia to shoot into that. | ||
|
Lucidity
South Africa603 Posts
On September 28 2011 23:50 Curu wrote: 12+ hours in and Mig still hasn't PMed everyone in the game, keep an eye on him. That's almost enough to lynch him on its own. Mig not interested in PMs? What? | ||
|
Mig
United States4714 Posts
| ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
On September 29 2011 00:57 Mig wrote: If a medic heals a burn victim does it inform the medic that he healed them? Medic is never noticed about successful heal. | ||
|
NotChezinu
Zimbabwe61 Posts
On September 28 2011 23:17 tnkted wrote: Also, I agree with mig about the Engineer watcher/medic but for different reasons. I think the extra medic is a waste in a game in which 1. we already have a medic and 2. There are only 4.5 kp floating around, only 2.5 of which belong to scum. Don't even THINK about getting the dispenser station. That's just asking for more KP. Should people who are burned at night claim, so that medic can choose to protect them, or what? that tells mafia where the medic is gonna be, but mafia can just fakeclaim a burn and draw the medic too. I'm uncomfortable with introducing a town mechanic that allows mafia to manipulate the medic that way. You seem to have vaster knowledge than the rest of us mortals. How are you aware of the presence of 4.5 KP? You know the mafia has 2.5kp? The presence of a medic is a certainty? Truly you are wise. Or perhaps foolish, I'll leave that up to observation. Also let the record show that jcarlsoniv is probably mafia, so if I'm on your team jcarlsoniv I would appreciate an informative PM informing me. | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
On September 29 2011 01:05 NotChezinu wrote: You seem to have vaster knowledge than the rest of us mortals. How are you aware of the presence of 4.5 KP? You know the mafia has 2.5kp? The presence of a medic is a certainty? Truly you are wise. Or perhaps foolish, I'll leave that up to observation. Also let the record show that jcarlsoniv is probably mafia, so if I'm on your team jcarlsoniv I would appreciate an informative PM informing me. I am? Interesting. But then...if I were mafia, and you were on my team, wouldn't that also make you mafia? O_o | ||
|
NotChezinu
Zimbabwe61 Posts
On September 29 2011 01:14 jcarlsoniv wrote: I am? Interesting. But then...if I were mafia, and you were on my team, wouldn't that also make you mafia? O_o It would, which is why I would appreciate you telling me if I am on your team! I need some outside data before I can observe my role PM! Quantum uncertanty is hard. | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
On September 28 2011 22:56 tnkted wrote: I disagree, I think we SHOULD know who is muted. There are going to be enough muted players anyway that if the mafia shoots into them, they'll have a small chance of hitting someone town, and if they do, its guarrenteed to be a person who isn't being an active townie behind the scenes, pming away, with a smaller chance of someone who is useful to town. Will mafia take that gamble? No, they're going to kill the town organizer, because an organized town is much more scary than a single vig. So I'm going to PM everybody and see who responds. I'll post the results tmrw when I get back to the internet If you don't want people to know if you're mute or not, don't respond, but I encourage you to do so. More info for town = better town play. One thing about publicly revealing who is mute and who is not, is that the fewer people that scum knows are mute, the easier it would be to hit the Blu sniper, just by sheer probability. I'm not sure how many people would start the game mute (sinani has claimed it so far). | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
On September 29 2011 01:18 NotChezinu wrote: It would, which is why I would appreciate you telling me if I am on your team! I need some outside data before I can observe my role PM! Quantum uncertanty is hard. Oh of course! Silly me, I forgot you were playing Schrodinger's Role. Although I don't think I could help you much. I don't know anything about quantum uncertainty, I'm just a lowly math major! | ||
| ||
