EPTTL Mafia XXXVII - Page 65
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
| ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
Am I reading it right, or is it all based on one PM? (And also how LD is a bit more inactive than usual?) | ||
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
| ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
![[image loading]](http://imgur.com/zo6ON.jpg) [img]http://imgur.com/zo6ON.jpg[/img] | ||
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On March 02 2011 00:38 LSB wrote: I don't get the LD lynch. Am I reading it right, or is it all based on one PM? (And also how LD is a bit more inactive than usual?) I mean, it's all circumstantial evidence but it's all we have to go on right now. OK BACK TO WORK NO TL!!! see you guys tomorrow! | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
Then again, it's not his first game. I'll look at how he played in Orgah | ||
|
RebirthOfLeGenD
USA5860 Posts
| ||
|
gryffindor
United States524 Posts
On March 01 2011 23:52 JBright wrote: Well, that was something I wrote right before I went to sleep, so I wasn't going to answer any more until later. Going back to SA's axis of evil, I already gave my (non)opinion on LD, but what about Seraph? Since I haven't been too active myself, I can hardly point my fingers at another low activity player. He seems to come on in spurts during each day/night cycle and didn't have very much to say except for his latest post. I didn't think too much of it, but I suppose the part about the icemac analysis seems strange. There was only ~20 min before the end of voting, so who was he really trying to convince? Won't be reading this until at least 9pm Eastern, so I'll place my vote now. Since I've already thrown around some FoS, might as well vote for one of them. I believe that townies tend to play more aggressive in terms of scum hunting, so I'll keep my vote off GM and SA for now. If LD does post before voting ends, I could be persuaded to vote for him. I'll just go with gryffindor since he's the third of my gut picks. ##Vote: Gryffindor I have actually been defending most of the bigger wagons to people in PMs. 1) why did you feel the need to use parenthesis here? I have only seen scum do that 2) why would you vote for the 3rd of your gut reads? That looks suspicious. @LSB 1) why are you defending LD? 2) you cut out the pimp shoes 3) I feel like you are fake-defending JBright to cover up your actual wanting to keep LD alive | ||
|
deconduo
Ireland4122 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + The Axis: Lunar, Seraph, JBright These guys have been lumped together as scum by the allies. To be honest, I feel the case against them is weak at best, but I'm not very good at scumhunting. Still, I don't think Lunar responded too well to the case against him. He also has enough experience to know that self-voting and defeatism is somewhat of a town tell. Seraph had a similar amount of posts in Pokemafia and only slightly more in XXXV at this point (30 vs 50) JBright I dunno, don't have a read on him really. The Allies: Foolishness, Ser Aspi, LSB Ser Aspi is pretty obviously parroting what Foolishness has said. I put LSB in this group due to Foolishness swooping in out of nowhere to save his ass by switching the bandwagon to LD. I think if Foolishness is mafia then I'd be pretty certain about the other two as well. Not the other way around however. Similarly if Lunar is mafia I'd probably cross off Foolishness and LSB. I doubt mafia would bus two days in a row. The weird posting: Gryff, Coag, Bumatlarge, Jackal58 Gryff should be obvious. Coag has 110 posts in the game, all of them one liners. He has voted for people without explanation or reasoning. Bum has so few posts in the game I'm surprised no one has picked up on it. If Foolishness is focusing on different playstyles, this should be pretty obvious yet he hasn't mentioned it at all. Jackal is here because of his bizarre opinions on posting PMs and use of logic. Lurking: ohN - 4 posts, not short ones but nothing big enough to get noticed. Said he would contribute more but hasn't so far. why - Seems to sheep a fair bit. He hasn't really offered any of his own opinions as far as I can see, just tagged on to others. Not a lot of posts. LastA - Has some opinions at least, not a lot of posts either though. Cubed - Somewhat inactive also, but has an excuse. kevconsim - More posts than the rest but mostly spam/one liners. Others: GMarshal, chaoser, Barundar If anything, my gut says they are more likely to be town. Voting patterns: + Show Spoiler + Same votes: LSB: Annul, Icemac chaoser: annul, Icemac Gryff: annul, icemac Cubed: annul, icemac kevconsim: annul, icemac Coag: gryff, JBright Jackal58: gryff, Jbright Axis of evil? Lunar: Icemac, Lunar Seraph: Ican, Icemac JBright: JBright, Icemac One green Ican/bum: icemac, LSB why: Icemac, Lunar Ser Aspi: Mr Wig, Lunar One red decon: annul, LSB Unknown Foolishness: Seraph, LD Barundar: Jackal, LSB LastA: ican, LSB GMarshal:Ican, JBright ohn: gryff, Lunar Mafia kills*: Darmousseh: annul Kitaman27: darmousseh Mr. Wiggles: annul Kenpachi: kenpachi, icemac Beneather: icemac, icemac OriginalName: icemac, lunar *Possible vig day 2 Other: + Show Spoiler + Vig claiming now would be kind of reassuring. Don't forget that you are essentially a normal townie now so theres no real reason to stay quiet. If there was no vig shot then we are very close to lylo judging by the KP. Either that or one of LSB/Jackal is lying about being roleblocked for whatever reason. The kills last night were strange also. None of the three had been doing anything interesting and curiously, none of them had voted for annul in the day 1 lynch. In addition they had all been voting for town, except possibly ON's 2nd vote. | ||
|
deconduo
Ireland4122 Posts
Between the three I think I'd be most suspicious of Lunar. Similar to LSB I don't think he defended himself well against the accusation. Vote:LunarDestiny | ||
|
CubEdIn
Romania5359 Posts
I watched him from a scum perspective, and he was a bit of a thorn in our pawn. This game, however, I barely noticed him. Still, I expected that if he were scum, he would have become more active once the FoS was pointing at him, but he hasn't, so I'm not completely dismissing the possibility that he's simply being less active for this one. But yeah I do agree with one thing wholeheartedly: get the lurkers to talk. Someone in PM told me that people might be lurking due to the fact that they're medics or such and don't want to be sticking out, but mafia already knows who's mafia, so the green/blue lurkers WILL stick out like a sore thumb to them, especially if they don't start talking and town doesn't cast any blame on them. See Mafia XXXVI's Mr.Wiggles and BrownBear for example. At the end of the game I had to guess who medic was, and I picked one of these two. BB was medic and Wiggles was Mason. And it was obvious because town was protecting them. So, yeah, bottom line is, get everyone to talk. Let's start with... ohN. Are you even part of this game? | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
@LSB 1) why are you defending LD? The lynch sucks 3) I feel like you are fake-defending JBright to cover up your actual wanting to keep LD alive Again, I feel like its another "iceman" esq lynch. This time I don't even think he supported Annul. | ||
|
LunarDestiny
United States4177 Posts
On March 01 2011 21:40 Jackal58 wrote: Which I answered. Perhaps my answer was too simple. Posting PMs in my opinion is an easy way for scum to influence town. Particular at end game. That is "IN MY OPINION". If you disagree with my opinion fine. It's not worthy of an argument. Unless you are scum and wish to appear that you are contributing. Because that's all it is. Appearance. And ![[image loading]](http://www.powderblueorbit.com/2wm3x36.gif) Just noting that I am currently busy and will respond to this along with my promised respond to Ser Aspi tonight. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
O_o | ||
GMarshal
United States22154 Posts
| ||
|
Coagulation
United States9633 Posts
| ||
|
Coagulation
United States9633 Posts
From: gryffindor [ 321 posts | Profile | Buddy | Report ] Subject: mafi Date: 3/1/11 21:23 why are you voting JBright with a nearly RVS-style post on d3? Can you not make a case? Like, are you completely incapable of giving proper reasoning? someone doesnt want jbright lynched? | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
On March 02 2011 06:21 GMarshal wrote: Yep, so I think its safe to assume that the vigi isn't going to claim (meaning there was no vigi shot), which presents us with an issue, either scum have 3.5+ kp or someone is lying... Was anybody role blocked during night 1? If somebody claimed it I missed it. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
Didn't have to be rb. Dammit GM you're scaring me. Wtf is this "Super Mafia"? | ||
|
GMarshal
United States22154 Posts
| ||
| ||
