[S2] World Championships Discussion - Page 607
Forum Index > LoL Tournaments |
Keep the rage to a minimum. This includes wait times between games, music, and balance. Fair warning to all. | ||
LaNague
Germany9118 Posts
| ||
Redox
Germany24794 Posts
On October 09 2012 21:00 LaNague wrote: im mad, this incompetence is ridiculous. This head referee Riot guy allready stated they had referees for every player and none of them saw anyone cheating. Now they say frost cheated? Everybody says Frost cheated. Because there is video evidence that is pretty much unrefutable. But it seems like they will do nothing about it, so I dont quite get where you are coming from. | ||
LaNague
Germany9118 Posts
On October 09 2012 21:08 Redox wrote: Everybody says Frost cheated. Because there is video evidence that is pretty much unrefutable. But it seems like they will do nothing about it, so I dont quite get where you are coming from. you probably missed riots first statement, which was that they had a referee for every player and watched them at all times and there was no cheating. Only a few reddit posts later they suddenly forgot about that statement. also you should have quoted my other paragraph, which explains it. But forget it, dyrus was just trolling anyways. | ||
Redox
Germany24794 Posts
On October 09 2012 21:11 LaNague wrote: you probably missed riots first statement, which was that they had a referee for every player and watched them at all times and there was no cheating. Only a few reddit posts later they suddenly forgot about that statement. I didnt forget that statement at all. Obviously the referee thought there was no cheating, otherwise he would not have made such a bold statement. Later video evidence emerged, showing that he was wrong. So of course at this point he can not hold this statement up. At which point is this hard to understand? | ||
DragoonTT
3398 Posts
On October 09 2012 21:14 Redox wrote: I didnt forget that statement at all. Obviously the referee thought there was no cheating, otherwise he would not have made such a bold statement. Later video evidence emerged, showing that he was wrong. So of course at this point he can not hold this statement up. At which point is this hard to understand? The "video evidence" is shaky at best, and if TSM didn't have a million fanboys making reading the boards or reddit hell at the moment, people probably wouldn't even care any more. Riot referees on stage decided there was no cheating, and only started "investigating" after TSM claimed there was cheating involved and the shitstorm broke loose. Seriously, isn't it a little biased to instantly condemn Frost and take everything TSM says about possible cheating at face value?! | ||
NHY
1013 Posts
On October 09 2012 13:13 Jaksiel wrote: I'm not taking a position on whether Frost cheated or not, or what if anything should be done if they did. With that out of the way, I think it's wrong to say Riot shouldn't even look into this on the hypothetical that it might hurt the scene in Korea. If the best team in Korea "cannot afford to have a cheating scandal", I really don't see how that's Riot's concern. Riot's concern should be to keep the integrity of their competitive scene as best they can. To me, taking a hard line on cheating (IF THAT'S WHAT THIS IS, AND IF THEY DO THE SAME FOR OTHER TEAMS FOUND GUILTY) is far more important than worrying how Korea will react to it. (As an aside, and as someone who plays Magic: the Gathering competitively, I've always hated when people justify players cheating by saying better controls should have been in place. Yes, Riot screwed up by having a set-up where looking at the mini-map is possible. That does not justify any players actually doing so. If a player is found guilty of this, I'm willing to bet they apologize and acknowledge they shouldn't have looked, and they won't say it's Riot's fault for the set-up.) You are reading it the wrong way. It's not that actual cheating / punishment is problematic. The problem is the way they are handling this accusation. They don't seem to realize that the damage is already done by dragging out their 'investigation.' Only thing worth investigating from last week's event is how incompetent Riot's preparation has been and who was responsible. Trust me, any Korean caught cheating will be crucified by angry Korean fans before Riot / foreign fans have their chance. | ||
LaNague
Germany9118 Posts
| ||
seanisgrand
United States1039 Posts
| ||
Redox
Germany24794 Posts
On October 09 2012 21:16 DragoonTT wrote: The "video evidence" is shaky at best, and if TSM didn't have a million fanboys making reading the boards or reddit hell at the moment, people probably wouldn't even care any more. Seriously, isn't it a little biased to instantly condemn Frost and take everything TSM says about possible cheating at face value?! TSM is the team I dislike most in all of the finals. My posting history pretty much shows this. Still its a fact that a Frost player tilted his head towards the mini-map and immediatly afterwards the position of the TSM players on the map was pinged, screwing up their lvl 1. That people dont want to see this seems to be a case of anti-TSM bias, or fear to be mistaken for obnoxious TSM fans. That said, I believe TSM would have lost anyways, because they got outplayed the whole series and Frost was the much better team. | ||
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
On October 09 2012 21:16 DragoonTT wrote: The "video evidence" is shaky at best, and if TSM didn't have a million fanboys making reading the boards or reddit hell at the moment, people probably wouldn't even care any more. Riot referees on stage decided there was no cheating, and only started "investigating" after TSM claimed there was cheating involved and the shitstorm broke loose. Seriously, isn't it a little biased to instantly condemn Frost and take everything TSM says about possible cheating at face value?! "Shaky at best" tell me more about that please. There is a video, we see a guy watching the screen, then there is a ping in the dark, then there is both maokai and mf going in TSM's jungle like they know there is nobody in there, please tell me how is it shaky. At least, saying WE or any other team cheated is shaky, but the evidences against frost are pretty huge. Jayce checking the bush is completly normal, but at best he could have known that one person was there, it's not enough for MF to pass the tribush nor for maokai to body check wraith. | ||
NHY
1013 Posts
On October 09 2012 21:21 Redox wrote: TSM is the team I dislike most in all of the finals. My posting history pretty much shows this. Still its a fact that a Frost player tilted his head towards the mini-map and immediatly afterwards the position of the TSM players on the map was pinged, screwing up their lvl 1. That people dont want to see this seems to be a case of anti-TSM bias, or fear to be mistaken for obnoxious TSM fans. That said, I believe TSM would have lost anyways, because they got outplayed the whole series and Frost was the much better team. TSM's invade was screwed the moment Shy picked Jayce. It was obvious that he would be checking the bush, because that's what Frost has been doing the entire tournament. It was nothing special, although I can see how it would be shocking for TSM to see someone actually not face-check. | ||
NHY
1013 Posts
On October 09 2012 21:23 WhiteDog wrote: "Shaky at best" tell me more about that please. There is a video, we see a guy watching the screen, then there is a ping in the dark, then there is both maokai and mf going in TSM's jungle like they know there is nobody in there, please tell me how is it shaky. At least, saying WE or any other team cheated is shaky, but the evidences against frost are pretty huge. Jayce checking the bush is completly normal, but at best he could have known that one person was there, it's not enough for MF to pass the tribush nor for maokai to body check wraith. Case in point. First TSM point to Jayce, then they try to create more evidence. | ||
CROrens
Croatia1005 Posts
On October 09 2012 18:27 Keniji wrote: What are they doing? This stuff came up all the time in the dota 2 vs riot thread in the dota 2 forum as well. I have never read something from riot that aggressively or even passive aggressively attacked dota2/valve. I mean, I just play the game sometimes and watch the big tournaments so I don't know that's why I'm honestly asking what riot is actually doing? Allegedly they tried to force tournament hosts to only have 1 ARTS game (in other words, you dont let DotA 2 on your tournament or we go away with our money). Of course it was covered up by Riot later on, but many sources confirm it. If it really is true it was a really really cheap shot by riot. | ||
Gorsameth
Netherlands21687 Posts
On October 09 2012 22:13 CROrens wrote: Allegedly they tried to force tournament hosts to only have 1 ARTS game (in other words, you dont let DotA 2 on your tournament or we go away with our money). Of course it was covered up by Riot later on, but many sources confirm it. If it really is true it was a really really cheap shot by riot. And i dont see what the problem is. Riot sponsering a tournament for a lot of money. taking care of a lot of things (shoutcasters/tech team on standby/price money). It saves a tournament money and they dont want that money to then get send to there competitor. No one is stopping anyone from running both Dota2/Hon and LoL. you just dont get the Riot bonusses. | ||
LaNague
Germany9118 Posts
On October 09 2012 22:16 Gorsameth wrote: And i dont see what the problem is. Riot sponsering a tournament for a lot of money. taking care of a lot of things (shoutcasters/tech team on standby/price money). It saves a tournament money and they dont want that money to then get send to there competitor. No one is stopping anyone from running both Dota2/Hon and LoL. you just dont get the Riot bonusses. no, this is wrong, riot has 100% control over LoL usage, you cant do a bigger tournament without them approving. its the 100% opposite from broodwar and im pretty sure they deliberately set it up this way because of the kespa-blizzard relationship. you think tournament organizers WANT phreak and rivington casting? ![]() | ||
Redox
Germany24794 Posts
On October 09 2012 22:20 LaNague wrote: no, this is wrong, riot has 100% control over LoL usage, you cant do a bigger tournament without them approving. its the 100% opposite from broodwar and im pretty sure they deliberately set it up this way because of the kespa-blizzard relationship. you think tournament organizers WANT phreak and rivington casting? ![]() You can do a bigger LoL tournament, if you pay for it yourself. If Riot pays for it, of course they also have a say in it. And there were plenty of tournaments without the Riot casters. | ||
Praetorial
United States4241 Posts
On October 08 2012 23:13 DOUDOU wrote: http://na.leagueoflegends.com/board/showthread.php?p=29971787#29971787 "Players make eye contact on stage fairly regularly" it's impressive how easily the community swallows the shameless doublespeak of riot That red post has ~2K downvotes | ||
DOUDOU
Wales2940 Posts
and that one http://na.leagueoflegends.com/board/showthread.php?t=2655300 that totally ignore the fact that the lead referee said there was no cheating has 900upvotes | ||
jpak
United States5045 Posts
Once that fails, all fail. The fact that these accusations are even being flung around is a testament to Riot failing to prioritize correctly. | ||
ihasaKAROT
Netherlands4730 Posts
| ||
| ||