On September 03 2011 01:11 cronican wrote:
At least give him a catch phrase or something when he's looking over the railing. "Shocking, isn't it?"

I second the demand for a catchprase. Something like "did you foresee that too, bitch?"

howerpower

United States619 Posts

September 02 2011 16:18 GMT

#43

I was a lot younger when the episode 3 came out and even I thought him screaming "noooooo" at the end was the goofiest most out of place dialogue ever. so so bad.

Divergence

Canada363 Posts

September 02 2011 16:19 GMT

#44

On September 03 2011 00:46 JustPassingBy wrote:
reminds me of that: http://www.geekologie.com/2010/05/what-if-super-mario-bros-was-m.php
meaning that they think if vader does not say "no", the audience would not get the scene.

Haha nice article there. Really sums up some of the problems with modern games.

wishbones

Canada2600 Posts

September 02 2011 16:19 GMT

#45

On September 03 2011 00:46 MadPretty wrote:
George Lucas has turned into that kid at the playground who keeps changing his superpowers while you play "X-Men".

haha that reminded me of myself. I was that friend who wanted your base when we played "guys". Then when you finally gave up and let me have your base, i wanted your new one because it was better than mine still.

QuanticHawk

United States32054 Posts

September 02 2011 16:22 GMT

#46

This wasn't realized after the last batch of new starwars movies???

This is really stupid though

also, how many times is that bastard going to add new content and digitally remaster the same goddamn movies??

ReDShiFT

United States106 Posts

September 02 2011 16:25 GMT

#47

Someone needs to limit Lucas' budget on movies and then he might make something good. When he is limitless he just goes too far. The main reason the original trilogy was good was that his lack of funds made him have to imply stuff rather than just pouring money into the screen to make it look interesting. Too bad that people actually buy these new versions, thus funding more hideous fuckups.

wishbones

Canada2600 Posts

September 02 2011 16:25 GMT

#48

^ yea for real, he should come out with at least one, most filthy rich old men die before they turn 80. He was born in 1944. HURRY UP NEW MOVIE!.

+ Show Spoiler +

as for the above post ^ By the time he is done, StarWars will have magically become 3D movie

askTeivospy

1525 Posts

September 02 2011 16:27 GMT

#49

why is everyone mad? Star Wars would be so much better if all vader dialogue was replaced with NOOOOO

infact i think this must be done as a joke

PolSC2

United States634 Posts

September 02 2011 16:27 GMT

#50

On September 03 2011 01:22 Hawk wrote:
This wasn't realized after the last batch of new starwars movies???

This is really stupid though

also, how many times is that bastard going to add new content and digitally remaster the same goddamn movies??

As many times as he still makes money from people who keep buying the same goddamn movies.

TheMooseHeed

United Kingdom535 Posts

September 02 2011 16:27 GMT

#51

I just died a little inside.

WHYYYY LUCAS WHYYY.

I am thankful I have one of the earlier dvd releases.

Even that has been tainted by Lucas

Carnac

Germany / USA16648 Posts

September 02 2011 16:28 GMT

#52

it's dumb, but it's his movie, so he can do whatever the fuck he wants

how many versions are there by now lol

URfavHO

United States514 Posts

September 02 2011 16:28 GMT

#53

I foresee many fathers showing this movie to their sons and suddenly muting the television for a brief instant.

The KY

United Kingdom6252 Posts

September 02 2011 16:29 GMT

#54

On September 03 2011 00:59 LayZRR wrote:
So what? can anybody explain why this is so bad? it doesnt change anything right?

It's indicative of Lucas' complete disregard for a classic of cinema, his fans, film as an artwork. I'm not a big Star Wars fan but imagine if, for example, at the end of Godfather II when Michael stands silently at the window while Fredo is shot on the lake, if he heard the gunshot and then fell to his knees and went 'NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!'. Imagine if they released a blu ray version where that happened.

The change itself is shit and retarded, but it's not as bad as what is says about Lucas. He just doesn't get it. With his constant revisions he is taking a fucking chainsaw to the original trilogy. The man doesn't understand why it's a fucking awful idea to composite in CGI creatures to existing scenes in original trilogy, he doesn't understand why jamming the screen full of effects doesn't make a film better, he basically doesn't know what the fuck he's doing and shouldn't be allowed anywhere near his own work.

The fact that he thinks the original films need revising to be more like the universally reviled and objectively fucking terrible new trilogy is what makes people angry.

Frigo

Hungary1023 Posts

September 02 2011 16:30 GMT

#55

Don't worry we hate him too. After Jar Jar and midi-chlorians it is the only reasonable reaction.

Talin

Montenegro10532 Posts

September 02 2011 16:31 GMT

#56

On September 03 2011 01:11 pred470r wrote:
I'll just have to quote Jar Jar Binks on this one:
"Dis is nutsen."

I expected Jar Jar Binks to actually be in this scene.

George Lucas, you disappoint.

QuanticHawk

United States32054 Posts

September 02 2011 16:32 GMT

#57

On September 03 2011 01:28 Carnac wrote:
it's dumb, but it's his movie, so he can do whatever the fuck he wants

how many versions are there by now lol

there's got to be at least four or so of the originals...

the orignal releases post movie
then there was digital remastering in the 90s
then there was the OMG NEW FOOTAGE ones late 90s/early 00s to promote the new trilogy
then this

it's quite depressing as a fan of the franchise, but fuck that's good business