|
Keep your off topic discussions out of this thread and show some damn respect! |
On July 26 2011 05:27 Shikyo wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 05:23 Haemonculus wrote:On July 26 2011 05:14 FallDownMarigold wrote:Glenn Beck himself admits that he is an entertainer - not a bringer of true journalism or sound opinion. He aims to entertain a specific demographic that is predictable and easy to entertain. Who knows, the guy might actually be a hard-left leaning liberal  Also keep in mind that here in America, (especially on Fox news), the word "socialism" actually means "hates America, wants to take your guns away, and probably pro-gay marriage and flag burning". It's sad, but when the camp is described as a "socialist youth camp", people here in the states, (again, especially those watching Fox) WILL assume the worst and think that it's some crazy left-wing indoctrination camp. but socialist in this context isn't really socialist, it's more like social liberalist or something of that effect Nono, my point was that the word is so loaded in American politics that merely mentioning it will instantly slant many people's opinions.
|
Let's stop comparing this to american whatevers. That discussion will always devolve into a US versus the world, and there's plenty other threads already going in that direction. In general, norwegian society has different values than the american society, so the actions and reactions of the other will always be somewhat alien. Comparisons are moot.
On July 26 2011 05:38 Sandermatt wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 05:11 Myrtroll wrote: According to politadvokat Christian Hatlo (prosecutor), they are considering charges with a penalty of 30 years. I didn't know about these, but they apparently exist. So any 21 year nonsense people are throwing about is false. Seems it's a war crime paragraph added recently and haven't been used yet (2005).
I guess the "forvaring" part still applies so it's still practically a life sentence, but it looks better on paper at least. I hope they will not charge him for "war crimes". This would imply he acted as some kind of soldier. The ability to wage war against norway makes him more important than he is. http://www.bt.no/nyheter/innenriks/Breivik-risikerer-30-rs-fengsel-2543511.html
Norwegian source. Basically what it says in regard to the 30 year sentence possibility, is that if Breivik's actions fall under crimes against humanity, which is a war crime, he can be sentenced for that maximum sentence. Otherwise, he's limited to the 21 year life time sentence, plus additional 5 year periods of 'forvaring' after that, depending on the mental state of the prisoner.
Wether or not that would make him into some sort of soldier or not is up to interpretation. What matters is wether or not his act is rated as a crime against humanity or not.
|
On July 26 2011 06:22 plated.rawr wrote:Let's stop comparing this to american whatevers. That discussion will always devolve into a US versus the world, and there's plenty other threads already going in that direction. In general, norwegian society has different values than the american society, so the actions and reactions of the other will always be somewhat alien. Comparisons are moot. Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 05:38 Sandermatt wrote:On July 26 2011 05:11 Myrtroll wrote: According to politadvokat Christian Hatlo (prosecutor), they are considering charges with a penalty of 30 years. I didn't know about these, but they apparently exist. So any 21 year nonsense people are throwing about is false. Seems it's a war crime paragraph added recently and haven't been used yet (2005).
I guess the "forvaring" part still applies so it's still practically a life sentence, but it looks better on paper at least. I hope they will not charge him for "war crimes". This would imply he acted as some kind of soldier. The ability to wage war against norway makes him more important than he is. http://www.bt.no/nyheter/innenriks/Breivik-risikerer-30-rs-fengsel-2543511.htmlNorwegian source. Basically what it says in regard to the 30 year sentence possibility, is that if Breivik's actions fall under crimes against humanity, which is a war crime, he can be sentenced for that maximum sentence. Otherwise, he's limited to the 21 year life time sentence, plus additional 5 year periods of 'forvaring' after that, depending on the mental state of the prisoner. Wether or not that would make him into some sort of soldier or not is up to interpretation. What matters is wether or not his act is rated as a crime against humanity or not.
To the maximum of 5 years forvaring. In case the therapeuts would say he is likely to kill again, can't they keep him longer?
|
On July 26 2011 06:44 Sandermatt wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 06:22 plated.rawr wrote:Let's stop comparing this to american whatevers. That discussion will always devolve into a US versus the world, and there's plenty other threads already going in that direction. In general, norwegian society has different values than the american society, so the actions and reactions of the other will always be somewhat alien. Comparisons are moot. On July 26 2011 05:38 Sandermatt wrote:On July 26 2011 05:11 Myrtroll wrote: According to politadvokat Christian Hatlo (prosecutor), they are considering charges with a penalty of 30 years. I didn't know about these, but they apparently exist. So any 21 year nonsense people are throwing about is false. Seems it's a war crime paragraph added recently and haven't been used yet (2005).
I guess the "forvaring" part still applies so it's still practically a life sentence, but it looks better on paper at least. I hope they will not charge him for "war crimes". This would imply he acted as some kind of soldier. The ability to wage war against norway makes him more important than he is. http://www.bt.no/nyheter/innenriks/Breivik-risikerer-30-rs-fengsel-2543511.htmlNorwegian source. Basically what it says in regard to the 30 year sentence possibility, is that if Breivik's actions fall under crimes against humanity, which is a war crime, he can be sentenced for that maximum sentence. Otherwise, he's limited to the 21 year life time sentence, plus additional 5 year periods of 'forvaring' after that, depending on the mental state of the prisoner. Wether or not that would make him into some sort of soldier or not is up to interpretation. What matters is wether or not his act is rated as a crime against humanity or not. To the maximum of 5 years forvaring. In case the therapeuts would say he is likely to kill again, can't they keep him longer?
they can ( and will) give him 5 years again and again and again and again and again...
|
On July 26 2011 05:04 TokO wrote: Just want to clarify, most youth politicians I know are intelligent people who are actively contributing to democracy in Norway. I'm actually insulted that Glenn Beck would even make that ignorant statement given the situation. People are there voluntarily because they agree with their respective party, and most of all, they want to make Norway a better country. They all are an inspiring group of people for the democratic world.
Many on the camp were there probably just because it was a free trip. That was what a couple of classmates did when they went there some years ago, it was a free trip to Oslo and an island with hundreds of other kids, it was fun for them even if they didn't care about politics.
|
I can't say I'm impressed with the media so far. Showing microphones and cameras in the faces of the kids this early is just wrong in my opinion, even if the kids wants it themselves. You can also clearly see that many of the reporters are new or summer-employees, at least the Norwegian ones. I sure hope they do some cleanup with the media when everything has settled.
|
On July 26 2011 05:04 TokO wrote: Just want to clarify, most youth politicians I know are intelligent people who are actively contributing to democracy in Norway. I'm actually insulted that Glenn Beck would even make that ignorant statement given the situation. People are there voluntarily because they agree with their respective party, and most of all, they want to make Norway a better country. They all are an inspiring group of people for the democratic world.
I'm equally insulted that one off-the-cuff comment during a 3 hour radio show generates the headline "Glenn Beck On Norway Killings: Children Like 'Hitler Youth" (Huffingtonpost headline). Using this tragedy to score a cheap political win with a sensationalist and misleading headline for an off-the-cuff comment taken out of context is equally outrageous, imo. I'm no fan of Beck, but it's clear to me that he's not the only one out of line here.
|
On July 26 2011 06:44 Sandermatt wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 06:22 plated.rawr wrote:Let's stop comparing this to american whatevers. That discussion will always devolve into a US versus the world, and there's plenty other threads already going in that direction. In general, norwegian society has different values than the american society, so the actions and reactions of the other will always be somewhat alien. Comparisons are moot. On July 26 2011 05:38 Sandermatt wrote:On July 26 2011 05:11 Myrtroll wrote: According to politadvokat Christian Hatlo (prosecutor), they are considering charges with a penalty of 30 years. I didn't know about these, but they apparently exist. So any 21 year nonsense people are throwing about is false. Seems it's a war crime paragraph added recently and haven't been used yet (2005).
I guess the "forvaring" part still applies so it's still practically a life sentence, but it looks better on paper at least. I hope they will not charge him for "war crimes". This would imply he acted as some kind of soldier. The ability to wage war against norway makes him more important than he is. http://www.bt.no/nyheter/innenriks/Breivik-risikerer-30-rs-fengsel-2543511.htmlNorwegian source. Basically what it says in regard to the 30 year sentence possibility, is that if Breivik's actions fall under crimes against humanity, which is a war crime, he can be sentenced for that maximum sentence. Otherwise, he's limited to the 21 year life time sentence, plus additional 5 year periods of 'forvaring' after that, depending on the mental state of the prisoner. Wether or not that would make him into some sort of soldier or not is up to interpretation. What matters is wether or not his act is rated as a crime against humanity or not. To the maximum of 5 years forvaring. In case the therapeuts would say he is likely to kill again, can't they keep him longer? As electricwizard says, this is a 5year period that marks the time for a new evaluation; if the prisoner is deemed still too dangerous to be let into society, they will add a new 5 year period. This can in theory keep going until the prisoner dies if no signs of change is made.
|
On July 26 2011 07:01 Lobo2me wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 05:04 TokO wrote: Just want to clarify, most youth politicians I know are intelligent people who are actively contributing to democracy in Norway. I'm actually insulted that Glenn Beck would even make that ignorant statement given the situation. People are there voluntarily because they agree with their respective party, and most of all, they want to make Norway a better country. They all are an inspiring group of people for the democratic world. Many on the camp were there probably just because it was a free trip. That was what a couple of classmates did when they went there some years ago, it was a free trip to Oslo and an island with hundreds of other kids, it was fun for them even if they didn't care about politics.
You're probably right, I'm just talking about the people I knew or had acqaintance of that were there, and generally the air I get about the youth politicians whom I go to school with.
|
|
On July 26 2011 07:18 BlackJack wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 05:04 TokO wrote: Just want to clarify, most youth politicians I know are intelligent people who are actively contributing to democracy in Norway. I'm actually insulted that Glenn Beck would even make that ignorant statement given the situation. People are there voluntarily because they agree with their respective party, and most of all, they want to make Norway a better country. They all are an inspiring group of people for the democratic world. I'm equally insulted that one off-the-cuff comment during a 3 hour radio show generates the headline "Glenn Beck On Norway Killings: Children Like 'Hitler Youth" (Huffingtonpost headline). Using this tragedy to score a cheap political win with a sensationalist and misleading headline for an off-the-cuff comment taken out of context is equally outrageous, imo. I'm no fan of Beck, but it's clear to me that he's not the only one out of line here.
He was not out of line comparing a summer camp for youth, which by most accounts is just as much a place to pick up girls/boys as it is about politics, with the hitler jugend? What planet are you living on? You either have no idea what kind of camp this was, or you have no understanding of history and what the hitler jugend actually was and represented - or all of the above. And there was nothing "off the cuff" about Beck's comment. He had heard about the situation before going on air and had time to form an opinion on the matter before making the comment. He'll take any chance to take a random stab at a social democratic society, because that's just what he does
that's EXTREMELY unproffessional of The Telegraph. His mother and sister are entitled to as much anonymity as they can get at this point, this situation has already ruined their lives. His mother even needed emergency psychiatric help (which I assume means she was contemplating or had attempted to take her own life)
|
The link to the picture posted by Plexa in first page (2nd post) is dead, I had a quick look through a few pages but couldn't really be bothered going through 123 of them - is there a valid one? This whole "most horrible picture i've ever seen" comments got me curious. Not a really good thing really, but now that I'm there, I kinda wanna see it..
I'm very impressed by the reactions from people from Norway in here, you guys are definitely a very smart country if I'm to trust what I read in this post which I tend to do. My most sincere condoleances but as someone who tends to be very realistic, I'd just say stuff like that unfortunately is bound to happen and not always where you expect it. Such a sad world in which people can get such weapons so easily.
|
On July 26 2011 08:58 Quotidian wrote:that's EXTREMELY unproffessional of The Telegraph. His mother and sister are entitled to as much anonymity as they can get at this point, this situation has already ruined their lives. His mother even needed emergency psychiatric help (which I assume means she was contemplating or had attempted to take her own life) Well, the picture is in his manifest so it should be pretty easy to figure out who is in it. But yeah I agree, I don't really even get the point of the article (except to copypaste stuff from the manifest)
|
On July 26 2011 08:58 Quotidian wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 07:18 BlackJack wrote:On July 26 2011 05:04 TokO wrote: Just want to clarify, most youth politicians I know are intelligent people who are actively contributing to democracy in Norway. I'm actually insulted that Glenn Beck would even make that ignorant statement given the situation. People are there voluntarily because they agree with their respective party, and most of all, they want to make Norway a better country. They all are an inspiring group of people for the democratic world. I'm equally insulted that one off-the-cuff comment during a 3 hour radio show generates the headline "Glenn Beck On Norway Killings: Children Like 'Hitler Youth" (Huffingtonpost headline). Using this tragedy to score a cheap political win with a sensationalist and misleading headline for an off-the-cuff comment taken out of context is equally outrageous, imo. I'm no fan of Beck, but it's clear to me that he's not the only one out of line here. He was not out of line comparing a summer camp for youth, which by most accounts is just as much a place to pick up girls/boys as it is about politics, with the hitler jugend? What planet are you living on? You either have no idea what kind of camp this was, or you have no understanding of history and what the hitler jugend actually was and represented - or all of the above. And there was nothing "off the cuff" about Beck's comment. He had heard about the situation before going on air and had time to form an opinion on the matter before making the comment. He'll take any chance to take a random stab at a social democratic society, because that's just what he does that's EXTREMELY unproffessional of The Telegraph. His mother and sister are entitled to as much anonymity as they can get at this point, this situation has already ruined their lives. His mother even needed emergency psychiatric help (which I assume means she was contemplating or had attempted to take her own life)
I said he was out line.
|
Some people are saying he filmed the whole thing with a small video camera that was attached to his gun, if that is true that clip will guaranteed leak since evidence is official and anyone is allowed to see evidence after the trial I belive. That would probably be a really disgusting clip to watch =/
|
On July 26 2011 09:39 BlackJack wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 08:58 Quotidian wrote:On July 26 2011 07:18 BlackJack wrote:On July 26 2011 05:04 TokO wrote: Just want to clarify, most youth politicians I know are intelligent people who are actively contributing to democracy in Norway. I'm actually insulted that Glenn Beck would even make that ignorant statement given the situation. People are there voluntarily because they agree with their respective party, and most of all, they want to make Norway a better country. They all are an inspiring group of people for the democratic world. I'm equally insulted that one off-the-cuff comment during a 3 hour radio show generates the headline "Glenn Beck On Norway Killings: Children Like 'Hitler Youth" (Huffingtonpost headline). Using this tragedy to score a cheap political win with a sensationalist and misleading headline for an off-the-cuff comment taken out of context is equally outrageous, imo. I'm no fan of Beck, but it's clear to me that he's not the only one out of line here. He was not out of line comparing a summer camp for youth, which by most accounts is just as much a place to pick up girls/boys as it is about politics, with the hitler jugend? What planet are you living on? You either have no idea what kind of camp this was, or you have no understanding of history and what the hitler jugend actually was and represented - or all of the above. And there was nothing "off the cuff" about Beck's comment. He had heard about the situation before going on air and had time to form an opinion on the matter before making the comment. He'll take any chance to take a random stab at a social democratic society, because that's just what he does that's EXTREMELY unproffessional of The Telegraph. His mother and sister are entitled to as much anonymity as they can get at this point, this situation has already ruined their lives. His mother even needed emergency psychiatric help (which I assume means she was contemplating or had attempted to take her own life) I said he was out line. You also said it's out of line to make a big deal of a person being way out of line... which imo isn't the case
|
On July 26 2011 09:48 Otori wrote: Some people are saying he filmed the whole thing with a small video camera that was attached to his gun, if that is true that clip will guaranteed leak since evidence is official and anyone is allowed to see evidence after the trial I belive. That would probably be a really disgusting clip to watch =/ Has this been verified? I did hear the news mentioning that he had written in his manifest about experimenting with a small camera, but I never heard anything about actual usage of it.
If he has filmed it, I
Well, it
It will be terrible.
|
On July 26 2011 09:51 plated.rawr wrote:Show nested quote +On July 26 2011 09:48 Otori wrote: Some people are saying he filmed the whole thing with a small video camera that was attached to his gun, if that is true that clip will guaranteed leak since evidence is official and anyone is allowed to see evidence after the trial I belive. That would probably be a really disgusting clip to watch =/ Has this been verified? I did hear the news mentioning that he had written in his manifest about experimenting with a small camera, but I never heard anything about actual usage of it. If he has filmed it, I Well, it It will be terrible.
No this has not been verified by any 'reliable' source, only about ~30 people on a big nordic forum stated that he did but would give any reliable source, so I'm not really guessing anything.
But in a logical manner, I'd say he definatly filmed it, since it was his "big thing" and he had planned it for so many years, if he wanted this to be remembered even more, he would definatly film the whole thing, I mean he even wrote hundreds of papers and made short filmclips of himself beforehand, about this thing.
Either way, dont think anyone will know if its true if he filmed it or not within the next couple of months. Just speculations.
|
Heard on NPR that they have lowered the death count to 73 on the island. Apparently in the confusion they counted some people twice or something like that.
Wonderful news.
|
On July 26 2011 10:00 On_Slaught wrote: Heard on NPR that they have lowered the death count to 73 on the island. Apparently in the confusion they counted some people twice or something like that.
Wonderful news.
Yes I heard the same, but what I heard was 68.. from 85 to 68, and that's quite a large difference from the previous statement, so i'm really hoping that's true, even though it's still a ridicilous number and a pure massacre/slaughter of young children.
|
|
|
|