• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 01:57
CET 07:57
KST 15:57
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over5Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Dark completes military service, returns to SC2
Tourneys
soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ NaDa's Body
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread The PlayStation 5 Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread The Big Programming Thread Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 18013 users

Stabbing burglars 'will be legal' in UK - Page 8

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 6 7 8 9 10 20 Next All
OsoVega
Profile Joined December 2010
926 Posts
June 30 2011 06:26 GMT
#141
On June 30 2011 15:20 Morfildur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:12 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


Have you ever tried to "incapacitate" someone? It is a hell of a lot less reliable than the movies make it look. A gun, however, requires considerably less finesse/luck to remove a threat from the equation.


Yes, but that potential thread has a high chance of being dead after that. Well, maybe it's really the country as the poster before you suggests, but i would never, ever use force that has the potential of being deadly. When in doubt, i'd rather die and let the murderer rot in prison later than risk killing someone who never was a threat in the first place.

Maybe you don't mean what you said but I doubt you would really never use potentially lethal force and if you really meant that, I think you're an incredibly weak human being. What if you are completely sure that the person plans on killing you and very much has the ability to kill you if you do not kill him? Would you never launch an artillery shell in the unlikely situation that a foreign country is invading your country?

As for when there is doubt, I think it's insane that you would risk your life (family's life?) over someone who has chosen to put themselves in the threatening of a burglar.
Sea_Food
Profile Blog Joined May 2011
Finland1612 Posts
June 30 2011 06:29 GMT
#142
On June 30 2011 15:10 abominare wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


For some reason your country tag makes me giggle about your response.

Seriously though why should the burden fall on the victim to minimize the danger the criminal may be in? Granted crime and violent crime in Germany is most likely less than in the states, but hitting some one with a frying pan that potentially has a gun isn't exactly high on my list, I find that .45 acp injected from my 1911 wisens them up

Non sensical. You are afraid to hit burgular with gun, but not afraid to shoot him? If he is in range so are you, or are you willing to risk your life because you belive your a superior gunman compared to him?
teekesselchen
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
Germany886 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-06-30 06:29:52
June 30 2011 06:29 GMT
#143
With no doubt it is for almost every person a very scary situation to meet a burglar in their home. But I think that generally legalising to go as far as stabbing them goes too far.

Let's just take a totally extreme example: A professional heavy weight martial artist catches two young kids (who don't even match his weight combined) in his house and stabs them. Seriously necessary?

I don't mean to say that this was a normal case, but there have to be exeptions to still punish exceeded self defense.
When they were introduced, he made a witticism, hoping to be liked. She laughed extremely hard, hoping to be liked. Then each drove home alone, staring straight ahead, with the very same twist to their faces.
Kamais_Ookin
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Canada4218 Posts
June 30 2011 06:31 GMT
#144
On June 30 2011 15:29 teekesselchen wrote:
With no doubt it is for almost every person a very scary situation to meet a burglar in their home. But I think that generally legalising to go as far as stabbing them goes too far.

Let's just take a totally extreme example: A professional heavy weight martial artist catches two young kids (who don't even match his weight combined) in his house and stabs them. Seriously necessary?

I don't mean to say that this was a normal case, but there have to be exeptions to still punish exceeded self defense.
In that case stabbing was showing mercy because the heavyweight's 2 fists would be way worse.
I <3 Plexa.
Deleted User 101379
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
4849 Posts
June 30 2011 06:32 GMT
#145
On June 30 2011 15:23 Gheed wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:20 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:12 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


Have you ever tried to "incapacitate" someone? It is a hell of a lot less reliable than the movies make it look. A gun, however, requires considerably less finesse/luck to remove a threat from the equation.


Yes, but that potential thread has a high chance of being dead after that. Well, maybe it's really the country as the poster before you suggests, but i would never, ever use force that has the potential of being deadly. When in doubt, i'd rather die and let the murderer rot in prison later than risk killing someone who never was a threat in the first place.


You'd rather die then kill someone that was trying to kill you? That's some pretty hardcore turning of the other cheek. Do you have kids? Family? People who like you? I'm pretty sure they'd value your life more than that of some asshole burglar.


If i'd kill someone only to later find out that he never was a threat (i.e. was unarmed), i couldn't live with it anyways and probably end up killing myself because of that.
Unless the person is actively shooting at me or trying to stab me (in which case i'd probably already be dead), deadly force is not an option for me, no matter who the other person is. Criminals don't just become criminals because they are born evil, they have a life too. Some of them even have a wife and children. Their life is in no way worth less than mine just because they got on the wrong path somewhere.

There are lots of options to scare intruders away or incapacitate them.
OsoVega
Profile Joined December 2010
926 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-06-30 06:35:46
June 30 2011 06:32 GMT
#146
On June 30 2011 15:29 Sea_Food wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:10 abominare wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


For some reason your country tag makes me giggle about your response.

Seriously though why should the burden fall on the victim to minimize the danger the criminal may be in? Granted crime and violent crime in Germany is most likely less than in the states, but hitting some one with a frying pan that potentially has a gun isn't exactly high on my list, I find that .45 acp injected from my 1911 wisens them up

Non sensical. You are afraid to hit burgular with gun, but not afraid to shoot him? If he is in range so are you, or are you willing to risk your life because you belive your a superior gunman compared to him?

It's about incapacitating them in the safest way possible. That would be a gun. And yes, I do believe I know my house better than any burglar. What is your solution? Run? That is not an option when you have a family.
vetinari
Profile Joined August 2010
Australia602 Posts
June 30 2011 06:33 GMT
#147
On June 30 2011 15:29 teekesselchen wrote:
With no doubt it is for almost every person a very scary situation to meet a burglar in their home. But I think that generally legalising to go as far as stabbing them goes too far.

Let's just take a totally extreme example: A professional heavy weight martial artist catches two young kids (who don't even match his weight combined) in his house and stabs them. Seriously necessary?

I don't mean to say that this was a normal case, but there have to be exeptions to still punish exceeded self defense.


The nice thing about blades and guns, is that they, in whole or in part, negate size and skill differences...

Romantic
Profile Joined January 2010
United States1844 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-06-30 06:38:05
June 30 2011 06:36 GMT
#148
I live in a Castle Doctrine state. Also had to deal with a burglar, but I didn't shoot him. I was sleeping at about lunchtime and he broke in thinking nobody was home.

Edit: To clarify, had he not left immediately or made any dangerous move I would have filled him with 9mm rounds and slept soundly that night.
OsoVega
Profile Joined December 2010
926 Posts
June 30 2011 06:36 GMT
#149
On June 30 2011 15:29 teekesselchen wrote:
With no doubt it is for almost every person a very scary situation to meet a burglar in their home. But I think that generally legalising to go as far as stabbing them goes too far.

Let's just take a totally extreme example: A professional heavy weight martial artist catches two young kids (who don't even match his weight combined) in his house and stabs them. Seriously necessary?

I don't mean to say that this was a normal case, but there have to be exeptions to still punish exceeded self defense.

He doesn't know if those kids are armed are not. He is justified.
valaki
Profile Joined June 2009
Hungary2476 Posts
June 30 2011 06:40 GMT
#150
I wish this was the case in my country too.
ggaemo fan
Sea_Food
Profile Blog Joined May 2011
Finland1612 Posts
June 30 2011 06:40 GMT
#151
On June 30 2011 15:32 OsoVega wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:29 Sea_Food wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:10 abominare wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


For some reason your country tag makes me giggle about your response.

Seriously though why should the burden fall on the victim to minimize the danger the criminal may be in? Granted crime and violent crime in Germany is most likely less than in the states, but hitting some one with a frying pan that potentially has a gun isn't exactly high on my list, I find that .45 acp injected from my 1911 wisens them up

Non sensical. You are afraid to hit burgular with gun, but not afraid to shoot him? If he is in range so are you, or are you willing to risk your life because you belive your a superior gunman compared to him?

It's about incapacitating them in the safest way possible. That would be a gun. And yes, I do believe I know my house better than any burglar. What is your solution? Run? That is not an option when you have a family.

Actually because i live in a nation where getting a personal gun is so hard I dont have the option to shoot the burglar, but if i did I still belive pretending to be asleep and calling police quietly is the safest option.
OsoVega
Profile Joined December 2010
926 Posts
June 30 2011 06:41 GMT
#152
On June 30 2011 15:32 Morfildur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:23 Gheed wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:20 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:12 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


Have you ever tried to "incapacitate" someone? It is a hell of a lot less reliable than the movies make it look. A gun, however, requires considerably less finesse/luck to remove a threat from the equation.


Yes, but that potential thread has a high chance of being dead after that. Well, maybe it's really the country as the poster before you suggests, but i would never, ever use force that has the potential of being deadly. When in doubt, i'd rather die and let the murderer rot in prison later than risk killing someone who never was a threat in the first place.


You'd rather die then kill someone that was trying to kill you? That's some pretty hardcore turning of the other cheek. Do you have kids? Family? People who like you? I'm pretty sure they'd value your life more than that of some asshole burglar.


If i'd kill someone only to later find out that he never was a threat (i.e. was unarmed), i couldn't live with it anyways and probably end up killing myself because of that.
Unless the person is actively shooting at me or trying to stab me (in which case i'd probably already be dead), deadly force is not an option for me, no matter who the other person is. Criminals don't just become criminals because they are born evil, they have a life too. Some of them even have a wife and children. Their life is in no way worth less than mine just because they got on the wrong path somewhere.

There are lots of options to scare intruders away or incapacitate them.

What if someone was holding a fake gun to your family. Would you feel bad over killing them? That is no different than someone who breaks into your house. They are putting themselves into a threatening position in which they have the potential to kill and it is not up to you to take the risk of assuming that they don't.
Deleted User 101379
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
4849 Posts
June 30 2011 06:47 GMT
#153
On June 30 2011 15:41 OsoVega wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:32 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:23 Gheed wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:20 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:12 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


Have you ever tried to "incapacitate" someone? It is a hell of a lot less reliable than the movies make it look. A gun, however, requires considerably less finesse/luck to remove a threat from the equation.


Yes, but that potential thread has a high chance of being dead after that. Well, maybe it's really the country as the poster before you suggests, but i would never, ever use force that has the potential of being deadly. When in doubt, i'd rather die and let the murderer rot in prison later than risk killing someone who never was a threat in the first place.


You'd rather die then kill someone that was trying to kill you? That's some pretty hardcore turning of the other cheek. Do you have kids? Family? People who like you? I'm pretty sure they'd value your life more than that of some asshole burglar.


If i'd kill someone only to later find out that he never was a threat (i.e. was unarmed), i couldn't live with it anyways and probably end up killing myself because of that.
Unless the person is actively shooting at me or trying to stab me (in which case i'd probably already be dead), deadly force is not an option for me, no matter who the other person is. Criminals don't just become criminals because they are born evil, they have a life too. Some of them even have a wife and children. Their life is in no way worth less than mine just because they got on the wrong path somewhere.

There are lots of options to scare intruders away or incapacitate them.

What if someone was holding a fake gun to your family. Would you feel bad over killing them? That is no different than someone who breaks into your house. They are putting themselves into a threatening position in which they have the potential to kill and it is not up to you to take the risk of assuming that they don't.


The typical strawman argument...

No, i still wouldn't use deadly force. Anyways, that situation is totally unrelated to this thread as a burglary usually doesn't turn into an hostage situation. If it does, give him what he wants and later call the police and get your stuff back and that guy into prison. If your property is worth more than a human life, your priorities are really messed up.
Fighter
Profile Joined August 2010
Korea (South)1531 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-06-30 06:51:03
June 30 2011 06:49 GMT
#154
Edit: Wrong thread, why do I do this so often?

On topic: Seems like a pretty common sense law, glad to see this get "clarified." Were most British under the impression that stabbing a burgler was illegal before this?
For Aiur???
Usul
Profile Joined April 2010
Germany150 Posts
June 30 2011 06:54 GMT
#155
Wow, its sad to see how few people here value human life. Or think that killing is the appropiate answer for stealing. Yes, stealing is wrong, but stabbing is way off.
smokeyhoodoo
Profile Joined January 2010
United States1021 Posts
June 30 2011 06:57 GMT
#156
On June 30 2011 15:40 Sea_Food wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:32 OsoVega wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:29 Sea_Food wrote:
On June 30 2011 15:10 abominare wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


For some reason your country tag makes me giggle about your response.

Seriously though why should the burden fall on the victim to minimize the danger the criminal may be in? Granted crime and violent crime in Germany is most likely less than in the states, but hitting some one with a frying pan that potentially has a gun isn't exactly high on my list, I find that .45 acp injected from my 1911 wisens them up

Non sensical. You are afraid to hit burgular with gun, but not afraid to shoot him? If he is in range so are you, or are you willing to risk your life because you belive your a superior gunman compared to him?

It's about incapacitating them in the safest way possible. That would be a gun. And yes, I do believe I know my house better than any burglar. What is your solution? Run? That is not an option when you have a family.

Actually because i live in a nation where getting a personal gun is so hard I dont have the option to shoot the burglar, but if i did I still belive pretending to be asleep and calling police quietly is the safest option.


That's safe, but you'll likely never see your shit again. Do you have insurance for that?
There is no cow level
semantics
Profile Blog Joined November 2009
10040 Posts
June 30 2011 06:57 GMT
#157
Don't worry bros
I got dis~
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=102027
Romantic
Profile Joined January 2010
United States1844 Posts
June 30 2011 06:59 GMT
#158
On June 30 2011 15:54 Usul wrote:
Wow, its sad to see how few people here value human life. Or think that killing is the appropiate answer for stealing. Yes, stealing is wrong, but stabbing is way off.

You don't know what intruders in your home are planning on doing.

I'm surprised so many people (Europeans) have posted as if they believe police always solve crimes and get your stuff back and their response time to a call is 12 seconds while people who commit burglaries are completely safe to be around and even if they weren't you'd rather die than defend yourself.

That said, I will admit to valuing the life of someone breaking into my home very little.
nemo14
Profile Joined January 2011
United States425 Posts
June 30 2011 07:00 GMT
#159
On June 30 2011 15:20 Morfildur wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:12 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


Have you ever tried to "incapacitate" someone? It is a hell of a lot less reliable than the movies make it look. A gun, however, requires considerably less finesse/luck to remove a threat from the equation.


Yes, but that potential thread has a high chance of being dead after that. Well, maybe it's really the country as the poster before you suggests, but i would never, ever use force that has the potential of being deadly. When in doubt, i'd rather die and let the murderer rot in prison later than risk killing someone who never was a threat in the first place.


That is your view and I respect it. However, I believe that the law does and should allow me to exercise my own right to self-defense against a potential threat in my home. I'd be haunted forever after killing someone, I'm sure, but I'd rather live after shooting a confused sleepwalker than die after hesitating to put one in a serial killer. Differences in disposition, I suppose.
dogabutila
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
United States1438 Posts
June 30 2011 07:01 GMT
#160
On June 30 2011 15:16 OsoVega wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:05 exog wrote:
Ive thought a bit about house defence. I think knife is a bad option because if you bring it to a chaotic fight in darkness with a stranger it is very possible to have two unfavourable outcomes:

1. He takes the knife and kills you/hurt you bad.
2. You kill him when he stole a bread and go to prison for using excessive force. (A bit dumb example for this thread, but a relevant point in basically every civilized country).

Gun also has many disadvantages, with bullets hurting others through the walls, also see point 2 above. Guns and knives have little "in-between" options, maim or kill is basically random with a stab/shot.
up to me to
I concluded that some form of metal-club should be the best, where you can maintain distance, but be able to bash him bad without killing him.

Buckshot generally, won't penetrate a wall but it depends. I would not use FMJ pistol rounds, rifle rounds or slugs to defend my home. You should also train yourself never to shoot without being completely aware of your target and what's behind it, even in stressful situations. Guns do have an in between, the sound of a round being racked into the chamber and your voice. If they aren't running at that point, it is foolish not to shoot to kill them. To me, not killing the person is hardly a concern when my life may be in imminent danger as he is the one who chose to put himself in a threatening position and it is not up to me to take the risk.

Your scenario with a bat has an unfavorable outcome too.

1. He kills you.


Are we talking about standard fare drywall? Buckshot will go through 6 normal sized sheets easily. If it won't go though drywall it probably shouldnt be relied on to stop a person....


On June 30 2011 15:33 vetinari wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:29 teekesselchen wrote:
With no doubt it is for almost every person a very scary situation to meet a burglar in their home. But I think that generally legalising to go as far as stabbing them goes too far.

Let's just take a totally extreme example: A professional heavy weight martial artist catches two young kids (who don't even match his weight combined) in his house and stabs them. Seriously necessary?

I don't mean to say that this was a normal case, but there have to be exeptions to still punish exceeded self defense.


The nice thing about blades and guns, is that they, in whole or in part, negate size and skill differences...



Not really. They magnify skill difference. But it always gives the underdog a chance, even if the other person is far more skilled. If I went hand to hand with Travis Haley he would win 100% of the time. If we went with guns, i would have 1 chance out of 10,000.


On June 30 2011 15:29 Sea_Food wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 30 2011 15:10 abominare wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:55 Morfildur wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:44 nemo14 wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:26 MozzarellaL wrote:
On June 30 2011 14:22 Hekisui wrote:
This is where proportionality applies. You can't irrationally assume a person is out to kill or rape you. If a person is deemed a threat, you can respond in a certain manner. If a person is violent, you can respond with violence.
Burglars are almost never armed. So how is killing unarmed people with lethal weapons proportional?

Tell me what is irrational about assuming an intruder into your home is there to kill or rape you when it's the middle of the night. I'm really interested in knowing your reasoning. I would not confront any intruder with anything less than deadly force. It's either that, or I hide in a closet and call the police. there is no middle ground, because you don't know, in fact, it is impossible to know, without putting yourself in grave danger, what the intruder is carrying or intends to do.


Exactly. What is the homeowner supposed to do, turn the lights on and ask the intruder what his intentions are and whether he has any weapons? When it's two in the morning and a stranger is creeping through your house, it is time to shoot first and ask questions later. No law should restrict a person's right to defend their last place of refuge.


What about incapacitating the intruder?
Are the only options for you hide or kill? Is there nothing in between?

Just give him a nice little smack with a frying pan or whatever blunt object you have ready and then call the police and the ambulance.
Deadly force should always be the last option after every other option fails and someone who considers it his first and only option and a natural right needs some psychological assistance imho.


For some reason your country tag makes me giggle about your response.

Seriously though why should the burden fall on the victim to minimize the danger the criminal may be in? Granted crime and violent crime in Germany is most likely less than in the states, but hitting some one with a frying pan that potentially has a gun isn't exactly high on my list, I find that .45 acp injected from my 1911 wisens them up

Non sensical. You are afraid to hit burgular with gun, but not afraid to shoot him? If he is in range so are you, or are you willing to risk your life because you belive your a superior gunman compared to him?


Bro, would you prefer to be in 10 feet away from a guy with a gun and have to be 1-2 feet away to be able to take action or 10 feet away with both of you able to take measures immediately?

Most owners of firearms for defensive purposes have trained with them in some measure (even if only going to the range every other month) and most burglars do not have a regular training or maintenance regimen. Not only that, the homeowner has defenders advantage.
Baller Fanclub || CheAse Fanclub || Scarlett Fanclub || LJD FIGHTING!
Prev 1 6 7 8 9 10 20 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 3h 3m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
ProTech116
StarCraft: Brood War
Shine 69
ajuk12(nOOB) 15
Icarus 12
Force[name] 7
Other Games
summit1g9384
Coldzera 755
JimRising 643
WinterStarcraft493
C9.Mang0281
Happy163
Mew2King74
Trikslyr19
trigger9
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• practicex 30
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 1
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2327
League of Legends
• Rush1009
• Lourlo680
Upcoming Events
KCM Race Survival
3h 3m
Ultimate Battle
5h 3m
ZerO vs Bisu
Big Brain Bouts
10h 3m
FoxeR vs Bly
LetaleX vs MilkiCow
Reynor vs Lambo
RSL Revival
1d 4h
AI Arena Tournament
1d 10h
BSL
1d 13h
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
2 days
IPSL
2 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
2 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
2 days
[ Show More ]
WardiTV Weekly
3 days
Kung Fu Cup
4 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
4 days
The PondCast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.