• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 18:05
CET 00:05
KST 08:05
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11[ASL22] Ro16 Preview: Holy Diver5
Community News
Dark completes military service, returns to SC212[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0Weekly Cups (October 19-25): Clem triples first in 5.0.175
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Serral's getting trashed by New Catsle's Mind Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top? Liquibets sc2 season 30
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Top Players of October 2026 (EBPD Rankings)
Tourneys
2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [$1250] International ShieldBattery League [BSL23] Ro16 Group C - Sunday 21:00 CET [Megathread] Daily Proleagues
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc Nintendo Switch Thread List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 16269 users

Is Morality Subjective or Objective? - Page 30

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 28 29 30 31 32 40 Next All
Fyodor
Profile Blog Joined September 2010
Canada971 Posts
May 12 2011 08:30 GMT
#581
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

I have no idea what that is supposed to mean.
llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll
imagine7xy
Profile Joined March 2010
United States34 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-05-12 08:38:13
May 12 2011 08:35 GMT
#582
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.
Jameser
Profile Joined July 2010
Sweden951 Posts
May 12 2011 08:38 GMT
#583
morality is obviously subjective by definition

ethics however can be constructed to have an arbitrary set of laws, in which case it can become objective
HULKAMANIA
Profile Blog Joined December 2004
United States1219 Posts
May 12 2011 08:41 GMT
#584
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.

Natural selection wants nothing.
If it were not so, I would have told you.
Poffel
Profile Joined March 2011
471 Posts
May 12 2011 08:42 GMT
#585
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

I'll just take this as an illustration of my former post, where I criticised Harris for being a demagogue. Only in demagogy, one could actually be perceived as the losing side of an argument when arguing for well-being... in a real argument, systemic doubt would be below the belt, and only factual doubt counts.

As for your Nietzsche reference, please look that up again. Nietzsche's amor fati implies to accept suffering as a part of life, but nowhere does Nietzsche argue against well-being... quite the opposite actually.
imagine7xy
Profile Joined March 2010
United States34 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-05-12 08:50:53
May 12 2011 08:48 GMT
#586
On May 12 2011 17:41 HULKAMANIA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.

Natural selection wants nothing.

Yes, technically, but natural selection is running simulations that maximize the survival of genes... No?
D10
Profile Blog Joined December 2007
Brazil3409 Posts
May 12 2011 08:50 GMT
#587
On May 12 2011 06:04 HuHEN wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 05:50 D10 wrote:
Theres 2 things in the bible and other religions that stand out to me as moral constants in the universe.

Love the others as you love yourself, which means, do not to the other what you wouldnt want done in yourself (basically, dont get other people in shit, give em shit, hurt em, blind fanatics trying to opress people with religious views wouldnt exacly qualify in my view, as being correct as much as they disagree)

Thats a powerfull message right there, bigger and broader than any religion, but people fail to see it for what it is



I think "do onto others as you would have done to yourself" is a good mantra, but it cant be applied inflexibly to everything, I mean, is it good to hurt a masochist? Probably yes, but I wouldn't want to be spanked. lol.


Yes of course, context is of the essence
" We are not humans having spiritual experiences. - We are spirits having human experiences." - Pierre Teilhard de Chardin
Lixler
Profile Joined March 2010
United States265 Posts
May 12 2011 08:55 GMT
#588
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.


There's a bit of a gap in your logic here. I'll give you the idea that natural selection binds us to moral actions (let's say, for the sake of argument, entirely and universally), but it's an error to assume that we can expand this class of actions with scientific research. The things natural selection binds us to may fit into a certain class (maximizing well-being), but that does not mean we are bound to all actions in that class. Scientific investigation might help us find out more things that maximize well-being, but we are not actually bound (by natural selection, at least) to do these things.

Take a couple examples of moral cases. One example of a moral good from natural selection is feeding starving people. Clearly it's advantageous for a species to give some food to people who are about to die. Now, for a scientifically discovered moral good, let's take the example of stem cell therapies (assume that they work 100%, if you don't mind). It generally increases well-being to take unused stem cells from aborted fetuses or what-have-you (we don't need to do that any more, but this is a half-hypothetical example) and to give those stem cells to Alzheimer's patients/quadraplegics/I don't have any more examples. But we run into a problem after we acknowledge this - a lot of people don't actually approve of stem cell research. Many people don't feel an obligation to support stem cell research, even though it increases well-being, and a few people even actively try to hinder it.

So we can see that even if we might say that natural selection is trying to point us in the direction of a certain class of actions, all it can actually bind us to are things which could be discovered during the evolutionary process (forgive my bad terminology). Natural selection has no way to bind us to things we found out after it's been completed, e.g. any scientific discoveries. There is, of course, another class of argument which could say our inherited inclinations have nothing to do with morality (you can argue this from an objective or a subjective viewpoint), but that's an entirely differently thing.
HULKAMANIA
Profile Blog Joined December 2004
United States1219 Posts
May 12 2011 08:57 GMT
#589
On May 12 2011 17:48 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:41 HULKAMANIA wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.

Natural selection wants nothing.

Yes, technically, but natural selection is running simulations that maximize the survival of genes... No?

I dunno. I think you're still talking as if there is some entity called "natural selection" and it has agency. "Natural selection" is just a phrase. It's just a model for explaining certain aspects of biology. The phenomena to which "natural selection" refers has no purpose. It has no goal. It's not wanting or giving or running anything.
If it were not so, I would have told you.
imagine7xy
Profile Joined March 2010
United States34 Posts
May 12 2011 09:06 GMT
#590
On May 12 2011 17:57 HULKAMANIA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:48 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:41 HULKAMANIA wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.

Natural selection wants nothing.

Yes, technically, but natural selection is running simulations that maximize the survival of genes... No?

I dunno. I think you're still talking as if there is some entity called "natural selection" and it has agency. "Natural selection" is just a phrase. It's just a model for explaining certain aspects of biology. The phenomena to which "natural selection" refers has no purpose. It has no goal. It's not wanting or giving or running anything.

No, you misunderstood me. I was simply referring to the fact that natural selection tries to maximize survival. Whether you want to use the term purpose or agency is a matter of semantics.
imagine7xy
Profile Joined March 2010
United States34 Posts
May 12 2011 09:10 GMT
#591
On May 12 2011 17:55 Lixler wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.


There's a bit of a gap in your logic here. I'll give you the idea that natural selection binds us to moral actions (let's say, for the sake of argument, entirely and universally), but it's an error to assume that we can expand this class of actions with scientific research. The things natural selection binds us to may fit into a certain class (maximizing well-being), but that does not mean we are bound to all actions in that class. Scientific investigation might help us find out more things that maximize well-being, but we are not actually bound (by natural selection, at least) to do these things.

Take a couple examples of moral cases. One example of a moral good from natural selection is feeding starving people. Clearly it's advantageous for a species to give some food to people who are about to die. Now, for a scientifically discovered moral good, let's take the example of stem cell therapies (assume that they work 100%, if you don't mind). It generally increases well-being to take unused stem cells from aborted fetuses or what-have-you (we don't need to do that any more, but this is a half-hypothetical example) and to give those stem cells to Alzheimer's patients/quadraplegics/I don't have any more examples. But we run into a problem after we acknowledge this - a lot of people don't actually approve of stem cell research. Many people don't feel an obligation to support stem cell research, even though it increases well-being, and a few people even actively try to hinder it.

So we can see that even if we might say that natural selection is trying to point us in the direction of a certain class of actions, all it can actually bind us to are things which could be discovered during the evolutionary process (forgive my bad terminology). Natural selection has no way to bind us to things we found out after it's been completed, e.g. any scientific discoveries. There is, of course, another class of argument which could say our inherited inclinations have nothing to do with morality (you can argue this from an objective or a subjective viewpoint), but that's an entirely differently thing.

Again, semantics around the word bound.
HULKAMANIA
Profile Blog Joined December 2004
United States1219 Posts
May 12 2011 09:14 GMT
#592
On May 12 2011 18:06 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:57 HULKAMANIA wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:48 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:41 HULKAMANIA wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.

Natural selection wants nothing.

Yes, technically, but natural selection is running simulations that maximize the survival of genes... No?

I dunno. I think you're still talking as if there is some entity called "natural selection" and it has agency. "Natural selection" is just a phrase. It's just a model for explaining certain aspects of biology. The phenomena to which "natural selection" refers has no purpose. It has no goal. It's not wanting or giving or running anything.

No, you misunderstood me. I was simply referring to the fact that natural selection tries to maximize survival. Whether you want to use the term purpose or agency is a matter of semantics.

I may have misunderstood you, but there exists the possibility that you misunderstood me or that we misunderstood one another. At any rate, I don't know how helpful the "you're just talking semantics" tack is at this point.
If it were not so, I would have told you.
HULKAMANIA
Profile Blog Joined December 2004
United States1219 Posts
May 12 2011 09:15 GMT
#593
On May 12 2011 18:10 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:55 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.


There's a bit of a gap in your logic here. I'll give you the idea that natural selection binds us to moral actions (let's say, for the sake of argument, entirely and universally), but it's an error to assume that we can expand this class of actions with scientific research. The things natural selection binds us to may fit into a certain class (maximizing well-being), but that does not mean we are bound to all actions in that class. Scientific investigation might help us find out more things that maximize well-being, but we are not actually bound (by natural selection, at least) to do these things.

Take a couple examples of moral cases. One example of a moral good from natural selection is feeding starving people. Clearly it's advantageous for a species to give some food to people who are about to die. Now, for a scientifically discovered moral good, let's take the example of stem cell therapies (assume that they work 100%, if you don't mind). It generally increases well-being to take unused stem cells from aborted fetuses or what-have-you (we don't need to do that any more, but this is a half-hypothetical example) and to give those stem cells to Alzheimer's patients/quadraplegics/I don't have any more examples. But we run into a problem after we acknowledge this - a lot of people don't actually approve of stem cell research. Many people don't feel an obligation to support stem cell research, even though it increases well-being, and a few people even actively try to hinder it.

So we can see that even if we might say that natural selection is trying to point us in the direction of a certain class of actions, all it can actually bind us to are things which could be discovered during the evolutionary process (forgive my bad terminology). Natural selection has no way to bind us to things we found out after it's been completed, e.g. any scientific discoveries. There is, of course, another class of argument which could say our inherited inclinations have nothing to do with morality (you can argue this from an objective or a subjective viewpoint), but that's an entirely differently thing.

Again, semantics around the word bound.

Yeah, Lixler, quit bringing your semantics into a philosophical discussion.
If it were not so, I would have told you.
Lixler
Profile Joined March 2010
United States265 Posts
May 12 2011 09:15 GMT
#594
On May 12 2011 18:10 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:55 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.


There's a bit of a gap in your logic here. I'll give you the idea that natural selection binds us to moral actions (let's say, for the sake of argument, entirely and universally), but it's an error to assume that we can expand this class of actions with scientific research. The things natural selection binds us to may fit into a certain class (maximizing well-being), but that does not mean we are bound to all actions in that class. Scientific investigation might help us find out more things that maximize well-being, but we are not actually bound (by natural selection, at least) to do these things.

Take a couple examples of moral cases. One example of a moral good from natural selection is feeding starving people. Clearly it's advantageous for a species to give some food to people who are about to die. Now, for a scientifically discovered moral good, let's take the example of stem cell therapies (assume that they work 100%, if you don't mind). It generally increases well-being to take unused stem cells from aborted fetuses or what-have-you (we don't need to do that any more, but this is a half-hypothetical example) and to give those stem cells to Alzheimer's patients/quadraplegics/I don't have any more examples. But we run into a problem after we acknowledge this - a lot of people don't actually approve of stem cell research. Many people don't feel an obligation to support stem cell research, even though it increases well-being, and a few people even actively try to hinder it.

So we can see that even if we might say that natural selection is trying to point us in the direction of a certain class of actions, all it can actually bind us to are things which could be discovered during the evolutionary process (forgive my bad terminology). Natural selection has no way to bind us to things we found out after it's been completed, e.g. any scientific discoveries. There is, of course, another class of argument which could say our inherited inclinations have nothing to do with morality (you can argue this from an objective or a subjective viewpoint), but that's an entirely differently thing.

Again, semantics around the word bound.

I apologize, but I feel like those semantics are crucial in saying that natural selection establishes any kind of system of morality. What word would you say best fits the relationship between natural selection and morality?
THE_DOMINATOR
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
United States309 Posts
May 12 2011 09:18 GMT
#595
On May 12 2011 07:16 Blyadischa wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 07:12 THE_DOMINATOR wrote:
Morality is by definition an abstract societal construct. Since morality is only(at the present) created by and used by human beings and since human beings are subjective in nature morality is therefore subjective and only constructed by a subjective mind.


No, morality is, by definition, a concept of right and wrong. Whether it is a societal construct or something much greater than that is the subject of debate.

whoop de doo doesn't change anything in my argument
DOMINATION
HornyHydra
Profile Joined February 2011
Taiwan222 Posts
May 12 2011 09:19 GMT
#596
I think morals are inherently objective, but later on in one's life, they become influenced by the people around them and they start to have more of a subjective view on morals.
Prime ♥
THE_DOMINATOR
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
United States309 Posts
May 12 2011 09:19 GMT
#597
On May 12 2011 07:18 Fyodor wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 07:12 THE_DOMINATOR wrote:
Morality is by definition an abstract societal construct. Since morality is only(at the present) created by and used by human beings and since human beings are subjective in nature morality is therefore subjective and only constructed by a subjective mind.


Morality is by definition an abstract societal construct.

Not so sure about that.

Since morality is only(at the present) created by and used by human beings

Irrelevant?

human beings are subjective in nature

Since when? I think your computer would have great difficulty processing information if that were true.

since human beings are subjective in nature morality is therefore subjective and only constructed by a subjective mind.

I guess the inference is valid somewhat but your premises are beyond ridiculous. Untenable conclusion.

Build me a physical manifestation of morality and we'll talk
DOMINATION
zocktol
Profile Blog Joined December 2010
Germany1928 Posts
May 12 2011 09:32 GMT
#598
On May 12 2011 18:06 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 17:57 HULKAMANIA wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:48 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:41 HULKAMANIA wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.

Natural selection wants nothing.

Yes, technically, but natural selection is running simulations that maximize the survival of genes... No?

I dunno. I think you're still talking as if there is some entity called "natural selection" and it has agency. "Natural selection" is just a phrase. It's just a model for explaining certain aspects of biology. The phenomena to which "natural selection" refers has no purpose. It has no goal. It's not wanting or giving or running anything.

No, you misunderstood me. I was simply referring to the fact that natural selection tries to maximize survival. Whether you want to use the term purpose or agency is a matter of semantics.

Natural selection in and of itself wants nothing. Just like breathing wants nothing. it is just the description of a process.
During natural selection however the most succesfull genes are passed on. If theses involve cooperation, then something like morality is passed on and would be universal.
However, the fact that Xenophobia is also part of Human nature and violence is a big part of human history, i would not go so far and state that morality is universal. As we can see in the difference between cultures(Taliban vs. the "Western" culture), where totally different forms of moral exist. This indicates that the form of Moral you follow is subjective, morality in and of itself, if we define it as the ability to create a way that you are supposed to act in, is however universal.
Concluding i would reason that the ability to have Moral is universal, but what is acceptable within your form of moral is subjective however.
If something about my train of thoughts is unclear, please tell me cause i am not a native speaker so my thoughts might not be understandable
imagine7xy
Profile Joined March 2010
United States34 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-05-12 09:52:33
May 12 2011 09:42 GMT
#599
On May 12 2011 18:15 Lixler wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 18:10 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:55 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.


There's a bit of a gap in your logic here. I'll give you the idea that natural selection binds us to moral actions (let's say, for the sake of argument, entirely and universally), but it's an error to assume that we can expand this class of actions with scientific research. The things natural selection binds us to may fit into a certain class (maximizing well-being), but that does not mean we are bound to all actions in that class. Scientific investigation might help us find out more things that maximize well-being, but we are not actually bound (by natural selection, at least) to do these things.

Take a couple examples of moral cases. One example of a moral good from natural selection is feeding starving people. Clearly it's advantageous for a species to give some food to people who are about to die. Now, for a scientifically discovered moral good, let's take the example of stem cell therapies (assume that they work 100%, if you don't mind). It generally increases well-being to take unused stem cells from aborted fetuses or what-have-you (we don't need to do that any more, but this is a half-hypothetical example) and to give those stem cells to Alzheimer's patients/quadraplegics/I don't have any more examples. But we run into a problem after we acknowledge this - a lot of people don't actually approve of stem cell research. Many people don't feel an obligation to support stem cell research, even though it increases well-being, and a few people even actively try to hinder it.

So we can see that even if we might say that natural selection is trying to point us in the direction of a certain class of actions, all it can actually bind us to are things which could be discovered during the evolutionary process (forgive my bad terminology). Natural selection has no way to bind us to things we found out after it's been completed, e.g. any scientific discoveries. There is, of course, another class of argument which could say our inherited inclinations have nothing to do with morality (you can argue this from an objective or a subjective viewpoint), but that's an entirely differently thing.

Again, semantics around the word bound.

I apologize, but I feel like those semantics are crucial in saying that natural selection establishes any kind of system of morality. What word would you say best fits the relationship between natural selection and morality?

The relationship is that following certain morals directly affects our behavior, and that behavior directly affects our survival. Ideas concerning morality propagate mainly through indoctrination, but those ideas origins are from human minds. The net effect of those ideas have severe consequences on survival.

If you had to guess if there was a civilization of people who believed its OK to kill children, and a civilization that decided its NOT OK, which one will continue to EXIST? Thus, a simulation is occurring, and TODAY after tens of thousands of years MORALITY is getting FINE-TUNED through natural selection. That is a very extreme example, but we have limited time, but do not underestimate time duration and net effects of morality.

The tricky thing is, do we have to LET NATURAL SELECTION run a simulation to find good morality, or can we do so scientifically. Well first, lets look at what took place in the example above... What is natural selection doing? It is maximizing survival, ie a big part of well-being.

So when I say we are "We are bound to maximizing well-being" perhaps you are closer to understanding the context, aside from the semantics. Keep in mind, there is a reason he uses "maximize well-being" and not "maximize survival". Well-being is more appropriate because it hints at ideas about what helps human flourish in sophisticated contexts, and conditions, or having nervous systems and feelings, and all that jazz built into us on the long journey here... I don't have enough time to go into all of it right now but realize in the end its subjective morality. It is by no means completely objective, you can't explain to an extra terrestrial why its wrong to physically torture if they are in a body that doesn't feel physical pain for some reason (as an extreme example.)

and at the same time its not appropriate to say evolution has nothing to do with morality.
Lixler
Profile Joined March 2010
United States265 Posts
May 12 2011 09:51 GMT
#600
On May 12 2011 18:42 imagine7xy wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 12 2011 18:15 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 18:10 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:55 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:35 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:29 Lixler wrote:
On May 12 2011 17:26 imagine7xy wrote:
On May 12 2011 16:59 Fyodor wrote:
On May 12 2011 15:53 XeliN wrote:
Instead of saying that perhaps provide a coherent argument for why you disagree with him and/or think he is a bad philosopher.

Harris keeps stumbling on the point Craig keeps hammering. The concept that maximizing well-being is something which we are all bound to is ridiculous. He refutes himself when he says "who are you to say that we are obligated to maximize well-being?" but then he shrugs it off without giving the question the seriousness it deserves. He just gives you a dumbfounded look that just says "duh, well-being man, it's soooo obvious duuude".

Craig is right on that. Harris has not succeeded in grounding his well-being concept as a binding moral obligation. His entire philosophy is a failure. It seems good enough at first sight yes. But consider for example the Nietzschean thought that suffering, intoxication and destruction can be desirable for the life-affirming type of man. Harris does not cover that angle very well and he knows it. He tries to cover it up so hard with that mocking look on his face. I do believe Nietzsche has a much more satisfying account of human morality than Harris. On so many levels. It's so arrogant on Harris' part to claim that his work is objective and no one else's is.

But I will say that evolutionary accounts of morality are interesting. However I think they have a limit. I think they are more useful as a descriptive, historical, explanatory tool than a prescriptive tool for me or future generations.

(BTW, I used Nietzsche here but feel free to insert any other philosopher. It's just who I had in mind at that precise moment."

We are bound to maximizing well-being, that is what natural selection does. That is where it enters the realm of the physical.

That isn't really a coherent idea. What does "bound" mean? "Bound" in the same sense that we are bound to eat food? But certainly this is false - we aren't physically incapable of performing immoral acts.

Do you mean natural selection has somehow placed moral obligations on us that transcend our inclinations?

Bound in the Homeward Bound sense, as Headed or intending to head in a specified direction. Yes, that is what natural selection wants, to survive. It gives you a nervous system so you can sense pain and avoid danger for instance. Harris's morality is subjective in the sense that it is up to us to determine individual or collectively what maximizes well being. It's a scientific approach to morality that takes into account our evolutionary origins as well.


There's a bit of a gap in your logic here. I'll give you the idea that natural selection binds us to moral actions (let's say, for the sake of argument, entirely and universally), but it's an error to assume that we can expand this class of actions with scientific research. The things natural selection binds us to may fit into a certain class (maximizing well-being), but that does not mean we are bound to all actions in that class. Scientific investigation might help us find out more things that maximize well-being, but we are not actually bound (by natural selection, at least) to do these things.

Take a couple examples of moral cases. One example of a moral good from natural selection is feeding starving people. Clearly it's advantageous for a species to give some food to people who are about to die. Now, for a scientifically discovered moral good, let's take the example of stem cell therapies (assume that they work 100%, if you don't mind). It generally increases well-being to take unused stem cells from aborted fetuses or what-have-you (we don't need to do that any more, but this is a half-hypothetical example) and to give those stem cells to Alzheimer's patients/quadraplegics/I don't have any more examples. But we run into a problem after we acknowledge this - a lot of people don't actually approve of stem cell research. Many people don't feel an obligation to support stem cell research, even though it increases well-being, and a few people even actively try to hinder it.

So we can see that even if we might say that natural selection is trying to point us in the direction of a certain class of actions, all it can actually bind us to are things which could be discovered during the evolutionary process (forgive my bad terminology). Natural selection has no way to bind us to things we found out after it's been completed, e.g. any scientific discoveries. There is, of course, another class of argument which could say our inherited inclinations have nothing to do with morality (you can argue this from an objective or a subjective viewpoint), but that's an entirely differently thing.

Again, semantics around the word bound.

I apologize, but I feel like those semantics are crucial in saying that natural selection establishes any kind of system of morality. What word would you say best fits the relationship between natural selection and morality?

The relationship is that following certain morals directly affects our behavior, and that behavior directly affects our survival. Ideas concerning morality propagate mainly through indoctrination, but those ideas origins are from human minds. The net effect of those ideas have severe consequences on survival.

If you had to guess if there was a civilization of people who believed its OK to kill children, and a civilization that decided its NOT OK, which one will continue to EXIST? Thus, a simulation is occurring, and TODAY after tens of thousands of years MORALITY is getting FINE-TUNED through natural selection. That is a very extreme example, but we have limited time, but do not underestimate time duration and net effects of morality.

The tricky thing is, do we have to LET NATURAL SELECTION run a simulation to find good morality, or can we do so scientifically. Well first, lets look at what took place in the example above... What is natural selection doing? It is maximizing survival, ie well being.

So when I say we are "We are bound to maximizing well-being" perhaps you are closer to understanding the context, aside from the semantics.

I'm terribly sorry, but I asked you what the relationship was between natural selection and morality. It might look like "morality" and "well-being/survival" mean the same thing, but that assumption is what the argument is about. Why is morality defined by "promoting survival?"

I understand the basic point here - an appeal to morality as a sort of shared concept throughout humanity which was developed through environmental pressures - but I think the question that is being asked is what about that concept of morality makes it "objective?" Subjectivists are trying to ask something like "Why should I do moral actions?" and I don't think the answer "Natural selection has prodded you in that direction" is what they are looking for.
Prev 1 28 29 30 31 32 40 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 17h 56m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Nathanias 111
SpeCial 57
StarCraft: Brood War
Rain 2273
Noble 6
Dota 2
monkeys_forever300
Counter-Strike
pashabiceps1848
Super Smash Bros
PPMD104
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr73
Other Games
tarik_tv5977
Grubby2888
summit1g2775
shahzam451
PiGStarcraft340
Liquid`Hasu232
ToD192
C9.Mang0184
Organizations
Other Games
BasetradeTV149
[ Show 12 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hupsaiya 106
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Eskiya23 25
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Other Games
• imaqtpie1335
• Shiphtur628
Upcoming Events
Monday Night Weeklies
17h 56m
PiGosaur Cup
1d 1h
The PondCast
1d 10h
OSC
1d 16h
Replay Cast
1d 23h
GSL
2 days
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
2 days
OSC
2 days
Replay Cast
2 days
KCM Race Survival
3 days
[ Show More ]
RSL Revival
4 days
BSL
4 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
5 days
BSL
5 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
5 days
WardiTV Weekly
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Individual League
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 6
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.