On July 25 2012 05:15 wei2coolman wrote:
What's KMD's overall sentiment on Kpop groups making albums/songs in other languages, just to spread market value? ie, SNSD making japanese album, and american album. etcetc? personally i don't really like it. The k-pop-ness just doesn't spread in other languages/countries that well imo.
What's KMD's overall sentiment on Kpop groups making albums/songs in other languages, just to spread market value? ie, SNSD making japanese album, and american album. etcetc? personally i don't really like it. The k-pop-ness just doesn't spread in other languages/countries that well imo.
Well at least in America, the idea of "Idols" is completely foreign, which hurts it a bit. The girls are as tied to the songs as the music and lyrics are. I mean, sure, we have pop stars and celebrities, but it's not quite the same thing. A K-pop idol (and the J-pop ones as well, though I don't follow those as closely) is an image, it's a role and personality. You're not "someone who makes music", you're an icon for more or less anyone following you, which includes most of the young adult to adult crowd in Korea (and Japan). In contrast, I could tell you who some of the big pop icons are in America, but they don't permeate society the way idols do.
Another reason, and one a bit more easily seen, is the type of music. Many K-pop hits (especially the title songs) are bubblegummy, fun songs that haven't been part of American media for quite some time. It's quite different compared to the type of party rock and pop music you hear in the states. Some female audiences find it childish (mostly because it's not talking about sex and drinking :\ ), many guys find it girly. It's nearly the epitome of acquired taste, so I'd really never expect it to seep into American markets any time soon.
Japan seems to embrace them a bit more, but I think they'll never have quite the same sales over there because Japan has their own set of idols and groups. Only the really big names or really good groups are probably looked at, you're not going to get every group that pops up.