It would be a mindfuck if theon did kill bran and Rickon. Everything points to it obviously not being them but those orphan boys, but you never know.
Don't spoil, jesus christ wtf?
Very much not a spoiler. It showed us the boys heading to a farmhouse where there were two orphan boys, Theon being there and not being able to find them, them finding a clue and then two charred corpses. Our assumption as the viewer is that he killed the orphans but we don't know for sure.
ty for defending, I havn't even read the books yet so was just saying it would be a mindfuck if it ended up being them.
On May 15 2012 01:07 Art_of_Kill wrote: damn it only 3 episodes left :-(
Indeed,, i'm always hyped as fuck before watching the eps.. But after it's over i know it's one more episode from the season ending and having to wait a LONG freaking time for the next one.. =/
Definitely have to agree with them on Theon he is really not trying to be bad but he is always getting over his head. He is so royally fucked now though.
I think Arya is giving too much to Tywin. He already figured out that her father is not a stone worker. And whoever keeps secrets is a danger to him at this point. She should look and act dumb and ignorant more if she cares about her life. But i guess she started respecting Tywin not only as enemy, as a human being, maybe a friend too. She is playing with fire.
On May 15 2012 01:33 Aelfric wrote: I think Arya is giving too much to Tywin. He already figured out that her father is not a stone worker. And whoever keeps secrets is a danger to him at this point. She should look and act dumb and ignorant more if she cares about her life. But i guess she started respecting Tywin not only as enemy, as a human being, maybe a friend too. She is playing with fire.
I think people are giving Arya too much credit. She's been really clever about stuff so far, and she's definitely smarter than your average 9 yearold (or however old she is), but in the end she's still a kid, and kids slip up in their lies.
I hope those were the orphans getting killed. (Well there's a sentence I didn't think I'd ever write). The Mini Starks, just haven't done enough stuff in the story yet to be sacrificed. The whole dream-thing Bran has got going seems like it requires some kind of followup/conclusion, for instance.
On May 15 2012 01:33 Aelfric wrote: I think Arya is giving too much to Tywin. He already figured out that her father is not a stone worker. And whoever keeps secrets is a danger to him at this point. She should look and act dumb and ignorant more if she cares about her life. But i guess she started respecting Tywin not only as enemy, as a human being, maybe a friend too. She is playing with fire.
I think people are giving Arya too much credit. She's been really clever about stuff so far, and she's definitely smarter than your average 9 yearold (or however old she is), but in the end she's still a kid, and kids slip up in their lies.
I know that she is only a kid but she is still giving away too much anyway. She is smart but not enough to outsmart Tywin so she needs to be careful.
I think it's pretty obvious that Theon killed orphans, if they were really the stark boys he wouldn't have burned them. He would have let the townspeople see their lords in all their glory.
It's a shame though because I fucking hate Bran.
Episode was nice, Jamie is a fucking cruel sob, bashing his cousin's face in.. ouch. I wonder how much longer lady stark can hold off the men from ripping Jamie apart. I like the scene where the queen speaks with Sansa and Tyrion and finally admits (to us) that Jeoffrey is a little shit.
That warlock guy saved Dany's story from being dreadfully boring and Arya and Tywin are as awesome as ever.
On May 15 2012 03:02 crms wrote: I think it's pretty obvious that Theon killed orphans, if they were really the stark boys he wouldn't have burned them. He would have let the townspeople see their lords in all their glory.
But what does he gain by pretending to have killed them? Now he needs to act as if the job was done and stop looking for them. Does not seem like a smart move to me..... unless I am missing something.
On May 15 2012 03:02 crms wrote: I think it's pretty obvious that Theon killed orphans, if they were really the stark boys he wouldn't have burned them. He would have let the townspeople see their lords in all their glory.
But what does he gain by pretending to have killed them? Now he needs to act as if the job was done and stop looking for them. Does not seem like a smart move to me..... unless I am missing something.
He sure would look the fool in front of his sister if he had his few man scattered across the land searching for a crippled boy
might as well say screw it, we aint doing nothin about it
On May 15 2012 03:02 crms wrote: I think it's pretty obvious that Theon killed orphans, if they were really the stark boys he wouldn't have burned them. He would have let the townspeople see their lords in all their glory.
But what does he gain by pretending to have killed them? Now he needs to act as if the job was done and stop looking for them. Does not seem like a smart move to me..... unless I am missing something.
He Lost the scent trail, and probably wanted to return without being laughed at, So used the two orphans so he could concentrate on other jobs at winterfell
When Tywin referred to the current situation as a war of 5 kings, who does he refer to? Robb, Stanis, Jeoffery and ? (keeping in consideration Renly is already deceased >.>)
On May 15 2012 03:02 crms wrote: I think it's pretty obvious that Theon killed orphans, if they were really the stark boys he wouldn't have burned them. He would have let the townspeople see their lords in all their glory.
But what does he gain by pretending to have killed them? Now he needs to act as if the job was done and stop looking for them. Does not seem like a smart move to me..... unless I am missing something.
I'm 50/50 on whether he killed them or not. On one hand, two dead bodies plus if he let them go they would just make their way back to their brother and his family/men would find out he is weak.
But maybe, he found the stark boys and caught them. Kept them locked up somewhere safe then burned the two orhapn boys? Because it really doesn't make sense to have burned them unless you are trying to hide their face/identity imo.
Either way we will most likely find out next week!!! Can't wait!
On May 15 2012 03:18 constantine wrote: So can anyone recap for me so far?
When Tywin referred to the current situation as a war of 5 kings, who does he refer to? Robb, Stanis, Jeoffery and ? (keeping in consideration Renly is already deceased >.>)
On May 15 2012 03:18 constantine wrote: So can anyone recap for me so far?
When Tywin referred to the current situation as a war of 5 kings, who does he refer to? Robb, Stanis, Jeoffery and ? (keeping in consideration Renly is already deceased >.>)
who am I missing, help me out
Iron islands perhaps.
Robb, Stannis, Jeoffery, Renly(when the war started he was involved so he counts in the history books) and then yea the Theon's dad
On May 15 2012 03:18 constantine wrote: So can anyone recap for me so far?
When Tywin referred to the current situation as a war of 5 kings, who does he refer to? Robb, Stanis, Jeoffery and ? (keeping in consideration Renly is already deceased >.>)
who am I missing, help me out
Robb, Stannis, Renly, Joffrey, and Balon Greyjoy, I believe are the 5 kings referenced in the "War of the 5 Kings".
There's also Mance Rayder, "King Beyond the Wall" but I don't think people other than the Night Watch really know about what the hell is going on up there.
EPT
