|
On May 13 2016 05:45 Nedereden wrote:Show nested quote +On May 13 2016 05:34 Sn0_Man wrote:On May 13 2016 05:32 Aldehyde wrote:On May 13 2016 05:26 Dracolich70 wrote:On May 13 2016 05:25 Aldehyde wrote:On May 13 2016 05:21 Dracolich70 wrote:On May 13 2016 05:19 TanGeng wrote:On May 13 2016 05:12 Aldehyde wrote: I genuinely feel that people consistently read too much into too little. This constant talk about which team is t1/2/3.... Whatever, it changes from week to week and it's all because we don't see them play enough games to really know. Lose? Disband! Win? Reband! Draft Lost? Fire the drafter! Draft Win? Next genius! Such is the life of L/R threads. On a more calmer level. NewBee isn't terrible after losing one Bo3, but have better learn and adapt. OG looks stronger on this patch after finally playing some games on this one. Liquid making a strong case to be in the finals yet again. Evil Geniuses? Have some issues and Storm still sucks. Win or Lose, Epicenter is a great cup but against Major or TI, it doesn't even matter all that much. Aren't you and yours much of the reason for this overhype, overexaggeration of whom are good etc, until you actually find out the world is more grey area? Do you mean the previews and such? Because, yeah, those can fall on the overly dramatic side but it makes sense, they're just normal dudes who like Dota like the rest of us. The "problem" is with the whole community's mentality towards winning/losing and the meaning of it all. Probably won't change, too much fun to talk about dumpsters and these "dank" memes. Not just the previews, but their own opinions in the threads until proven wrong. Then they pretend it never happened. Don't follow the LRs on here frequently enough to notice many individual people other than maybe Azarkon. And that's primarily because he gets quoted 5 times per page. specifically he's mad at everybody with the moderator tag because i told him og aren't the 5 best dota players in the land and that i happen to think EG are better than OG Are you srs bout that? Current iteration EG better than OG? Sigh... when will you guys reach acceptance?
come on now EG has been top 4 to like 20 different LAN's in the past year or something
all of a sudden OG beats Newbee and omg they're the best team in teh world!! 1 one
|
The best team in the world must win the best team in China, that much is fact.
But they also have to be the best team in the West, That is not yet fact.
|
So who plays in the game after col vs VP tomorrow? still says TBD vs TBD on the schedule
|
Taking the discussion into a little different direction, I was reflecting on how good the Dota has been at Epicenter. Because all of the Chinese teams were terrible, most of Shanghai was pretty damn bad (regardless of production issues). That's part of the reason the Top 8 came out so odd. MVP wouldn't really get really good until after Shanghai, and they're they only real top-tier team that isn't at Epicenter.
It does help to have all of the teams working really hard in preparation for Manila. Which bodes really well for the Major.
|
On May 13 2016 06:05 Wineandbread wrote: So who plays in the game after col vs VP tomorrow? still says TBD vs TBD on the schedule
Liquidpedia has Newbee vs against the winner of Secret vs Alliance.
|
Before Frankfurt brackets: OG tier 3 team lost twice to Vega
Before Shanghai brackets: Secret tier 3 team lost to MVP and had shit results after Cr1t called them trash from end of Frankfurt
Every potentially top tier team is a single tournament away from changing the narrative you people are so fucking dramatic and this isn't even a relevant tournament in the first place
|
Russian Federation40190 Posts
On May 13 2016 06:12 hariooo wrote: Before Frankfurt brackets: OG tier 3 team lost twice to Vega
Before Shanghai brackets: Secret tier 3 team lost to MVP and had shit results after Cr1t called them trash from end of Frankfurt
Every potentially top tier team is a single tournament away from changing the narrative you people are so fucking dramatic and this isn't even a relevant tournament in the first place OG were tier 2 whole Frankfurt, get with your tiers. Also, Vega was considered kinda good back at Frankfurt.
|
On May 13 2016 05:33 Azarkon wrote:Show nested quote +On May 13 2016 05:10 InFiNitY[pG] wrote:On May 13 2016 05:01 Azarkon wrote:On May 13 2016 04:59 Taf the Ghost wrote: Well, still a chance for EG vs Secret on Saturday. (EG doesn't play again until Saturday, with the split up lower bracket.)
Though I'd expect EG vs Newbee, if we're being honest. Provided Secret goes through tomorrow's games without a problem, they should be able to win Newbee now that OG has shown how to play against them. OG didn't show anyone anything. They just played their own game at which they are by far the best in the world, and evem then they barely beat newbee in a very close series. To think that this secret team could play OGs strategy anywhere close to that level is delusional. Newbee isn't a one trick pony that you destroy once you figured out their style, they are a legitimately strong team. OG tried to play their own game against Kuroky's team and lost bad. Thinking that strategy has little to do with it is ridiculous. Newbee looked bad in their third game against OG because of how easy it was to out pick them. Now, Secret doesn't necessarily have the heroes and team work to do it. But that's why I said - provided they win tomorrow's games without a problem, which would then show that they have found their team work, because they're going up against teams that do have team work.
Never did I say that strategy had little to do with it, what I'm saying is that Secret would have lost Game 1 vs Newbee had they been given OG's heroes, simply because they cannot play the strategy OG used as well as OG plays it. Liquid were prepared for OG's style because they had studied/scrimmed against it and simply outplayed them based on that, Newbee obviously weren't prepared. But OG's basic strategy of defensive supports, tanky cores and great team fight was the same against each of their opponents, they didn't specifically draft any special "counter newbee" line-up that everyone can now copy to easily beat Newbee
|
On May 13 2016 07:09 InFiNitY[pG] wrote:Show nested quote +On May 13 2016 05:33 Azarkon wrote:On May 13 2016 05:10 InFiNitY[pG] wrote:On May 13 2016 05:01 Azarkon wrote:On May 13 2016 04:59 Taf the Ghost wrote: Well, still a chance for EG vs Secret on Saturday. (EG doesn't play again until Saturday, with the split up lower bracket.)
Though I'd expect EG vs Newbee, if we're being honest. Provided Secret goes through tomorrow's games without a problem, they should be able to win Newbee now that OG has shown how to play against them. OG didn't show anyone anything. They just played their own game at which they are by far the best in the world, and evem then they barely beat newbee in a very close series. To think that this secret team could play OGs strategy anywhere close to that level is delusional. Newbee isn't a one trick pony that you destroy once you figured out their style, they are a legitimately strong team. OG tried to play their own game against Kuroky's team and lost bad. Thinking that strategy has little to do with it is ridiculous. Newbee looked bad in their third game against OG because of how easy it was to out pick them. Now, Secret doesn't necessarily have the heroes and team work to do it. But that's why I said - provided they win tomorrow's games without a problem, which would then show that they have found their team work, because they're going up against teams that do have team work. Never did I say that strategy had little to do with it, what I'm saying is that Secret would have lost Game 1 vs Newbee had they been given OG's heroes, simply because they cannot play the strategy OG used as well as OG plays it. Liquid were prepared for OG's style because they had studied/scrimmed against it and simply outplayed them based on that, Newbee obviously weren't prepared. But OG's basic strategy of defensive supports, tanky cores and great team fight was the same against each of their opponents, they didn't specifically draft any special "counter newbee" line-up that everyone can now copy to easily beat Newbee
We'll see tomorrow, I guess. My personal thought about Newbee is that as a team, they play a certain way and with specific heroes, and don't change it up as much as, say, PPD's team does. OG found a way to beat the usual Newbee; Secret might or might not, but it ought to be easier for them to do so now that OG has shown two ways to deal with Newbee's run at you team fight strategy.
Of course, Secret has to get through Alliance, first. They won't necessarily do so.
|
On May 13 2016 06:12 hariooo wrote: Before Frankfurt brackets: OG tier 3 team lost twice to Vega
Before Shanghai brackets: Secret tier 3 team lost to MVP and had shit results after Cr1t called them trash from end of Frankfurt
Every potentially top tier team is a single tournament away from changing the narrative you people are so fucking dramatic and this isn't even a relevant tournament in the first place I think at least in part it's to do with just how few games a lot of these teams play now. It gives people even less to judge them off of, so when you finally do see them play, and they lose, it's no surprise people would be reacting pretty strongly. I do agree though that even with this in mind, our community is still way too dramatic. But I guess that's what it's all about nowadays, people want this forced and fake "storyline" bullshit for every tourney ever, so they put even more meaning on every match that's played.
|
I think the loss is actually a gift for newbee.
they wouldn't want to run into major or TI and be "figured out" or into a style that counter them.
that's the bane of Chinese teams, great timings (when they bother to practice), stubborn reliance on picks that achieve those timings, refusal to adapt until they run into a brick wall, then they disband and find another style.
that might be a TI4 era championship team, with the rise of west and the general understanding of the game these days, they won't be able to reproduce such results with the way they run their games.
newbee and China as a whole needs to diversify and really get into the pick/ban game.
|
Just watched the VoDs. Pretty sure this is going to be a rough 6 months. I feel like AUI contributes nothing at all. His carry play is really bad honestly.
|
Sanya12364 Posts
On May 13 2016 09:46 haduken wrote: I think the loss is actually a gift for newbee.
they wouldn't want to run into major or TI and be "figured out" or into a style that counter them.
that's the bane of Chinese teams, great timings (when they bother to practice), stubborn reliance on picks that achieve those timings, refusal to adapt until they run into a brick wall, then they disband and find another style.
that might be a TI4 era championship team, with the rise of west and the general understanding of the game these days, they won't be able to reproduce such results with the way they run their games.
newbee and China as a whole needs to diversify and really get into the pick/ban game. Overconfidence can be a thing for many teams that win too much before TI, if they think their strategy is impregnable or their skill is insurmountable.
That's not to abandon style though because teams have to play their style but still adapt to the meta. Like OG has a distinct style and Alliance has too. Reinventing themselves with other styles just doesn't work that well.
I don't see the critique about range of ban/picks. There is plenty of variety in games among Chinese but teams still play their own style and have varied amounts of success.
|
On May 13 2016 10:44 OuchyDathurts wrote: Just watched the VoDs. Pretty sure this is going to be a rough 6 months. I feel like AUI contributes nothing at all. His carry play is really bad honestly.
new teams new patch. everything is reset. now please for the love of icefrog everyone stop whining about your once top team not beeing at the top anymore.
|
On May 13 2016 10:55 Nyan wrote:Show nested quote +On May 13 2016 10:44 OuchyDathurts wrote: Just watched the VoDs. Pretty sure this is going to be a rough 6 months. I feel like AUI contributes nothing at all. His carry play is really bad honestly. https://twitter.com/FearDotA/status/726835891235336193new teams new patch. everything is reset. now please for the love of icefrog everyone stop whining about your once top team not beeing at the top anymore.
I mean, that's just flat out not true. But they can't change roles around because nothing would change. Gotta go back to the drawing board honestly or puberty better provide Sumail with some REALLY broad shoulders.
|
Newbee's problem has always been the draft. Take example of the final game vs OG. They have 0 lock down against puck and drow. Once the big disabling ulti (Static storm + ravage) is out, they can't control the Puck anymore. This happens multiple time. OG lure the static storm into Puck, Wisp saves him, then hold on until Wisp + Puck return, then voila, no way they can stop the Puck. I'm no mega pro drafter, but I think it would be better for Newbee to last pick something like Sven that has reliable stun.
Newbee too often get outdrafted. They "survive" Secret and EG by picking tanks and hold the game as long as possible until their enemies make mistakes. While OG pick the cheese strat and go for ultimate timing builds (at least in game 3) and Phoenix basically melts their Tanks in 2 first game, then force then to no lockdown in game 2
|
I think people are jumping their guns too quickly on an individual's performance without considering all the aspects. Let's not forget Dota is a team game. How a certain role performs is heavily reliant on others' performance as well. Misplays can be caused by your team mates not allowing you enough time or space to execute properly. Supports not warding at a proper place to provide sufficient vision for the initiator to do their job might eventually cause the carry to act instinctively and engage on a wrong target. Now if the carry ends up dying, most people blame the carry for wrong choice of target, but not knowing that based on the information he has at the point of execution, it is the only option. Now if that happens 5 times in a row, everyone would say that carry is subpar and doesn't know what he's doing. But no one questions why the shot caller decides to engage with insufficient vision in all those fights.
I'm not defending Aui or anyone in particular, just that core positions generally got bashed more frequently when things go wrong simply on the assumption that they should have performed better because they had more farm.
|
Wake up to a bunch of EG fanboys crying and pointing fingers. This is glorious. As if they can pinpoint failure on one person.
When Newbee started crumbling whose fault was it? I don't think they played worse, their strategy was just inferior for that game and they unraveled pretty quickly against OG's style of gameplay.
EG might look like they have execution problems, but maybe that is because they are setting themselves up for failure. When your criteria for winning requires too many specifics, maybe its time to think of a better plan.
|
i think EG is probably still likely to get top 3 at this tournament. So.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|