|
Calgary25980 Posts
REPLAYS: http://www.teamliquid.net/staff/Kennigit/Teamliquid_Attack__Episode_1.rar
Stream is Over: DOWNLOAD THE VOD from the tracker! (use the alternative download link) Or use the direct download link available here (courtesy of R1CH)
Episode 1 - {88}iNcontroL - February 24, 2008 @ 5 PM EST / 2 PM PST / 2200 GMT / 2300 CET Episode 2 - IdrA - ?
For those of you still unclear of what this is exactly, let me explain. I think it's pretty exciting.
This is a direct ripoff of B.Net Attack! You can find VODs of it here.
Each episode we will link up with a top Brood War player. We will then announce via a live stream which channel we are in, and wait for you to show up. It will then be your job to convince the staff on the stream that you are worthy of a game with our pro. If you are lucky enough to get a game, your game will be streamed live to hundreds of viewers while we comment on it with our pro.
This is all in good fun, so we encourage trash talk via the stream, and we will be definitely giving our pro some less than encouraging words if he does happen to make a mistake and lose. In this vein, we also encourage top players to smurf and embarass our pro on a live stream (wink wink).
Episode 1 Our first guest will be none other than iNcontroL! The number one player at the 2007 USA WCG finals, iNcontroL should need little introduction to BW fans anywhere. iNcontroL is not known for being shy in front of a microphone, so look forward to hearing many colourful comments during our first episode.
Episode 1 takes place this Sunday, February 24th, at 5 PM EST / 2 PM PST / 2200 GMT / 2300 CET. Hop on our stream and listen for the gateway and channel we are in for your chance to take him down. iNcontroL is known for giving plenty of games to weaker players, but this may be your one chance to take him down during a live event.
See you on Sunday!
+ Show Spoiler [Results] +Incontrol < uncontrollable (intrigue) ZvT Incontrol > ToT)Incontrol( ZvZ Incontrol < sMi.FakeSteve (ret) ZvT Incontrol > xmShake ZvT Incontrol > fagtron5000 ZvP Incontrol > Bisu-TL (gh-salv) ZvP Incontrol < Superiorwolf PvZ
|
intrigue
Washington, D.C9933 Posts
incontrol i'm gonna ez you LOL
|
|
Aha, this sounds cool. Maybe I'll try to get a freewin from these nubs.
|
I'm going to prepare something really special for our gosu!
Or maybe I'll just 5 pool.
|
Are you gonna try to get any korean pros?
|
What are you going to use for the stream?
|
Imma get that game and win it! lol
|
Sweet! 
This is sunday 23.00 CET (central european time, germany etc) or 22.00 GMT. Please dont forget us european members.
|
Haha, stream details?
Let's play scv football...1 pwn j00 ez
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 19 2008 03:31 Cascade wrote:Sweet!  This is sunday 23.00 CET (central european time, germany etc) or 22.00 GMT. Please dont forget us european members.  Thanks! I didn't mean to exclude you I was just too dumb to do the conversion. I edited my post with this information.
To answer the other questions: The stream will be a full video stream. I need to talk to R1CH to get the exact details, but I would assume it would be a VLC stream similar to his other streams. I believe it will have our audio embedded in it so you will only need one stream. I also asked if there can be a separate audio-only stream for people who cannot stream video and am waiting to hear back. Finally, the VODs should be saved and uploaded later with the commentary so you can watch past episodes at any time.
|
This is gonna be great, can't wait!
|
Will there be videos saved of it?
For those that can't get the stream of course. I would hate to miss out on this.
|
Oldschooler like Rekrul, Assem, Legionnaire or FiSheYe would be great, but still niiiice event, trying to watch it
|
On February 19 2008 03:34 Chill wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2008 03:31 Cascade wrote:Sweet!  This is sunday 23.00 CET (central european time, germany etc) or 22.00 GMT. Please dont forget us european members.  Thanks! I didn't mean to exclude you I was just too dumb to do the conversion. I edited my post with this information. To answer the other questions: The stream will be a full video stream. I need to talk to R1CH to get the exact details, but I would assume it would be a VLC stream similar to his other streams. I believe it will have our audio embedded in it so you will only need one stream. I also asked if there can be a separate audio-only stream for people who cannot stream video and am waiting to hear back. Finally, the VODs should be saved and uploaded later with the commentary so you can watch past episodes at any time.
Can the GomTV client stream VLC?
Don't make fun of me :[
|
Sure, Ctrl-U and input URL, or right-click, second option, third option (the Ctrl-U one ).
|
Calgary25980 Posts
I have no idea, VLC is a pretty lightweight program.
If for some reason you can't install VLC I will direct R1CH to answer your question to make sure you can watch.
|
|
Germany2896 Posts
There is no vlc stream. There are several streamingprotocols, including HTTP and MMS. These protocols usually transfer a containerformat like asf. The data itself is then encoded in formats such as mpeg,vc1 for video and aac or mp3 for audio. So you need a program which understands the streamingprotocoll, the container and has codecs for both video and audio. Both VLC and GOM claim to support everything important. So GOM is probably fine too. Perhaps even WMP works.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
Yep. I just know trying to use R1CH's streams with WMP didn't work for me, and his webpage says to use VLC. That's why I called it that.
|
Alright, thanks guys.
I'll be sure to tune into this.
|
This will be one kickass show
|
DAMMIT
now i wish i didn't give up gaming for lent. D:
seemed like an ok idea at the time.
now i deeply regret it. T_T
|
I wouldn't miss this for the world
|
I will for sure tune in
|
On February 19 2008 04:18 grobo wrote: I wouldn't miss this for the world
|
|
51446 Posts
On a Monday afternoon for me argh.
|
what a shameless ripoff
I like it!
|
Is this going to be like a weekly thing?
|
Awesome stuff, I'll definately try to be there! :D
|
Calgary25980 Posts
Probably not weekly. It will be sporadic, more like once a month. The first two episodes will be be pretty close to each other since we need to get Idra before he's out of the country.
Edit: Yep, it's really important to me that you try to show up and participate or get on the stream for this first run, just so we know that there is support for continuing this kind of thing.
Thanks!
|
so divided. I want to be selfish and play some games, but I know there are much better players out there.
I guess I should start working on a build :D
|
Everyone start studying some Inc reps, and hone your sniping skills!
|
fOrTT > Pads 2-0
edit: heh, this isint the clan art tour thread.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 19 2008 06:20 Pads wrote: fOrTT > Pads 2-0
Sick.
|
"iNcontroL is known for giving plenty of games to weaker players, but this may be your one chance to take him down during a live event."
CHARITY!
|
So, the average newbie like me could play geoff or do I need skill to convince the staff? If so, I'm A on iccup.
|
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 19 2008 06:42 Mandalor wrote: So, the average newbie like me could play geoff or do I need skill to convince the staff? If so, I'm A on iccup.
No skill required, just heart and some timely wit during the opponent selection to convince us you're worthy.
|
I will make incontrol cry!!!!!!!
|
Oh great, in that case I'm D- :D
|
I'm gonna min hack that sucker.
|
Awesome idea. Here's hoping someone will take down Inc.
|
|
hahaha this is a great idea, testie used to do this but it wasnt broadcasted ;x. I hope to get some very good players besides these two and I hope the matches last for a couple hours to get a few people a shot at playing. NICE
|
Calgary25980 Posts
Yea thanks dick. Because of you I have to make some elaborate clue system that didn't make sense and went nowhere.
:D <3
|
haha man this is gonna be wicked...
|
Kennigit
Canada19447 Posts
Yeah ShallowBay i know you cheated when you saw us talking about it in IRC.
|
On February 19 2008 08:55 Chill wrote:Yea thanks dick. Because of you I have to make some elaborate clue system that didn't make sense and went nowhere. :D <3
All in a days work <3 Kennigit, I don't even know how IRC works
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
|
Oh snap I bet iNc is just going to mass Queens and overrun my army with thousands of Broodlings.
/fail for me
|
On February 19 2008 04:00 goldenkrnboi wrote: DAMMIT
now i wish i didn't give up gaming for lent. D:
seemed like an ok idea at the time.
now i deeply regret it. T_T I gave up catholicism for lent.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
TL Attack is now sponsored (sort of)!
In each event (hopefully, but definitely for the first two) we will be giving out a prize. The prize will be announced tomorrow night when more details are nailed down.
This prize will be given for "best play". Now, that is difficult to define, but I can tell you that we will know it when we see it. The "best play" could be similar to Jumper]i['s epic trouncing of FakeSteve with a pimp play. It could be an innovative or risky build order. Or it could be solid, high-level play all game (wink wink high-level gamers thinking of coming). After the event, two TeamLiquid staff members, alongside the invited pro, will come to a decision on who is deserving of this prize. If a decision cannot be reached, even two out of three, then the pro will have final say.
Stay tuned for more details, and see you on Sunday!
|
On February 21 2008 01:33 Chill wrote: The "best play" could be similar to Jumper]i['s epic trouncing of FakeSteve with a pimp play.
Steve getting trounced is always a pimp play
|
Will there be a VOD's of this?
|
8748 Posts
gl hf inc! i know you like to do fun builds vs newbs so lets see that creativity! if you get in trouble, lurk drop!
|
Kennigit
Canada19447 Posts
On February 21 2008 02:56 ReiKo wrote: Will there be a VOD's of this? There will be replays and audio commentary. Not sure my or hotbid's comp could handle recording and streaming at the same time...we dont have a second comp for tv out yet.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 21 2008 03:21 Kennigit wrote:There will be replays and audio commentary. Not sure my or hotbid's comp could handle recording and streaming at the same time...we dont have a second comp for tv out yet.
Actually I can record it I think. Only thing is we'll have to wait 2-3 minutes between games while the video finishes encoding from Camtasia to avi.
|
On February 21 2008 03:34 Chill wrote:Show nested quote +On February 21 2008 03:21 Kennigit wrote:On February 21 2008 02:56 ReiKo wrote: Will there be a VOD's of this? There will be replays and audio commentary. Not sure my or hotbid's comp could handle recording and streaming at the same time...we dont have a second comp for tv out yet. Actually I can record it I think. Only thing is we'll have to wait 2-3 minutes between games while the video finishes encoding from Camtasia to avi. then you'll have a few minutes to find the next person right?
|
haha cool, coollll
|
Baltimore, USA22254 Posts
I think this is awesome... I might actually be working at that time, but I'd love to get a chance to play against someone like that... although they'd need some severe handicaps to make it anything but a one-sided rape, I'm so out of shape (and was never very good to begin with!).
|
This is overall good for the community and yet another opportunity for iNc to own some newbs or vise-verca ;D
|
Where is the link to the stream?
|
Kennigit
Canada19447 Posts
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
I cant wait to use queens / protoss ^_^
|
On February 25 2008 03:17 {88}iNcontroL wrote: I cant wait to use queens / protoss ^_^
lol u fucked up son
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On February 25 2008 03:17 {88}iNcontroL wrote: I cant wait to use queens / protoss ^_^
use only zerg! nobody wants to watch you play protoss
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
A. No, that isn't true. B. You cant mock someone with Z. Aside from infesteds/queens. P can do MUCH more. C. I naturally dont listen to you so...
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
if i show up i wanna play your zerg ok
|
we gonna see some infested CCs?
|
I hope something like bisu or something hosts a game.
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
On February 25 2008 05:59 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: if i show up i wanna play your zerg ok
Only if you promise not to leave until I say its ok
|
On February 25 2008 06:00 slained wrote: I hope something like bisu or something hosts a game.
HAHAHAHA. Bisu reads TL and is waiting for this opportunity!
|
am i doomed if i can't create games?
|
Camtasia is so horrible for viewing that unless you have a crazy tweak scheme, why not use Fraps?
|
On February 25 2008 06:38 Raithed wrote: Camtasia is so horrible for viewing that unless you have a crazy tweak scheme, why not use Fraps?
Crazy tweaked scheme?.. What on earth are you talking about?
|
Calgary25980 Posts
STREAM IS UP: VLC/GOM: mmsh://vps2.r1hosting.net:8080 WMP:mms://vps2.r1hosting.net:8080
|
Media player not working =/
|
Calgary25980 Posts
It was working 100% we're now having issues. Please keep trying and I'll update when I see it working.
|
On February 25 2008 06:57 Pwntrucci[sR] wrote: Media player not working =/
|
Stream not working in GOM or WMP for me using either URL so far.
edit: I wasted my 3000th post on this
|
On February 25 2008 07:00 NovaTheFeared wrote:Stream not working in GOM or WMP for me using either URL so far. edit: I wasted my 3000th post on this 
lol, you wouldn't have had to waste that post if you read the last 3 messages. .
gratz though.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
technical problems with the sound, it'll be fixed soon and then the stream will be up
|
At least I got a devourer avatar out of the deal.
Thanks for the update FakeSteve.
|
plzz how u watch this ???
where do i have to paste the link ???
|
On February 25 2008 07:02 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:technical problems with the sound, it'll be fixed soon and then the stream will be up 
Please tell us when its up, I don't want to have to repeatedly try every few seconds.
|
sorry I echo that guy how do we watch this again plz?
|
On February 25 2008 07:03 trollbone wrote: plzz how u watch this ???
where do i have to paste the link ???
In the URL address, or just go to the top right and click on the link next to the calendar
|
On February 25 2008 07:03 Try wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 07:02 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:technical problems with the sound, it'll be fixed soon and then the stream will be up  Please tell us when its up, I don't want to have to repeatedly try every few seconds.
Then you shouldn't have named your account "Try"....
+ Show Spoiler + Not funny?..
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 25 2008 07:03 Try wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 07:02 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:technical problems with the sound, it'll be fixed soon and then the stream will be up  Please tell us when its up, I don't want to have to repeatedly try every few seconds.
obviously we will
its not up
|
On February 25 2008 07:04 Nintu wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 07:03 Try wrote:On February 25 2008 07:02 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:technical problems with the sound, it'll be fixed soon and then the stream will be up  Please tell us when its up, I don't want to have to repeatedly try every few seconds. Then you shouldn't have named your account "Try".... + Show Spoiler + Not funny?..
...Fail?
|
Braavos36374 Posts
everyone please sit tight, incontrol is powering up
|
On February 25 2008 07:05 Hot_Bid wrote: everyone please sit tight, incontrol is powering up
Lol, for some reason that gave me some funny imagery (I can see Incontrol working out and getting pumped up).
|
Incontrol is powering up??
Over 9000?
|
On February 25 2008 07:06 Try wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 07:05 Hot_Bid wrote: everyone please sit tight, incontrol is powering up Lol, for some reason that gave me some funny imagery (I can see Incontrol working out and getting pumped up).
Weird, I pictured multiple "Over 9000!!!!!" videos.
edit:
On February 25 2008 07:07 Psyonic_Reaver wrote: Incontrol is powering up??
Over 9000?
Yeah, he get's it.
|
On February 25 2008 07:05 Hot_Bid wrote: everyone please sit tight, incontrol is powering up
lol, building a bunch of pylons around his computer station
|
Trying to block a ling rush.
|
On February 25 2008 07:04 Try wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 07:03 trollbone wrote: plzz how u watch this ???
where do i have to paste the link ??? In the URL address, or just go to the top right and click on the link next to the calendar
thx i'm so dumb !
|
heh, walling off his house (despite the fact that his house is made of walls) I like his style.
|
Braavos36374 Posts
almost there guys just sit tight a few more minutes
|
Calgary25980 Posts
Almost ready. Should be up VERY shortly.
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
I've been curling 100lb weights and benching trees getting ready for this.
|
The suspense is destroying me.
|
Explaosion!!!! Let's gogogo :D iNcontrol-TL !!!!
|
How heavy were the trees? They might not have prepared you enough.
|
|
|
On February 25 2008 07:12 {88}iNcontroL wrote: I've been curling 100lb weights
Wow...just had quite an unholy thought involving the WC.
lol actually I just thought Water Closet 3: The Frozen Throne actually does pretty much represent my bathroom in these cold winter months. Especially due to the resident Blademaster, panderen brewmaster and creep camp.
|
Real inc. here. Some bastard hacked my account.
|
|
|
|
On February 25 2008 07:18 ToT)Incontrol( wrote: Real inc. here. Some bastard hacked my account.
lol?
|
|
Glad to see you're back in ToT) inc.
|
On February 25 2008 07:18 ToT)Incontrol( wrote: Real inc. here. Some bastard hacked my account.
Countdown til ban... 5...4...3...2...1...
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
|
Braavos36374 Posts
WE ARE LIVE EVERYONE GO TO STREAM
|
Calgary25980 Posts
STREAM IS LIVE [15:22] <@R1CH> For Windows Media Player users, File / Open URL, mms://89.46.37.126:8081/ [15:22] <@R1CH> For VLC users, File, Open Network Stream, MMS, mmsh://89.46.37.126:8081/
|
YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH !!!!!!
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
|
sweet it works :O gl everyone thx rich!
|
i thought inc was gonna commentate as well :/
|
Why can't I see a 'File' on WMP?
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
2 questions:
- Video? - Are observers allowed?
|
channel and server plz? stream's not working for me
|
|
KENNINGIT turn down ur game sound
|
UNCONTROLABE VS INCONTROL
incontrol mic is crap
|
is Inc's mic low for everyone?
|
|
Turn on the sc BGM! it sounds so barren without it T_T
|
On February 25 2008 07:29 abomi.nation wrote: is Inc's mic low for everyone?
yes
|
|
"can i pause to look at stream?" "your penis is tiny"
|
|
nvm found the channel and the server.
|
On February 25 2008 06:39 Nintu wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 06:38 Raithed wrote: Camtasia is so horrible for viewing that unless you have a crazy tweak scheme, why not use Fraps? Crazy tweaked scheme?.. What on earth are you talking about? There's something called lag. ]:
|
Damn thing doesn't work for me, CRAP.
|
not working for me any more
|
On February 25 2008 07:43 Raithed wrote: Damn thing doesn't work for me, CRAP.
QFT. -.-
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
|
|
Me either... Something about a network error, the server might not be available, verify that you are connected to the network and that your proxy settings are correct.
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
Try watching the Media Player stream in GOM. Works for me.
|
|
On February 25 2008 07:47 BluzMan wrote: Try watching the Media Player stream in GOM. Works for me. nevermind
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
copypaste the URL into GOM playlist/add URL
|
|
GG! Uncontrollable kicked ass.
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
|
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
|
mine did work, but now i get network error. i have tried in winamp, gom, vcl and media player. i tried rebooting. any ideas? my friend also has same problem
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
says some shit about codec.
|
Do people also have the stream open on Bnet attack?
Would it be impossible to beat a progamer otherwise?
|
oh, so this is where the discussion is lol
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
Ok, the problem is identified now.
The stream dies evry time I go to SC/alt-tab back and has like 5 minutes "recovery time".
No idea if it's possible to do it on purpose, but if it is, not the best idea as many people who didn't get to play can't watch.
|
Finally it works!
|
Hmm I can hear it, but I can't see anything...
|
Stream stopped working for me, I closed it and now it wont reopen.
|
|
holy shit fakesteve top foreigner top tvz
|
ROFL ROFL. Inc lost again. But that Terran was really good.
|
Hey Inc, in B.net Attack the invitee is supposed to WIN most of his games.
|
Ugh I give up trying to watch. The stream is just too frustrating.
|
LOL wtf it's UPSIDE DOWN?!
on gom player. How the hell?!
|
ret is retje right? Retje was in op tl-west while that game was played
|
it's upside down AND mirror vision now ><
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
I'm pretty sure it was the real fakesteve.
|
|
incontrol is the new yellow!
|
On February 25 2008 08:08 Luddite wrote: Hmm I can hear it, but I can't see anything...
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
fakesteve was ret
they switched
|
inc would have lost that game too if the terran was a D+ instead of a D-
|
|
well, i gotta stop watching and work on my paper now, so here are my thoughts on tl.net attack:
i LOVE watching live streams! i really hope the progaming scene has a channel or two for english games for SC2. having commentators is always a plus, but i wish they wouldnt feel so restricted on what they can say because of the stream. but this is a fairly good first episode!
|
|
u gotta skate8152 Posts
|
On February 25 2008 08:31 {88}iNcontroL wrote: fakesteve was ret
they switched Put the rep up ill check hotkeys.
|
i can only hear the stream
|
video is WMV3...don't know if that helps
|
|
Will there be VODs available later for this? I am not able to stream up T_T
|
Belgium6771 Posts
|
why would Bisu be nervous?! So not him. :D
|
Btw, who's commenting? I just tuned in.
|
oh THIS IS THE THREAD ^_^
|
stream doesnt work anymore?
|
mines still good. I'm on the first one though, not sure about you.
|
I'm on first one and it works.
|
See news thread for latest stream info.
|
|
man would be nice if you said channel. my stream ist working ;d
|
Works fine on VLC now! wasnt working on WMP for some reason (only audio)
|
Russian Federation4235 Posts
Inc you don't know PvZ lol ^^
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
was lotsa fun! thanks everyone for including me and I look forward to doing more of these!
|
lol i enjoyed it going to bed noww
|
|
|
Shit I wanted to see his desktop lol.
|
fagtron deserves the mousepad for his 4gate
or
yubee since he played like 5 games
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
According to R1CH we peaked at 317 viewers, thanks everyone for tuning in
|
|
That was absolutely brilliant.
Really looking forward to the next TL Attack. :D
|
i really thought 88)SlimControl should have got a game :<
|
Superiorwolf will host a commentary shortly, STAY TUNED!
|
wtf i tried every url in every player and still didn't get anything
|
It's over, the first post needs updating.
|
United States11390 Posts
|
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
VOD is now on the tracker courtesy of R1CH
|
Canada55 Posts
That was really cool. Cant wait for the next one. Good job to everyone involved.
|
Braavos36374 Posts
lots of fun and a great time everyone!
big thanks to r1ch and kennigit for being our technical wizards, chill for making so many good jokes, incontrol for being a great sport the entire time, and of course all the people participating and viewing
also, the smurfs for fagtron5000 and ToT)Incontrol( reveal yourselves!
+ Show Spoiler [Results] +Incontrol < uncontrollable (intrigue) ZvT Incontrol > ToT)Incontrol( ZvZ Incontrol < sMi.FakeSteve (ret) ZvT Incontrol > xmShake ZvT Incontrol > fagtron5000 ZvP Incontrol > Bisu-TL ZvP Incontrol < Superiorwolf PvZ
|
the torrent doesnt work for me... does it work for others?
|
On February 25 2008 10:52 Danka wrote: the torrent doesnt work for me... does it work for others?
use the alternative download link
|
intrigue
Washington, D.C9933 Posts
|
you were right lol! wish i couldve seen it. what a great idea.
|
|
On February 25 2008 10:59 ShaLLoW[baY] wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 10:52 Danka wrote: the torrent doesnt work for me... does it work for others? use the alternative download link It doesn't work for me, and I'm having trouble finding a download link. Help, please?
|
|
I think it was chill and hot_bid?
|
According to text in the chat, Valentine was smurfing as Fagatron5000 =p.
|
oh i recognized chills dulcet tones from his ZvP commentaries but I didn't know who the other one was 
oh ok it is hot_bid, they brought up the player screen
|
United States24676 Posts
For me it was fun trying to confirm if the first player was Intrigue. It didn't even occur to me until about 5 minutes in, then when he eventually said 'pewpew' I knew it for sure.
It was funny that everyone denied that it was intrigue... Chill and Hot_Bid shoulda at least considered it when he said pewpew lol... not to mention that he played at about his level, give or take a few minor things.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
We suspected it was Intrigue, just like we knew it was Ret. Half the fun is convincing the pro who it isn't.
|
United States24676 Posts
On February 25 2008 12:46 Chill wrote: We suspected it was Intrigue, just like we knew it was Ret. Half the fun is convincing the pro who it isn't. Was all the "I don't think it was intrigue" after the game to fool incontrol... ?
|
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 25 2008 12:48 micronesia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 12:46 Chill wrote: We suspected it was Intrigue, just like we knew it was Ret. Half the fun is convincing the pro who it isn't. Was all the "I don't think it was intrigue" after the game to fool incontrol... ?
Yes.
|
I wasn't Bisu-TL. Who told you that?
|
ROFL. that's hilarious!
I thought you guys were just being super harsh to Incontrol, and kinda being dicks with some of your comments, I didn't even consider the idea that you knew the truth and were tricking him. Looking back on it now, that's brilliant =D. I remember Incontrol being like "That WASN'T Fakesteve!" and freaking out. So great.
Thanks to everyone who made it all happen, and thanks to Inc for being such a good sport. I would have gotten so pissed off! <3
|
LOL @ unreal macro and sick timing senses
|
United States24676 Posts
On February 25 2008 13:48 ShaLLoW[baY] wrote: LOL @ unreal micro and sick timing senses IIRC it was unreal 'macro' but I'm too lazy to go back and check.
|
the game vs fagtron5000 was probably the most entertaining one. zerglings massacred running into the protoss main, zealots and probes simply walking into the zerg base, hidden four-gates, 3-5 spires.. gg
|
lmfao loved the fagtron5000 game 
he obviously got those 5 spires in anticipation of those zeals rofl hahahaha
|
how good is intrigue at tvz?
|
|
Can someone compile the thing and host on youtube? :X
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
the multiple spires was to reduce upgrade time for spires.. but when he walked into my naked base they came in handy as well
|
United States24676 Posts
On February 25 2008 16:14 Ilikestarcraft wrote: how good is intrigue at tvz? I believe it's his best mu, or at least it used to be.
|
Melbourne5338 Posts
The viewing audience has no criticism or ideas for future shows?
|
On February 25 2008 20:43 pachi wrote: The viewing audience has no criticism or ideas for future shows? FPVOD commentary instead of an observer?
I think the most lacking though in this TLAttack was the "no microphone" from Incontroll. IT would have been so much better if he had a mic
|
On February 25 2008 20:43 pachi wrote: The viewing audience has no criticism or ideas for future shows?
I'm trying to think of realistic ways of making it more like bnet attack but I can't think of a method that wouldnt get abused by the community as soon as the stream starts
In my opinion it would be a really awesome show if it was like a live fpvod with both commentators and the star player talking. But the only way as an obs to not give a huge advantage would be if they just had vision of the star player
The current set up needs to be rethought though I think, it just cripples the commentators ability to talk about the game.
Of course I don't know if the idea is to make it any more than what it is. I didn't really find the idea of the star trying to show off and ultimately losing in what ended up being really crappy games with a few exceptions. Inc getting owned by fakesteve was lol especially since he played straight up
it would be nice if it was real games where the star can explain why they are the star and his opponent isn't as he plays them. Without just resorting to a bm-off. Like bnet attack, instead of the joke games. But that would also require a star that doesn't lose to bad players.
I think the players need to be decided before hand and be people who are atleast C. Total newb bashing won't be fun to watch and neither will the star trying to show off and making the games horrible as a result.
I don't see a reason why it can't be insightful and educational and entertaining. Edutainment if you will
|
"But the only way as an obs to not give a huge advantage would be if they just had vision of the star player"
And that's the way it should be.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
I'll just give my two cents, feel free to disagree in this thread. Of course the opinions will be used to mould TL Attack.
I feel like people who are asking for commentary might be missing the point. I highly doubt the Korean commentators on BNet Attack commentate the game from beginning to end. My assumption is that they spend the majority of the time talking to the player, and might point out a key move to tease the player or his opponent.
That's what we're looking to do. We're not looking to comment on everything that's going on, if you want that I encourage you to watch Liquibition, which will be exactly that.
I think the people asking for FPVods haven't thought it all the way through. Do you REALLY want to watch 6-8 games at 350 apm? You probably won't even get an understanding of the game because it will be flying around so fast and won't encode properly.
Couple this with the fact that the person streaming the video cannot talk, so if the pro was streaming the FPVod he wouldn't be able to say anything on his mic. And there are a lot of technical issues that go into streaming this (as shown by us having technical difficulties at the start), so asking the pro to stream video would just add another layer to this. Those are a few reasons why this show will never be an FPVod. Even if it were technically capable, I still wouldn't do it because it doesn't make any sense from an audience's perspective.
On February 25 2008 22:52 JoxxOr wrote:Show nested quote +On February 25 2008 20:43 pachi wrote: The viewing audience has no criticism or ideas for future shows? FPVOD commentary instead of an observer? I think the most lacking though in this TLAttack was the "no microphone" from Incontroll. IT would have been so much better if he had a mic 
If you want this, then download an FPVod with commentary? I don't see why this would be in TL Attack. What would be the point of an event where someone stomps newbs while solo commenting on it? If you want that I suggest you look up Combat-Ex on Youtube. This coupled with the fact of how hard it is to comment while playing. It's REALLY hard.
On February 25 2008 23:12 True_Spike wrote: "But the only way as an obs to not give a huge advantage would be if they just had vision of the star player"
And that's the way it should be.
Since both pro and player are on the stream, anything we say about either player is heard. There is no way to make it a "fair" game. That's the entire point of this event! Why would you want to watch half a game? The idea is a fun event, not competitive play.
I feel like the underlying theme of TL Attack will stay the same but we'll add some polish so things feel like they're running smoothly and a little more professional. But the commentary will stay immature and the opponent will be able to cheat. That's half of the point of this!
|
I didn't realize the games were meant to be so relaxed. I haven't seen the show TL Attack is based on, so I didn't quite get that.
I do have a couple of comments:
- Is it fair for both players to be listening to the streams? While I understand these aren't tournament games, it's still nice for the commentators to be able to say things other than ambiguous comments that don't give anything away to the other player. You can't really discuss certain nuances of the game. For example, I got on the stream just before FakeSteve/ret's timing attack, and someone noted that since both players were on the stream, it was difficult to talk about the games themselves. What's the point of commentators if you can't discuss the actual games?
- Players shouldn't be commentating. I used to do RWAs, and it's outstandingly difficult to both play and commentate. Adding commentary after the game has been played is great, but not during the game. It's next to impossible to pay attention to the game and comment simultaneously.
|
8748 Posts
I think the mood of the show should adjust for the players. Some newbs want a chance at glory by winning a real game, some newbs are content with a win by cheating, and some newbs just want to be silly. The pros might feel like playing their best to show off their skill or they might offrace or do weird strategies or whatever. The hosts should recognize what kind of game is about to be played and then adjust for it. The newbs should be picked so that there is a variety of games so that the whole audience is satisfied.
Also, a microphone from the pro is pretty much a must. Inc ended up having a good episode without a mic but the quality of the show will definitely go up with a mic.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 26 2008 00:40 rpf wrote: I didn't realize the games were meant to be so relaxed. I haven't seen the show TL Attack is based on, so I didn't quite get that.
I do have a couple of comments:
- Is it fair for both players to be listening to the streams? While I understand these aren't tournament games, it's still nice for the commentators to be able to say things other than ambiguous comments that don't give anything away to the other player. You can't really discuss certain nuances of the game. For example, I got on the stream just before FakeSteve/ret's timing attack, and someone noted that since both players were on the stream, it was difficult to talk about the games themselves. What's the point of commentators if you can't discuss the actual games?
- Players shouldn't be commentating. I used to do RWAs, and it's outstandingly difficult to both play and commentate. Adding commentary after the game has been played is great, but not during the game. It's next to impossible to pay attention to the game and comment simultaneously.
Yea dude you're completely missing the point. Have you seen Pros vs Joes or a similar show involving "professionals" versus amatuers? They don't have live in-depth analysis during the games. What they do have is people trash talking and random banter.
|
It's possible to delay the stream with 2-3 minutes, so the commentators are free to talk about the game, if people want it so much.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 26 2008 00:46 NonY[rC] wrote: I think the mood of the show should adjust for the players. Some newbs want a chance at glory by winning a real game, some newbs are content with a win by cheating, and some newbs just want to be silly. The pros might feel like playing their best to show off their skill or they might offrace or do weird strategies or whatever. The hosts should recognize what kind of game is about to be played and then adjust for it. The newbs should be picked so that there is a variety of games so that the whole audience is satisfied.
Also, a microphone from the pro is pretty much a must. Inc ended up having a good episode without a mic but the quality of the show will definitely go up with a mic.
Agreed. I think we tried to do that, like giving Fagtron5000 and Bisu-TL hints when they were losing, while avoiding giving anything away when Uncontrollable and SuperiorWolf were playing. It's kind of hard telling what kind of game it's going to be until you're a few minutes into it.
A (working) mic will be a prerequisite to being on the show in the future. Inc's lucky he snuck by in episode 1 :D
Also I wanted to give you the mousepad for best play for your "ROFLSUPPLECAKES" but SuperiorWolf was just too good. You'll have to be content with 2nd place this time, which is pretty good for only having 2 seconds of air time.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 26 2008 00:54 lololol wrote: It's possible to delay the stream with 2-3 minutes, so the commentators are free to talk about the game, if people want it so much.
How would that work? "We're in channel "come"". 2-3 miuntes later people start joining? I mean we could make it work if need be, but I think people need to get over the fact that people are listening to the stream. That is a positive, not a negative. People can turn the stream off if they want, but it probably wouldn't affect what we said at all.
|
On February 26 2008 00:59 Chill wrote:Show nested quote +On February 26 2008 00:54 lololol wrote: It's possible to delay the stream with 2-3 minutes, so the commentators are free to talk about the game, if people want it so much. How would that work? "We're in channel "come"". 2-3 miuntes later people start joining? I mean we could make it work if need be, but I think people need to get over the fact that people are listening to the stream. That is a positive, not a negative. People can turn the stream off if they want, but it probably wouldn't affect what we said at all.
why do you have to announce on the stream what channel you're in or going to?
If you want to be the SC equivalent of a horrible spike tv show thats cool but why do you ask for feedback if you're just gonna tell everyone how wrong they are and how great it is watching 2 people flounder arounding building 6 spires while fagtron5000 spams LOL EZ HOMO I could just hang out in x17 for that
not to mention pretty much every game ended with the commentators pleading for the players to hurry things up. Imagine how the spectators feel if even the commentators are getting tired of the antics
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 26 2008 01:06 lake wrote:Show nested quote +On February 26 2008 00:59 Chill wrote:On February 26 2008 00:54 lololol wrote: It's possible to delay the stream with 2-3 minutes, so the commentators are free to talk about the game, if people want it so much. How would that work? "We're in channel "come"". 2-3 miuntes later people start joining? I mean we could make it work if need be, but I think people need to get over the fact that people are listening to the stream. That is a positive, not a negative. People can turn the stream off if they want, but it probably wouldn't affect what we said at all. why do you have to announce on the stream what channel you're in or going to? If you want to be the SC equivalent of a horrible spike tv show thats cool but why do you ask for feedback if you're just gonna tell everyone how wrong they are and how great it is watching 2 people flounder arounding building 6 spires while fagtron5000 spams LOL EZ HOMO I could just hang out in x17 for that
I'm giving you feedback on your feedback. I think a lot of the comments people are making miss some key issues.
We need to announce which channel we're in so we can get in it? We can't use the same channel because there's always 40 people and we get put into The Void. So we need to announce a new channel so we can all get in AND so a new 36 people get a chance at a game.
There are already plenty of events with commentary, Yankee League, FPVods, replays all over the place. Liquibition will be your answer to having high-level, live commentary on games. There is no point doubling that in a second event, which is why this event should be different.
|
You could announce on the forums. There's a million alternatives but you're pretty set on the way things are so lets both pretend there aren't. Why do you have to pick a player from a bunch of spamming retards in the first place eludes me as well. LOL THIS GUYS NAME IS NIGGERBALLS, GAME HIM ASAP.
Second 1 good player vs 1 baddish player who wants to be good is not the same as liquibition or replays that are all over the place no matter what form it's presented in
Seriously youre so adamant about the way you want it you aren't even maknig sense when refuting my suggestions. The mere fact that you have to sit here and refute suggestions on improving the show that you asked for is telling enough about how receptive you are to criticism.
|
lake u made ur point clear enough. no need to repeat yourself over and over again. if chill wants to implement your suggestions he'll do it if not it's also fine. stop attacking him like he did something wrong. PM him or are you just looking for attention?
|
Calgary25980 Posts
You are asking for an entire format change. That isn't going to happen based on one or two people's thoughts. If this topic is flooded with people mirroring your thoughts, then we will obviously have to look into changing formats.
In refuting your suggestions, I'm more pointing out a few things that people may have not thought about before suggesting that format change.
|
I thought the format was fine, sure it caters to the immature spamming and nicknames and what-not, but that's all in the fun of the show. Laughs were had, both by the commentators and viewers (you should have seen IRC). It sounds like you want something too serious lake, I think this first episode did a damn fine job of capturing the atmosphere of BNet Attack. Now when we get a pro with a mic, the commentators can actually talk to him like they do on the real show, asking his comments and insight into why he thinks that way. If you take a look at the subtitled BNet Attack released by FConnectionUK you see the commentators do very little game calling and mostly chat with the pro.
|
On February 26 2008 00:53 Chill wrote:Show nested quote +On February 26 2008 00:40 rpf wrote: I didn't realize the games were meant to be so relaxed. I haven't seen the show TL Attack is based on, so I didn't quite get that.
I do have a couple of comments:
- Is it fair for both players to be listening to the streams? While I understand these aren't tournament games, it's still nice for the commentators to be able to say things other than ambiguous comments that don't give anything away to the other player. You can't really discuss certain nuances of the game. For example, I got on the stream just before FakeSteve/ret's timing attack, and someone noted that since both players were on the stream, it was difficult to talk about the games themselves. What's the point of commentators if you can't discuss the actual games?
- Players shouldn't be commentating. I used to do RWAs, and it's outstandingly difficult to both play and commentate. Adding commentary after the game has been played is great, but not during the game. It's next to impossible to pay attention to the game and comment simultaneously. Yea dude you're completely missing the point. Have you seen Pros vs Joes or a similar show involving "professionals" versus amatuers? They don't have live in-depth analysis during the games. What they do have is people trash talking and random banter. -_-;;
I haven't seen that show, but I understand what you're saying. I actually thought the games were supposed to be semi-serious games. I misunderstood.
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
In order to think the games were semi serious you would have had to look past an awful lot of indicators that spoke to the contrary.
|
That's why I got confused. What I expected was not what I saw, hence my comments after the games. Now I get what the point was.
|
|
Braavos36374 Posts
On February 26 2008 01:17 lake wrote: You could announce on the forums. There's a million alternatives but you're pretty set on the way things are so lets both pretend there aren't. Why do you have to pick a player from a bunch of spamming retards in the first place eludes me as well. LOL THIS GUYS NAME IS NIGGERBALLS, GAME HIM ASAP.
Second 1 good player vs 1 baddish player who wants to be good is not the same as liquibition or replays that are all over the place no matter what form it's presented in
Seriously youre so adamant about the way you want it you aren't even maknig sense when refuting my suggestions. The mere fact that you have to sit here and refute suggestions on improving the show that you asked for is telling enough about how receptive you are to criticism. uh, nobody is saying TL attack is trying to be the same as liquibition, that's stupid
it's a fun event where people dick around in the game, where the community can participate and where we can be relaxed and joke around
all the stuff you are asking for is essentially "make it liquibition2" which is a dumb suggestion because it's a it's not the point of TL attack to be a high level showmatch
|
Where did I say make it a high level show match. Chill is the one who brought that shit up
What part of a low skilled player getting the chance to play a high skilled player who isn't going play like a fucking retard (incontrol) who can also contribute to the commentating on the game by answering the commentators questions and sharing in some part of the commenting since you know they are the pro. In some set up that isn't just 2 people vent hacking against eachother both doing their best to make the game as horrible as humanly possible as even the commentators themselves urge the players to hurry up and end the farce so the next one can begin
When you name it after Bnet Attack you can't blame someone for expecting it to be like the show its named after. Which isn't 3 dorks on vent and 2 retards typing obscenities at eachother in caps and calling it a quality production
|
Calgary25980 Posts
You're right, how could I make sense while refuting that priceless advice? If you don't like it move on, it's not for you. There's no point in veiling your flames and personal attacks as helping us improve. You don't like the Attack! series, that's fine, move along.
|
you know you can always start your own show if you dont like this.
|
Braavos36374 Posts
you could even call it "Temp Ban Attack" and co-host with Kennigit
|
Calgary25980 Posts
|
Braavos36374 Posts
first episode already aired ~20 minutes ago
|
8748 Posts
when is next episode of tlnet attack?
|
Kennigit
Canada19447 Posts
next weekend? holy shit thats liquibition too. Also, we require more roflsupplecakes
|
and tomfoolery
also learn more about ur damn community. you could've had JUMPER on! (the kid that drove a tour bus over fakesteve during TL race wars)
|
shit i wanna do tl attack rofl
|
On February 26 2008 03:59 ATeddyBear wrote: and tomfoolery
also learn more about ur damn community. you could've had JUMPER on! (the kid that drove a tour bus over fakesteve during TL race wars) yeah thats what i thought too could have been a second prize for the RW
|
"Since both pro and player are on the stream, anything we say about either player is heard. There is no way to make it a "fair" game. That's the entire point of this event! Why would you want to watch half a game? The idea is a fun event, not competitive play."
I think that this show should concentrate on the "star" player rather than the game itself. Like you said, it's not supposed to be fair - but only the "star" player is supposed to be at an disadvantage; it doesn't make any sense when you make it even easier for that "gosu" to crush his opponents, he's supposed to be doing that without any help at all and handicapped - because he's *that* good. Most of the commentary has nothing to do with the game itself anyway, so "watching half of it", as you said, won't really be a problem. I actually think it would be more fun this way, since you could elaborate on the guest player's play, his build orders (as crazy as they are) and whatever he's doing on right now - making it much harder for him (as his opponent might be listening to the stream) and therefore, more fun for the spectators - as the entire show is much less predictable.
Also, don't get me wrong, even if the games were played for fun using silly build orders most of them were just bad. It would all look a lot more fun if we wouldnt be able to see how much the players chosen to play the "star" suck I think that would give an illusion of skill, in some cases, as we couldn't see any idle scv's, messed up build orders and so on.
And if they don't suck - lack of their vision would make the game look more dramatic. Dropships, rushes, sunken brakes - nobody could anticipate that coming, it would always be a huge surprise to both the star player and the spectators. Every single game incontrol played would look a 100x better if we didn't have vision of his opponent and everything was concentrated on his play only.
I *do* understand that show is all about fun and I *do* think that lack of the guest player opponent's vision would make it much, much more fun as everything would be completely unpredictable.
|
My suggestion would be to make the players close the stream while they are playing. I suppose if the noob wants to cheat and have it open then that's OK, but at least make the star and any SERIOUS challengers close it. That way the commentators would have a lot more flexibility, and they can still talk to the players by in-game chatting.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 26 2008 05:14 True_Spike wrote:"Since both pro and player are on the stream, anything we say about either player is heard. There is no way to make it a "fair" game. That's the entire point of this event! Why would you want to watch half a game? The idea is a fun event, not competitive play." I think that this show should concentrate on the "star" player rather than the game itself. Like you said, it's not supposed to be fair - but only the "star" player is supposed to be at an disadvantage; it doesn't make any sense when you make it even easier for that "gosu" to crush his opponents, he's supposed to be doing that without any help at all and handicapped - because he's *that* good. Most of the commentary has nothing to do with the game itself anyway, so "watching half of it", as you said, won't really be a problem. I actually think it would be more fun this way, since you could elaborate on the guest player's play, his build orders (as crazy as they are) and whatever he's doing on right now - making it much harder for him (as his opponent might be listening to the stream) and therefore, more fun for the spectators - as the entire show is much less predictable. Also, don't get me wrong, even if the games were played for fun using silly build orders most of them were just bad. It would all look a lot more fun if we wouldnt be able to see how much the players chosen to play the "star" suck  I think that would give an illusion of skill, in some cases, as we couldn't see any idle scv's, messed up build orders and so on. And if they don't suck - lack of their vision would make the game look more dramatic. Dropships, rushes, sunken brakes - nobody could anticipate that coming, it would always be a huge surprise to both the star player and the spectators. Every single game incontrol played would look a 100x better if we didn't have vision of his opponent and everything was concentrated on his play only. I *do* understand that show is all about fun and I *do* think that lack of the guest player opponent's vision would make it much, much more fun as everything would be completely unpredictable.
Interesting. We'll think about it.
|
Awww man I missed it cuz of crappy Stats homework. I wanted to a cannon rush too... =D
ANyways things liek these are supposed to be fun. The mood is supposed to be chill compared to real matches
|
On February 26 2008 05:18 Chill wrote:Show nested quote +On February 26 2008 05:14 True_Spike wrote:"Since both pro and player are on the stream, anything we say about either player is heard. There is no way to make it a "fair" game. That's the entire point of this event! Why would you want to watch half a game? The idea is a fun event, not competitive play." I think that this show should concentrate on the "star" player rather than the game itself. Like you said, it's not supposed to be fair - but only the "star" player is supposed to be at an disadvantage; it doesn't make any sense when you make it even easier for that "gosu" to crush his opponents, he's supposed to be doing that without any help at all and handicapped - because he's *that* good. Most of the commentary has nothing to do with the game itself anyway, so "watching half of it", as you said, won't really be a problem. I actually think it would be more fun this way, since you could elaborate on the guest player's play, his build orders (as crazy as they are) and whatever he's doing on right now - making it much harder for him (as his opponent might be listening to the stream) and therefore, more fun for the spectators - as the entire show is much less predictable. Also, don't get me wrong, even if the games were played for fun using silly build orders most of them were just bad. It would all look a lot more fun if we wouldnt be able to see how much the players chosen to play the "star" suck  I think that would give an illusion of skill, in some cases, as we couldn't see any idle scv's, messed up build orders and so on. And if they don't suck - lack of their vision would make the game look more dramatic. Dropships, rushes, sunken brakes - nobody could anticipate that coming, it would always be a huge surprise to both the star player and the spectators. Every single game incontrol played would look a 100x better if we didn't have vision of his opponent and everything was concentrated on his play only. I *do* understand that show is all about fun and I *do* think that lack of the guest player opponent's vision would make it much, much more fun as everything would be completely unpredictable. Interesting. We'll think about it. I like this idea. :O lake should take a lesson on how to give constructive criticism and not sound like a butthole.
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
only a temp ban for lake? Follow his posts.. the dude flames and is a bitch to these forums for the majority of his sub 200 posts.. make em go through the trouble of a new name rofl
|
On February 25 2008 20:43 pachi wrote: The viewing audience has no criticism or ideas for future shows?
Like I mentioned, I think it sucks that the commentators have their hands tied (so to speak) when talking. The Star player should at least close the stream during the game and allow the commentators to comment. The Star player should be able to play a decent game even at a disadvantage, and the 300+ listeners (remember, lots of people had trouble with the stream and only got audio) would have something to listen to. It doesnt even need to be hard analysis or anything; it could just be a play-by-play kinda thing as the action unfolds (like "red doom drops in the protoss main, but teal responds with massive storms") or maybe quips and trivia about the player and so on.
Thats probably what I feel is the biggest issue: commentators not talking enough. There were good laughs in there, but it felt too quiet, even with the game music turned on after the second game.
Other little things: - I was irked when I see action going on in the mini-map, but the streaming was just clicking on buildings being built. Didnt happen too often, but that still bothers me. - inc's mic was too low. Not really an issue, in the future, Star players should check their equipment beforehand.
Summary: - commentators need to talk more - obs/streamer, great job, keep up on the in-game action - star player, turn off stream but stay on vent, for less "dicking around" games
overall, a great first episode though
|
Calgary25980 Posts
You have to remember that if the Star player is not on Vent we can't talk to him at all. Unless we are running Teamspeak AND Vent, one with him and one without, and use different talk-to-speak buttons for each.
That's the only way I can see it working, and it introduces some complications like us hitting the wrong button to talk to the wrong people. Maybe it's worthwhile testing, I'm not sure.
|
no, i said to stay on vent, so he can talk and comment whenever. just that his stream should be off so commentators can talk about the two players builds or whatnot
|
Braavos36374 Posts
i think when we have a star player with a better mic, it will go a lot smoother, and we will be able to have much better back and forth with the player
i don't think it'll be good to have him be able to talk to us and us not be able to talk to him, the banter between the hosts and the star player is one of the attractive things about the event
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 26 2008 07:27 useless wrote: no, i said to stay on vent, so he can talk and comment whenever. just that his stream should be off so commentators can talk about the two players builds or whatnot
He doesn't have the stream open, he is in Vent with us. You are talking about some magical filter where he can talk to us and we can't talk to him but we can still talk to Kennigit. While this filter may exist (like him locally muting us), what's even the point of havnig him talk then? And he doesn't even know if we're talking? He just randomly cuts in and talks over us?
...
|
how I think it should work is if you did it like battle.net attack and have the "gosu" player only show vission to you and then u can talk about the game freely with him and ask what hes thinking because you will only see what he sees/
|
On February 26 2008 08:28 G5 wrote: how I think it should work is if you did it like battle.net attack and have the "gosu" player only show vission to you and then u can talk about the game freely with him and ask what hes thinking because you will only see what he sees/
Yeah, and this way I think the Star player would be able to give little hints, like Bisu's thing about zeal ratio and optimal strategies on Python. They wouldn't necessarily commentate the entire game but just say the stuff like "his timing is off here" or "fuck it im ending this now", while the commentators do what commentators do.
|
On February 26 2008 07:23 Chill wrote: You have to remember that if the Star player is not on Vent we can't talk to him at all. Unless we are running Teamspeak AND Vent, one with him and one without, and use different talk-to-speak buttons for each.
That's the only way I can see it working, and it introduces some complications like us hitting the wrong button to talk to the wrong people. Maybe it's worthwhile testing, I'm not sure.
dumb question, why cant you have all 3 in vent? both the commentators and the star? just give the commentators vision of the star(or not, w/e u want to do)? You can record a vent convo, too btw, and overlay it onto a vod.
|
Calgary25980 Posts
On February 26 2008 08:44 LumberJack wrote:Show nested quote +On February 26 2008 07:23 Chill wrote: You have to remember that if the Star player is not on Vent we can't talk to him at all. Unless we are running Teamspeak AND Vent, one with him and one without, and use different talk-to-speak buttons for each.
That's the only way I can see it working, and it introduces some complications like us hitting the wrong button to talk to the wrong people. Maybe it's worthwhile testing, I'm not sure. dumb question, why cant you have all 3 in vent? both the commentators and the star? just give the commentators vision of the star(or not, w/e u want to do)? You can record a vent convo, too btw, and overlay it onto a vod.
This is exactly what we currently do. The other poster wanted us to give full commentary without giving anything to either player, which is impossible if we also want to be able to have conversations with the star.
|
ah ok, see i told you it was a dumb question~! The torrent tracker gives me an error about a truncated file or something, so i cant dl the vods. I dont know why people are giving you shit then, to me thats the best way to do it.
|
On February 26 2008 12:16 LumberJack wrote:ah ok, see i told you it was a dumb question~!  The torrent tracker gives me an error about a truncated file or something, so i cant dl the vods. I dont know why people are giving you shit then, to me thats the best way to do it.
Try the alternate DL link. The first one didn't work for me either, but second worked fine!
|
This is exactly what we currently do. The other poster wanted us to give full commentary without giving anything to either player, which is impossible if we also want to be able to have conversations with the star. Open 2 instances of vent, and just have different hotkeys for each instance. You alluded to it before, but I just wanted to tell you that you don't need TS to make it work.
Can work pretty easily. Used to use it for a few games, guild wars, dota, cs 1.6 etc.
|
On February 26 2008 08:28 G5 wrote: how I think it should work is if you did it like battle.net attack and have the "gosu" player only show vission to you and then u can talk about the game freely with him and ask what hes thinking because you will only see what he sees/
This sounds like a good idea from the entertainment aspect because the "nubs" play will be a mystery and the viewers will see it just as the "gosu" does (it adds suspense because something could surprise the gosu and surprise the audience as well instead of the audience seeing everything in advance) and it also adds to the "educational" aspect because the viewer can see how the gosu scouts and reacts in response to what they scout and stuff like that.
|
I agree with useless, the commentary lacked a bit of... energy.
There were a lot of periods of silence and it lacked some flow. It'd be cool also if you put a big more emotion into the commentary. I know this can be tough for some, but a few of had very low and monotonous voices which was a bit at times.
It's a great concept though and it'll no doubt get better with time. Live casting games is hard so it should become easier the more you do it.
|
Braavos36374 Posts
i think these issues will be resolved when
1. the player gets a mic so we can banter better with him 2. the vision stuff gets resolved so we can get excited without revealing anything
|
United States24676 Posts
On February 26 2008 06:05 {88}iNcontroL wrote: only a temp ban for lake? Follow his posts.. the dude flames and is a bitch to these forums for the majority of his sub 200 posts.. make em go through the trouble of a new name rofl Haha I've been thinking this for like 1-2 pages already. The icing on the cake was when he said something like 'three fags on ventrillo and two idiots spamming each other, or something like that. My guess is, the mods were a bit worried (perhaps subconsciously) they would look like abusers if they banned the guy who claimed they were mistreating his ideas... but it would probably be 100% justified 
Edit: I also agree that you should consider removing vision from the newbie player. This makes it more like bnet attack, save the fact that the announcers will still be using observer mode so to speak... but I think that's a reasonable change.
|
I watched that B.net Attack subtitled episode, and I can see it's quite different from what I thought it was going to be. Sorry about that.
With that said, I agree with the viewers not being able to see the "newb" player, but I'm not sure how you could do that.
|
Kennigit
Canada19447 Posts
On February 27 2008 02:39 micronesia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 26 2008 06:05 {88}iNcontroL wrote: only a temp ban for lake? Follow his posts.. the dude flames and is a bitch to these forums for the majority of his sub 200 posts.. make em go through the trouble of a new name rofl Haha I've been thinking this for like 1-2 pages already. The icing on the cake was when he said something like 'three fags on ventrillo and two idiots spamming each other, or something like that. My guess is, the mods were a bit worried (perhaps subconsciously) they would look like abusers if they banned the guy who claimed they were mistreating his ideas... but it would probably be 100% justified 
No i just don't like perming. ;_; too nice.
|
United States24676 Posts
On February 27 2008 02:43 rpf wrote: With that said, I agree with the viewers not being able to see the "newb" player, but I'm not sure how you could do that. Like I was mentioning earlier, you could do it the way bnet attack does it, meaning you look at the player's screen, rather than use ums. The only problem with that is, like someone mentioned earlier, you have to stare at like 350 apm. The alternative is to use ums like someone said earlier, and just tell the newbie to unvision, or even make a map which only gives vision for the skilled player...
|
First person view isn't an option, for technical reasons.
|
|
I regret that I missed this, but I was wondering if replays or even YouTube videos will be available to view?
|
United States24676 Posts
On February 27 2008 04:29 StripedBlueCrow wrote: I regret that I missed this, but I was wondering if replays or even YouTube videos will be available to view? Well you can download the vod via torrent or ddl since I'm not sure if anyone put it on youtube.
|
|
Good job for a first try! Looking forward to a TLattack with working gosu mic. 
I also agree on the challenger not giving vision to TL observers.
|
Kennigit
Canada19447 Posts
|
On February 26 2008 14:52 Hot_Bid wrote: i think these issues will be resolved when
1. the player gets a mic so we can banter better with him 2. the vision stuff gets resolved so we can get excited without revealing anything
Oh, when chill said incontrol was in the vent, i assumed he had a mic and was talking with them. I definately agree that the player should add his own commentary/banter. So i can see why people would want it improved now. There's always time, and there will always be interest, so people should just be patient
edit: watching it now, sounds like he did a have a mic, but i cant understand what hes saying, weird
|
Braavos36374 Posts
he had a mic it just had this horrible feedback on it so we couldn't really hear him
the games and everything turned out fine, it just could've been better had he had a working microphone, because i'm sure people wanted to hear him
|
Germany2762 Posts
you have a mic mit feedback? wow then lock your spellcasters away guys, or the mic of death will come and feedback them ^^
i watched tl attack live and i really enjoyed that whole event. i'm looking forward to the next episode. the only problem with this whole thing is, that you can not keep the players from watching the stream while playing. sure not all of the contenders do that, but if they do, the whole thing is pretty screwed up T_T
|
|
|
|