|
10387 Posts
On September 01 2010 13:03 Onisparda wrote:Its always like this, each sides has its own stories and the truth has to be somewhere in the middle. lol wtf does that even mean, so vague. All of Kespa's profits, from Broadcasting Rights, go to supporting and paying for Proleague. Very little money is left over so thats why there isn't any "real profit"
|
so uh its been 12 years now since starcraft's release do people really see this lasting much longer.... really?
I mean at this point BW is stagnant it is contributing zero new players outside of the handfull of Koreans who will pick it up; for BW to continue new generations will have to want to play it and having a 12 year old game be the pinnacle of e-sports is pushing it.
|
On September 01 2010 13:09 ArvickHero wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 13:03 Onisparda wrote:Its always like this, each sides has its own stories and the truth has to be somewhere in the middle. ...Even though Proleague does not have any real profits... lol wtf does that even mean, so vague. All of Kespa's profits, from Broadcasting Rights, go to supporting and paying for Proleague. Very little money is left over so thats why there isn't any "real profit"
Profit is profit, they could have said that they dont make a lot of profit instead. A lot less ambiguous. Trivial matter cuz the meaning could have been lost in translation. To me that sounds like they are trying to appear to be non-profit but don't want to lie about it.
|
Okay, so it looks like Gretech is in the business of crowding out competition by raising the barrier to entry (charging "GSL reimbursement fees" because Proleague conflicts with GSL).
Now that's just greedy and anti-competitive behavior that I really can't justify.
|
It's very difficult to read this and not get the impression that Gretech is moving to specifically stop the PL from happening. People can get all uppity over the history between all of the entities here, but it's mostly just banter. The reality is that Gretech wants either a bunch of money as some sort of competition fee, or alternate means of 'reimbursement' - which we can only assume is something like free advertising for the GSL all over the place.
What's literally insane is that this is happening after OGN has already done a deal for this OSL, and after even KeSPA has said they're willing to pay for IP rights. It's becoming harder and harder to paint Gretech/Blizzard as the good guys here, and the fact that they're actively working to phase out BW and phase in SC2 is becoming even more obvious.
This is just saddening.
|
On September 01 2010 13:18 Onisparda wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 13:09 ArvickHero wrote:On September 01 2010 13:03 Onisparda wrote:Its always like this, each sides has its own stories and the truth has to be somewhere in the middle. ...Even though Proleague does not have any real profits... lol wtf does that even mean, so vague. All of Kespa's profits, from Broadcasting Rights, go to supporting and paying for Proleague. Very little money is left over so thats why there isn't any "real profit" Profit is profit, they could have said that they dont make a lot of profit instead. A lot less ambiguous. Trivial matter cuz the meaning could have been lost in translation. To me that sounds like they are trying to appear to be non-profit but don't want to lie about it.
Kespa is non-profit. It is probably ambiguous because it's an unofficial translation from the Korean article.
|
On September 01 2010 13:10 DonKey_ wrote: so uh its been 12 years now since starcraft's release do people really see this lasting much longer.... really?
I mean at this point BW is stagnant it is contributing zero new players outside of the handfull of Koreans who will pick it up; for BW to continue new generations will have to want to play it and having a 12 year old game be the pinnacle of e-sports is pushing it.
Excuse me? "BW is stagnant"? "...having a 12 year old game be the pinnacle of e-sports is pushing it"?
What rock have you been living under? BW was and ALWAYS will be the pinnacle of e-sports for a long time to come. Nowhere else in the world have we seen a more successful proleague (two for that matter). We are talking full-time progamers, paid full-time on a salary basis. Even then, the quality of the televised matches are unmatched; have you even watched the old days of Boxer, Nada, iloveoov and Savior? The reason why BW has lasted this long is because of the success of Kespa (no matter its shortcomings) and the devotion of its fans.
I don't think BW will die out anytime soon, that is, UNLESS Blizzard continues to push this issue even further. I really despise their attitude in this, but I do not want to keep on swearing for now.
|
ALLEYCAT BLUES50107 Posts
wait I don't really understand since it sounds vauge to me.Does this mean that Pro-league is a no go?Is there any negotiating of this?I mean PL has to survive if there is any chance of SC2 surviving.
|
Pushing SC2 by any means necessary...
|
United States33325 Posts
KeSPA dangerously skirting the line of breaking the NDA by leaking information to Fomos like that -__-
|
I just hope it will go to Korean court and they will say that Blizzard has no rights to tell who, how, and for how much money is playing or broadcasting their game. Can someone from Korea comment if there is chance for that ?
|
United States33325 Posts
On September 01 2010 14:13 sAAvior wrote: I just hope it will go to Korean court and they will say that Blizzard has no rights to tell who, how, and for how much money is playing or broadcasting their game. Can someone from Korea comment if there is chance for that ?
Not being a lawyer, I can't predict much about a hypothetical trial.
But my line of thinking is: If KeSPA thought they would win in court, wouldn't they have taken it to trial a looong time ago? It seems like going to trial has been their last and most undesirable option, if you look at how they've gone through every other method possible.
|
"Since this is an NDA, we cannot reveal everything about the negotiations, but there are a lot of people are using wrong information and is reading the situation wrong"
This quote should be the most important.
|
On August 31 2010 23:42 Milkis wrote: However, Gretech, starting with the beginning of the 4th negotiation, has said that "We cannot sign off on the Proleague, since it will compete with the GSL", and KeSPA reacted saying that "If you refuse to sign off on the Proleague, that's like saying we shouldn't be negotiating". Continuing, Gretech, rather than talking about intellectual property fees, has demanded "Reimbursement for the GSL", and KeSPA has rejected the guidelines set by Gretech. This is just disgusting, fuck I hate blizzard/gom right now. Just sheer greed, SC2 is not ready to carry esports on its shoulders alone. Fucking scum. The GSL is not even going to have that much content and people can always watch both....
User was warned for this post
|
This is starting to look like the political situation in Belgium, going nowhere fast...
Our government is also negotiating between 2 sides, also about for about the 4th time now. Experience tells me, when everyone is silent, they are still making progress. But when information starts leaking out, it's only a few days before everything starts exploding...
|
i think its time to let go of SC1.
User was warned for this post
|
With the latest update, assuming it's true, we can definitely point the finger at the party in the wrong in this dispute. By which I mean gretech of course. Do they really need to try to crush proleague to promote GSL? Are they that insecure in the probability of success for SCII?
|
On September 01 2010 13:24 cocoa_sg wrote: What rock have you been living under? BW was and ALWAYS will be the pinnacle of e-sports for a long time to come. Nowhere else in the world have we seen a more successful proleague (two for that matter). We are talking full-time progamers, paid full-time on a salary basis. Even then, the quality of the televised matches are unmatched; have you even watched the old days of Boxer, Nada, iloveoov and Savior? The reason why BW has lasted this long is because of the success of Kespa (no matter its shortcomings) and the devotion of its fans.
I don't think BW will die out anytime soon, that is, UNLESS Blizzard continues to push this issue even further. I really despise their attitude in this, but I do not want to keep on swearing for now.
Agreed with this post.
We probably don't have half the data but this is getting borderline ridiculous. It sounds like they really want to kill off the #1 success esport event in the world just out of greediness.
Would love to hear what the netizen think of this, as well as people involved in progaming (team managers, players, current proteam sponsors, casters).
|
gretch: pay me money kespa: ok i will pay u to run proleague, how much u want? gretch: no. dont pay us money we dont want u to run proleague kespa: ....
|
On September 01 2010 13:10 DonKey_ wrote: so uh its been 12 years now since starcraft's release do people really see this lasting much longer.... really?
I mean at this point BW is stagnant it is contributing zero new players outside of the handfull of Koreans who will pick it up; for BW to continue new generations will have to want to play it and having a 12 year old game be the pinnacle of e-sports is pushing it.
Did you watch the MSL finals? Did you? Point to a single match in SC2 that even begins to compare to the excitement in that matchup.
|
|
|
|