EPTClosed Casket Mafia - Page 28
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Caller
Poland8075 Posts
| ||
|
Chezinu
United States7430 Posts
RebirthOfLeGenD ilovejonn GMarshal sandroba Amber[LighT] LSB deconduo Caller Palmar BloodyC0bbler Fishball Radfield Chezinu VisceraEyes Scamp GGQ Jackal58 Kurumi | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
| ||
|
Chezinu
United States7430 Posts
RebirthOfLeGenD ilovejonn - was third to confirm GMarshal - first to confirm and quite a few people suspected him sandroba - has been mean to me, disappointed that I'm not crazy enough to distract town and I don't really know this person.. Amber[LighT] LSB deconduo Caller - claimed blue Palmar BloodyC0bbler Fishball - was third to post Radfield - has been strange the whole game (though some argue he was only strange lately) Chezinu - town aligned VisceraEyes Scamp GGQ - 2nd to confirm Jackal58 - Don't really know that well and seems to not have a collective understand with the rest of the thread and what people think. Kurumi | ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
Night 1 Scamp has been slaughtered With 14 alive, it is 8 to lynch. It is now Day 2 and it will end on Friday at 12AM ET/13:00 KST. | ||
|
RebirthOfLeGenD
USA5860 Posts
| ||
|
Fishball
Canada4788 Posts
On June 30 2011 13:16 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote: Who the fuck tried to kill me last night? Oh, if only if it was true. So the first cycle was somewhat eventful for me. My little spin with deconduo was able to keep me low for a couple Nights. When he claimed that he had a gun, I had no choice but to improvise with my plan, accusing him scum. If what he claimed was true, the stubborn tunnel-vision fucker would have really shot me. In truth, he was never a true scum candidate to me. I made my "best case" against deconduo, but I knew that the town wouldn't fall for it (especially in an invitational game) and him resulting in a lynch would be far from likely. In doing so, it was a subtle attempt to talk deconduo off NOT to shoot me, and also to observe how all the players would react; I saw a lot of things. I would have ride along for another Night if possible, but I think I have sufficient information to come forward. I am a Cop Since I cannot copy and paste my role description, let me explain how my role works. When I check a player, the results either comes back as "Innocent" for Town aligned players, or "Guilty" for Mafia. I questioned Ace immediately upon receiving my role, and he has clarified that there are no sanity variants of my role. Everything is straight forward with my checks, which is pretty much what I had expected in a no-flip game. Here are my check results: Night 0 - Innocent - BloodyC0bbler Night 1 - Guilty - RebirthOfLeGenD Night 0 was with limited information and was hard to get a read on everyone. I picked BC to have him out of the way first, for good or bad. Night 1 was a bit trickier. My goal was to check the less obvious targets, those that are in the gray area, but you know that something doesn't add up. I had a few candidates: Palmar, ilovejonn, and RebirthOfLeGenD. At the end, I picked RoL based on a my observation of his posting, the overall voting pattern for Day 1, and the fact that he took off his vote from VisceraEyes and broke the promise that he would his change his vote back; A key factor that Day 0 resulted in a no-lynch. Since RebirthOfLeGenD ended up as Guilty, based on the move he pulled with his vote, I'm even more inclined that VisceraEyes is also scum, not like he isn't a major candidate already. RoL had explained why he missed the vote change, but I obviously don't buy it, he knows way better than that. Not like I can doubt my own check anyways. Now 4 players had voted for Amber[Light]: VisceraEyes, Chezinu, Scamp, and RebirthOfLeGenD. Amber has not been the most active player, yes, but there were not many holes among his minimal amount of posting either. As you can see, none of the so called "well-known-solid-players" have voted for him, and it only make sense. It seems to me that Mafia is using a lurker (Amber) as a scapegoat to divert their votes onto, as they obviously do not want to lynch one of their own, which is VisceraEyes. Scamp is obviously Town since he was killed on Night 1, and Chezinu? No comment. Moving back to deconduo and the 3 players who voted for him. Myself, ilovejonn, and LSB. I already explained my thoughts up top on why I had voted for deconduo. To be honest, there shouldn't be anyone beside myself voting for deconduo. Let's talk about LSB first. Based on the posts he made on page 14 and 15, I already had him locked as Mafia. What I said back then was sincere. If I were a Day Vigilante, I would have instantly shot him. + Show Spoiler + On June 28 2011 14:27 Fishball wrote: Ah yes, LSB logic. Oh, how I miss it. 1. If deconduo decides not to shoot me, that doesn't necessarily prove anything. It can be a ploy, or it can a be a genuine decision. 2. If we both die, that also doesn't proves anything. What is this "story" that your dreamt about?. deconduo thinks I'm green, but wants to kill me because he is annoyed. If I'm Mafia and I try to take him out with me, how would this story make sense? What would be the point for Mafia to take him out if I were for sure to die? I'm sure there are better targets out there. 3. Square one? If that is what you think, then you have already written me off, as I have no use to the Town at all; What do you take me for, a disposable chess piece? I don't even know what to say. WTF is this shit? This is even worse than deconduo. If I were a Dayvig, I'd instant kill you now. At first, he suggests letting deconduo shoot me and Town should not intervene, which I pointed out would not prove anything, and at worst I die for nothing except for satisfying deconduo's bloodlust, Town loses a Cop (maybe the one and only) and Mafia can laugh at my "foolishness"™. Then for whatever reason, he votes for deconduo that is not likely to be lynched, instead of the more scummy VisceraEyes that was already leading the majority of the votes. It seems to me that this was just another case of Mafia spreading out their votes. My case against deconduo seems to be "decently developed" but it was just a trap and LSB stepped right into it. Caller, BC and maybe a couple others has also called out LSB as well, so this only supports my claim - LSB is Mafia. Last, we have ilovejonn. ilovejonn is a smart player, his posts doesn't give away much, and even talks a lot of sense in some. Why would a smart player such as himself vote for deconduo? In Radfield's words, deconduo was oozing with green. I was a bit perplexed and had him listed as one of my check candidates as mentioned above. If a fourth Mafia is still alive, I'd be willing to put my money on him; No matter, I will check him on Night 3. In conclusion, these are my Mafia picks. - VisceraEyes - RebirthOfLeGenD - LSB - ilovejonn (If we have a fourth Mafia, which is likely we still do) Oh, and before someone questions, I realize there is a possibility of a Godfather or a similar type of role which would affect my check results. However, as you can see, I don't solely rely on my check ability. As for my claim and credibility, if there are players that think what I've said up top does not make any sense, I'm pretty sure there are role(s) out there to confirm the alignment of dead players, especially in a game like this. We'll discuss more tomorrow. Great, now it's almost 1:30am and I have to wake up 6am for work. Good night. PS. ##Vote RebirthOfLeGenD | ||
|
RebirthOfLeGenD
USA5860 Posts
| ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22630 Posts
So, time to hang Fishball. ##Vote Fishball | ||
|
Chezinu
United States7430 Posts
Why are you still alive? You seem fishy.. | ||
|
sandroba
Canada4998 Posts
##Vote: RebirthofLegend | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22630 Posts
So, I don't know how many cycles the game will last, or how long we can gamble our Coroner that may or may not exist will stay alive, but in my opinion he is more valuable than our cop, and if we have to choose between the two I'd rather give a coroner the chance of surviving longer. Of course, ideally we luck out and let Fishball get at least one more check before we kill him and sodomize his corpse, and the coroner will then take a look at his alignment. There is a chance though, a tiny workaround we can use to extend the checks and gain more information... hmm I have a plan. | ||
|
RebirthOfLeGenD
USA5860 Posts
| ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22630 Posts
Unless more really cool information presents itself I'm changing my mind, and now I want to hang rol. Also, I thought he was scum anyway for thinking I was saying clever stuff. ##Unvote ##RebirthofLegend Come on town, burn him! | ||
|
Chezinu
United States7430 Posts
On June 30 2011 17:33 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote: Sandroba, you have to be joking. We went over this countless fucking times. A DT claim is absolutely worthless in this set up, and he knows it. In fact his shit might of worked if he did it on a lessor player, but more importantly if I wasn't saved by a fucking medic last night. Which means at least one person out there knows he's full of shit. Wait... are you saying that you didn't med protect yourself? I thought that was the plan! Geez, getting other people to do your work for you... Well, atleast Scamp follows orders and blew the defenses.. | ||
|
Scamp
United States1086 Posts
That's three games in a row. GG everyone. Good luck to whatever side I'm on. | ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
##vote RebirthofLegend Hanging DT first was retarded from very start. | ||
|
Chezinu
United States7430 Posts
So without further delay: Question: + Show Spoiler + Do you guys think the other DT, if there is one should claim? | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22630 Posts
| ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
| ||
| ||
