Student Mafia XV

On October 09 2015 11:47 The Shining wrote:
I'll probably regret this.

/confirm...

On October 12 2015 06:19 The Shining wrote:
Oh and "I don't like this so far" & a quick "Oh you're right Celestial, he's lying and that post felt half assed so let me instavote" isn't you trying to get Obvious killed. It's a quick jump onto something someone else caught on someone you were suspicious of. You could even be spewing Obvious town here.

Now let me go eat and watch my kdrama in peace, Fecalscum @.@

On October 12 2015 06:06 The Shining wrote:
I hate doing list posts but it is what it is. This is what I get for starting late, I guess.

Town
Eversince - pretty active in the game with a clear train of thought in every direction she's going. Especially that WoT. I would be very surprised if newbie scum is taking notes and making point after point and being transparent in their reads. She also addresses almost everyone so far, and wants to lynch a few, so there's no buddying or pocketing from what I can see. I would like her to give a read on Stoicism, though, I don't remember seeing that.

Moosy - Town, methinks. I'm not really sure where Onegu got the idea that he was voting for OO for no reason after reading Moosys filter. It seemed to follow a solid train of thought and he mentioned OO and questioned him before voting him. I don't really like him admitting to actively lurking but its something I'll let slide for now because I agree with his OO read and I don't think scum would set themselves up to be scrutinized hard by admitting that.

Probably town
Kels - its mostly a toneread tbh but his honesty and willingness to answer ES even when he didn't have much to go off of just reads as townie to me. And his later post giving reads and giving thoughts on the Vivax - SL interaction looked good, and most of the reads correlate with mine.

Celestial - again I hate list posts but I know its her(are you a girl or did I make a fool of myself? o.o) style and the reads were actually fleshed out, both in the list post and the few posts afterwards. She also picked up on some of the same things from Moody's filter that I did, although admittedly some of that goes out the window once Moosy himself said he wasn't actively in the thread the way his filter made it seem. (Speaking of which, how the hell did he even do that? That's some voodoo or some shyt)

Null
Sicklucker - I felt like he was townie at times last game when I rolled scum with him lol. I've never been able to read him. If I read his filter on any other player, I'd probably lean slightly town but since it's SL, I'd much rather someone better than I could help me flesh this one out. I do like that he caught Vivaxs weird read on him but someone said last game that his reads were very SL-centric, which seems to be the case here, and he was scum.

Vivax - the SL are you drunk thing was weird and I found myself agreeing with ES's request to post something of value. However, he stepped it up a bit after and considering I think both OO and Fecal could be scum, I have trouble thinking he'd be bussing either. I need to see more from him, though, before I can town him.

Onegu - somewhat bare filter. His VT claim is nai, he does it every game. He calls ES an RSoul smurf so he's aware of how ES is playing but I saw no read on ES. Then he tunnels into Moosy after hinting at not liking him early, then invites him for Marv. And comes back with a post saying he has nothing to comment on. But he hasn't commented on much to begin with. Moar reads a d do moar stuff pls, or this will shift into scum territory.

Stoicism - short filter with a few questions and poking at the thread, which I like. But he asked SL to discuss his Moosy read with him and was never heard from again. I need to see more from him.

Possible scum
FecalFeast - Super underwhelming. I found his joke post of "worried about appearance obvious mafia" kind of ironic since he states in his very next post that Vivax is as underwhelming as he is, which shows he is quite aware of how he looks in-thread. Also, most of his reads don't seem to lean very strongly either way which leaves a lot of wiggle room. Gums opening is awkward but not screaming scummy, wants OO to come back to confirm suspicion, Moosy is posting fine things but has the ability to play scum well. His eye is on vivax but he's just as bad. That's scumming yourself by default lol. And believing Vivaxs scum claim is just bad. I've seen vivax just roll over and die as scum but I haven't seen him outright claim it.

ObviousOne - I really hate self-meta so that's a negative for me. He isn't reading or paying attention, or he would've realized Celestials vote on me was pregame as a joke. Instead he misrepresents Celestial by saying she's voting the AWOL guy. His list post looked pretty yucky and he landed on Kelsier, one of my probtowns after making an unflipped association note between him and Celestial. But why is Kelsier a better lynch than Celestial? He doesn't say. And he says he could lynch Gumdrop waiting on reurn of the Jedi? But Marv is gone too but he's just being Marv. His reads just don't add up to me.

Marv - one page filter Marv in a newbie game is not town Marv. Super underwhelming and nothing of substance in his filter. He once asked if I was so unmotivated to solve the game as town and the answer was no becasue I was scum. Now I'm asking the same question. Why is he so unmotivated this late into a newbie game if he's town?

Plynch
Gumdrop - this one is pretty obvious and has been talk of the town so I won't go too much into it. Scum has trouble entering and participating in the thread, but from the game I played with Gumdrop, that one post isn't enough to be scum. It's more policy territory for me but I'd like to see if Gum actually gives us something to work with before jumping on that wagon.