Based on his contribution so far, I'm going to second XeliN in his bid for nomination. It's important that we have someone active in the thread as mayor or sherrif, and also good to have someone providing reasoning behind thier decisions, whether they be good or bad.

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 20 2010 11:58 GMT

#107

And what's general day 1 voting etiquette? Do we wait to last minute, because it seems as though it's pretty much going to be a wild guess.

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 20 2010 17:01 GMT

#132

On January 21 2010 00:27 d3_crescentia wrote:

Two things: I don't think QuickStriker is mafia, but I'm not 100% sure. His posting behavior is pretty similar to the last game he played in.

I know it's too soon, but it seems crazy that someone who is mafia could be that prominent in his posting. He has about 15% of posts in a 34 player game.

Mods, for future reference, can we ask for a current vote count at any stage?

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 21 2010 12:42 GMT

#287

On January 21 2010 12:56 johnnyspazz wrote:
Okay Xelin, what is your opinion on RoyW? I think either he's a new at this and doesn't spend time to read a decent amount of posts before he judges or he is a mafia member and your accomplice.

I am new to the game, and this is my first time ever playing it. I voted for Xelin and still do, because it seems to my newbie eyes that he is obviously not Mafia. Maybe to the experienced eyes in this game, his activities are a comman Mafia-gambit, but I don't think so.

I'm unsure about QS, but ultimately I think it's just an instinctive reaction to his many posts and multiple edits, so I don't know.

I live in Ireland, and will mostly only be active 18.00 KST-03.30 KST. If someone could give me the PST equivalent, I will try and ensure that I am around for voting deadlines.

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 21 2010 14:07 GMT

#294

I take it that the first deadline is voting tonigh, then do we have a 'night break' for 24 hours, before another 48 hours to vote lynch day 1? Or am I misunderstood?

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 22 2010 09:23 GMT

#396

Ugh, I can't believe I didn't realise there was a voting thred. Yes, I am a newbie retard, sorry Xelin. Congratulations to our new Mayor and Sherrif, though I can't help but feel one of them must have snuck in as Mafia.

So, is every day going to have a separate voting thread, or are all votes going to be here:

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=110391&currentpage=4

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 22 2010 14:36 GMT

#400

I'm not sure, but based on the thread so far, my feeling for Mafia is pointing towards ShoCkeyy. Pretty much every one of his posts so far have been one-liners that are poking or prodding accusations at others.

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 22 2010 17:03 GMT

#405

On January 23 2010 01:03 ShoCkeyy wrote:
Royw you high? I have posted mostly facts and base lines as to why people can be mafia. Which I suspect, you're mafia. I feel like you and xelin are mafia. Because I pointed out xelin the most, which now you're trying to back up xelin because that's all you have been doing with oiut a reasonas to why you are. Now you're out to attack me, even though I haven't attacked you yet. Now I am.

Well congratulations and a poly-sentence reply

I haven't actually attacked you, but have just said that I have impression based on your many one liners that have seemed to just be inflammatory rather than constructive.

Even here, you're immediately combatitive, trying to stoke up flames.

In relation to Xelin, I provided my reasoning for support of him - He instinctively seemed so obviously a town member to me based on his initial self-nomination, so I supported him straight away. Nothing he has done so far would change that first impression, although as I have said, I'm a complete newbie and maybe a bad judge of these things.

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 23 2010 02:18 GMT

#455

On January 23 2010 10:04 ShoCkeyy wrote:

You have read my mind. I don't like the way Xelin has to offer things, or the way he puts things.

Come on people, am I the only one who thinks it's obvious that Xelin is not Mafia? I can't imagine anyone making a 'lynch me on condition of lynching person x next' gambit unless they're ultra-defensive and feeling persecuted.

We have many many people in game, and many people are flying under radar through inactivity.

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 25 2010 17:04 GMT

#584

On January 26 2010 01:43 ShoCkeyy wrote:

Show nested quote +

There's actually a lot of reasons as to why he's a mafia. You just have to look through the thread.

There's no real indication of Xelin being Mafia, unless you take his inconsistent post frequency as some sort of tenuous link. You have been continuously pushing for his lynching without evidence, ShoCkeyy, and I don't believe that he is guilty.

But based on where the voting thread and this thread are going, I can see us digging ourselves deeper by voting off Xelin and then voting off me. Add that to another 6 Mafia night kills, and we'll be left with a 15-7 ratio. (can we even win from there)

I do like the direction the game is now going in, with actual review of the possible clues. I have nothing to add to what has already been assessed after last night. I wasn't around at the time due to travelling to Sweden, but I should be around much more for the rest of the week.

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 26 2010 23:46 GMT

#632

waiting for day 3 and a new batch of clues

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 27 2010 10:22 GMT

#646

Well, that was a nice sleep, just awoke. Still waiting on start if Day 3.

I hadn't realised that QS had abstained on all 3 votes. Why is that? Is it generally considered a good tactic to play if you are a member of the town or Mafia?

RoyW

Ireland270 Posts

January 27 2010 23:39 GMT

#677

Ugh, that's it