There's this rough comparison table for performance: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/gaming-graphics-card-review,3107-7.html
Computer Build Resource Thread - Page 1405
Forum Index > Tech Support |
When using this resource, please read FragKrag's opening post. The Tech Support forum regulars have helped create countless of desktop systems without any compensation. The least you can do is provide all of the information required for them to help you properly. | ||
Ropid
Germany3557 Posts
There's this rough comparison table for performance: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/gaming-graphics-card-review,3107-7.html | ||
MrCon
France29748 Posts
- 2500K (got it for 134€, the 3570K is 50€ more so I took the 2500K) - MSI Z77A-G43 - 4GO DDR Cucial Ballistic Elite CL8 - Sapphire Radeon 7850 1GO - Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 SATA 6Gb/s 1 To - Cheap but still good case ( http://www.ldlc.com/fiche/PB00117527.html ) - Seasonic 400W 80 Plus Bronze for 532€ (+20€ shipping) Works like a charm, thanks everyone who answered me in the past few weeks ! | ||
Shai
Canada806 Posts
These are the original stats of that computer: http://reviews.cnet.com/desktops/compaq-presario-sr5552f-phenom/4505-3118_7-33773301.html I've since upgraded the graphics card to an NVidea GeForce GT 430 and to 4GB of RAM (2x2GB). -My processor and/or motherboard are dying, which is one reason I want to build a new rig. -I want to stream, and my processor isn't up to the task. -I want to emulate PS2 on my computer (I have the real games I want to use, I just want to emulate them on my PC) and my processor is too old. So I want help from the good folks at TL to help me build a new PC. -I don't want to spend more than ~800 Canadian Dollars before taxes and shipping (we have sales tax added on). -If possible, I'd like to get all of my parts from one supplier (preferably NewEgg.ca, the Canadian sister site of NewEgg, since shipping would be better) -I don't need a new graphics card ~yet~. So we don't need to go looking for one. -I DO need a 64bit version of Windows, since I'm currently running Windows 7 32 bit. -I don't need an asthetically pleasing case, just a functional one. -I don't want to overclock. I'm not that confident in doing it and I want my processor to last a long time. My resolution is 1680-1050. I have no problem upgrading individual parts after the build, so what's most important to me is a good processor and a good motherboard (and obviously decent cooling and power supply). I'm not enough of an enthusiast that I need both an SSD and SATA hard drive, I'll do fine with any old hard drive, and I don't need more than 500GB unless something is cheap. If anyone wants to help and needs more information, feel free to ask. I'm ignorant but not stupid, I can probably answer any questions with a bit of research. EDIT: I'm actually fine with keeping my 500GB barracuda hard drive and reformatting to 64bit. | ||
llIH
Norway2142 Posts
On March 06 2013 22:43 Ropid wrote: @llIH: You can't find it as it's last generation and probably not produced anymore. There's this rough comparison table for performance: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/gaming-graphics-card-review,3107-7.html Hey Thanks a lot! ![]() | ||
Ropid
Germany3557 Posts
On March 07 2013 01:22 Shai wrote: -I DO need a 64bit version of Windows, since I'm currently running Windows 7 32 bit. I think the license works for both, you can simply install 64 bit. EDIT: I just checked to make sure, and it's true. Quote: "You are free to switch between a 64-bit and 32-bit version of Windows at any time. This requires a reinstall, but you can use the same license key. Depending on how recently you have reinstalled, reactivation may be possible over the internet, or may require you to call the activation hotline." | ||
MrCon
France29748 Posts
On March 07 2013 01:22 Shai wrote: Hey TL. It's been about 6 years since I last bought a "new computer." I'm using an AMD Phenom X3 8450 processor that came from a box-store Compaq Presario. These are the original stats of that computer: http://reviews.cnet.com/desktops/compaq-presario-sr5552f-phenom/4505-3118_7-33773301.html I've since upgraded the graphics card to an NVidea GeForce GT 430 and to 4GB of RAM (2x2GB). -My processor and/or motherboard are dying, which is one reason I want to build a new rig. -I want to stream, and my processor isn't up to the task. -I want to emulate PS2 on my computer (I have the real games I want to use, I just want to emulate them on my PC) and my processor is too old. So I want help from the good folks at TL to help me build a new PC. -I don't want to spend more than ~800 Canadian Dollars before taxes and shipping (we have sales tax added on). -If possible, I'd like to get all of my parts from one supplier (preferably NewEgg.ca, the Canadian sister site of NewEgg, since shipping would be better) -I don't need a new graphics card ~yet~. So we don't need to go looking for one. -I DO need a 64bit version of Windows, since I'm currently running Windows 7 32 bit. -I don't need an asthetically pleasing case, just a functional one. -I don't want to overclock. I'm not that confident in doing it and I want my processor to last a long time. My resolution is 1680-1050. I have no problem upgrading individual parts after the build, so what's most important to me is a good processor and a good motherboard (and obviously decent cooling and power supply). I'm not enough of an enthusiast that I need both an SSD and SATA hard drive, I'll do fine with any old hard drive, and I don't need more than 500GB unless something is cheap. If anyone wants to help and needs more information, feel free to ask. I'm ignorant but not stupid, I can probably answer any questions with a bit of research. EDIT: I'm actually fine with keeping my 500GB barracuda hard drive and reformatting to 64bit. Look at the config I posted just above, replace the i5 2500K by something like an i3 3220 (about 110$), or for a longer term CPU an i5 3570 (about 60$ more), I was exactly in your price range, and I'm also a big PCSX (1 and 2) user, and a big Dolphin user (in fact for the last few weeks I spend all my free time playing the various Fire Emblems on GC and Wii :p), and it works perfectly (emulation speed 100% for PS2, PS1, Wii/Gamecube emulators). Without the need for a graphic card you change my 4go ram for 8go, choose a case you like and a good 450-500W power supply (important, power supply is a part you can't afford to buy noname) . I didn't follow hardware for some years, but as I just bought the kind of setup you're looking for, I read and asked a lot about that so it's the period can help on this =) | ||
Elairec
United States410 Posts
| ||
llIH
Norway2142 Posts
On March 06 2013 23:44 MrCon wrote: So thanks to everyone here, I finally bought, received and built my new computer : - 2500K (got it for 134€, the 3570K is 50€ more so I took the 2500K) - MSI Z77A-G43 - 4GO DDR Cucial Ballistic Elite CL8 - Sapphire Radeon 7850 1GO - Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 SATA 6Gb/s 1 To - Cheap but still good case ( http://www.ldlc.com/fiche/PB00117527.html ) - Seasonic 400W 80 Plus Bronze for 508€ (+20€ shipping) Works like a charm, thanks everyone who answered me in the past few weeks ! I am trying to get my pc at that price. But I can't. Did you get a really good deal on those parts? | ||
MrCon
France29748 Posts
On March 07 2013 03:22 llIH wrote: I am trying to get my pc at that price. But I can't. Did you get a really good deal on those parts? No, only the 2500K was a good deal (I bought it separately). Everything else was at ldlc.com, I had a 6% discount code too. Here's my invoice : + Show Spoiler + LDLC BG-400 Quality Select 80PLUS Bronze avec Pack classique 1 47,95 € MSI Z77A-G43 avec Pack classique 1 89,95 € Intel Core i3-3220 (3.3 GHz) avec Pack classique 1 109,95 € Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 SATA 6Gb/s 1 To avec Pack classique 1 66,25 € Sapphire Radeon HD 7850 1 Go avec Pack classique 1 146,95 € Crucial Ballistix Elite 4 Go (2 x 2 Go) DDR3 1600 MHz CL8 avec Pack classique 1 31,05 € LDLC Danube V2.0 LED Bleue avec Pack classique 1 32,95 € this is the case Discount : -17,32 € Shipping : 19,95 € TOTAL 527,68 € The i3 was for a friend, so in fact I paid 24€ more than what I said as I paid my CPU 134€ bought in this shop http://www.rue-montgallet.com/prix/acheter,intel-core-i5-2500k-3.3ghz-oem-unlocked-edition,748781. The "LDLC BG-400 Quality Select 80PLUS Bronze" is a rebranded 400W Seasonic | ||
Alryk
United States2718 Posts
On March 07 2013 03:18 Elairec wrote: Do you guys think a G2020 paired with a GTX 550ti would have much trouble running SC2 at medium settings? Currently looking to upgrade my system and give the wife my old video card, meanwhile building her a relatively cheap system that can still play SC2 at decent graphics. Resolution is 1600x900. Thanks for any input. Yes. Do you already own the 550Ti? Otherwise there are better options at that price range (it sounds like you do, but I'm just checking). For medium graphics it might be worth it to lower the GPU a little bit and get something like an i3-3220, or even just a pentium G2120. The clock speed increase (decently sized for the i3, + hyperthreading although that doesn't do much) might make a difference late game, although I'm not entirely sure. I have an i3-3220 with GTX 650, and at medium CPU settings (I believe) I still get framerate drops into the 19-23 range lategame PvZ. Keep that in mind if you are worried about it. Granted, that's going to happen for most processors without overclocking. | ||
llIH
Norway2142 Posts
On March 07 2013 03:26 MrCon wrote: No, only the 2500K was a good deal (I bought it separately). Everything else was at ldlc.com, I had a 6% discount code too. Here's my invoice : + Show Spoiler + LDLC BG-400 Quality Select 80PLUS Bronze avec Pack classique 1 47,95 € MSI Z77A-G43 avec Pack classique 1 89,95 € Intel Core i3-3220 (3.3 GHz) avec Pack classique 1 109,95 € Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 SATA 6Gb/s 1 To avec Pack classique 1 66,25 € Sapphire Radeon HD 7850 1 Go avec Pack classique 1 146,95 € Crucial Ballistix Elite 4 Go (2 x 2 Go) DDR3 1600 MHz CL8 avec Pack classique 1 31,05 € LDLC Danube V2.0 LED Bleue avec Pack classique 1 32,95 € this is the case Discount : -17,32 € Shipping : 19,95 € TOTAL 527,68 € The i3 was for a friend, so in fact I paid 24€ more than what I said as I paid my CPU 134€ bought in this shop http://www.rue-montgallet.com/prix/acheter,intel-core-i5-2500k-3.3ghz-oem-unlocked-edition,748781. The "LDLC BG-400 Quality Select 80PLUS Bronze" is a rebranded 400W Seasonic Have you tried playing with low settings in sc2 at 1920x1080? How does it perform with fps? | ||
MrCon
France29748 Posts
| ||
Alryk
United States2718 Posts
On March 07 2013 03:51 MrCon wrote: I haven't, but Dota 2 stays at a constant 60fps with max settings at 1600*1200 in a 5vs5, I'm pretty sure it is more than enough for sc2 at 1920*1080. Assuming it's the i3/7850 build: yeah a 7850 can max SC2 graphically easily. But SC2 is more cpu demanding than Dota2 (even though it's 1v1 vs "5v5" because each player controls way more units than there are heroes/minions at any time if I'm not mistaken. Lategame that is). So it will lag lategame in SC2 on max settings (source: I have one.) With low settings on CPU lategame btw, you'd probably be looking at 20-25 fps? in the worst case scenario. | ||
llIH
Norway2142 Posts
| ||
MrCon
France29748 Posts
On March 07 2013 04:28 Alryk wrote: Assuming it's the i3/7850 build: yeah a 7850 can max SC2 graphically easily. But SC2 is more cpu demanding than Dota2 (even though it's 1v1 vs "5v5" because each player controls way more units than there are heroes/minions at any time if I'm not mistaken. Lategame that is). So it will lag lategame in SC2 on max settings (source: I have one.) With low settings on CPU lategame btw, you'd probably be looking at 20-25 fps? in the worst case scenario. i5 2500K ! --- The 3570K is basically the best possible CPU for sc2, it should be good enough =) French article but the graphs are clear enough, resolution is 1920*1080, the GPU is - GeForce GTX 580 drivers version 280.26 http://www.hardware.fr/articles/863-21/jeux-3d-total-war-shogun-2-starcraft-ii-anno-1404.html ![]() Sous Starcraft II, nous utilisons un replay spécialement enregistré par des utilisateurs du forum que nous remercions. Ce replay contient une attaque très (très) importante et nous mesurons le framerate durant cette dernière en 1920*1080 avec les détails poussés au maximum. "For Starcraft, we use a recorded replay from one of our users. This replay features an extremely massive fight that we play and record the framerate in 1980*1080 with maximum graphical settings" ![]() | ||
llIH
Norway2142 Posts
| ||
MrCon
France29748 Posts
I know the Ivy CPUs draw less power than the Sandy one, so the 3570K should use less power than the 2500K. It's the same for GPUs, I think the 77xx generation draw less power than the previous one but I don't know how much the previous one was using =) If you overclock 400W could not be enough. It also depend on how much hard drives and other stuff you have. You can read the technical details to know exactly how much power each part needs. http://www.hardware.fr/articles/863-9/consommation-efficacite-energetique.html this page tests most CPU's power consumption. A 3570K uses 130W in full charge, a radeon 7770 use 75W google just told me. A hard drive uses 10W maximum, more about 5-7W. So a good 400W is enough unless you overclock big or you have 6 hard drives, 2 blue ray writers, 10 USB peripherals and 10 fans. | ||
llIH
Norway2142 Posts
On March 07 2013 05:31 MrCon wrote: I'm not sure so I'd wait more qualified people to answer. I know the Ivy CPUs draw less power than the Sandy one, so the 3570K should use less power than the 2500K. It's the same for GPUs, I think the 77xx generation draw less power than the previous one but I don't know how much the previous one was using =) If you overclock 400W could not be enough. It also depend on how much hard drives and other stuff you have. You can read the technical details to know exactly how much power each part needs. http://www.hardware.fr/articles/863-9/consommation-efficacite-energetique.html this page tests most CPU's power consumption. A 3570K uses 130W in full charge, a radeon 7770 use 75W google just told me. A hard drive uses 10W maximum, more about 5-7W. So a good 400W is enough unless you overclock big or you have 6 hard drives, 2 blue ray writers, 10 USB peripherals and 10 fans. I will only have 1DVD and 1 HDD But if I can overclock the cpu that would be cool. | ||
MrCon
France29748 Posts
| ||
Gumbi
Ireland463 Posts
Regarding the 7850 max quality thing: I think people under-estimate the hit sc2 takes from some graphical settings near the higher end of the scale. To be honest I'm GPU-bound until late lategame (I have a 3570k @ 4.6ghz and a 7950 @ 1050mhz core). My FPS have dropped to 25 in a 200/200 PvZ fight (and that wasn't on creep, didn't have things like carriers involved). Of course, I can easily have that up at 40 + if I bothered to tweak the settings, with minimal graphical loss, but I can't be bothered. | ||
| ||