Hello everybody! I came to this idea by watching Dota 2, where screen goes red on edges if your hero gets attacked, and a lot of games actually have similar thing. In SC2, it would basically show you when your units are attacked and where. Now I made these illustrations to show how do I imagine it, and to show what I mean to those that maybe don't understand.

[image loading]

I personally think this would be pretty helpful for both casuals and pros. Now if Blizzard would accept this idea, they should make it look that it doesn't block vision of important stuff like resources on top right of screen. What do you think about this?

Poll: Share your opinion in poll!

No (131)

79%

Yes (34)

21%

165 total votes

Your vote: Share your opinion in poll!

(Vote): Yes
(Vote): No

swissman777

1106 Posts

May 18 2016 11:40 GMT

why so many nos? This would make this more casual friendly game! If it doesn't affect the pro scene too much this is great improvement!

Bastinian

Serbia177 Posts

May 18 2016 11:45 GMT

On May 18 2016 20:40 swissman777 wrote:
why so many nos? This would make this more casual friendly game! If it doesn't affect the pro scene too much this is great improvement!

I'm wondering too.. :D I expected a feedback after those No votes but I didn't got it :D

Sennmeister

United Kingdom7 Posts

May 18 2016 11:49 GMT

Having that makes the game simpler, and it's already simple enough. Not having that means you have to look at the minimap and figure out where you are being attacked, which adds to the complexity and requires more skill.

Also what happens if you are being attacked in multiple places at once? I'd expect this to become annoying quite quickly!

Musicus

Germany23579 Posts

May 18 2016 11:49 GMT

Sure why not, make it optional so high level players who want to stick to the old way and don't need it can turn it off. But if it helps lower league players it could be a nice option. Nobody is complaining about simple command card and the other stuff, since you can just turn it off.

On May 18 2016 20:49 Sennmeister wrote:
Also what happens if you are being attacked in multiple places at once? I'd expect this to become annoying quite quickly!

Good point. I personally would certainly not use it. I want to improve my minimap awareness and avoid any clutter on the screen.

Imagine Showtime's screen vs Nerchio in game 1 haha.

Sapphire.lux

Romania2620 Posts

May 18 2016 11:50 GMT

"no" because it's a RTS and you get that info from the minimap, you get attacked on multiple fronts, and promotes bad behavior for people the tunnel vision on the main screen instead of looking at the UI features like the minimap.

I could see it as a turn on/off feature, but if you use it, it will greatly slow your progress.

TedBurtle

Belarus201 Posts

May 18 2016 11:59 GMT

it can be like AUTO-ON in bronze and silver.
But then, your screen can jump fast in many directions every seconds, so it would be like disco party with red signs all over the screen if you attack from 2 sides, your enemy attacks from 2-3 sides + you expanding....its just RED EVERYWHEEEEEERE

Thinh123456

70 Posts

May 18 2016 12:03 GMT

)))) you don't want to cover all your screen with those red arrows because of multi-pronged attacks

)) So, i say: HELL NO!!!

-NegativeZero-

United States2142 Posts

May 18 2016 12:06 GMT

i don't like it, the whole "screen flashing red" thing is closely associated to the idea that the player character got injured in 1st person games, and in an RTS there is no player character so it doesn't make sense.

Bastinian

Serbia177 Posts

May 18 2016 12:26 GMT

#10

I dislike these "make simpler game", "no-skill" as valid feedback, because a lot of things that were implemented in game "simplified" game and people eventually accepted it. Now I like having option to keep it on or off if you need it. Also having arrows all over screen on multiple attacks would be something that Blizz would configure. I imagine it as not being too bright and not last for ever, and not too distracting or blinding.
Also, my basic idea would be these red arrows. Blizz could add some basic arrows that you can see, and not cover half of screen.

About this, it wouldn't work like that, but like minimap indicator. It would basically show you where is attack like minimap, and point it out on screen.

PharaphobiaSC

Czech Republic457 Posts

May 18 2016 12:31 GMT

#11

I would implement this from Bronze to Gold league!

BisuDagger

Bisutopia19352 Posts

May 18 2016 12:35 GMT

#12

It would be okay if there was an option to turn it off. I think at the highest level it is a distraction. Imagine the Nerchio game where he attacked at 4 locations. It is much more important he looks at the minimap then has 4 different parts of the screen glowing. I'm no pro and maybe I'm old school, but I would rather have it off.

AusProbe

Australia235 Posts

May 18 2016 12:46 GMT

#13

Because there isn't a "single character" that a player controls I don't really think it fits agree with sc2. It could get really messy when shit gets real in the midgame. Imagine Terran dropping everywhere and everything flashing red. Plus the information is already conveyed on the minimap and with sounds.

Maybe it would be useful for lower level players, so the motive behind it is good

deacon.frost

Czech Republic12129 Posts

May 18 2016 12:46 GMT

#14

On May 18 2016 21:35 BisuDagger wrote:
It would be okay if there was an option to turn it off. I think at the highest level it is a distraction. Imagine the Nerchio game where he attacked at 4 locations. It is much more important he looks at the minimap then has 4 different parts of the screen glowing. I'm no pro and maybe I'm old school, but I would rather have it off.

Army warning:
- full warning(what is shown)
- light warning(what someone wrote, only small arrows)
- map only warning(what I would love)
- off(your setting :-))

I think everybody could take what is their desire :-)

On May 18 2016 21:46 mGGrinehart wrote:
Because there isn't a "single character" that a player controls I don't really think it fits agree with sc2. It could get really messy when shit gets real in the midgame. Imagine Terran dropping everywhere and everything flashing red. Plus the information is already conveyed on the minimap and with sounds.

Maybe it would be useful for lower level players, so the motive behind it is good

Hmm, actually the red color would be wonderful. I cannot count how many games I lost to a drop + some light harass. Because the "announcer" was silent as the only thing I heard was "we cannot hold" and then I realized I do not have workers.
(meaning I haven't heard "your workers are under attack" message)

The red warning on a map would be a miracle for me.

RaiZ

2813 Posts

May 18 2016 12:49 GMT

#15

For a deaf player, that would help a TON.

iLovePartinG

20 Posts

May 18 2016 12:57 GMT

#16

Add some juicy red "press F to pay respects" blood splatters all over the screen on supply block and I'm all for it (^:

Bastinian

Serbia177 Posts

May 18 2016 13:01 GMT

#17

Because the "announcer" was silent as the only thing I heard was "we cannot hold" and then I realized I do not have workers.

Yes this is also a huge problem, and one of reasons why I suggested this.

IIEclipseII

Germany157 Posts

May 19 2016 06:33 GMT

#18

Maybe not that big? If there are multiple attacks, the screen will be just red. Maybe a small exclemation mark at the border would be enough. or a small red dot.

Cyro

United Kingdom20327 Posts

May 19 2016 06:48 GMT

#19

I cannot count how many games I lost to a drop + some light harass. Because the "announcer" was silent as the only thing I heard was "we cannot hold" and then I realized I do not have workers.
(meaning I haven't heard "your workers are under attack" message)

This is one of the biggest problems with sc2 sound and why you can not trust audio. I'm not a fan of this idea in particular but i would like some more audio and minimap settings