• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 16:35
CET 22:35
KST 06:35
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11[ASL22] Ro16 Preview: Holy Diver5
Community News
Dark completes military service, returns to SC212[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0Weekly Cups (October 19-25): Clem triples first in 5.0.175
StarCraft 2
General
Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Serral's getting trashed by New Catsle's Mind Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top? Liquibets sc2 season 30
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Top Players of October 2026 (EBPD Rankings)
Tourneys
2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [$1250] International ShieldBattery League [BSL23] Ro16 Group C - Sunday 21:00 CET [Megathread] Daily Proleagues
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc Nintendo Switch Thread List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 9670 users

The future of RTS games - Page 60

Forum Index > SC2 General
Post a Reply
Prev 1 58 59 60 61 62 81 Next
Keep "my game is better than yours"-slapfights out of this. If the discussion devolves into simple bashing, this thread will be closed.
TMG26
Profile Joined July 2012
Portugal2017 Posts
June 15 2014 13:54 GMT
#1181
On June 15 2014 22:18 urboss wrote:

Show nested quote +
On June 15 2014 21:45 FeyFey wrote:
On June 15 2014 18:53 urboss wrote:
Any multiplayer game is "competitive".
The only reason Blizzard needs to pay close attention to balance issues is because it uses three distinct races.
No one whines about balance in chess or poker.
I'm perfectly OK with having a "Terran Only" RTS if it kicks ass otherwise!


No one whines about balance in chess, because we know no one can change the game for everyone. So chess players accept that their game will be imbalanced forever.
Just as everyone accepts that card games are heavily based on luck.


Card games are based on luck, that doesn't mean that they are imbalanced. The luck can hit anyone.
If you mean White's advantage in chess, the way they solve this is by having players play BOTH White and Black in alternation.
Similarly, there would be no balance whine in SC2 if players were required to play ALL 3 races in each matchup.
So if Taeja meets MC at Dreamhack in the quarter final, this is how it would look like:

Game 1: MC chooses Protoss, Taeja chooses Terrain
Game 2: MC chooses Zerg, Taeja chooses Protoss
Game 3: MC takes Terrain, Taeja takes Zerg

If Blizzard would have enforced this from the beginning, there would never have been any balance issues.



That is indeed an interesting concept for tourneys. Is it feasible?
Supporter of the situational Blink Dagger on Storm.
urboss
Profile Joined September 2013
Austria1223 Posts
Last Edited: 2014-06-15 14:19:53
June 15 2014 14:19 GMT
#1182
Since the players are already super-specialized on one race, you would run into problems now if you choose the races randomly:

Let's say, MC picks Zerg and Taeja picks Terrain.
Obviously, Taeja would roflstomp MC and the match wouldn't be very interesting to watch.

Therefore, the first game would have to be fixed to the best race for existing pro players.
i.e. for Game 1 MC always Protoss, Taeja always Terran
After that they can choose.
New players would be able to choose in game 1 already.
Big J
Profile Joined March 2011
Austria16289 Posts
June 15 2014 15:35 GMT
#1183
On June 15 2014 23:19 urboss wrote:
Since the players are already super-specialized on one race, you would run into problems now if you choose the races randomly:

Let's say, MC picks Zerg and Taeja picks Terrain.
Obviously, Taeja would roflstomp MC and the match wouldn't be very interesting to watch.

Therefore, the first game would have to be fixed to the best race for existing pro players.
i.e. for Game 1 MC always Protoss, Taeja always Terran
After that they can choose.
New players would be able to choose in game 1 already.


MC is said to be one of the best European Zerg players. ;-)

Anyways, imo race in RTS games means some form of identity and playstyle. With an undynamic race concept like Starcraft's, I think it would simple decrease the game's quality and fandom for players.
Though it would be interesting to prevent players playing the same units or playstyles over and over again.
Taeja's 2rax lost against MC's 2base Colossus build? 2nd game MC has to play the same playstyle and Taeja has to use a different configuration.
sc2isnotdying
Profile Joined June 2014
United States200 Posts
July 09 2014 20:55 GMT
#1184
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?
Thieving Magpie
Profile Blog Joined December 2012
United States6752 Posts
July 09 2014 21:13 GMT
#1185
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.
Hark, what baseball through yonder window breaks?
vOdToasT
Profile Blog Joined September 2010
Sweden2870 Posts
July 09 2014 21:17 GMT
#1186
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )
If it's stupid but it works, then it's not stupid* (*Or: You are stupid for losing to it, and gotta git gud)
pjc8513
Profile Joined October 2012
20 Posts
July 09 2014 21:41 GMT
#1187
This thread is full of awful ideas.

Basically, the main idea here is: make the game easier, in every way possible

Base building is core to RTS would be awful to remove.
The need for build orders to be precise arises because people get good at the game. Same "problem" with the multitasking. Essentially, this is complaining about players getting good at the game.

I really do not understand all the complaints about the "boring" phase of the game. You mean the interesting part where you are gathering intelligence and deciding what you are going to do (build-wise) in the game?

Making comebacks "easier" would just eliminate what makes comebacks 'epic'--it would pretty much destroy any possibility of an epic game being played in that game. Comebacks rock because they are unexpected and they require fantastic play by one player (and possibly a key mistake by the other). If they were easier, then who would care?

Personally, I love pro Sc2 exactly because it is 1v1 and not team matches. Why is being team oriented marked as a "good" for MOBA? It is great to see two champions battle it out one on one. I mean, being a team sport isn't really a "good" or "bad" thing, neither is being an individual sport. They both have their pros and cons to them.


My solution: Bring back Boxer. Fixed it.
Excludos
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
Norway8281 Posts
July 09 2014 21:54 GMT
#1188
On July 10 2014 06:41 pjc8513 wrote:
This thread is full of awful ideas.

Basically, the main idea here is: make the game easier, in every way possible

Base building is core to RTS would be awful to remove.
The need for build orders to be precise arises because people get good at the game. Same "problem" with the multitasking. Essentially, this is complaining about players getting good at the game.

I really do not understand all the complaints about the "boring" phase of the game. You mean the interesting part where you are gathering intelligence and deciding what you are going to do (build-wise) in the game?

Making comebacks "easier" would just eliminate what makes comebacks 'epic'--it would pretty much destroy any possibility of an epic game being played in that game. Comebacks rock because they are unexpected and they require fantastic play by one player (and possibly a key mistake by the other). If they were easier, then who would care?

Personally, I love pro Sc2 exactly because it is 1v1 and not team matches. Why is being team oriented marked as a "good" for MOBA? It is great to see two champions battle it out one on one. I mean, being a team sport isn't really a "good" or "bad" thing, neither is being an individual sport. They both have their pros and cons to them.


My solution: Bring back Boxer. Fixed it.


Didn't fix sc2..
obesechicken13
Profile Blog Joined July 2008
United States10467 Posts
July 09 2014 22:00 GMT
#1189
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )

Risk BW was a more fun experience than any of the new blizz games. I loved Micro Tournament and all the weird defense maps too.

I just hated all the leavers and the difficulty of finding games to start. SC2 ums really failed for me.
I think in our modern age technology has evolved to become more addictive. The things that don't give us pleasure aren't used as much. Work was never meant to be fun, but doing it makes us happier in the long run.
Thieving Magpie
Profile Blog Joined December 2012
United States6752 Posts
July 09 2014 22:29 GMT
#1190
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )


Yes, casuals enjoy battle more than non-battles, this was true in BW and is true today. The difference was that back in BW people had to resort to UMS maps while today they can download a free game on Steam. The results are the same, more people play casual games than hardcore RTS games.
Hark, what baseball through yonder window breaks?
sc2isnotdying
Profile Joined June 2014
United States200 Posts
July 09 2014 22:56 GMT
#1191
On July 10 2014 07:29 Thieving Magpie wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )


Yes, casuals enjoy battle more than non-battles, this was true in BW and is true today. The difference was that back in BW people had to resort to UMS maps while today they can download a free game on Steam. The results are the same, more people play casual games than hardcore RTS games.


I would argue that RTS as single player games aren't hardcore. But they've still stopped making them. I would never play the Red Alert games online in any case, yet I still valued those purchases for the single player experience.
Ryndika
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
1489 Posts
July 09 2014 23:08 GMT
#1192
Haven't you played Age of Empires 2? Where you all megaomegapros there? Most of people I know enjoyed AoE to death and we all were "casuals" in those days.
as useful as teasalt
StarStruck
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
25339 Posts
July 10 2014 02:26 GMT
#1193
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )


i know you think that means a lot but it doesn't.
Thieving Magpie
Profile Blog Joined December 2012
United States6752 Posts
July 10 2014 03:11 GMT
#1194
On July 10 2014 07:56 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 07:29 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )


Yes, casuals enjoy battle more than non-battles, this was true in BW and is true today. The difference was that back in BW people had to resort to UMS maps while today they can download a free game on Steam. The results are the same, more people play casual games than hardcore RTS games.


I would argue that RTS as single player games aren't hardcore. But they've still stopped making them. I would never play the Red Alert games online in any case, yet I still valued those purchases for the single player experience.


And I would argue that the single player experience does not accurately depict the RTS experience.
Hark, what baseball through yonder window breaks?
sc2isnotdying
Profile Joined June 2014
United States200 Posts
July 10 2014 04:04 GMT
#1195
On July 10 2014 12:11 Thieving Magpie wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 07:56 sc2isnotdying wrote:
On July 10 2014 07:29 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )


Yes, casuals enjoy battle more than non-battles, this was true in BW and is true today. The difference was that back in BW people had to resort to UMS maps while today they can download a free game on Steam. The results are the same, more people play casual games than hardcore RTS games.


I would argue that RTS as single player games aren't hardcore. But they've still stopped making them. I would never play the Red Alert games online in any case, yet I still valued those purchases for the single player experience.


And I would argue that the single player experience does not accurately depict the RTS experience.


I agree that single player and multiplayer RTS are two distinct things but for the majority of the market the single player campaign is the entire RTS experience. Blizzard understands this and they are the only developer to make an RTS hit in recent memory. If the genre is to have a future beyond Starcraft, the single player portion has to be the draw.
Xiphos
Profile Blog Joined July 2009
Canada7507 Posts
July 10 2014 04:23 GMT
#1196
On July 10 2014 12:11 Thieving Magpie wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 07:56 sc2isnotdying wrote:
On July 10 2014 07:29 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )


Yes, casuals enjoy battle more than non-battles, this was true in BW and is true today. The difference was that back in BW people had to resort to UMS maps while today they can download a free game on Steam. The results are the same, more people play casual games than hardcore RTS games.


I would argue that RTS as single player games aren't hardcore. But they've still stopped making them. I would never play the Red Alert games online in any case, yet I still valued those purchases for the single player experience.


And I would argue that the single player experience does not accurately depict the RTS experience.


Well originally, RTS was purely based on "solving puzzles". Meaning that each campaign levels are a puzzle to solve. It only evolved into a multiplayer game much later on. And only a few games were able to deliver a good multiplayer experience.
2014 - ᕙ( •̀ل͜•́) ϡ Raise your bows brood warriors! ᕙ( •̀ل͜•́) ϡ
Thieving Magpie
Profile Blog Joined December 2012
United States6752 Posts
July 10 2014 16:26 GMT
#1197
On July 10 2014 13:23 Xiphos wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 12:11 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 07:56 sc2isnotdying wrote:
On July 10 2014 07:29 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )


Yes, casuals enjoy battle more than non-battles, this was true in BW and is true today. The difference was that back in BW people had to resort to UMS maps while today they can download a free game on Steam. The results are the same, more people play casual games than hardcore RTS games.


I would argue that RTS as single player games aren't hardcore. But they've still stopped making them. I would never play the Red Alert games online in any case, yet I still valued those purchases for the single player experience.


And I would argue that the single player experience does not accurately depict the RTS experience.


Well originally, RTS was purely based on "solving puzzles". Meaning that each campaign levels are a puzzle to solve. It only evolved into a multiplayer game much later on. And only a few games were able to deliver a good multiplayer experience.


Yes.

But in those puzzles, base building was not an actual intrinsic aspect since half the time you're already given a base or don't even need one (in installation maps), meaning that the only "core" RTS aspect of the single player is pure army control without base management.

RTS as we understand them today as a genre intrinsically is intertwined with the base building and management aspect of the game in conjunction with army control. The single player experience of RTS games only has army control as it's main focus.
Hark, what baseball through yonder window breaks?
TMG26
Profile Joined July 2012
Portugal2017 Posts
July 13 2014 18:21 GMT
#1198
I think the biggest problem in the difficulty on the game is the macro aspect of the game.

Keeping cycling between building to keep productions going and charges up requires a good chunk of the player APM and attention.

An interesting proposal is being able to "auto-produce" units. Similar to auto casting of spells. Of course there is a few problems with a pure auto-produce, but that can always be tuned.

Opinions on it? Restrictions on it?
Supporter of the situational Blink Dagger on Storm.
Thieving Magpie
Profile Blog Joined December 2012
United States6752 Posts
July 13 2014 21:21 GMT
#1199
On July 14 2014 03:21 TMG26 wrote:
I think the biggest problem in the difficulty on the game is the macro aspect of the game.

Keeping cycling between building to keep productions going and charges up requires a good chunk of the player APM and attention.

An interesting proposal is being able to "auto-produce" units. Similar to auto casting of spells. Of course there is a few problems with a pure auto-produce, but that can always be tuned.

Opinions on it? Restrictions on it?


Nexus Wars is already the most popular arcade for a reason
Hark, what baseball through yonder window breaks?
Xiphos
Profile Blog Joined July 2009
Canada7507 Posts
July 13 2014 21:59 GMT
#1200
On July 11 2014 01:26 Thieving Magpie wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 10 2014 13:23 Xiphos wrote:
On July 10 2014 12:11 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 07:56 sc2isnotdying wrote:
On July 10 2014 07:29 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:17 vOdToasT wrote:
On July 10 2014 06:13 Thieving Magpie wrote:
On July 10 2014 05:55 sc2isnotdying wrote:
Is the genre on it's last legs? I have some theories on why this might be the case but none of them are completely satisfying so I'm curious as to what the TL community thinks.

Theory 1: RTS games feature too high a learning curve to attract new players. It's true that commanding an entire army while simultaneously building a base and managing resources is incredibly difficult but this is not a wholly satisfying conclusion. For one, this didn't seem to deter players when RTS games were the hottest thing around circa the release of Starcraft 1. Secondly, a good single player campaign embraces the learning curve as the core of the experience. We're all multiplayer gamers here, but what sold me and everybody on the genre in the first place was playing well designed single player campaigns with a manageable learning curve. Are new players scared off the genre through reputation alone?

Theory 2: Starcraft is so dominant in the genre, there's no room for any competitors. Maybe, but I don't buy the notion that a Starcraft player wouldn't also play other RTS games. Anyways most people who bought Starcraft 2 stopped playing by now. That doesn't mean they've given up on RTS games.

Theory 3: RTS were popular in the 90's because they required less computing power to be compelling than other genres. AKA when shooters got pretty, the RTS died. Except it doesn't really seem like the RTS audience jumped to shooters, but rather to games like DOTA, which brings me to the next theory...

Theory 4: The RTS audience really just wanted to be playing MOBAs all along but they hadn't been invented yet. The decline in RTS popularity does seem to line up with the release of Warcraft 3 and DOTA. Honestly, this is a pretty compelling theory, but the genres are so different it's hard to believe the MOBA audience cannibalized the RTS audience to the degree it appears to have done.

What does everybody else think?


MOBAs provide what most RTS promise to give casual players without breaking their mind.

Army combat where you are a commander leading troops and it is your decision making and abilities that define the outcome.

For people to truly enjoy an RTS they'd have to enjoy the non-combat aspects of it as much as the combat aspects of it, otherwise they will simply shift to a MOBA.


I got to diamond in LoL and I still think Micro Tournament in Brood War is more exciting. ( A map that is nothing but battles )


Yes, casuals enjoy battle more than non-battles, this was true in BW and is true today. The difference was that back in BW people had to resort to UMS maps while today they can download a free game on Steam. The results are the same, more people play casual games than hardcore RTS games.


I would argue that RTS as single player games aren't hardcore. But they've still stopped making them. I would never play the Red Alert games online in any case, yet I still valued those purchases for the single player experience.


And I would argue that the single player experience does not accurately depict the RTS experience.


Well originally, RTS was purely based on "solving puzzles". Meaning that each campaign levels are a puzzle to solve. It only evolved into a multiplayer game much later on. And only a few games were able to deliver a good multiplayer experience.


Yes.

But in those puzzles, base building was not an actual intrinsic aspect since half the time you're already given a base or don't even need one (in installation maps), meaning that the only "core" RTS aspect of the single player is pure army control without base management.

RTS as we understand them today as a genre intrinsically is intertwined with the base building and management aspect of the game in conjunction with army control. The single player experience of RTS games only has army control as it's main focus.


Not exactly sure why you brought the base building into a conversation of multiplayer and single player aspect of RTS game.

But this doesn't change the fact that originally, RTS was purely based on "solving puzzles". Meaning that each campaign levels are a puzzle to solve. It only evolved into a multiplayer game much later on. And only a few games were able to deliver a good multiplayer experience.
2014 - ᕙ( •̀ل͜•́) ϡ Raise your bows brood warriors! ᕙ( •̀ل͜•́) ϡ
Prev 1 58 59 60 61 62 81 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 1h 25m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
mouzHeroMarine 589
Codebar 98
StarCraft: Brood War
Rain 2021
Noble 9
Dota 2
monkeys_forever268
Counter-Strike
pashabiceps1920
allub1274
zeus602
Super Smash Bros
PPMD73
Heroes of the Storm
Liquid`Hasu679
Trikslyr77
Other Games
tarik_tv5352
Grubby3120
shahzam372
PiGStarcraft195
QueenE74
UpATreeSC44
Mew2King39
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hupsaiya 31
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Azhi_Dahaki57
• Eskiya23 11
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Other Games
• imaqtpie1255
• Shiphtur482
Upcoming Events
Replay Cast
1h 25m
Monday Night Weeklies
19h 25m
PiGosaur Cup
1d 3h
The PondCast
1d 12h
OSC
1d 18h
Replay Cast
2 days
GSL
2 days
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
2 days
OSC
2 days
Replay Cast
3 days
[ Show More ]
KCM Race Survival
3 days
RSL Revival
4 days
BSL
4 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
5 days
BSL
5 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
WardiTV Weekly
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Individual League
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 6
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.