EPTSome constructive criticism for tasteless? - Page 18
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Kfcnoob
United States296 Posts
| ||
|
Flying_Cake
Canada117 Posts
| ||
|
TDN
United States133 Posts
To me, a true caster is the one that does play-by-play talk with a professional radio voice and language like that of TotalBiscuit or HDstarcraft. A commentator is the one who gives opinion about the game based on his knowledge, not biased like Artosis. For example, Poltprime executed his games against Alicia perfectly, but Artosis made it to be like they were cheesy and even recommended viewers not to watch those games. Just because your mom "Alicia" loses to Polt and Polt's past comment about Jinro, doesn't mean you have to downplay Polt that much when the "cheesier" player was always Alicia since he did sneaky voidrays and DT in early game all the time. If I were GOMtv and Artosis recommends viewers not to watch their games, I would've fired Artosis for sure. What kind of employee recommend others not to buy his employer's product. If this community prefers fanboyism over professionalism, then I don't think the foreign SC scene would go anywhere. Only being professional and hire professional casters and commentators would push the scene to a professional level. If you look at Korean caster and commentators and real sports castings in the US, they all have single caster with a radio voice and one or two non-biased commentators. Tastosis are super biased and nonprofessional. Just think about Clide, Alicia, Inca. Then think about BitByBit, Polt, TheBest. Your job is to be professional and non-biased, not going after and praising someone's butt and spreading hates on the ones you don't like. User was banned for this post. | ||
|
LemOn
United Kingdom8629 Posts
| ||
|
acrimoneyius
United States983 Posts
| ||
|
SnipedSoul
Canada2158 Posts
His knowledge base will probably increase as the game matures, but I would really like to see him get his old passion back. | ||
|
Snuggles
United States1865 Posts
| ||
ZeromuS
Canada13389 Posts
| ||
|
Zim23
United States1681 Posts
| ||
|
namedplayer
844 Posts
| ||
|
Von
United States363 Posts
| ||
|
jimmydu444
Canada250 Posts
| ||
|
guitarizt
United States1492 Posts
On June 13 2011 04:15 LemOn wrote: we definitely don't get enough Mutalisk pleasure sex discussions! I demand more seconded | ||
|
uSnAmplified
United States1029 Posts
| ||
|
opaque
Russian Federation89 Posts
| ||
|
Clog
United States950 Posts
On June 13 2011 04:13 TDN wrote: People like them not because they're professional nor good casters, but because of fanboyism. That's the way the community works. I watch SC2 for the entertainment value. Therefore, to me, a good caster is one that is entertaining. These two are very fun to listen to and watch, and therefore entertaining, and good casters. Did you ever consider that the "fanboyism" resulted from them being so entertaining, not the other way around? | ||
|
VoidEU
Sweden24 Posts
Last gsl (not the supertournament) I tuned into the finals just to hear "this is gg". Turned off the stream again and played ladder.. Im raging so hard everytime I hear it.. For the love of god.. Good players can see for them selves when its GG.. Bad players dont want to hear its gg. They are there for the excitement. And saying "this game is over" pretty much kills ANY excitement.... even if its obviously gg. Totalbiscuit wrote a long post on reddit explaining it a lot better than I can ever do. | ||
|
StateAlchemist
France1946 Posts
On June 13 2011 04:13 TDN wrote: I've always thought Tastosis are not professional and way too repetitive. They always commentate in a joking style and use the word "like" frequently since they don't have the ability to do play-by-play with proper grammar. People like them not because they're professional nor good casters, but because of fanboyism. That's the way the community works. To me, a true caster is the one that does play-by-play talk with a professional radio voice and language like that of TotalBiscuit or HDstarcraft. A commentator is the one who gives opinion about the game based on his knowledge, not biased like Artosis. For example, Poltprime executed his games against Alicia perfectly, but Artosis made it to be like they were cheesy and even recommended viewers not to watch those games. Just because your mom "Alicia" loses to Polt and Polt's past comment about Jinro, doesn't mean you have to downplay Polt that much when the "cheesier" player was always Alicia since he did sneaky voidrays and DT in early game all the time. If I were GOMtv and Artosis recommends viewers not to watch their games, I would've fired Artosis for sure. What kind of employee recommend others not to buy his employer's product. If this community prefers fanboyism over professionalism, then I don't think the foreign SC scene would go anywhere. Only being professional and hire professional casters and commentators would push the scene to a professional level. If you look at Korean caster and commentators and real sports castings in the US, they all have single caster with a radio voice and one or two non-biased commentators. Tastosis are super biased and nonprofessional. Just think about Clide, Alicia, Inca. Then think about BitByBit, Polt, TheBest. Your job is to be professional and non-biased, not going after and praising someone's butt and spreading hates on the ones you don't like. Korean casters in action : + Show Spoiler + Professionnal and serious you said? :D Tasteless and Artosis love the game and try to make us love it too. i don't care if they have their favorites, i just want to see passionates guys talking about their passion (the game). We are watching gsl to have fun and some exciting moments, not to be bored by looking at 2 serious guys casting some serious content imho. They make mistakes for sure, but who doesn't? | ||
|
iamke55
United States2806 Posts
On June 13 2011 04:13 TDN wrote: I've always thought Tastosis are not professional and way too repetitive. They always commentate in a joking style and use the word "like" frequently since they don't have the ability to do play-by-play with proper grammar. People like them not because they're professional nor good casters, but because of fanboyism. That's the way the community works. To me, a true caster is the one that does play-by-play talk with a professional radio voice and language like that of TotalBiscuit or HDstarcraft. A commentator is the one who gives opinion about the game based on his knowledge, not biased like Artosis. For example, Poltprime executed his games against Alicia perfectly, but Artosis made it to be like they were cheesy and even recommended viewers not to watch those games. Just because your mom "Alicia" loses to Polt and Polt's past comment about Jinro, doesn't mean you have to downplay Polt that much when the "cheesier" player was always Alicia since he did sneaky voidrays and DT in early game all the time. If I were GOMtv and Artosis recommends viewers not to watch their games, I would've fired Artosis for sure. What kind of employee recommend others not to buy his employer's product. If this community prefers fanboyism over professionalism, then I don't think the foreign SC scene would go anywhere. Only being professional and hire professional casters and commentators would push the scene to a professional level. If you look at Korean caster and commentators and real sports castings in the US, they all have single caster with a radio voice and one or two non-biased commentators. Tastosis are super biased and nonprofessional. Just think about Clide, Alicia, Inca. Then think about BitByBit, Polt, TheBest. Your job is to be professional and non-biased, not going after and praising someone's butt and spreading hates on the ones you don't like. This is when my PBU alarm went off. Why am I not surprised it was accurate? | ||
|
Piy
Scotland3152 Posts
| ||
| ||
