| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Alvar
Sweden61 Posts
On October 17 2011 09:16 sGs.Kal_rA wrote: Pretty much  This isn't Halo. If it was like Halo it would work fine, but its not. Sigh.I do not realy care about Halo. But I cannot for the life of me understand why it works better there? It is still the same kind of crap that ultimately can double-punish some people while others have luck on their side and do not get punished for loosing earlier. | ||
|
Fubi
2228 Posts
On October 17 2011 09:17 Mementoss wrote: Is this necessary for every time MLG is going on? I'm pretty sure they know the majority doesn't like it. They are comfortable with there format and are not going to change it. I'm personally fine with the rule as the person from the winners bracket deserves some sort of advantage. God, can people seriously not scroll back one or two pages before posting? The "winner deserves advantage" has been brought up a millions of time and had been counter-reasoned every time. | ||
|
TheBomb
237 Posts
| ||
|
labbe
Sweden1456 Posts
On October 17 2011 06:57 bbm wrote: How did it screw over boxer? Out of the games he played against idra, he won three and idra won four, so idra went through. If it wasn't extended series, and he'd 2-1'd idra, then idra would have won three games overall but boxer only two games... and you think that is more fair? That's the entire point to the argument against extended series, so yeah, I think that would be fair. Idra got rewarded for his 2-0 vs Boxer by getting higher seed in the bracket. He doesn't need another benefit from that win. Not only do I think it's unfair, but it's kind of silly that Idra actually benefitted from the fact that Boxer beat Stephano and SaSe earlier. Had SaSe or Stephano gone through, Idra would not have had that advantage. So why should Idra benefit from Boxer's wins? | ||
|
BuddhaMonk
781 Posts
On October 17 2011 09:17 Mementoss wrote: Is this necessary for every time MLG is going on? I'm pretty sure they know the majority doesn't like it. They are comfortable with there format and are not going to change it. I'm personally fine with the rule as the person from the winners bracket deserves some sort of advantage. I'm not so sure they're not going to change it, Sundance has hinted at format changes before for next year's circuit. Obviously they're not going to change their rules mid-season. | ||
|
darklight54321
United States361 Posts
On October 17 2011 09:19 Fubi wrote: God, can people seriously not scroll back one or two pages before posting? The "winner deserves advantage" has been brought up a millions of time and had been counter-reasoned every time. not really, it's counter reasoned as in they disagree, but not counter reasoned as in a clear point as to why they shouldn't deserve advantage. Though i believe thats the wrong way to put it. Its simply an extended series of the original one. | ||
|
Silidons
United States2813 Posts
On October 17 2011 09:22 darklight54321 wrote: not really, it's counter reasoned as in they disagree, but not counter reasoned as in a clear point as to why they shouldn't deserve advantage. Though i believe thats the wrong way to put it. Its simply an extended series of the original one. can you read? That's the entire point to the argument against extended series, so yeah, I think that would be fair. Idra got rewarded for his 2-0 vs Boxer by getting higher seed in the bracket. He doesn't need another benefit from that win. Not only do I think it's unfair, but it's kind of silly that Idra actually benefitted from the fact that Boxer beat Stephano and SaSe earlier. Had SaSe or Stephano gone through, Idra would not have had that advantage. So why should Idra benefit from Boxer's wins? If that right there isn't enough reason to change it, I don't know what is. | ||
|
Phayze
Canada2029 Posts
| ||
|
Full.tilt
United Kingdom1709 Posts
| ||
|
MMello
279 Posts
On a happy note + Show Spoiler + Protoss wins  | ||
|
Pyskee
United States620 Posts
Tough to say. | ||
|
CursOr
United States6335 Posts
| ||
|
Fubi
2228 Posts
On October 17 2011 09:22 darklight54321 wrote: not really, it's counter reasoned as in they disagree, but not counter reasoned as in a clear point as to why they shouldn't deserve advantage. Though i believe thats the wrong way to put it. Its simply an extended series of the original one. I guess to you, everything is just an opinion of disagreement unless scientific statistics or experimental theories are presented right? | ||
|
Yorke
England881 Posts
I don't care about it being "fair", you cannot have an entire tournament lead up to a match that can end in 2 games, potentially less than 10 minutes of play. This is appallingly bad planning for several reasons. | ||
|
endy
Switzerland8970 Posts
On October 17 2011 09:21 labbe wrote: That's the entire point to the argument against extended series, so yeah, I think that would be fair. Idra got rewarded for his 2-0 vs Boxer by getting higher seed in the bracket. He doesn't need another benefit from that win. Not only do I think it's unfair, but it's kind of silly that Idra actually benefitted from the fact that Boxer beat Stephano and SaSe earlier. Had SaSe or Stephano gone through, Idra would not have had that advantage. So why should Idra benefit from Boxer's wins? Totally agree, Idra was already rewarded by a higher seed, and a "tired" (Idra just chilled while Boxer was playing Stephano and Sase). There is no reason at all to be up in the series, especially 2-0. It's unfair and kills the hype. The only advantage I'm ok with, is the classic 1-0 advantage to the player coming from the winner bracket against the player coming from the loser bracket for the grand finals. | ||
|
Dew.
Brazil104 Posts
On October 17 2011 09:21 labbe wrote: That's the entire point to the argument against extended series, so yeah, I think that would be fair. Idra got rewarded for his 2-0 vs Boxer by getting higher seed in the bracket. He doesn't need another benefit from that win. Not only do I think it's unfair, but it's kind of silly that Idra actually benefitted from the fact that Boxer beat Stephano and SaSe earlier. Had SaSe or Stephano gone through, Idra would not have had that advantage. So why should Idra benefit from Boxer's wins? Nailed it bro =) | ||
|
Yorke
England881 Posts
| ||
|
Cheeseburgered
United States716 Posts
| ||
|
floor exercise
Canada5847 Posts
| ||
|
CursOr
United States6335 Posts
People are going to complain about PvP finals no mater what you do, Extended Series is just the whipping boy this time. | ||
| ||
FEL
Cracow 2025
Clem vs Krystianer
uThermal vs SKillousLIVE!
Reynor vs MaNa
Lambo vs Gerald
[ Submit Event ] |
|
|
|
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
Bonyth vs Zhanhun
Dewalt vs Mihu
Hawk vs Sziky
Sziky vs QiaoGege
Mihu vs Hawk
Zhanhun vs Dewalt
Fengzi vs Bonyth
Sparkling Tuna Cup
WardiTV European League
Online Event
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
The PondCast
Replay Cast
Korean StarCraft League
CranKy Ducklings
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
