• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 21:59
CET 03:59
KST 11:59
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #238[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over4Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
Trading/Investing Thread US Politics Mega-thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 15310 users

[NASL] Sunday Showdown - IdrA vs Alive - Page 62

Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Tournaments
Post a Reply
Prev 1 60 61 62 63 64 71 Next
TeamBanished
Profile Joined September 2011
United States301 Posts
February 13 2012 21:50 GMT
#1221
Has Idra responded? Has NASL made any comment regarding this?
For Aiur
EtherealDeath
Profile Blog Joined July 2007
United States8366 Posts
February 13 2012 21:52 GMT
#1222
On February 14 2012 06:50 morevox wrote:
Has Idra responded? Has NASL made any comment regarding this?

nasl says idra has forfeited his $100 and they will reconsider inviting him to future special events.
theJob
Profile Joined October 2010
272 Posts
February 13 2012 21:52 GMT
#1223
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.
Winners train. Loosers complain.
ClysmiC
Profile Blog Joined December 2010
United States2192 Posts
February 13 2012 21:54 GMT
#1224
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


There shouldn't need to be a rule. When someone throws a match due to indifference, it is so fucking obvious that no rule is needed. If IdrA did just 1 six-pool, we could chalk it up to frustration/tilt. But 2 in a row shows that he clearly didn't care at all about the games, and thus shouldn't be awarded anything for "playing" them.
Seraphone
Profile Joined January 2012
United Kingdom1219 Posts
February 13 2012 21:55 GMT
#1225
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


No one cares about your technicalities. Everyone (you included) knows Idra was raging and just throwing the games, there is no burden of proof in a Starcraft tournament.
Mvp, Nestea, Leenock, MC, Oz, Jjakji!
liberal
Profile Joined November 2011
1116 Posts
February 13 2012 21:55 GMT
#1226
On February 14 2012 06:25 Nagano wrote:
NASL Sunday Showdown Idra vs Alive VODs

Game 1:
+ Show Spoiler +


Game 2:
+ Show Spoiler +


Game 3:
+ Show Spoiler +


Game 4:
+ Show Spoiler +

Thank you very much for posting these
skyflyfish
Profile Joined January 2012
Canada499 Posts
February 13 2012 21:56 GMT
#1227
ppl should really watch the video first before arguing whether if 6pool is viable strategy.its all about the context.
as1
EtherealDeath
Profile Blog Joined July 2007
United States8366 Posts
February 13 2012 21:57 GMT
#1228
On February 14 2012 06:54 ClysmiC wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


There shouldn't need to be a rule. When someone throws a match due to indifference, it is so fucking obvious that no rule is needed. If IdrA did just 1 six-pool, we could chalk it up to frustration/tilt. But 2 in a row shows that he clearly didn't care at all about the games, and thus shouldn't be awarded anything for "playing" them.

Not to mention that in this community, unmerited action of league towards player would result in huge backlash for the league. Showmatches tend to work via acclamation.
1Eris1
Profile Joined September 2010
United States5797 Posts
February 13 2012 21:57 GMT
#1229
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


Six pools become pretty unviable once you keep doing them after you fail. I wouldn't mind if idrA had done only one of them, but doing two in a row just shows he doesn't care anymore
Known Aliases: Tyragon, Valeric ~MSL Forever, SKT is truly the Superior KT!
Bellygareth
Profile Joined October 2010
France512 Posts
February 13 2012 21:58 GMT
#1230
On February 14 2012 06:50 EtherealDeath wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:44 Bellygareth wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.


Apparently it's as easy as : it's Idra = he throws it. It's not Idra = it's legit he lost because he played bad.

Game 3 was fine, common to proxy rax. Game 4 as well makes it highly questionable. Add in no gg ever makes it quite clearly not giving a fuck.

Seriously, I don't understand megafans sometimes. No one is criticizing idra for trying to six pool. It's the context that creates the criticism.


I'm not a megafan. I'm not trying to excuse him. Just saying that the context doesn't make alive allins better than Idra's. In this thread people are assuming that Alive's cheese because successful makes it ok. When it made the first two games a mess as well. As a viewer I find as bad (in a showmatch) cheesing and winning and cheesing and losing.
theJob
Profile Joined October 2010
272 Posts
February 13 2012 22:00 GMT
#1231
On February 14 2012 06:54 ClysmiC wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


There shouldn't need to be a rule.


Allright cool. Then shouldn't NASL add a line like "There are a set amount of builds that we won't specify which if you execute during a tournament you will never be reinvited" somewhere on their site?
Winners train. Loosers complain.
theJob
Profile Joined October 2010
272 Posts
February 13 2012 22:01 GMT
#1232
On February 14 2012 06:57 1Eris1 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


Six pools become pretty unviable once you keep doing them after you fail. I wouldn't mind if idrA had done only one of them, but doing two in a row just shows he doesn't care anymore



Ok, then it's: "sixpooling twice in a row = punishable offence" to the NASL rules?
Winners train. Loosers complain.
pak150
Profile Joined September 2010
United States531 Posts
February 13 2012 22:03 GMT
#1233
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that


There may not be any "no idra" signs at the next tournament, but I guarantee there'll be some "u sixpoll?" signs
1Eris1
Profile Joined September 2010
United States5797 Posts
February 13 2012 22:07 GMT
#1234
On February 14 2012 07:01 theJob wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:57 1Eris1 wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


Six pools become pretty unviable once you keep doing them after you fail. I wouldn't mind if idrA had done only one of them, but doing two in a row just shows he doesn't care anymore



Ok, then it's: "sixpooling twice in a row = punishable offence" to the NASL rules?

How stupid are you? It's the forfeiting that's the problem, not the fucking cheese
Known Aliases: Tyragon, Valeric ~MSL Forever, SKT is truly the Superior KT!
Grumbels
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Netherlands7032 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-13 22:14:15
February 13 2012 22:10 GMT
#1235
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.

There are organisations that have the discretionary power to punish Idra regardless. In this case both NASL and EG have ways to come to an arrangement. EG does have the power to punish Idra and can easily get him to forfeit his second place prize and NASL can pressure EG too since they organize leagues and showmatches that EG might want to participate in.

There is no real need to have laws for some arbitrary lack of respect for a tournament as long as there is some sort of ethical standard that gets enforced by the organisations in the scene.

And also, I read a blog by EGAlex once (I believe it's linked in this thread even) where he said he had a chat with Idra after the latter forfeited the semi-finals in a TL-open when playing Nerchio, because Alex felt that was going too far and wasn't like his other antics. Since Idra forfeited the prize money maybe Alex had another chat, though that's just speculation - it's not inconceivable NASL discussed this with just Idra, until Xeris or EG tells us we won't know (and it's not super important I guess).
Well, now I tell you, I never seen good come o' goodness yet. Him as strikes first is my fancy; dead men don't bite; them's my views--amen, so be it.
EtherealDeath
Profile Blog Joined July 2007
United States8366 Posts
February 13 2012 22:11 GMT
#1236
On February 14 2012 06:58 Bellygareth wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 06:50 EtherealDeath wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:44 Bellygareth wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:01 Snotling wrote:
nobody is banning him, but the will think twice before they invite him to a showmacht again. not the same ting. and totally justified



Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.


Apparently it's as easy as : it's Idra = he throws it. It's not Idra = it's legit he lost because he played bad.

Game 3 was fine, common to proxy rax. Game 4 as well makes it highly questionable. Add in no gg ever makes it quite clearly not giving a fuck.

Seriously, I don't understand megafans sometimes. No one is criticizing idra for trying to six pool. It's the context that creates the criticism.


I'm not a megafan. I'm not trying to excuse him. Just saying that the context doesn't make alive allins better than Idra's. In this thread people are assuming that Alive's cheese because successful makes it ok. When it made the first two games a mess as well. As a viewer I find as bad (in a showmatch) cheesing and winning and cheesing and losing.

Both of alive's cheeses have macro game transitions. Both are often used to probe an opponent in series play, and both are normally defended, resulting in a macro game.

Hard to blame alive for trying to start the pressure right away only to have idra fail to defend it. Playing to win makes for the best games if both players are evenly skilled. I guess we should tell better players to try to let worse players win in showmatches...
theJob
Profile Joined October 2010
272 Posts
February 13 2012 22:19 GMT
#1237
On February 14 2012 07:07 1Eris1 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 07:01 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:57 1Eris1 wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:06 theJob wrote:
[quote]


Well, it seems like that you can choose to play the showmatch without sixpooling and everything is fine.
But if you choose to sixpool you have to give up the pricemoney for NASL to consider inviting you to a future event.

This should be in the rulebook so that no missunderstandings occur in the future.



really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


Six pools become pretty unviable once you keep doing them after you fail. I wouldn't mind if idrA had done only one of them, but doing two in a row just shows he doesn't care anymore



Ok, then it's: "sixpooling twice in a row = punishable offence" to the NASL rules?

How stupid are you? It's the forfeiting that's the problem, not the fucking cheese



How stupid are you? It's the arbitrary use of power that's the issue.

Either you have specified rules OR you admit to having arbitrary powers to punish players.

If the first is true then they have to list the specific builds that players can be punished for executing.
If the latter is true then NASL can strip the pricemoney of the next NASL season 2 champion "because he smelled funny".

Punishing players on a fucking whim whenever they feel like their sponsors didn't get their monies worth is pure bullshit if anyone cares for the integrity of the game. But listing strategies as punishable offences are stupid unless we want to completely revamp the "meta-game".
Winners train. Loosers complain.
EtherealDeath
Profile Blog Joined July 2007
United States8366 Posts
February 13 2012 22:22 GMT
#1238
On February 14 2012 07:19 theJob wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 07:07 1Eris1 wrote:
On February 14 2012 07:01 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:57 1Eris1 wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
[quote]


really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


Six pools become pretty unviable once you keep doing them after you fail. I wouldn't mind if idrA had done only one of them, but doing two in a row just shows he doesn't care anymore



Ok, then it's: "sixpooling twice in a row = punishable offence" to the NASL rules?

How stupid are you? It's the forfeiting that's the problem, not the fucking cheese



How stupid are you? It's the arbitrary use of power that's the issue.

Either you have specified rules OR you admit to having arbitrary powers to punish players.

If the first is true then they have to list the specific builds that players can be punished for executing.
If the latter is true then NASL can strip the pricemoney of the next NASL season 2 champion "because he smelled funny".

Punishing players on a fucking whim whenever they feel like their sponsors didn't get their monies worth is pure bullshit if anyone cares for the integrity of the game. But listing strategies as punishable offences are stupid unless we want to completely revamp the "meta-game".

This reminds me of the slippery slope of Everest...
SockArms
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States591 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-13 22:28:32
February 13 2012 22:23 GMT
#1239
On February 14 2012 07:19 theJob wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 07:07 1Eris1 wrote:
On February 14 2012 07:01 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:57 1Eris1 wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:52 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:39 Necro)Phagist( wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:35 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:26 Snotling wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:17 theJob wrote:
On February 14 2012 06:11 Snotling wrote:
[quote]


really? even idra doesnt defend his actions (as we can se by him giving back the money). why do you?



Because arbitrary use of power to punish players is bad. And yes, it IS arbitrary if the prerequisit for being punished is "failing to please the league".

If Idra was somehow able to punish Alive for his early gamepushes – would that mean that Alive would have been the one to have to forfeit pricemoney to be considered being reinvited?

I don't defend Idra for his actions but I defend his right to do them UNLESS it's stated in the rules that he's not.



but the point is: nobody is punishing him. there wont be any NO-IDRA sings on tournaments anytime soon.
They just said "we may reconsider inviting him to SPECIAL events in the future. "

If someone pays for a SHOWmatch, its his right to invite the players who provide the best show. and idra didnt provide a good show.

i realy dont get how anyone could have a problem with that



Having to give up the pricemoney to be considered to being invited into special events in the future. If that's not a special kind of punishment then I'd have to say that this tournament treats its loosers pretty bad in general then.

And sure, I'm not arguing wether NASL does or doesn't have the right to invite whoever they want to their tournament. All I'm saying is that judging from the application of NASL tournament rules – you can be punished (in the form of having to forfeit pricemenoy) for doing certain builds in their tournament.

I'm also saying that I think this is very bad because there should be no "10 minute no attack" in SC2 IMO.

I'm also saying that unless they specify WHICH BUILDS then the application of this rule willl be arbitrary.


You can't specify which builds because a well executed 6 pool is viable, what Idra did is not. It's very, very easy to tell the difference between some one cheesing because they think it can win and some one cheesing because they don't give a fuck. Idra clearly didn't care, threw away the games, was BM the entire showmatch and was therefore punished for it. I see nothing wrong with this.



What if someone attempts to make a "viable sixpool" but it looks like a "unviable sixpool" to you – should that player be stripped from his pricemoney?

So the rule should be something like "If NASL deem a sixpool build being a result of "not giving a fuck" the player will never be reinvited to a future NASL event unless forfeiting his or hers price money".

These kind of rules has the risk of being extremely arbitrary and will be put in effect whenever it suits the league that it'll be the players that'll take it up the rear. It's effectively "if I don't like what you're doing you'll be punished" – there's a reason why we specify laws very well IRL.


Six pools become pretty unviable once you keep doing them after you fail. I wouldn't mind if idrA had done only one of them, but doing two in a row just shows he doesn't care anymore



Ok, then it's: "sixpooling twice in a row = punishable offence" to the NASL rules?

How stupid are you? It's the forfeiting that's the problem, not the fucking cheese



How stupid are you? It's the arbitrary use of power that's the issue.

Either you have specified rules OR you admit to having arbitrary powers to punish players.

If the first is true then they have to list the specific builds that players can be punished for executing.
If the latter is true then NASL can strip the pricemoney of the next NASL season 2 champion "because he smelled funny".

Punishing players on a fucking whim whenever they feel like their sponsors didn't get their monies worth is pure bullshit if anyone cares for the integrity of the game. But listing strategies as punishable offences are stupid unless we want to completely revamp the "meta-game".



ok to explain

6 pool can be a legit cheese mma lost to it in the korean winter mlg qualification BUT Lucky used a drone to block the wall off. that is how you can win playing a 6 pool. When you 6 pool 2 times in a row without trying to do anything about blocking the wallin in the ZvT matchup its subpar. When you do the same subpar rush 2 times in a row your throwing games.
| Cloud9 | DK | Liquid |
nvs.
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Canada3609 Posts
February 13 2012 22:27 GMT
#1240
On February 14 2012 06:10 bonifaceviii wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 05:18 Durp wrote:
This series reminds me of GSL Open Season 1.

hahahaha

But seriously, Incontrol or Alex needs to comment on this.


EG loves to lend their opinion to every other controvery under the sun but more than likely they will sweep this under the rug as yet another instance of "Greg being Greg."
Prev 1 60 61 62 63 64 71 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Replay Cast
08:00
SC2 Kevin Scrim
CranKy Ducklings121
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RuFF_SC2 59
StarCraft: Brood War
GuemChi 1374
Artosis 546
Terrorterran 9
LuMiX 0
Dota 2
NeuroSwarm114
capcasts66
Counter-Strike
Coldzera 1426
fl0m1130
taco 200
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr87
Other Games
summit1g17109
Day[9].tv629
C9.Mang0368
PiGStarcraft264
ToD163
Maynarde115
ViBE78
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick820
BasetradeTV143
[ Show 14 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hupsaiya 109
• davetesta23
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Azhi_Dahaki14
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota2841
Other Games
• Day9tv629
• Shiphtur530
Upcoming Events
Online Event
7h 1m
GSL
8h 31m
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
11h 1m
OSC
13h 1m
Replay Cast
20h 1m
KCM Race Survival
1d 7h
Ultimate Battle
1d 9h
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
2 days
BSL
2 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
3 days
[ Show More ]
IPSL
3 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
3 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
3 days
WardiTV Weekly
4 days
Kung Fu Cup
5 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
5 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.