| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
bp1696
United States288 Posts
On February 26 2008 22:47 Tracil wrote: If by 'clues' you mean things appearing in modposts akin to Chuiu's game, let this be another reminder that there aren't any, unless you count flips on death. Uh, how are we supposed to find out who is who without clues? | ||
MasterOfChaos
Germany2896 Posts
@bp: We have to find out who is mafia by their behavior and with the help of detectives. Who accuses whom, who votes against whom etc just like in a offline mafia. | ||
|
NatsuTerran
United States364 Posts
| ||
|
MasterOfChaos
Germany2896 Posts
The advantage of individual random is, evenso it has a higher probability of a townie dying, that it might give us some information to analyze. I still consider real random voting superior. Anyways my random returned: ##Vote:23-Klive5ive | ||
|
Alethios
New Zealand2765 Posts
Never fear though, since there is only 1 (or 2 with murderer) kill(s) per night, and everybody should be actively posting. I have no doubt that we'll see an exciting game that will come down to the wire. Look for clues in what people are saying, especially in retrospect after a death. @MasterOfChaos: Regarding central random voting: Perhaps you could outline exactly what it is you are proposing. As long as there is no private communication however, I doubt there will be any problem. | ||
|
Kingkosi
United States1215 Posts
| ||
|
So no fek
United States3001 Posts
Can he vote for himself? | ||
|
Alethios
New Zealand2765 Posts
| ||
|
ZBiR
Poland1092 Posts
##Vote: randombum | ||
|
randombum
United States2378 Posts
| ||
|
randombum
United States2378 Posts
Vote for a random number OR Vote for the person who suggested using random numbers for fairness because one dude decided that I was mafia for being the first to pick a random number | ||
|
Dr.Dragoon
United States1241 Posts
On February 27 2008 06:29 randombum wrote: WTF? people are voting for me because of random in my name? I didn't even think of that, but that would be a cool way to choose. I actually got you in the number generator though.  | ||
|
So no fek
United States3001 Posts
On February 27 2008 06:33 randombum wrote: Nm read a little more it seems that because I was the first to suggest random killing it means I'm the first to die. So... how else was the town suppose to choose the first person? If you can think of a better way to start it off other than random numbers then I'll concede that you guys have a base to vote for me. However if you guys are voting for me because one person suggested that I should be killed for starting random numbers than I think thats worse. Vote for a random number OR Vote for the person who suggested using random numbers for fairness because one dude decided that I was mafia for being the first to pick a random number I explained myself. I did a few random generations, and basically looked for 3 numbers to pop up out of 10. The first for this to happen was 4, which was my number, and then 24, which is yours. | ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
Start dialogue about whatever and kill anyone who doesn't speak. That way 2 things happen: 1.) If they are innocent but inactive they die anyway, and we get info on their role. No point in having anyone around that doesn't contribute so kill them anyway. 2.) By having the "everyone must speak" rule we make it so that Mafia also have to speak, which means any smart Innocents can potentially lure them into a logical trap and catch them in a lie. So I'm going to go with the "anyone who doesn't speak" or contribute to the discussion in any way for the first day's vote. Random lynching was a somewhat terrible choice mainly because we don't know how many Mafia members are in the game which makes it pointless. | ||
|
randombum
United States2378 Posts
On February 26 2008 16:33 jtan wrote: Here is why I think random voting is a bad idea: There is like 0% chance we will catch a mafia with the first lynch. All they gotta do is hop on a bandwagon against any townie, or claim to have randomed a townie. So even though I have like zero information, I will still ##vote randombum because he was the first suggesting lynching a specific person. Would be free kill if it had started a bandwagon, and he could just say that it was completly random afterwards. First so no fek and dragoon if you guys really did get me in the random generator than I have nothing against you. (Except maybe so no fek you know you are allowed to vote for yourself and able to change it away if it seems like you are about to die  It would help me, but you have no reason to so that is why this entire thing is in parentheses)Jtan, kingkosi and zbir however, are not voting off random number. They simply have followed Jtan's theory, which is wrong. We do not have 0% chance of getting a mafia, but at least 13.3_% (4/30) up to 23.3_%(7/30). That's decent based of pure luck. While its a high chance to get a townie.... there is no real way to increase chances of targeting a mafia member. However, if you guys really do insist on voting me off first because i was the first to suggest a name then I'm actually OK with it. It beats putting a lot of effort into this thread to lose 1/2 though. (Although these posts have taken some time) But I urge you guys to not kill me cause I would prefer to live. If disagree with random numbers then follow Ace's advice and get someone who does not contribute instead | ||
|
Kingkosi
United States1215 Posts
On February 27 2008 06:47 randombum wrote: God I'm thinking about changing my vote to a person who hasn't contributed, I want to believe you really, I wasn't using Jtan's theory I didn't even read his postFirst so no fek and dragoon if you guys really did get me in the random generator than I have nothing against you. (Except maybe so no fek you know you are allowed to vote for yourself and able to change it away if it seems like you are about to die It would help me, but you have no reason to so that is why this entire thing is in parentheses)Jtan, kingkosi and zbir however, are not voting off random number. They simply have followed Jtan's theory, which is wrong. We do not have 0% chance of getting a mafia, but at least 13.3_% (4/30) up to 23.3_%(7/30). That's decent based of pure luck. While its a high chance to get a townie.... there is no real way to increase chances of targeting a mafia member. However, if you guys really do insist on voting me off first because i was the first to suggest a name then I'm actually OK with it. It beats putting a lot of effort into this thread to lose 1/2 though. (Although these posts have taken some time) But I urge you guys to not kill me cause I would prefer to live. If disagree with random numbers then follow Ace's advice and get someone who does not contribute instead | ||
|
So no fek
United States3001 Posts
As for voting for myself, well, I'm a survivalist townie, and someone has gotta die. I really did get 24 a few tries after I got 4, and I'm not voting for myself. So, I'll look back at it, and possibly change my vote to an inactive. | ||
|
randombum
United States2378 Posts
On February 27 2008 06:49 Kingkosi wrote: God I'm thinking about changing my vote to a person who hasn't contributed, I want to believe you really, I wasn't using Jtan's theory I didn't even read his post How did you end up voting for me? Did You get me with random number generator too, or did you have your own reason for voting me? As of right now I think its 5 votes for me with 2 of them being random numbers 3 of them being something else. | ||
|
Kingkosi
United States1215 Posts
On February 27 2008 06:59 randombum wrote: It's just tough voting seeing is how there are no clues, and I would hate to have randombum who is contributing to get booted so early it seems that he like some of us want to catch some scum.How did you end up voting for me? Did You get me with random number generator too, or did you have your own reason for voting me? As of right now I think its 5 votes for me with 2 of them being random numbers 3 of them being something else. | ||
|
So no fek
United States3001 Posts
On February 27 2008 07:02 Kingkosi wrote: It's just tough voting seeing is how there are no clues, and I would hate to have randombum who is contributing to get booted so early it seems that he like some of us want to catch some scum. Then change your vote, fool. | ||
| ||
The PiG Daily
Best Games
Maru vs Solar
Reynor vs TriGGeR
herO vs Solar
Clem vs TriGGeR
Maru vs TBD
PiGStarcraft479
[ Submit Event ] |
|
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends Counter-Strike Super Smash Bros Other Games tarik_tv13926 gofns11499 summit1g5208 FrodaN5022 Grubby4331 shahzam347 Harstem281 KnowMe273 ToD242 mouzStarbuck229 Liquid`Hasu179 ArmadaUGS106 JuggernautJason35 ZombieGrub20 Maynarde0 |
|
Replay Cast
RongYI Cup
herO vs Maru
Replay Cast
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
Replay Cast
Wardi Open
Monday Night Weeklies
Sparkling Tuna Cup
The PondCast
|
|
|
EPT
