|
11589 Posts
That was the game Foolishness and Marv tunnelled each other into literal oblivion.
|
11589 Posts
On December 07 2020 14:03 WaveofShadow wrote: Wat :eyes:
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
Pretty early townread on Dandel personally
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
My townread of Dandel is waning but it was on such good logic too I'm a bit upset by the tone of his posting.
I would shoot wave if I had a gun but what else is new tbh.
|
11589 Posts
On January 08 2021 07:57 Dandel Ion wrote: nice dodge writer i think you're roleplaying and it's boring
|
11589 Posts
i dont trust you enough to help your role out
|
11589 Posts
Wave why would you want to no lunch ever this is not Among Us
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:15 ShoCkeyy wrote: I think my new role is trying to get me mod killed. Idk who the new mod is, is Dandel a mod now? Is hapa playing now? So many questions this leaves me. I'm scared enough to vote for every bad mafia player in here, shitters. pretty much same
|
11589 Posts
anyway i think eversince might be town for a variety of reasons
i literally have no idea what alignment dandel is anymore this role shit really makes all his activity just about meaningless
GB is among the only people actually scumhunting (even if poorly) so they are almost certainly town
conversion's lame he can die
same with JAT
I like Vivax's limited posting
same with Shockey tho not as limited
not sure why Slam literally only posts that Dandel is mafia
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:24 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 07:04 yamato77 wrote: Wave why would you want to no lunch ever this is not Among Us Because Im doing what I can right now to ensure Hapa doesn't get lynched. Why would we lynch Hapa over someone we think could actually be mafia?
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:37 Vivax wrote: I really just want to know if Gubby and yamato were scum in the last phase. I...wasn't town. im pretty sure your real alignment hasn't actually changed LMAO
|
11589 Posts
look guys dandel isn't actually the host and your "new" role PMs are not a replacement of your original role, this is just some stupid memes where dandel takes himself out of the game for a day
top meme flavor tho Hapa I dig it
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:42 Vivax wrote: Third party. I was TickTock and had to +1 the lynch for 5 times to win and get removed from the game. Special ability was to force a lynch between me and someone else to get a +2 towards the 5/5 if I won.
My new role is town. well you and HF both claimed ticktock so that's a good laugh
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:43 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 07:42 yamato77 wrote: look guys dandel isn't actually the host and your "new" role PMs are not a replacement of your original role, this is just some stupid memes where dandel takes himself out of the game for a day
top meme flavor tho Hapa I dig it There could be a distinct possibility that everything sticks if we lynch hapa though. I don't want to take that chance My new role is ass And that's probably Dandels wincon btw the "role" dandel sent me is a literal meme
that might be the case but there's literally 0 incentive to do that so we should just lynch normally
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:45 WaveofShadow wrote: Tictock also claimed tictock lol he did not
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:50 WaveofShadow wrote: Ugh the bold didnt work He said he has a new role as himself right but vivax and hf claimed it before the role changes
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:53 ghostofconversion wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 07:36 yamato77 wrote: anyway i think eversince might be town for a variety of reasons
i literally have no idea what alignment dandel is anymore this role shit really makes all his activity just about meaningless
GB is among the only people actually scumhunting (even if poorly) so they are almost certainly town
conversion's lame he can die
same with JAT
I like Vivax's limited posting
same with Shockey tho not as limited
not sure why Slam literally only posts that Dandel is mafia ok yall want to call me lame after inviting me to a game that i barely want to play im out then c ya /replace me Dandel or Hapa let Hopeless1der play bye bye if this is an impression of me i am upset
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 07:57 ghostofconversion wrote: so do i trust this Dandel post or not cause im getting conflicting information i trust hapa's post on the matter
i trust nothing dandel has posted.
|
11589 Posts
so funny haha third time you claim dayvig
|
11589 Posts
HF let's get Wave lynched
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 08:41 GlowingBear wrote: Actually, let me do this:
##Vote: Dandel Ion we can't lynch Dandel per Hapa's post, GB
|
11589 Posts
ill come back when people actually want to try to lynch someone
its all memes right now i guess
|
11589 Posts
I don't think lynching Vivax is ever smart
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 09:07 Hapahauli wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 08:16 ghostofconversion wrote: so because i have no idea wtf is going on i will do whatever i want
i am going to share with everyone why yamato should die
yamato has called me lame and said i can die. i do not appreciate this in the slightest
first of all, why am i lame? why would a town person not care about me at all and randomly ask me to die
because he is not town. town would just ignore me and my rambling, but he wants to make it seem like he doesnt care if i die, but still makes a post like he is caring about me as an individual while giving off apathy
that is tip top yamato should die in my books. u do not anger me with my powerful nukey nukes and u shall pay the price for insulting my honor
good bye yamato. no tears for you as insulting me means u get any of my sympathy
and with that we will proceed to nuCLEAR LAUNCH DETECTed
##NUKE: YAMATO Nuclear launch detected. The nuke is projected to hit Yamato in 24 hours.
oof
well if I die I posted my reads and I will do so again if anything changes
also you guys should probably lynch conversion
|
11589 Posts
if town conversion shot a nuke at town me on day 1 for calling him lame I am highly disappointed
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 09:18 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 09:10 yamato77 wrote: if town conversion shot a nuke at town me on day 1 for calling him lame I am highly disappointed I don't think that's a real nuke. He's roleplaying as me I think. Hapa just posted that it was
so...?
|
11589 Posts
I mean sure it's possible that the nuke conversion shot at me is a dud but ???
It's clear to anyone with a brain that I am town by now anyway so whatever. If I die lynch conversion.
I suppose I will continue to play as if it's a fake until proven otherwise.
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 09:18 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Why are people so convinced dandel is scum? I guess that's mostly slam but I don't get it. It definitely is all Slam and he hasn't given any reason afaik
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 09:21 Holyflare wrote:Yamato if you vote hapa we'll be in dandel's game where you aren't being nuked That's not a solution to anything. My role in "dandel's game" is an absolute meme and I refuse to acknowledge it exists
You can't even be guaranteed that this will happen.
Voting Hapa or Dandel is just trolling in my opinion. Seems like everyone's trolling tho
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 09:43 ghostofconversion wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 09:20 yamato77 wrote: I mean sure it's possible that the nuke conversion shot at me is a dud but ???
It's clear to anyone with a brain that I am town by now anyway so whatever. If I die lynch conversion.
I suppose I will continue to play as if it's a fake until proven otherwise. martyring is super town btw i dont like martyr yams can you make more smartass comments about my fake vigs? That is not martyring the host literally just said you shot a nuke at me.
I refuse to believe town you shoots a nuke at me at this stage in the game for real ergo
|
11589 Posts
I mean fakeclaims are lame and you did so twice. I stand by my statement. If you're town and you shot me for that you're the one ruining the game for someone else.
Oh well. I guess it's funny for you.
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 03:36 ghostofconversion wrote: что ты имеешь в виду, я святой, я понятия не имею, о чем ты говоришь This translates to "What do you mean, I'm a saint, I have no idea what you're talking about" in Russian fwiw
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 09:52 ghostofconversion wrote: anyways this is time for me to jetski outta here
i satisfied with my information so far
토끼가 썩은 악어 위를 달리다 Google translate says this means "rabbit runs on a rotten crocodile" which makes little sense so this must be an idiom or something
|
11589 Posts
On January 09 2021 10:06 Alakaslam wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 09:20 yamato77 wrote:On January 09 2021 09:18 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Why are people so convinced dandel is scum? I guess that's mostly slam but I don't get it. It definitely is all Slam and he hasn't given any reason afaik The reason is the whole shenanigan with replacing the host looks to me like a scum power The OP clearly says that roles have no correlation to alignment
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
I like lynching scumclaims
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
Alright conversion is just a troll lynch the claimed mafia
|
11589 Posts
I'm pushing a Wave lynch.
I would also lynch conversion.
I wanted to lynch JAT but he posted and I'm not caught up
Will read and post concise thoughts before I go to hed
|
11589 Posts
wave i didnt like your posting before you claimed mafia and now your defense of yourself is some WIFOM crap
where are your reads?
|
11589 Posts
Voting for Hapa or Dandel in seriousness should be treated as a scumclaim one way or the other.
Pushing a lynch on claimed 3p is likewise pretty stupid.
This game is very all over the place.
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 06:39 WaveofShadow wrote:Imagine doing anything to play the game but when you don't, blame things on people who did Oh yams, never change Weekends are bad times. I've been way more exhausted than usual. I'll play more tonight tho I promise
|
11589 Posts
In other news Hapa's role for me was excellent
|
11589 Posts
Alright friends, I promised I would catch up and actually play the game a couple times already and I am here to make good on that promise. I haven't read much of anything since the start of Day 1 so I have a lot of catching up to do. It's currently midnight my time and I still have to work tomorrow. I'd like to establish my thoughts on the game in case I die, and this will likely be my last opportunity to do so before deadline tomorrow.
I am going to type a lot in this post. I don't currently have the luxury of "interacting" with people so there's a lot I need to process, and the best way for me to do that is to write it out. I'd like to establish my thoughts on most of the claims made in the game, all of the actual roles used on Day 1, and obviously my analysis of how the lynch happened and what that says about players' alignments. I'm sure at this point in the game there is likely enough to go on that I should have a few decent townreads and at least one confident scumread.
Lastly, before I get to my reread and my reactions to things that have happened in my general absence, I want to clarify some of the statements I have made previously in my brief and direct filter. I obviously thought Wave was mafia early on based on his N0 posting (very fluff, mostly about setup and whining that people weren't playing like him) and his start to D1 where he concluded that a no lynch was the most viable path forward and took some amount of convincing otherwise. Then he scumclaimed, albeit for an instance of this game that doesn't necessarily apply anymore. However, I do not see the town motivation to scumclaiming in Dandel's game. My current read (before I read D1) is that Wave is playing to disrupt useful discussion and generally be unhelpful in actually forming a cohesive idea about the game and finding a good lynch, which I obviously think is a mafia motivated playstyle. He could also just be "playing around", but that is a convenient excuse for scumWave to fall back on/
Likewise, Conversion's playstyle has only served to create chaos and disrupt the thread. His multiple fakeclaims and his dud of a nuke on myself helped nothing. If he has reads I don't know them, and I stand by my statement saying and I would nuke him. Being a troll and mafia are not mutually exclusive, as it turns out. I didn't like JAT's early posting but as I stated earlier in my filter, I have not caught up on how he has played in some time.
I liked Vivax' posting and thought process, and I obviously believe his claim, which makes me heavily question HF and his counterclaim. I hope some light was shed on this conundrum in my absence.
Now, obviously we all know GB is town now, and I am not here to simply say "I told you so", even though I already did. My initial thought about his lynch, again, having not caught up, is that it might have been a bandwagon led by a strong mafia player given a weak town presence in pushing a lynch. Some of the blame for that inevitably falls at my feet for largely ignoring the game, as Wave pointed out, but nonetheless I feel as if there was some malfeasance going on there. That said, I will not simply call the first person to vote GB mafia without at least attempting to understand how the lynch actually happened, these are just my thoughts as someone who saw a person he thought was fairly town get lynched.
Now, TO READ
On January 09 2021 08:59 ObiWanShinobi wrote: I think conversion is me. I also don't really think anything that's happening right now matters - I think we just sit and wait until night falls and everything will go back to the way it was.
I vote we no lynch or lynch Vivax, but I'm pretty much hands off today I think. This post sticks out to me as another stinker. I think a Vivax lynch is inherently scum favored and obviously a no lynch is as well. Obi goes to the shit pile for me.
On January 09 2021 09:14 Alakaslam wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 09:10 yamato77 wrote: if town conversion shot a nuke at town me on day 1 for calling him lame I am highly disappointed Agreed but dandel is scum This is also a tangent that I find appalling. Slam's push of an impossible lynch on Dandel for a flimsy reasoning about the use of his role is something that I think any town player would quickly and rightly ignore. Hopefully Slam realizes his mistake at some point.
On January 10 2021 05:44 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 10 2021 04:50 justanothertownie wrote: I also love how Wave is voting for Dandel even though he knows that this is not helping. Show nested quote +On January 10 2021 01:35 WaveofShadow wrote: Haha what the hell there are 3 people voting Dandel right now? I mean I guess I'll join in to survive but so long as people understand it's a no lynch My gut reaction to this is "then find some fucking mafia instead of no-lynching and claiming scum". I usually don't mind survival plays but I also really don't like how hard Wave is working to not have scumreads up to this point in the game.
Going back in time, I wonder if this is the impetus for the GB lynch? It's not bad reasoning IMO if that's what people sheep off of since I think this heuristic is somewhat useful but GB also has reads outside of wanting to lynch Vivax, which I think is an important corollary to the concept. A mafia "hunting" 3p is one thing, a townie not believing a 3p claim is another. GB is not what one might call an optimal player given that he began the game with a scumread on me. Alas, this is an aside.
On January 10 2021 07:14 Holyflare wrote: GB is mafia btw really obvious HF's dismissively brief posting like this irks me, and especially here as a train is forming on Wave that HF himself has at least egged on.
On January 10 2021 07:25 justanothertownie wrote:Yeah, not unlikely I'd say. His appearance today was not very inspiring.
On January 10 2021 08:21 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Wouldn't surprise me either at this point tbh.
It's also quite frustrating that this gets sheeped immediately by two other people for apparently no reason.
On January 10 2021 12:01 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 10 2021 11:17 GlowingBear wrote:On January 10 2021 07:14 Holyflare wrote: GB is mafia btw really obvious Why??? You just kind of exist. Your actually like rolling mafia and so not voting Dandel for host is against the spirit of your alignment. You drew alignment conclusions on people based on Dandel's words but didn't think that Dandel could be mafia and other people know what his role does because they are mafia. You jumped to them being town (Obi). You have had little to no interaction with me, something like one post. You're not interested in solving the slots. You throw away voted Dandel at the start of the day instead of literally anyone you mafia read. Even now that people are voting Wave you've had little interest in even commenting on it. I disagree with a lot of this post and I can feel things turning against GB here, especially given his simultaneous decision to push a lynch on Vivax.
On January 10 2021 12:02 Holyflare wrote:And now you're voting a guy that claimed 3P with a role that is directly countered by someone else in this game and would possibly remove themselves from the game after this night. Truly this is a confusing post tho. If HF counterclaims Vivax in rolename, why does he not want to see him lynched? That's a question I hope gets answered.
On January 10 2021 13:21 Alakaslam wrote: Which, is why I am not pushing it anymore. Was trying to keep up RP but holy shit if it wasn’t actually super effective...
I guess Slam did realize his mistake? But he couldn't switch his vote for RP reasons... not in love with that, but it sounds like something he would do.
On January 10 2021 17:03 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 10 2021 15:15 yamato77 wrote: wave i didnt like your posting before you claimed mafia and now your defense of yourself is some WIFOM crap
where are your reads? They're sprinkled about. Not too many yet Don't spout buzzwords at me though you know I'm right. You didn't like my posting? I trolled and you jumped on like 5min into the game. Don't pretend like you have anything even remotely substantial. Do something useful yourself and maybe I'll do the same Wave clearly doesn't actually think I'm mafia but he's somehow using my activity as a defense of his own lack of reads when I definitely had more posted reads than him in a fraction of the filter? Good lord.
On January 11 2021 00:42 WaveofShadow wrote: You are the worst. I love you but, just the worst. Lynch me or don't. I've found scum and was happy again with this game until you came back
Putting down my phone
Wave's 1 actual read is a meta read that Obi is mafia and he literally refuses to play the game despite other people trying to push decent ideas on him.
In the last few pages Conversion made a decent case (I hate to admit) on TickTock that HF echoed and I really wish the lynch had gone in that direction. Wave's excuse for not voting him is his interactivity, but I think that a lot of his posts are seemingly rhetorical questions to get people to reiterate what they've already said in their posts.
I also agree with Conversion's suspicion of Shockey, fwiw. So maybe my fake murderer is JUST a troll and not actually mafia himself.
That said, I would expect a town GB lynch to include some mafia on the wagon SO we'll see.
On January 11 2021 02:51 WaveofShadow wrote: As for others, yams town, I hope jat/HF are town because it could still go either way. Town is certainly more likely at this point.
I'd look toward the people who just haven't done much tbh here, Shocckey, Slam, GB, it's all more or less a crapshoot. I agree that the wagon on me looks good because none of them have jumped on but I truly don['t think that's indicative here---partially because I know otherwise but partially because none of them have had to do much of anything. They haven't been forced to throw a vote or grilled in any way, so they haven't had to commit, which is I think more damning than bandwagoning at this point.
Oh also Conversion town. I hope
This post of Wave's I actually like. First one this game I like, and his reads are somewhat close to mine. I still don't think JAT is all that townie up to this point and I would be much less suspicious of GB but the rest of it is ok. His scumread of Obi, tho, is not something I really want to dissect. Seems like a huge waste of time. If Obi's mafia it's not because he made a weird post in a QT.
On January 11 2021 03:42 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 10 2021 12:46 GlowingBear wrote:On January 10 2021 12:38 Holyflare wrote: Not really, you shouldn't care about voting for a 3P who says his wincon involves getting removed from the game by arbitrary mechanics.
Very unlikely mafia makes that claim.
You can put it to the test by fulfilling his criteria each day (for instance making him the second biggest wagon and him voting the counter wagon should give him +3 and thus he will be removed from the game next cycle eod if we do it twice). You're right. ##vote Glowingbear
On January 11 2021 03:43 Holyflare wrote: Dude doesn't care what's happening.
On January 11 2021 03:43 justanothertownie wrote: I could get behind that too.
On January 11 2021 03:43 ObiWanShinobi wrote: I'm down. A literal 1 for 1 recreation of the earlier posting pattern that actually morphs into a real train on GB. I sort of have to believe there's mafia here, and right as of this moment it feels like JAT.
On January 11 2021 04:57 Tictock wrote: ##Vote: GlowingBear
I can consolidate on a null read.
Did people figure out Dandel is only showing in thread votes and it's not the real vote count? That was why my HF vote was not my focus kus it wasn't real Or maybe this is the mafia. Together with Vivax these are all the votes on GB I believe, and we can expect
On January 11 2021 05:12 ShoCkeyy wrote:LMFAO?? What does this even mean?... I knew GB wasn’t mafia, you’re the first to vote for him, then claim I’m mafia. You must be mafia with conversion. I would not be upset if Shockey dies. This likely also means that HF's "counterclaim" of Vivax was fake. Idk why he did this but at this point it's not nearly enough to make me suspicious of HF.
Most of N1's posting is largely irrelevant. Eversince's absence is concerning but not wholly damning. The tone of Eversince's posts is townish. Otherwise I see Shockey being mafia and TickTock analysis Dandel's role (which I think a mafia would really want to do)
That said, Dandel really needs to do something besides discuss his own game at this point. It is not material to the actual game we are playing now. Effectively, he removed himself from the lynch for a day and had some memey flavor. Ha ha. Time to find mafia.
I agree with general thread sentiment on TickTock and Shockey. I trust JAT much less than most people however. Wave is probably bad town. HF is probably town but if there's a sneaky mafia it's him. Conversion is probably town. Obi is town-ish for me but I strongly dislike how easily he sheeped onto GB.
I trust Vivax' claim. I don't think it's worth trying to lynch him for some time.
If I had to guess about Slam's alignment this game I would say town but really who knows. I think that's just about everyone in the game.
This read took me a little over an hour. I don't think I'll be around too long to respond to anything but this should be sufficient to explain my current thought processes and how I view the game going forward. I think there's a strong possibility that a good town cohesion forms from this post and we lynch the sus people. I don't really want to post this at night since mafia could easily choose to shoot me after this but they might already or Obi could have KP and wish to kill me SO here you go.
|
11589 Posts
To explain my thoughts on JAT in more detail:
He seems to be falling in line with thread sentiment a lot without much of his own apparent thought process.
His post-sheep work justifying a vote on Wave is unconvincing in particular. His lack of reasoning behind a GB vote is even more frustrating. I see him cite meta reasons at one point, a point of contention that I did not think was a driving factor behind the case on GB.
Right now my top 3 scumreads are Shockey, TickTock, and JAT, and the common denominator to me is how they acted around the GB vote. Shockey's voting makes no sense if he's town, and Ticktock/JAT sheeped a bit too willingly for my tastes.
|
11589 Posts
On January 10 2021 20:22 justanothertownie wrote: I would be interested in that reason right now. The conversion stuff also does not really convince me. The fakenuke on yamato was a decent choice for example. I also really, strongly dislike this line of reasoning. I said exactly why I believe otherwise already, and this reads like a fabricated reason to townread someone that you already know is town. I also believe he doesn't elaborate much on this point. Why is fakenuking me at that point in the game a pro-town move? If anything it sidetracked me at a point in time where I was actually interested in the game.
Later he posts this:
On January 11 2021 02:12 justanothertownie wrote: I obviously knew my nuke was a dud, which is also why I assume conversion knew that about his. I just didn't want Wave to be able to hide behind a claimed 3p. I also still think we should not lynch Vivax since his claim seemed genuine to me. If we are ever in doubt we can still kill him and if there are actual town KP he also wouldn't be a terrible shot but for now he is not a priority to me.
I agree in principle with his reasoning for faking a nuke on Vivax but I disagree with its equivalence to faking a nuke on me. I think JAT obviously had a similar role (maybe a copycat role, even, but that is idle speculation) and used his in a way he believes is pro town, but I do not think that he could really think that Conversion's nuke on me was pro town, especially given that he said it was a bad nuke if it was real. The difference is not that large in effect.
|
11589 Posts
ticktock why are you not mafia
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 17:58 Eversince wrote: If my ENTIRE ROLE DID NOTHING BUT SEW CHAOS I WOULDN'T FUCKING USE IT! Christ. I didn't mean to channel my inner Rayn. But if Dandel can steal the host I can steal somebody to RP that fits my mood enough I no longer RP. yeah but dandel would
|
11589 Posts
I was pretty sure from the start of the day that dandel's game was bs hf
|
11589 Posts
Why isn't town Wave smart enough to realize the same thing
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 22:21 Dandel Ion wrote: I don't really think Wave is mafia for that.
But that's because contrary to you I think he is a dick.
I don't even think it matters if he thought the game was real, he wanted it not to be and was willing to risk modkilling his entire squad for that selfish desire.
At least that was my take, didn't read d1 super closely. That would mean Wave didn't want to be mafia, an assertion I disagree with
|
11589 Posts
That certainly is A Take but I think it's simpler. I admit Wave could still be mafia but I don't think making a case that Wave is scum with Dandel for how he claimed mafia is the reason.
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 22:29 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2021 22:19 yamato77 wrote: I was pretty sure from the start of the day that dandel's game was bs hf You have literally no way to know that. Being smart is irrelevant. From a person's perspective it could easily be if hapa won we'd be in dandel's game. I mean, it looked like exactly what I said it was all along, and lo and behold I was right. There's a world where Wave began the day thinking not lynching Hapa was super important to make him not mafia and then realized that Dandel's game was a farce and decided to claim scum in it after telling his "scum buddies". None of that means he isn't town.
It does not require one to have extra knowledge to make this play. It's not a good case.
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 22:39 WaveofShadow wrote: I don't think we should be talking about me though I'll look into... Who, shockey? At work today so will be sporadic I agree this discussion feels like we're still talking about Dandel's role and I really want that thread of discussion to die immediately.
Shockey is absolutely mafia.
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 22:45 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2021 22:42 justanothertownie wrote:On January 11 2021 22:39 WaveofShadow wrote: I don't think we should be talking about me though I'll look into... Who, shockey? At work today so will be sporadic We should absolutely be talking about you. If you are mafia then the lynch yesterday is a lot more important than if you are town. Your alignment is a crucial piece of the puzzle. I mean not from my perspective. If we want to lynch Dandel I'm totally fine with that based on role alone, it seems pretty anti town, but I don't think there's anything else to learn from my perspective on the 'alignment change' despite the fact that hf thinks he nailed the scum team I'm way more inclined to listen to anything yamato has said than HF because so far everything hf has said has been completely wrong I think JAT is trying to associate between you and HF for how the lynch played out
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 22:47 WaveofShadow wrote: I also have very strong suspicion that Tictock is town, not in small part due to his 'trap' he set up in the QT for me, but I guess that could be marination, to borrow a term from among us
Though settings traps are overwhelmingly town mindset oriented I think your read on TickTock is shallower than "strong suspicion"
He really looks to me like someone trying to appear earnest but focusing on the absolute incorrect things
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 22:48 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2021 22:45 WaveofShadow wrote:On January 11 2021 22:42 justanothertownie wrote:On January 11 2021 22:39 WaveofShadow wrote: I don't think we should be talking about me though I'll look into... Who, shockey? At work today so will be sporadic We should absolutely be talking about you. If you are mafia then the lynch yesterday is a lot more important than if you are town. Your alignment is a crucial piece of the puzzle. I mean not from my perspective. If we want to lynch Dandel I'm totally fine with that based on role alone, it seems pretty anti town, but I don't think there's anything else to learn from my perspective on the 'alignment change' despite the fact that hf thinks he nailed the scum team I'm way more inclined to listen to anything yamato has said than HF because so far everything hf has said has been completely wrong What exactly have I said that's been wrong? If you are town then everyone that dodged your wagon and gave TMI is exactly who I called out? You want to look into Shockey, who I'm calling mafia. If you are town and you wanted to potentially ruin the game just so you wouldn't be a vanilla role (even though I am essentially a vanilla role in hapa's game) then I have absolutely 0 respect left for you. I choose to not believe that world. Man, you are putting too much stock into the Dandel game. I don't think Wave ever risked ruining the game with his play
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 22:49 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2021 22:48 yamato77 wrote:On January 11 2021 22:45 WaveofShadow wrote:On January 11 2021 22:42 justanothertownie wrote:On January 11 2021 22:39 WaveofShadow wrote: I don't think we should be talking about me though I'll look into... Who, shockey? At work today so will be sporadic We should absolutely be talking about you. If you are mafia then the lynch yesterday is a lot more important than if you are town. Your alignment is a crucial piece of the puzzle. I mean not from my perspective. If we want to lynch Dandel I'm totally fine with that based on role alone, it seems pretty anti town, but I don't think there's anything else to learn from my perspective on the 'alignment change' despite the fact that hf thinks he nailed the scum team I'm way more inclined to listen to anything yamato has said than HF because so far everything hf has said has been completely wrong I think JAT is trying to associate between you and HF for how the lynch played out Yeah, why wouldn't I? If Wave is scum there is a clear motivation in switching to GB. Pretty tinfoil on N1 if you ask me. Shockey/TickTock are much more likely mafia, not to mention Slam/Dandel/Obi who I would all lynch rn before digging into HF/Wave
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 22:52 justanothertownie wrote: I mean it doesn't necessarily have to be HF but I think it is quite obvious that Waves alignment is important when discussing our day1, yes? Yeah I have a flimsy townread on him because of his secondary reads post.
There's also the fact that he's one of the more central figures in the game and thus much less likely to be mafia overall than a tertiary player like Shockey/TickTock/Obi.
I get your point about his lynch not really taking off but I also think that D1 was such a mess that it doesn't necessarily have to mean that mafia were avoiding his wagon on purpose. That is, assuming you aren't mafia and joined on with me/hf
|
11589 Posts
I'm going to make my case on TT. I think everyone agrees Shockey is mafia and he basically claimed it so unless there's some crazy resistance to his lynch tomorrow (assuming he doesn't die tonight, town vig :wink wink: ) we should focus on finding the next lynch and I obviously think that should be TT
|
11589 Posts
The Case for TickTock
TickTock's opening posts were as the game began and thus not that meaningful. However:
On January 08 2021 16:48 Tictock wrote: I'm not sure where I am at with this game, my role is weird and my reads are weak.
I thin Yam is probably town for being to the point.
Vivax might have been role fishing with his opener.
I want to see where Dandel's stuff goes.
Oh and townfeels for Sho.
and bedtime for myself
His first reads post is pretty safe. Not obviously damning but it sets a precedent.
Next:
On January 10 2021 08:42 Tictock wrote: Ok, finally got done with back to back shifts. Sadly this game did not start when I had ample free time.
Dandle is 3rd party. His ability seems a little OP, but it seems like he just has a wincon to get happa lynched which would convenienly remove his slot by both lynch and wincon. So fairly anti-town if that's correct. My assumption right now is that if we done lynch Hapa things will return to normal, hopefully with night phase. In other words, not something I want to focus on for the day.
Vivax poses a bit of a conundrum though claiming he rolled me and was/is 3rd party. I would normally say there is no way we have 2 3P teams or w/e, but this is heavily theamed so maybe. His play does remind me of the game where he and Rayn were mafia though.
Conversion has made multiple "nuke" posts with wonky reasoning as to why he targets whoever he is. It's possible he is just RPing, but I kinda suspect he is just using that as a cover to not really enguage.
So if I had to pick right now I would lynch between Vivax/Conversion.
However I have only read through of 31 (or most of it) and will make an effort to finish reading tonight. I'm super tired though so I may pass out early to make sure I am up for EoD.
This begins TT's obsession with Dandel. He never shuts up about his role. Even right now he is making a post talking about how Dandel's role allowed mafia to reign free D1. He certainly would know, wouldn't he?
He also spends a lot of words on Vivax, who is actually claimed 3P. Why the focus on these claims he doesn't think make people mafia? Easy to look like you're scumhunting as scum.
After D1 begins, this is how he proceeds to "interact" with the thread:
On January 10 2021 11:02 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 10:13 Alakaslam wrote:On January 09 2021 10:11 yamato77 wrote:On January 09 2021 10:06 Alakaslam wrote:On January 09 2021 09:20 yamato77 wrote:On January 09 2021 09:18 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Why are people so convinced dandel is scum? I guess that's mostly slam but I don't get it. It definitely is all Slam and he hasn't given any reason afaik The reason is the whole shenanigan with replacing the host looks to me like a scum power The OP clearly says that roles have no correlation to alignment Still. What this is causing just looks like scum. You have to correlate roles to alignment! Are you gonna make scum a parity cop? I guess you could... Are you gonna make a townie godfather? Every townie that isn’t also a miller is a godfather! What makes you think this game has roles like that?
On January 10 2021 11:06 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On January 09 2021 21:42 Holyflare wrote:On January 09 2021 19:29 justanothertownie wrote: I think it is pretty clear that we cannot lynch Dandel today as per hapas post. I also don't think we should lynch Hapa as that is clearly dandels win condition regardless of his alignment and I don't see why we should hand that to him and waste a lynch. We should just treat this as a normal day as far as I am concerned. People that don't want to kill hapa rolled scum in Dandel's regime. Vote hapa and Jat is free win. Oh interesting, so you want Dandel's plan to succeed.
On January 10 2021 11:29 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On January 10 2021 00:02 WaveofShadow wrote: Because it's better to have my vote on that than nothing at the start of the day.
I honestly wouldn't have even minded rerolling scum but Dandel gave me you Why is putting your vote somewhere at the start important?
On January 10 2021 13:19 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On January 10 2021 01:35 WaveofShadow wrote: Haha what the hell there are 3 people voting Dandel right now? I mean I guess I'll join in to survive but so long as people understand it's a no lynch Did I miss something? Are you being attacked? Blink twice if you need help.
Like I said before, his interactions are extremely shallow. He's not pursuing reads, he's posting to post and appear as if he's trying to figure things out.
On January 10 2021 20:02 Tictock wrote: Well I responded to the HF stuff already I thought.
I don't trust HF to be honest. I have the sense he is playing his own game, and I question why he is wanting to lynch Hapa and push Dandel's agenda. He has made some good points, but that means little for his alignment.
I am more interested in lynching Conversion though. Mostly I just don't see him doing anything, but calling people mafia with weird or no reason and being upset. Like the majority of his posts feel like RP or are fairly meaningless (like the read based on hollow knight).
The RP is hurting the game, I am having a hard time telling who is just posting and who is RPing. Like Sho is throwing me through a loop with his posts kus I think he is RPing but he is already a low volume poster that this makes it impossible to get anything from most of his posts.
A bunch of people I feel I have no read on due to RP stuff.
I still think Yam is town, Jat is cutting through bullshit so feels town. Neither is really saying a lot though, and that makes it hard to know what the thinking behind some of their reads are (though atm it's possible I skimmed it missed stuff). A lot of these reads aren't particularly difficult to make nor are they particularly committal. In particular his "scumread" of Conversion is something that I think flies under the radar here. Conversion is the best lynch because he is calling people mafia and RPing, even though RPing makes Shockey impossible to read for TT? What kind of logic is that? I think so little focus has been on TT that this simply slipped through the cracks.
On January 10 2021 20:23 Tictock wrote: Oh almost forgot.
##Vote: Holyflare
Just covering my bases.
How is this ever his vote in this spot?
On January 10 2021 20:32 Tictock wrote: You think Conversion knew his nuke was gunna be fake?
Fair enough I suppose re Wave, a touch OMGUS though, and not something that convinces me since I am not very confident about either of being town.
There may be hints at the bad reason, my slightly better reason is that his wagon feels too easy. If somehow JAT/HF are right about Wave's alignment mattering a lot this post in particular feels important and is something I ACTUALLY think could be alignment indicative.
On January 11 2021 04:57 Tictock wrote: ##Vote: GlowingBear
I can consolidate on a null read.
Did people figure out Dandel is only showing in thread votes and it's not the real vote count? That was why my HF vote was not my focus kus it wasn't real This is his last post of the day. Real uninspiring sheep onto GB as I've pointed out before.
On January 11 2021 14:36 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2021 02:46 WaveofShadow wrote: SO y'all can take this with a few caveats. Some of this is not very strong reasoning, some of it I want to be true more than actually is. I will fully admit here to not being good at town. I'm good at looking very townie when I want to---this particular game I didn't feel like it for reasons stated earlier. What I'm not great at is scumhunting so again, y'all can take with a grain of salt.
Me Obi and unnamed thir dperson (for now) talking bak and forth a little. I warned them in advance I was going to scumclaim for the reasons I stated here---that I was increasingly disbelieving this was real especially due to my vanilla status. My scummates did not claim their roles or abilities to very much degree as I did.
At one point Obi (and I'll paraphrase here) said something along the lines of 'I hope this isn't real because if we're scum this game is going to suck,' which he admitted after he had edited. the word 'we're' used to be 'wave is.'
Basically he singled me out for some reason as it sucking going forward if I were really scum (n0) even though I scumclaimed, then fixing it because he realized it would suck equally as we're all in the same boat---but that edit reeks of some other information or way of thinking. The fact that he doesn't automatically think we're all in the same boat as being town n0 then 'turning into scum' with Dandel's D1 addition feels like s lip.
I will fully admit a great deal of the time scumslipping really isn't, but I'd look more at that weird mentality difference than what he said specifically.
There's other stuff. The softball questions that amount to nothing throughout the early game, refusing to take a stance or commit to much of anything.,
I will also admit part of me wants to be right because of something regarding Among Us---which HF can maybe vouch for if he was around? I think Conversion can. Yams can. It's very meta and I don't want to out my reasoning on this last one entirely because it ruins a read i have on him in that game so you can probably gnore this part lol Just to add my interpretation, though Waves description of what happened is accurate. I read Obis statement more like he thought Wave sucked as mafia and didn't want to play as scum with him, or that he was convinced Wave was going to be lynched so if our "team" turned real we would be a man down. He said as much in another post than what Wave was discussing here. From the rest of his messages though I see Obi wasn't sure if Dandel's stuff was or was not going to be perminant so that may have been part of it. Idk, I'm going to make a separate post of my thoughts about Dandel essentialy makng the three of us masons for a day. One more interesting thing though from that QT though, I dropped the idea that I had a way to save Wave from the lynch. Dandel's role for me did say it had something like that, not that I was ever going to use it, but wanted to see what Wave would say. He told me I shouldn't do it. Take that as you will. Wave, if this is your reason for thinking TT is town I am real disappoint.
On January 11 2021 15:29 Tictock wrote: To that end, I haven't fully decided what I think of Dandel's role and how he used it.
On the one hand he removed himself from the game and caused a fair bit of confusion. Both of which are fairly anti-town... Actually if he is town is it that bad to remove self as a target for a day? As a scum ability it actually would be pretty OP to force a mislynch.
The other hand is that it was ultimately all fluff and the game is now back to as normal as this game will be. So in that sense his ability was a ton of flavor but pretty weak.
The flavor was too notch though, besides the continued joke relating my name to TikToc. I was clearly here first and no silly video app should define me. I have also been using Tictock as a username since like 2010 so :p TT spends a LOT of posts N1 discussing Dandel's role.
On January 11 2021 15:36 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2021 04:44 ShoCkeyy wrote:On January 11 2021 04:42 justanothertownie wrote:On January 11 2021 04:41 ShoCkeyy wrote:On January 11 2021 04:38 justanothertownie wrote:On January 11 2021 04:36 ShoCkeyy wrote: ##vote Dandel Ion You are aware that the daypost states that we cannot lynch Dandel, yes? Yes, but why does he count others and not mine? Who cares? Why do you not want to lynch anyone? I care? And only other person I’m lynching today is conversion. I’ve already stated it like three-four times, are you reading? Uhh... I am pretty sure I was the only person to vote for conversion yesterday, this is laughable hypocritical-ness right here or just straight mafia. Probably mafia. Aside from what reads like a weak distancing attempt after everyone has already caught his scumbuddy.
He also spends quite a bit of time attempting to "help" Eversince catch up and nothing much comes of that conversation.
I think most of this is fairly strong evidence that TT is mafia. Also, in the previous game I played where TT was mafia, his posting felt initially very similar to how it does here, very safe and bland with little in the way of substantive reads. I certainly understand not having a lot of time to play and all but I am unconvinced that a town agenda exists within this filter, while I can certainly imagine a mafia TickTock making all of these posts.
|
11589 Posts
I could realistically see 2v2v9, a possibility HF discounts out of hand.
|
11589 Posts
HF I feel like one of us is soon to die.
|
11589 Posts
I think it's better for the game if you die and I can lead lynches from here on out but on a personal level I hope it's me
|
11589 Posts
Maybe JAT dies, I'd be kinda happy if that happens
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 23:40 Holyflare wrote: I can't die because then mafia will lose. lmao
|
11589 Posts
I'm really trying to WIFOM the NK as you can tell
|
11589 Posts
On January 11 2021 23:58 Dandel Ion wrote: Most of your case is that he focusses too much on me, doesn't have reads or push anything, but you're townreading eversince so it's hard to take you seriously on that front.
The rest is meta, which is fair enough i guess but i can't really do much with it.
I am actually cautiously unenthused. unlike eversince I think TT has been around a significant amount of time during important parts of the game
you're also ignoring his terrible sheep onto the GB lynch
|
11589 Posts
On January 12 2021 00:15 Dandel Ion wrote: true but you also need to factor in how much fun it is to lynch you a lot
|
11589 Posts
I regret wasting the start of this game being mad at Conversion
|
11589 Posts
A true comic genius and excellent scumhunter
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
I hope you all ignore this mess with the alternate QTs and play the game in this thread. I'm not in there and you all know I'm town
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
HF made the QTs and he says I should be in 3 QTs when I am only in 1
|
11589 Posts
He literally didn't believe I was town over this in a themed game
HF you outed yourself and Wave and me for this stupidity
|
11589 Posts
No we should kill Shockey
|
11589 Posts
Stay the course. Shockey is basically claimed scum. Just kill him. I'll evaluate everything else happening today when I get home from work.
|
11589 Posts
His N1 posting is essentially baby seal territory as far as I'm concerned
|
11589 Posts
I don't think I really need to convince you
|
11589 Posts
Your death is inevitable. I am basically confirmed town and everyone thinks you are scum.
|
11589 Posts
If by some chance you are actually town you should try harder to find mafia. Conversion is not it.
|
11589 Posts
On January 12 2021 11:05 WaveofShadow wrote: Why is obi not scum again? Bigger fish to fry Wave
It's majority lynch and Shockeyy's power might be more than he's letting on
|
11589 Posts
On January 12 2021 11:18 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On January 12 2021 11:13 yamato77 wrote:On January 12 2021 11:05 WaveofShadow wrote: Why is obi not scum again? Bigger fish to fry Wave It's majority lynch and Shockeyy's power might be more than he's letting on Oh god you did this last game I played with you and I got lynched and was town. Here you are doing the same exact thing again. Open your eyes mate. You did not get lynched in Greymist game
|
11589 Posts
If you're going to sit on those reads as you die please just stop posting
|
11589 Posts
On January 12 2021 11:43 WaveofShadow wrote: Ok but 4rlz
Explain like I'm some sort of bad player or something.
I'm fine to sheep I guess but I kinda feel a little bad for him here with how everyone is ganging up
What actually makes him scum If you need convincing I'll go through his filter but nobody likes my cases even though they r gud
|
11589 Posts
I mean it's going to take an act of God to get me to move off Shockey today tbh
|
11589 Posts
just practiced guitar for an hour and im too tired to make much of a case right now
we'll see after i wake up in the morning
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 03:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I can't wait for shockeyy to flip town despite the endless tunnel It will amuse me to no end he's not even reading the thread obviously so he can die and i won't care
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 03:48 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 03:47 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 03:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I can't wait for shockeyy to flip town despite the endless tunnel It will amuse me to no end he's not even reading the thread obviously so he can die and i won't care I've read and written more than you have. you've spammed a lot but you think i still think conversion is mafia so you're not reading
i also never said slam was mafia
you also didn't read the interaction between hf wave and myself
you're clearly not reading
|
11589 Posts
it's easy and lazy to just spam posts as mafia to shit up the thread
you're not contributing anything meaningful.
if you're actually town you need to try harder to find mafia and actually read the thread
right now you're just complaining because we think you're mafia which is just lazy
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 03:51 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 03:50 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 03:48 ShoCkeyy wrote:On January 13 2021 03:47 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 03:34 WaveofShadow wrote: I can't wait for shockeyy to flip town despite the endless tunnel It will amuse me to no end he's not even reading the thread obviously so he can die and i won't care I've read and written more than you have. you've spammed a lot but you think i still think conversion is mafia so you're not reading i also never said slam was mafia you also didn't read the interaction between hf wave and myself you're clearly not reading I'm finding yourself and HF to be more of a team than conversion and I've ready man. I've read. I can pull up any kind of info you want because I remember the whole thread. LMAO imagine thinking HF and myself are mafia
|
11589 Posts
If you're town and playing like this you need to die because you're just a liability at this point
I will not feel bad whatever you flip but obviously I think you are just lazy spammer mafia which fools people like Wave who think activity = towniness
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 03:57 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 03:54 yamato77 wrote: If you're town and playing like this you need to die because you're just a liability at this point
I will not feel bad whatever you flip but obviously I think you are just lazy spammer mafia which fools people like Wave who think activity = towniness I can be even lazier and not post at all. It'll fit into my role play. If your RP is to be terrible town please just die in silence
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 03:59 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 03:51 yamato77 wrote: it's easy and lazy to just spam posts as mafia to shit up the thread
you're not contributing anything meaningful.
if you're actually town you need to try harder to find mafia and actually read the thread
right now you're just complaining because we think you're mafia which is just lazy Your one big mega posts about me and tictock was one big shit post that also shitted up the thread cause its all nonsense conspiracy to frame tictock as mafia. I don't need to write five pages to make my point. he's next so please tell us why you think he's town so i can use it against him tomorrow
|
11589 Posts
Maybe he's roleplaying as Trump
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
I don't think a jester would have that ability
also jester is a terrible role and would be a 3rd 3p
I choose to believe he's just terrible
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 04:39 WaveofShadow wrote:I mean that's probably not a very good roleplay But would be hilarious nonetheless I feel like I should note here I'm not rping because I have no idea how to do it Take that as you will Yams I assume you haven't been either maybe i should... :thinking:
|
11589 Posts
whoever it is he needs to die
we are not moving from this lynch
|
11589 Posts
bro how the fuck is shockey a bad vote
you're mindgaming yourselves
he is mafia
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
the only other good vote today is TickTock
Remember, Wave protected me from mafia KP and I was on them
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 05:42 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 05:41 yamato77 wrote: bro how the fuck is shockey a bad vote
you're mindgaming yourselves
he is mafia So your stance is he is just fucking with us? And martyring through his ability but not in the thread? He is doubtlessly fucking with us, that much is so obvious it is without question
I don't know why he chose to use his ability, but it makes it super imperative we actually vote him so that his extra votes dont cause a mislynch from a bunch of split votes
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 05:44 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 05:42 yamato77 wrote: the only other good vote today is TickTock
Remember, Wave protected me from mafia KP and I was on them Devils advocate, not only are we not absolutely sure I protected you (though I probably did) you were screaming town so you were more likely shot at because of that, not necessarily because you're right. I'm still ok to follow you where you want to be, but I'm in the mood.to be a little critical Why shoot me over like HF for instance, he was also obviously town and people listen to him
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 05:47 yamato77 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 05:44 WaveofShadow wrote:On January 13 2021 05:42 yamato77 wrote: the only other good vote today is TickTock
Remember, Wave protected me from mafia KP and I was on them Devils advocate, not only are we not absolutely sure I protected you (though I probably did) you were screaming town so you were more likely shot at because of that, not necessarily because you're right. I'm still ok to follow you where you want to be, but I'm in the mood.to be a little critical Why shoot me over like HF for instance, he was also obviously town and people listen to him I did WIFOM the NK a lot tho so who cares really
point is they are also like actually mafia
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 05:55 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 05:47 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 05:44 WaveofShadow wrote:On January 13 2021 05:42 yamato77 wrote: the only other good vote today is TickTock
Remember, Wave protected me from mafia KP and I was on them Devils advocate, not only are we not absolutely sure I protected you (though I probably did) you were screaming town so you were more likely shot at because of that, not necessarily because you're right. I'm still ok to follow you where you want to be, but I'm in the mood.to be a little critical Why shoot me over like HF for instance, he was also obviously town and people listen to him Nah HF by virtue of being hf is always a little sneaky or untrustworthy unfortunately. And I don't think he was as obvious town. Why is his fucking with the votes a danger here? If we split votes too much Shockey's vote counts for 3 and he can sway a lynch
This town is too dumb to consolidate rn it seems
Really he is the best lynch by FAR
|
11589 Posts
I don't think it's worth my time to actually read your posts
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 00:13 Tictock wrote: Slam how exactly do you detect KP? I don't need your full role claim, I just want to know more details about what you are detecting. Did Dandel use KP? Or is it he has access to KP? Does the KP have to be a role ability or would it detect factional KP?
HF, you tried putting Ever, Jat, and Yam into a QT and you did some kind of action on Sho? I see a lot of this in TickTock's filter but I really don't think he comes to a lot of conclusions
Like I said I think he wants to appear interested but he stops short of the point of having convincing ideas in his posts.
|
11589 Posts
Also I'm reading back a bit and I really think Slam is town for the way he claimed and went after Dandel
I don't think Dandel "having KP" means he's mafia though.
|
11589 Posts
I literally only think Obi is town right now because he's willing to vote Shockey
|
11589 Posts
I don't think Dandel is mafia and I'm not particularly concerned with him "having KP" if there were no night kills last night.
Just simply not something worth lynching someone over right now. It's a damn themed game who knows what is going on there
|
11589 Posts
Vivax' filter is exactly why I don't like basically pure survivor roles, he's not trying and there's so little incentive to lynch him. Not a good dynamic for town to have to deal with, especially in a heavily themed game
|
11589 Posts
Man GB's lynch was so bad for town lmao, that role could have solved some problems!
|
11589 Posts
Stay the course on Shockey, lynch TickTock tomorrow, hopefully I am dead at some point so I don't have to figure this game out later.
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 06:35 WaveofShadow wrote: 9-3-1 or 9-2-2? Are those the only options that make sense? I'm thinking about something I don't see much of a point in speculating on the setup tbh.
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 06:41 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 06:35 yamato77 wrote: I don't think Dandel is mafia and I'm not particularly concerned with him "having KP" if there were no night kills last night.
Just simply not something worth lynching someone over right now. It's a damn themed game who knows what is going on there Do you have an alternative? Slam's check could have been messed with, or Dandel could be some sort of weird SK/Arsonist (a possibility, but what the fuck is this role?), or Slam could actually be mafia with a power that hunts 3P and is lying about the KP.
I'm really just choosing to believe the first option right now. Even if it's #2 Dandel is helping town more than Shockey, and the risk of not voting Shockey is too high I believe.
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 09:37 Holyflare wrote: I feel like a mafia power does not entail giving them 2 extra votes but receiving 3x as many from everyone that votes them. That is jester 101. I definitely can see it as a mafia power. If he used it on a day where he wasn't highly likely to be voted/lynched and didn't vote until late in the day it's a hilariously strong power and town would be very confused about what happened.
If anything, the power makes the MOST sense as a power. The drawback is obviously that it's incredibly easy to lynch him. His power would be ridiculously OP as jester and it's frustrating that you're being blinded by his role usage when he's otherwise so obviously mafia.
|
11589 Posts
EBWOP the power makes the MOST sense as a mafia***
|
11589 Posts
I truly think jester is a terrible role that would not be in this game
|
11589 Posts
Jester and useless survivor is such a handicap to town
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 15:42 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 15:31 yamato77 wrote: Jester and useless survivor is such a handicap to town Considering zero NKs so far we might not even be dealing with mafia but with a cult. „we“ I mean Or Wave actually protected me
which is like the simplest explanation
KISS
|
11589 Posts
imagine a game where i am the sanest player
this is sad really
|
11589 Posts
we should not lynch Dandel that's absurd
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 18:43 justanothertownie wrote: He is red checked and at worst we lynch a 3P. What is absurd about that? "having KP" is not a redcheck
did you read anything I posted on this topic
I am not going over it again
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 18:46 justanothertownie wrote: In all likelihood they are both mafia. I think that is exceedingly unlikely
Dandel actually appears to be thinking about the game for one
Not to mention all the scummiest people in the game are willing to lynch him so easily
This feels like a terrible lynch choice to avoid actually lynching mafia
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 18:57 justanothertownie wrote: Look, lynching Shockey will be easy today given his ability and you seem to be hellbent on it anyways. It doesn't hurt to get a wagon on dandel going for now and see what happens. It literally does hurt because of the amount of players who are relatively inattentive and don't explain their reads at all. I also don't want to waste a whole entire other day trying to lynch Shockey again.
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 19:24 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 16:17 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 15:42 Vivax wrote:On January 13 2021 15:31 yamato77 wrote: Jester and useless survivor is such a handicap to town Considering zero NKs so far we might not even be dealing with mafia but with a cult. „we“ I mean Or Wave actually protected me which is like the simplest explanation KISS It doesn't matter if he did, if the wording for the heal in the QT is "protects from 1kp damage" then it's almost certain this is an hp game. These speculations about the setup are so pointless
1kp means if you get shot twice you still die, why does it have to mean there is hp?
do you have hp? I have seen literally nothing that makes me think there is hp
so dumb
|
11589 Posts
you guys are making this game way harder than it has to be
|
11589 Posts
The role and usage also make no sense for town really
What kind of town ability gives you extra votes but guarantees that mafia can get you to majority by themselves
|
11589 Posts
Also what townie comes into today thinking it's a good time to make sure they get lynched
|
11589 Posts
Really just reeks of desperate mafia trying to wiggle his way out of dying
Fits with how he's played today, being a shithead and only arguing with people who think he is mafia
Literally, I have to see him flip red today or I will not be able to continue this game in any sane state of mind
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 19:30 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 19:29 yamato77 wrote: The role and usage also make no sense for town really
What kind of town ability gives you extra votes but guarantees that mafia can get you to majority by themselves Fair. But it is not very helpful as mafia either. But it is! Mafia getting extra votes is so good. How can you not see that?
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 19:32 Holyflare wrote: I don't like how invested yamato is in solely eliminating shockey. i don't like that you and JAT would rather play a mechanics game rather than rely on your damn READS
WHO READS LIKE MAFIA, HF?
|
11589 Posts
Also I've said I want to kill TickTock also but only Conversion seems to be on my side there
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 19:34 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 19:31 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 19:30 justanothertownie wrote:On January 13 2021 19:29 yamato77 wrote: The role and usage also make no sense for town really
What kind of town ability gives you extra votes but guarantees that mafia can get you to majority by themselves Fair. But it is not very helpful as mafia either. But it is! Mafia getting extra votes is so good. How can you not see that? Sure, but mafia also does not want to get lynched, right? This makes it highly likely to get lynched. I would say the role is not really helpful to any alignment. It depends on game state obviously. The writing was on the wall for him today, clearly, so he just used it because he figured he was going to die anyway
If he were not so likely to get lynched, using this ability and then voting late in the day to hide his voting strength is a strong mafia move that could literally sway a lynch and confuse the shit out of town
I made this point already though
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 19:34 Holyflare wrote: I've already said who reads like mafia and I'm voting one of them. Even if shockey is mafia I wouldn't put it past this game to habe some bs mechanic for being voted out with how that power works.
Imagine not talking about mechanics in a themed game though. Idk how you think Dandel is scummier than Shockey
You are putting more weight in an unconfirmed check of dubious validity than the obvious mafia.
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 19:37 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 19:35 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 19:34 justanothertownie wrote:On January 13 2021 19:31 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 19:30 justanothertownie wrote:On January 13 2021 19:29 yamato77 wrote: The role and usage also make no sense for town really
What kind of town ability gives you extra votes but guarantees that mafia can get you to majority by themselves Fair. But it is not very helpful as mafia either. But it is! Mafia getting extra votes is so good. How can you not see that? Sure, but mafia also does not want to get lynched, right? This makes it highly likely to get lynched. I would say the role is not really helpful to any alignment. It depends on game state obviously. The writing was on the wall for him today, clearly, so he just used it because he figured he was going to die anyway If he were not so likely to get lynched, using this ability and then voting late in the day to hide his voting strength is a strong mafia move that could literally sway a lynch and confuse the shit out of town I made this point already though Ok, that is true. Would be really idiotic to use it today then though. He's going to die anyway if people can ACTUALLY CONSOLIDATE VOTES IN A MAJORITY LYNCH GAME INSTEAD OF PLAYING LIKE MORONS WITH LATE CYCLE WAGONS
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 19:39 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 19:35 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 19:34 justanothertownie wrote:On January 13 2021 19:31 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 19:30 justanothertownie wrote:On January 13 2021 19:29 yamato77 wrote: The role and usage also make no sense for town really
What kind of town ability gives you extra votes but guarantees that mafia can get you to majority by themselves Fair. But it is not very helpful as mafia either. But it is! Mafia getting extra votes is so good. How can you not see that? Sure, but mafia also does not want to get lynched, right? This makes it highly likely to get lynched. I would say the role is not really helpful to any alignment. It depends on game state obviously. The writing was on the wall for him today, clearly, so he just used it because he figured he was going to die anyway If he were not so likely to get lynched, using this ability and then voting late in the day to hide his voting strength is a strong mafia move that could literally sway a lynch and confuse the shit out of town I made this point already though Sounds really dumb to me. It would be almost trivial to see shockey joining a wagon and then 2 votes miraculously appearing. Unless you're saying he could activate it while already being on a wagon but then any shenanigan fucks him totally. Sounds bad. You're assuming there are votecounts between every vote, which is almost never the case
Are you really even thinking with your brain
|
11589 Posts
On January 13 2021 19:42 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 19:41 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 19:39 Holyflare wrote:On January 13 2021 19:35 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 19:34 justanothertownie wrote:On January 13 2021 19:31 yamato77 wrote:On January 13 2021 19:30 justanothertownie wrote:On January 13 2021 19:29 yamato77 wrote: The role and usage also make no sense for town really
What kind of town ability gives you extra votes but guarantees that mafia can get you to majority by themselves Fair. But it is not very helpful as mafia either. But it is! Mafia getting extra votes is so good. How can you not see that? Sure, but mafia also does not want to get lynched, right? This makes it highly likely to get lynched. I would say the role is not really helpful to any alignment. It depends on game state obviously. The writing was on the wall for him today, clearly, so he just used it because he figured he was going to die anyway If he were not so likely to get lynched, using this ability and then voting late in the day to hide his voting strength is a strong mafia move that could literally sway a lynch and confuse the shit out of town I made this point already though Sounds really dumb to me. It would be almost trivial to see shockey joining a wagon and then 2 votes miraculously appearing. Unless you're saying he could activate it while already being on a wagon but then any shenanigan fucks him totally. Sounds bad. You're assuming there are votecounts between every vote, which is almost never the case Are you really even thinking with your brain Ah yes better make a mechanic that relies on lazy hosting at deadline. Do you even read the words you write? alright im out for now this is too dumb
|
11589 Posts
maybe the power to choose a lynch counts as kp in some way
|
11589 Posts
i dont know the wording of Slam's role/ability
dandel might have had access to kp at some point i do believe but i dont think he's an sk
|
11589 Posts
dandel/conversion, will you switch to shockey so we have 6
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 02:55 ghostofconversion wrote: why are we lynching dandel again?
b/c slam claimed he has kp? that's it? that's the whole reason
it's really dumb
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 02:55 Holyflare wrote: Vivax tomorrow you need to duel someone or die btw we are not lynching Vivax tomorrow
|
11589 Posts
i told her to sheep me conversion
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 02:59 ghostofconversion wrote:Show nested quote +On January 14 2021 02:57 Holyflare wrote:On January 14 2021 02:57 ghostofconversion wrote:On January 14 2021 02:55 Holyflare wrote: Why are we lynching the innocent child shockey? why arent we lynching tocktic? or u know, eversince who afked all game and pretended she didnt know what deadlines were I'm fine killing tt don't mind switching. ok lets all do a deep breath and get rid of tt then why dont you want to lynch shockey
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 03:08 ghostofconversion wrote: ok so shockeyy is innocent child so we aer not lynching him? so that means we blindly kill someone who has kp in a themed game where a lot of people can have kp, instead of someone like toctick?
wtf is this game lol shockey is not an innocent child holyflare is just being an asshole
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 03:11 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On January 13 2021 18:12 yamato77 wrote: imagine a game where i am the sanest player
this is sad really lol Back to talking about the game, I read somewhere that shockeyy is an IC? I'm going back to look for it and can't find it. HE'S NOT HOLYFLARE IS TROLLING
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 03:13 justanothertownie wrote: It is impressive how easy it is for HF to cause utter confusion. A reason for this is probably that almost noone in this game is actually following the thread. no shit
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 04:47 ShoCkeyy wrote: Of course tho, lynch the more active player. Never fails on these mafia forums. if you're town you have no one else to blame
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 04:54 ShoCkeyy wrote:I already did, I’m town, but I can just multiply my vote by 1, 2, or 3, it also multiplies if you’re voting for me. I asked that today my vote was multiplied by 3 :| you're a moron if you are town and used that today when i said all night i wanted to lynch you
|
11589 Posts
what a truly awful player
|
11589 Posts
I now want to lynch Holyflare and I will only post about it until i die
|
11589 Posts
dont protect hf
i'm gonna shoot him tonight
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 06:51 WaveofShadow wrote: I still think obi scum I will tunnel him until the end of tiiiiiiiiiiiiiii obi is probably mafia
in all realness obi/tt/eversince/vivax/dandle should all die
|
11589 Posts
wave it's your turn we can lynch obi
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 09:29 WaveofShadow wrote:Show nested quote +On January 14 2021 08:43 Tictock wrote:On January 14 2021 05:08 yamato77 wrote: I now want to lynch Holyflare and I will only post about it until i die Lol, I could support this. In other news breakfast was an amazingly tasty bagle sandwich which has shown me the beauty of simple things. I will try and take it's message forward and minimize my trash talking. See sandwiches may not be complicated but they don't need to be, you just gotta learn to appreciate then for what they are. Now to drink my coffee and reck some nerds! See this, I like. ????????????????????????
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 09:36 WaveofShadow wrote: If somebody wants to try to coordinate some shenanigans with my ability let me know, otherwise I'll do something.
Ps scum I'm probably a good target tonight cause I'm confirmed and won't be getting protection dont use it on HF
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 09:44 Holyflare wrote: For real though, I'm town, I've got big plans. Prot me or do whatever but just make sure I survive and I'll start churning out cases.
I think eversince was quite generous and nice inviting me to the QT. Don't think she'd be that bold as mafia to give me some random stuff. Maybe she would, idk, it was her idea to do it and Yamato kinda poo-pood it and made sure that I wasn't saved n1. He's making silly comments like "es go tell mafia qt to shoot hf" and stuff like that so he's just a troll at best and mafia at worst.
I don't think the QT has been too egregious to call either of them mafia tbh and yamato told es to sheep on shockey because she didn't really have time (a recurring theme in the QT). Could they be mafia? probably... but there's a long list of worse people I'd think I was the one who wanted to jail you N1
She said watch over jail
|
11589 Posts
been a less than fun game for me obviously
maybe i'll get back into it in a couple days
|
11589 Posts
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 10:21 ghostofconversion wrote: what gives hf prot? WIFOM
|
11589 Posts
TT we know you think Dandel is mafia
what's your read on Obi/Eversince
|
11589 Posts
On January 14 2021 15:38 Tictock wrote: I kinda just gave my read on Obi, and I honestly find it touching how the entire game kinda gave Ever several phases of space out of sympathy for her work. Though it was of course only a matter of time till the lower hanging fruit were knocked down.
I find Ever's post extremely honest in tone and she kinda distrusted Dandel heavily at the start so am inclined to leave her be. not much of a read there on obi
you also draw no conclusions
do you think he's mafia?
|
11589 Posts
I truly doubt Conversion is mafia
|
11589 Posts
I think wave is probably going to die so if people do that i support it
|
11589 Posts
My only regret is that I wasn't around much for D1, but there wasn't much I could do about that so whatever.
|
11589 Posts
Town overall played quite poorly outside of night actions.
Mafia played really well in almost all aspects of the game, and they still could have lost if the final day hadn't gone exactly as it did. Conversion easily could have nuked TT, town could have lynched Dandel, and the game would have come down to JAT attempting to solo against a lot of powerful town roles and at least a few people still trying to make sense of the game.
That's why the game is town favored. The events of this game do not reflect the balance of the setup very well because of how the last 2 days played out. Many people made mistakes, myself obviously included. I am not particularly interested in the minutiae. I will say though, there was a lot of self-fulfilling prophecy this game.
|
|
|
|