|
On September 18 2020 04:52 Number 4 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 04:30 Monadel wrote:On September 18 2020 04:19 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Okay so much for the confusion, just google number four + klaus + ben. I had my laughs :D
Let's play mafia. Monadel do you think anything sticks out as fishy atm? No I don't. I think what Glowingbear is saying is an unescessary over explanation on "the cop should claim" but I dont think it makes him mafia Why? Actually I agree. The cop gets n0 check then they need do claim.. 5v2 we get a red check for the cop is a good trade. I think cop shouldn't claim until d2 though. Rayn why push for a cop claim n0?
To be fair I like the idea of having cop claiming n0 so the doctor knows who to protect.
It either forces mafia to fakeclaim or doctor hunt. They will have 25% chance of hitting doctor while we guarantee we have a cop with a check day1.
The problem is when we don't have a clear claim and the doctor can't find out who the cop is because they "assume" it's someone else. This only helps mafia.
|
On September 18 2020 04:58 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 04:42 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:31 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:13 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:10 Number 4 wrote:
Detective Glowing Bear, I present myself ready for duty to destroy the mafia guys.
You might call me Number 4 from now on. Wait, Copcake? I am eversince. And I'm inevitable Good! Now tell me sme of your reads? ^^ Rayn mafia Damdy meh You and CopCake detectives forever. Who can it be now? Monadel newbie on the forums, may be a bit intimidated to post more, but for now meh. Still waiting Vivax to own the game once more
I don't think m!Ryan here.
Care to talk about it?
-ES
|
On September 18 2020 05:02 Number 4 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 04:58 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:42 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:31 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:13 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:10 Number 4 wrote:
Detective Glowing Bear, I present myself ready for duty to destroy the mafia guys.
You might call me Number 4 from now on. Wait, Copcake? I am eversince. And I'm inevitable Good! Now tell me sme of your reads? ^^ Rayn mafia Damdy meh You and CopCake detectives forever. Who can it be now? Monadel newbie on the forums, may be a bit intimidated to post more, but for now meh. Still waiting Vivax to own the game once more I don't think m!Ryan here. Care to talk about it? -ES
Sure, Ben!
I don't like his opening while forcing people to say if they're the cop or not. Just ask for the cop to claim and move on?
Also, if I got it right (I might have interpreted it wrong) if I said I was the cop he could think I was mafia fakeclaiming. If he thinks cop claiming is 100% the best option for town, why would I be mafia fakeclaiming?
|
Then why rayn?
I don't understand why mafia pushes same? The cop or doc dies. We have checks and 3 confirm town? Or am I dense?
|
On September 18 2020 05:02 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 04:52 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:30 Monadel wrote:On September 18 2020 04:19 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Okay so much for the confusion, just google number four + klaus + ben. I had my laughs :D
Let's play mafia. Monadel do you think anything sticks out as fishy atm? No I don't. I think what Glowingbear is saying is an unescessary over explanation on "the cop should claim" but I dont think it makes him mafia Why? Actually I agree. The cop gets n0 check then they need do claim.. 5v2 we get a red check for the cop is a good trade. I think cop shouldn't claim until d2 though. Rayn why push for a cop claim n0? To be fair I like the idea of having cop claiming n0 so the doctor knows who to protect. It either forces mafia to fakeclaim or doctor hunt. They will have 25% chance of hitting doctor while we guarantee we have a cop with a check day1. The problem is when we don't have a clear claim and the doctor can't find out who the cop is because they "assume" it's someone else. This only helps mafia.
Then what is the problem with Rayn’s plan?
Explain to me like if I was 3 years old.
- Cop Klaus
|
Its better for town that mafia has a 25% chance to hit a PR than a 40% chance
|
On September 18 2020 05:05 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:02 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:58 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:42 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:31 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:13 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:10 Number 4 wrote:
Detective Glowing Bear, I present myself ready for duty to destroy the mafia guys.
You might call me Number 4 from now on. Wait, Copcake? I am eversince. And I'm inevitable Good! Now tell me sme of your reads? ^^ Rayn mafia Damdy meh You and CopCake detectives forever. Who can it be now? Monadel newbie on the forums, may be a bit intimidated to post more, but for now meh. Still waiting Vivax to own the game once more I don't think m!Ryan here. Care to talk about it? -ES Sure, Ben! I don't like his opening while forcing people to say if they're the cop or not. Just ask for the cop to claim and move on? Also, if I got it right (I might have interpreted it wrong) if I said I was the cop he could think I was mafia fakeclaiming. If he thinks cop claiming is 100% the best option for town, why would I be mafia fakeclaiming?
Mafia can't fake claim n0? That's suicide. Oh you claim n0? We lynch into the two.
-ES
|
On September 18 2020 05:09 Monadel wrote:
Its better for town that mafia has a 25% chance to hit a PR than a 40% chance
How do you come to those numbers?
|
On September 18 2020 05:02 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 04:52 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:30 Monadel wrote:On September 18 2020 04:19 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Okay so much for the confusion, just google number four + klaus + ben. I had my laughs :D
Let's play mafia. Monadel do you think anything sticks out as fishy atm? No I don't. I think what Glowingbear is saying is an unescessary over explanation on "the cop should claim" but I dont think it makes him mafia Why? Actually I agree. The cop gets n0 check then they need do claim.. 5v2 we get a red check for the cop is a good trade. I think cop shouldn't claim until d2 though. Rayn why push for a cop claim n0? To be fair I like the idea of having cop claiming n0 so the doctor knows who to protect. It either forces mafia to fakeclaim or doctor hunt. They will have 25% chance of hitting doctor while we guarantee we have a cop with a check day1. The problem is when we don't have a clear claim and the doctor can't find out who the cop is because they "assume" it's someone else. This only helps mafia.
I was about to ask for more reasons why cop should claim N0, but I guess, it just needs to be done, and I really prefer town winning if that's the case here. I really want to trust Rayn and yourself GB for this claim, and really hope that I'm doing the right thing by doing so.
Hi. I'm finally a blue role (cop here [not copcake]) in one of Hapa's games. Who should I check on my N0 action? I was thinking of Monadel since he's new or Number4 since it's a hydra role.
|
On September 18 2020 05:10 Number 4 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 05:02 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:58 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:42 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:31 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:13 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:10 Number 4 wrote:
Detective Glowing Bear, I present myself ready for duty to destroy the mafia guys.
You might call me Number 4 from now on. Wait, Copcake? I am eversince. And I'm inevitable Good! Now tell me sme of your reads? ^^ Rayn mafia Damdy meh You and CopCake detectives forever. Who can it be now? Monadel newbie on the forums, may be a bit intimidated to post more, but for now meh. Still waiting Vivax to own the game once more I don't think m!Ryan here. Care to talk about it? -ES Sure, Ben! I don't like his opening while forcing people to say if they're the cop or not. Just ask for the cop to claim and move on? Also, if I got it right (I might have interpreted it wrong) if I said I was the cop he could think I was mafia fakeclaiming. If he thinks cop claiming is 100% the best option for town, why would I be mafia fakeclaiming? Mafia can't fake claim n0? That's suicide. Oh you claim n0? We lynch into the two. -ES
no its not.
|
On September 18 2020 05:10 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:02 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:52 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:30 Monadel wrote:On September 18 2020 04:19 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Okay so much for the confusion, just google number four + klaus + ben. I had my laughs :D
Let's play mafia. Monadel do you think anything sticks out as fishy atm? No I don't. I think what Glowingbear is saying is an unescessary over explanation on "the cop should claim" but I dont think it makes him mafia Why? Actually I agree. The cop gets n0 check then they need do claim.. 5v2 we get a red check for the cop is a good trade. I think cop shouldn't claim until d2 though. Rayn why push for a cop claim n0? To be fair I like the idea of having cop claiming n0 so the doctor knows who to protect. It either forces mafia to fakeclaim or doctor hunt. They will have 25% chance of hitting doctor while we guarantee we have a cop with a check day1. The problem is when we don't have a clear claim and the doctor can't find out who the cop is because they "assume" it's someone else. This only helps mafia. I was about to ask for more reasons why cop should claim N0, but I guess, it just needs to be done, and I really prefer town winning if that's the case here. I really want to trust Rayn and yourself GB for this claim, and really hope that I'm doing the right thing by doing so. Hi. I'm finally a blue role (cop here [not copcake]) in one of Hapa's games. Who should I check on my N0 action? I was thinking of Monadel since he's new or Number4 since it's a hydra role.
You check whoever you want to and shut up for the rest of the night unless there is a counter claim.
|
doctor on shockeyy no questions asked unless CC
|
On September 18 2020 05:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:09 Monadel wrote:
Its better for town that mafia has a 25% chance to hit a PR than a 40% chance How do you come to those numbers?
2/5
If no one claims then they have around 40% chance of hitting a power role
|
On September 18 2020 05:11 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:10 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 05:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 05:02 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:58 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:42 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:31 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:13 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:10 Number 4 wrote:
Detective Glowing Bear, I present myself ready for duty to destroy the mafia guys.
You might call me Number 4 from now on. Wait, Copcake? I am eversince. And I'm inevitable Good! Now tell me sme of your reads? ^^ Rayn mafia Damdy meh You and CopCake detectives forever. Who can it be now? Monadel newbie on the forums, may be a bit intimidated to post more, but for now meh. Still waiting Vivax to own the game once more I don't think m!Ryan here. Care to talk about it? -ES Sure, Ben! I don't like his opening while forcing people to say if they're the cop or not. Just ask for the cop to claim and move on? Also, if I got it right (I might have interpreted it wrong) if I said I was the cop he could think I was mafia fakeclaiming. If he thinks cop claiming is 100% the best option for town, why would I be mafia fakeclaiming? Mafia can't fake claim n0? That's suicide. Oh you claim n0? We lynch into the two. -ES no its not.
Claim cop. See flip. Lynch who's wrong? Or am I being stupid? If mafia fake claims and doc saves cop and we have green flip then I'm 100% sure that makes them scum.
|
On September 18 2020 05:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:09 Monadel wrote:
Its better for town that mafia has a 25% chance to hit a PR than a 40% chance How do you come to those numbers?
With a claimed cop theres 1 doc in 4 town. With an unclaimed cop there's 2 PRs in 5 town. This is assuming that the doc protects the cop
|
On September 18 2020 05:10 Number 4 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 05:02 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:58 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:42 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:31 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:13 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:10 Number 4 wrote:
Detective Glowing Bear, I present myself ready for duty to destroy the mafia guys.
You might call me Number 4 from now on. Wait, Copcake? I am eversince. And I'm inevitable Good! Now tell me sme of your reads? ^^ Rayn mafia Damdy meh You and CopCake detectives forever. Who can it be now? Monadel newbie on the forums, may be a bit intimidated to post more, but for now meh. Still waiting Vivax to own the game once more I don't think m!Ryan here. Care to talk about it? -ES Sure, Ben! I don't like his opening while forcing people to say if they're the cop or not. Just ask for the cop to claim and move on? Also, if I got it right (I might have interpreted it wrong) if I said I was the cop he could think I was mafia fakeclaiming. If he thinks cop claiming is 100% the best option for town, why would I be mafia fakeclaiming? Mafia can't fake claim n0? That's suicide. Oh you claim n0? We lynch into the two. -ES
It's not that mafia can't fakeclaim, it's that if he believes the cop should claim and with his question I immediately claim, why would he even foster the possibility of me being mafia for my answer?
|
On September 18 2020 05:16 Number 4 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:11 raynpelikoneet wrote:On September 18 2020 05:10 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 05:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 05:02 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:58 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:42 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:31 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:13 GlowingBear wrote:
[quote]
Wait, Copcake? I am eversince. And I'm inevitable Good! Now tell me sme of your reads? ^^ Rayn mafia Damdy meh You and CopCake detectives forever. Who can it be now? Monadel newbie on the forums, may be a bit intimidated to post more, but for now meh. Still waiting Vivax to own the game once more I don't think m!Ryan here. Care to talk about it? -ES Sure, Ben! I don't like his opening while forcing people to say if they're the cop or not. Just ask for the cop to claim and move on? Also, if I got it right (I might have interpreted it wrong) if I said I was the cop he could think I was mafia fakeclaiming. If he thinks cop claiming is 100% the best option for town, why would I be mafia fakeclaiming? Mafia can't fake claim n0? That's suicide. Oh you claim n0? We lynch into the two. -ES no its not. Claim cop. See flip. Lynch who's wrong? Or am I being stupid? If mafia fake claims and doc saves cop and we have green flip then I'm 100% sure that makes them scum.
Because if the cop survives long enough there would be around 4 confirmed townies by day2. That's why they always have to claim.
|
On September 18 2020 05:18 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On September 18 2020 05:16 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 05:11 raynpelikoneet wrote:On September 18 2020 05:10 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 05:05 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 05:02 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:58 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:42 Number 4 wrote:On September 18 2020 04:31 GlowingBear wrote:On September 18 2020 04:16 Number 4 wrote:
[quote]
I am eversince. And I'm inevitable Good! Now tell me sme of your reads? ^^ Rayn mafia Damdy meh You and CopCake detectives forever. Who can it be now? Monadel newbie on the forums, may be a bit intimidated to post more, but for now meh. Still waiting Vivax to own the game once more I don't think m!Ryan here. Care to talk about it? -ES Sure, Ben! I don't like his opening while forcing people to say if they're the cop or not. Just ask for the cop to claim and move on? Also, if I got it right (I might have interpreted it wrong) if I said I was the cop he could think I was mafia fakeclaiming. If he thinks cop claiming is 100% the best option for town, why would I be mafia fakeclaiming? Mafia can't fake claim n0? That's suicide. Oh you claim n0? We lynch into the two. -ES no its not. Claim cop. See flip. Lynch who's wrong? Or am I being stupid? If mafia fake claims and doc saves cop and we have green flip then I'm 100% sure that makes them scum. Because if the cop survives long enough there would be around 4 confirmed townies by day2. That's why they always have to claim.
Oh that makes it reasonable for rayn to think I can be mafia rofl. Okay.
|
Really that's 2. If mafia claims cop we have 1. If doc fake claims and we have town flip... Well that's both? Seems silly to me.
-ES
|
Let's play mafia instead of this bs?
Shockeyy is the cop so far, so who is mafia?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
