A normal game just for JAT <3 - Page 12

On April 21 2016 09:18 sicklucker wrote:
After that newb was vig shot it was obvious to everyone that super was mafia. But before that flip alot of people believed his fake claim

On April 21 2016 09:51 gumshoe wrote:
Welp, just skimmed over the game under the assumption that obis town, jat is town based off his day 1 interactions with super. ( defending Palmer from super ) the whole not lynching Palmer on a weekday is such a wierd reason for two scum to conflict so yeah, jats town

Tumb is town, don't wanna argue why again

Obi is evidently town.

Dick move analysis says onegu is town (can't see him getting that upset as scum, he was way calmer in vanilla)

That leaves jas sl and rels, so yes, there is a world where sl is town XD (the one where rels and jas are scum together)

On April 21 2016 09:59 gumshoe wrote:


quotes or it didnt happen. Find me games were onegu knowingly incured warnings as scum to make it look like he was genuine.

I think the guys delusional, terrible at mafia and has an undeserved persecution complex, but your asserting that he just outright cheated / : (breaking rules to earn confidence he cant be bothered to actually earn through play)

On April 21 2016 10:10 gumshoe wrote:


I just dont buy that / : it's another case where it's like, could Onegu be funneling the rage he feels to make himself look townie? Maybe.

But judging from what I have seen of him as scum, he doesn't get nearly as mad.

Also the key point I am making is that if Onegu is scum, he just knowingly cheated, his reference to my modkill comment shows he knew what he was doing, so unless onegu is a total piece of shit, hes not scum.

using a mod warning to make yourself look like a rageful townie is one of the most abusive moves possible. I would lose all respect for someone who did that.

Show me proof he can do that as scum and I'll concede the point and what little faith I have in him. Till then he gets the benefit of the douche/doubt / :

On April 21 2016 10:18 sicklucker wrote:


god this is too good I cant vote this man today

On April 21 2016 10:24 gumshoe wrote:


It makes a huge difference.

If he's town in his mind he is righteous.

If he's scum he's just slime.

It's easy to just say it makes no difference but it really does as it's the difference between being right and wrong outside the game. (He's moved things off the board)

And that's what onegu has done, he's made this about his morality and his sense of being wronged instead of being about the game itself.

Regardless of wether he was right to do that(he really wasn't)That does means a lot to me jat, I hope you don't think too less of me for that / :

On April 21 2016 12:50 sicklucker wrote:
then its probably jat if its shape. idk onegu is random but just as likely possible. If we lynch like shape he flips scum. We win if we lynch onegu then jat. unless im missing something.

If shape flips i dont think tumbles gonna be mafia

On April 21 2016 14:11 Tumblewood wrote:
I honestly don't know who we would lynch after Shape. I have six townreads and one scumread this game and these are pretty solid townreads.
Is the case against Rels just that one vote? Is the case on JAT just the low-hanging fruit argument? Is the case on Onegu just Onegu? These are all solid arguments but they also go against all the townie things those players have done and my feeeels are all I have to distinguish them.
I suppose the best way to go is Shape -> jat/rels -> rels/jat

On April 21 2016 23:29 Tumblewood wrote:

Then who the hell is?
I am tapping into the list of people I previously had as confirmed town.

On April 21 2016 23:29 Tumblewood wrote:

Then who the hell is?
I am tapping into the list of people I previously had as confirmed town.

On April 21 2016 23:51 gumshoe wrote:

##vote jas

Super may have started distancing himself from jas day 2.

As things stand, can't see who else could be scum.

On April 21 2016 23:59 Rels wrote:

But I did exactly that too.
TBF rsoul dying is an indicator that you are town, I should have been killed if you were scum. rsoul & I had kinda the same reads apart from you.

On April 21 2016 23:59 Rels wrote:

But I did exactly that too.
TBF rsoul dying is an indicator that you are town, I should have been killed if you were scum. rsoul & I had kinda the same reads apart from you.

On April 22 2016 00:11 Rels wrote:

Sure boss. ^^

We'll see about that. That doesn't feel very strong either, 'cause you probably can't control what Superbia wants to do if he's playing. In an hypothetical situation where you are his partner and he attacks Palmar for no reason, you will probably buddy Palmar and shut down your partner's bad attack.
Now I see how you will legitimately think that makes you town if you're town but this in particular is NAI.