Newbie Student Mafia XIX - Page 16

On January 31 2016 07:32 Trfel wrote:
So why are you saying it looks bad for Eden then? I don't understand.

On January 31 2016 07:44 PepperMintTea wrote:


I have to go back in my memory a little bit but from what I recall.

I had 4 people I was considering for a lynch, then after a sleep and another read through I added Kuragari , his filter was pretty bad.
I think his terrible push on darth and then nothing else made him scummy to me.
So I thought he was likely mafia and voted him.

I decided that voting for the scummy guy that everyone thought was scummy was pretty boring so I switched to Onegu who I thought was scummy. Then it turned out he was at hospital so switched back to Kura.

Iko I explained why I didn't want to to lynch and Tumblewood was still scummy but I thought Kura was more scummy.

The reason I didn't vote for jesus was because I thought he was going to turn out to be a role or at least that is how I read his blatant lack of investment. iko didn't post but when he finally started playing it was apologetic.
Jesus by contrast was arrogant and he read like a role that didn't want to get townread to hard. I felt that if he was pushed then he would claim a role and I didn't want to get involved in that.

Now we are well into day 2, Jesus did not post his promised information and hasn't actually contributed anything at all. The roles have been claimed and therefore Jesus has no excuse for his play other than being mafia.

I can work out the other mafia the next day but for now Jesus is the lynch and other suggestions are ridiculous.

On January 31 2016 07:42 Trfel wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +

I don't know if an Eden lynch is even practical today. Like, I feel that no one would support it.

On February 01 2016 07:39 nooniansoong wrote:


hell no.

On February 01 2016 07:40 nooniansoong wrote:


fuck yeah.

On February 01 2016 07:42 nooniansoong wrote:


ikido

On February 01 2016 07:48 nooniansoong wrote:


no. Eden is definitely town. Your case is based on misinterpretations on eden and just in general stuff that doens't make him scum.

If you look at the cases Eden makes they are very good and townie.

On January 31 2016 13:38 Trfel wrote:
Oh yeah, I left that line in there. Whoops.

I mean, everyone hates playing with me every game I play. I keep thinking I can fix it, but I still haven't found the solution. At some point I need to just stop playing, if no one likes playing with me and it makes everyone miserable, I shouldn't do it.

Some parts of this game were fun. Other parts were miserable. It took a lot of time. I need to move on.

On January 31 2016 15:26 Tumblewood wrote:
Okay. Here are all reasonable motivations I can come up with for making that post:
1. Noon is town, thinks that Trfel is still scum, and wants more support to get him lynched.
2. Noon is scum and wants to draw support for a mislynch.
3. Noon wants to ally darth. (unlikely)
4. Noon didn't make that in a serious light. (likely)
Results prove inconclusive, but that post is still really weird to me.

On January 31 2016 15:45 darthfoley wrote:


I'm personally offended that you have Shapelog as more of a town read than me given that i'm the vigilante aka blue role lol

On February 01 2016 05:39 nooniansoong wrote:
@Shape I'm reading your megapost on Eden lol. I think I'm the only one who's going to read it.

Eden calling onegu scum for not realizing shape was town, when Eden himeslf said Shape might be scum
I think you are misunderstanding Eden here.
This doesn't mean Eden thinks shape might be town. He is using a rhetorical device, juxtaposition, to present you with two possibilities: one likely, and the other unlikely.

The rest of it.. i mean I think there is some OMGUS from Eden towards Onegu. (OMGUS is when you scumread someone for scumreading you). But often OMGUS does come from town. You are convinced of your own towniness, of course, so it seems fake when someone else is scumreading you.

On February 01 2016 05:54 Eden1892 wrote:
Because why on Earth would I ever go to all the trouble of making my teammate look horrendous and then weakly walk it back like I did?

I am legitimately stunned that this isn't obvious to everyone. That's horrible mafia play. If Iki was going to incriminate himself like that, then the correct thing to do is to ignore it for a bit and hope no one else really calls it out. Maybe they don't and you coast (especially in a newbie game), neither one of you are in the spotlight and it's perfect. If someone else calls it out, then you bus Iki and move along.

But look at how the game has played out, literally the only reason any of you chuckleheads are talking about Iki at all is because I put Iki's big post during day 1 on blast. How does that make any sense for a partner to do?

On February 01 2016 05:58 Trfel wrote:
Okay, thanks, that was the reaction I was digging for.

I guess that might not have been the nicest thing to do, though, so I'm sorry.

On February 01 2016 06:15 Eden1892 wrote:
The Iki flip makes me town because if I were Iki's partner we could have easily lynched Trfel together instead of shipping Iki out.