/in
Fair warning, I start a new job this week so I will be a bit more strapped for time than usual, at least till later this week.
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
/in Fair warning, I start a new job this week so I will be a bit more strapped for time than usual, at least till later this week. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 08:01 LightningStrike wrote: Hey guys! Let's lynch some scum and here how we should do it: Step 1: Find the scum through interactions Step 2: Lynch the scum Step 3: ????? Step 4: Profit. Any questions or comments? I have mixed feelings about this post, Quoting it so I remember to check something later. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 08:36 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 08:18 LightningStrike wrote: Sukrit is a smurf obviously lol.... Oh yeah i just saw his post count lol. ![]() makes me wonder. Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 08:14 LightningStrike wrote: On December 14 2015 08:12 Damdred wrote: Hi I'm a Miller ls, how do I play this? Miller's aren't aware......... Are you mafia? Must admit is a bit weird to out yourself as a Miller already. Could be scum posing as Miller or Really is Miller who find out day. And if we really want to get next level we could say a scum team of LS/Damdred could be possible? I mean its a bit far fetch right now but.......think about it. LS building town cred by pointing out the elephant in the room. Which could be his mafia partner? But not pushing him hard enough (or for that matter seriously enough) to actually draw big attention to Damdred? Then the two follow up posts kinda fits this like a glove. Idk I take note of it being possible and move on. I like this post. Possibly an early townread. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 08:09 Koshi wrote: I ll keep my filter low this game. Just going to focus on cases and finding mafia. Not making excuses but my game might be trash. We will see. But I will not be buddied. disclaimer: don't expect too much though. Will probably still be pretty low content stuff. Why do you want to keep your filter low Koshi? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 08:41 Koshi wrote: Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 08:39 Damdred wrote: On December 14 2015 08:29 LightningStrike wrote: On December 14 2015 08:20 Damdred wrote: On December 14 2015 08:14 LightningStrike wrote: On December 14 2015 08:12 Damdred wrote: Hi I'm a Miller ls, how do I play this? Miller's aren't aware......... Are you mafia? My master plan ruined thanks to you ls. You caught me. Good. Now can you tell me who else is mafia with you? You obviously! Though shape is a good chance at town Because he is typing nonsense? On December 14 2015 08:50 Koshi wrote: Another fun fact: I actually wanted to roll mafia this game. Humm, I wonder... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 09:02 Koshi wrote: Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 08:54 Tictock wrote: On December 14 2015 08:09 Koshi wrote: I ll keep my filter low this game. Just going to focus on cases and finding mafia. Not making excuses but my game might be trash. We will see. But I will not be buddied. disclaimer: don't expect too much though. Will probably still be pretty low content stuff. Why do you want to keep your filter low Koshi? No real reason. I just want to play more in the shades this game. Hopefully, not scummy though. It will be a challenge. Or will it? Seems a bit odd to me that you'd want to try to post less when our last game had such an issue with inactive people. Maybe, I'm overreacting though kus I know my own time will be more limited this game. Time will tell. I hope. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 09:48 Damdred wrote: It's honestly be the most helpful to everyone if you basically ignored koshi for the first 24 and see what kind of smart things he says and then make a decision going into,the lynch. If you keep badgering him about low posting you will just have a horrendous amount of non information. Tt I think ls is town should I get my head checked? His open reminds me of how I started off when I posted first as scum, trying to look eager to lynch scum. Other than that he's fine. I liked him calling Koshi no fun. Not much to go on, but. I might put him as a town lean atm | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 09:51 Sukrit wrote: Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 09:48 Damdred wrote: It's honestly be the most helpful to everyone if you basically ignored koshi for the first 24 and see what kind of smart things he says and then make a decision going into,the lynch. If you keep badgering him about low posting you will just have a horrendous amount of non information. Tt I think ls is town should I get my head checked? Man I am finding everything terrible. Koshi is best read by his day one. Like this post is also terrible. Koshi, Damdred scum team. What exactly was terrible about that post? I think Damdred is actually talking some good sense here. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 11:52 Sukrit wrote: Maybe Dude. Welcome Back + Show Spoiler + If True | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 12:19 Sukrit wrote: I am Palmar and claiming mafia... Ok, Redact my last post plz. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 14:01 kushm4sta wrote: hello dear friends. I was not expecting this game to start so quickly. The number of potential signups made me think this was a large game and that it would start nearer to christmas. Should I ask for replacement? hmm no I think I would rather just piss everyone off with my minimal activity. I'm going to placeholder on ritoky because i see his name up there and I recall him posting pics of miley cyrus. I dislike this opening, though your vote has a solid reason. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Damdred is prob town for the Miller thing, plus he made a good point about meta-ing Koshi (or rather not rushing to meta Koshi). Easy start to a townpile. Gunna retract my town read on Shape from earlier, though I think I just need to see more out of him. Scummy Stuff: Jumped on the LS vote real fast, applying meta based on one game, kinda all over the place with reads Towny Stuff: Throwing out lots of thoughts/ideas, engaged, not concerned with how his suggestions make him look @Shape, have you read other games or just Haunted Mansion? Also welcome to the forums! | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 14:13 GiygaS wrote: Just getting in, question for Dam. Why did you make that post claiming Miller? On December 14 2015 14:29 GiygaS wrote: Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 10:30 Damdred wrote: Let me tell you why you are totally wrong in how you are approaching koshi. 1) you say that koshi is going to be super lazy and you are content voting him because that's his scum meta. In actuality you are right about his meta but dead wrong in your interpretation of what koshi said. If you read koshis post he clearly states he's going to focus on building cases and finding mafia. A clearly different thing especially since generally cases take a decent bit of effort which scum koshi lacks. Koshi then immediately back tracked by saying that his posts were going to be low content and possibly trash. How is his interpretation of that wrong? Not sure why you are fixated on Damdred. Do you have any thoughts on how LS (or anyone else) reacted to Damdred's claim? Whats your opinion oh Shape? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
3 Rels 4 Tubesock 6 Vivax Also an update on the GB tunnel: Closed for Repairs, use alternate routes | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Rit you might be right about Shape, I just saw those couple of things when rereding and wanted to take a step back. It sounds like you did pick up on the same thing in that post I liked though, I think Damdred saw it too. @Rels, I was thinking of checking LS's past games if his activity dropped off here after that open. He's stayed pretty active though so didn't seem worth the time. Might like Kush a little more since his open. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
And no, I only followed/read Haunted Mansion. But I figured Koshi's town meta would be more like that since everyone else jumped on his post about only lower activity. This makes more sense, that your gauging meta based on peoples reactions as well as your own read. Seemed a bit off for you to read one game and start to base reads off it. Thinking about it now it would be pretty odd for you to join your first game heree, roll mafia, then try to use meta reads. Guess I'm just overreacting kus meta is kinda overused here and often used badly ( glares at Rels). Oh, this was a quote from Shape btw, it got messed up on mobile. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 15 2015 03:11 GiygaS wrote: tt since you're here and it doesn't take much analysis to figure out your own thoughts, could you tell us the reason for the questions you were making? Sidenote: since everyone will inevitably do so by end of game, just call me giggles I'm not sure I know which ones you are reffering to. If you mean the ones I asked you. I thought it was a bit strange you were only reacting to Damdred, wanted to see if you were going somewhere with it. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 15 2015 05:21 GiygaS wrote: What about the question about shape? (you wanted my thoughts on him in particular for some reason) Kus I was rethinking my read on Shape at the time and wanted to push you to talk about someone else. Win Win. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Who am I sheeping so I don't have to bother doing anything? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Rit is giving me seriuse Dejavu, like This push on me is so similar to GB's push on me last game it's scary. The problem I have with Rit's push is that he is basing it off an unwavering townread on Shape and has in turn formed an unwavering scumread on me. What especially bugs me is the fact that both GB last game and Rit this game throw out is " I like to be right" as if that furthers your read at all. Now I realize my posting has been lackluster due to my lack of time and I don't expect anyone to have a townread on me or anything, but being tunneled for posting my thoughts on a null read is pretty lame. @ Rit, I totally disagree with the " One moment seals your alignment" nonsense you are spouting. Maybe you think that way, but I like to take a step back from my reads and reevaluate from time to time. I still need to get better at it because I tend to get tunneled on shit like GB last game. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 15 2015 22:33 Rels wrote: Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 22:29 Tictock wrote: Hey guys, I am a bit behind due to the past few days being crazy with work. Who am I sheeping so I don't have to bother doing anything? What do you think of giygas ? He's been fairly lackluster thus far, think I recall him promising to do some stuff then had a RL emergency and never did it. Possibly low-activity town or lurking mafia. Idk, the interaction we had felt kinda ok. I'll poke into his filter and give a better read when I get home. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I'll do the filter dive of Gig I promised Rels and then catchup with what I've missed thus far. While at work I was thinking about the whole Rit hardreading Shape. It's possible that what he said about "One moment defines a player" is just really how he's approaching this game (I don't recall him ever useing thinking like this before though, so it's weird) but I think it might be an indication that Rit is mafia. So I know for sure we aren't looking at a Rit/Shape team here, kus I just don't believe Rit would hard defend a teammate like he is. I'm wondering now if the hard townread is a sign of TMI? Like it dosn't make a ton of sense for Rit to have such a hard townread on Shape if he's town, he even made a post pointing out that Shape was doing some stuff that was stupid or looked bad, it also makes no sense for Rit to hard defend a scummate. However it makes perfect sense for a scum!Rit to hard defend a new-to-our-fourms town!Shape who people might have a hard time reading well. Would give him a nice platform to push from while seeming like he wants to prevent a mislynch. The other thing that I was thinking about, is why am I the only person to have irked Rit for my read on Shape? I know he posted out his thoughts on why he thought I was scum for rethinking my read but he's given little to no reaction to anyone else scumreading Shape. I realize my view on Rit is rather tainted with OMGUS kus he has a fordrawn conclusion to lynch me here, and my thinking here is more WIFOM than real evidence but I'm thinking Rit might be scum here. Only thing making me a bit unsure is that Rit is rather invested in his reads (pushing them etc) and cares about the lynch. So right now I'd put Rit as a OMGUS tainted scumlean. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 15 2015 13:56 ritoky wrote: too many people don't have an opinion on who is mafia. too many null reads. everyone should call someone mafia in their next post and stop wasting time pussyfooting. the time for your pointless shitty information gathering questions is past; form some opinions and stop being less useful than me. shape is town kush is probably town not interested in lynching koshi not interested in lynching damdred not interested in lynching rels no girls in the game so dunno LS alignment tt is probably mafia gb is underwhelming and should be a potential vote gig does the whole not delivering on promises shit every1 else is nai or unremarkable ##vote: glowingbear i am voting on you to piss you off so that you can shit town on me and then i can lynch tt at the eod. please stop being worse than me, cuz if you're worse than me you're probably mafia. Rit can you talk to me more about your bolded reads here? Kush has made a few okish posts since his open, but what has he done to warrant a townread like this? Why are you saying you need girls to read LS? is this a joke I'm missing, kus it seems really werid to me. Why have you given Rels a free pass but not GB? I don't really recall anything noteworthy from either of them so why is Rels a no lynch but GB a pressure vote? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 15 2015 02:58 GiygaS wrote: Thanks for NAI help. Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 22:57 Shapelog wrote: When Giyga posts two questions about him, TT becomes defensive and ask why Giyga was fixated on Damred. Kinda of a weird thing to do this early. I would of seen how my town lean would of reacted to the questions and then go on from there. Instead, he loses this chance and deters Giyga from Damred for the time being. This is only true if I was that focused on Damdred in the first place. The first was only because I was initially confused why he posted the miller claim. The second was because I just didn't agree with his reasoning and wanted to point it out, it wasn't because I had a scum read on him. I'll reread tt filter and see, but all I have is null or town reads on everyone, except a tiny lean on Koshi from meta that I haven't even experienced. ![]() So here is the 2nd time Gig responds to why he was talking about Damdred in his first 2 posts, which is a bit odd as in the post he's responding too Shape was talking about me getting defensive of Damdred and pinging out Gig's first 2 posts not talking to Gig at all. Shows he's being rather defensive of those posts for no real reason. I'm also noting the Bolded line where he says everyone is null or town to him. The next part about Koshi is really weird, he just says a "lean" (I assume scumlean) on Koshi but for a meta he hasn't experienced. Unless you really trust the person making the meta argument I don't get why you would let a meta read you have no experience with influence your reads. Next he throws a vote on me with a townread on Rit. On December 15 2015 04:09 GiygaS wrote: Woops forgot vote. I'll add I have a town read on ritoky as well since his posts have been short but decently high quality. ##Vote ticktock This really looks to me like it could be mafia hopping on a bandwagon, he doesn't make a read on me himself but rather declares Rit is town and then votes with him (not literally since Rit wasn't voting then, but you know what I mean). It's really interesting then how Gig unvotes me almost right after. On December 15 2015 06:48 GiygaS wrote: ##Unvote tictock He's swapped back to null for me, will look over more when I get home from studying. The unvote came after I answered Gig's questions regarding my questions to him early on. Which would imply that those questions were why Gig was scumreading me, not the case Rit made. Gig's next post: On December 15 2015 10:38 GiygaS wrote: Home from studying. Since I'm in the note-taking mood I'm going to go through the thread again writing in a notebook to organize my thoughts a bit. I'll keep looking at the newer posts though so I'll be around. So far have null or town reads on everybody, but hoping to change that within the next 2-ish hours. Talks about putting effort into some note taking, reads are again all town or null. NAI stuff happens with RL, then after he returns. On December 15 2015 14:36 GiygaS wrote: Finished reading through and writing general notes. Going to go through filters and hang around still. Current scum reads are on tt (again, I really don't like that list of townread retraction with NAI stuff) and shape (holy shit that random asslist in to weird sukrit fos). Might get some more/less post-filters, but we'll see. For the record, my name has been spelled 9 different ways, so that's pretty neat. Also, these posts :D Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 23:28 Koshi wrote: On December 14 2015 23:24 Shapelog wrote: If that is Onegu I will do a shot and watch as Koshi calls him cancer ![]() No. This Onegu I could fall in love with. Therefore, if this would be Onegu I would kill Onegu for being Onegu in the past. I love this new meta of mine with all these content rich posts. Scum reads me again kus of same post Rit is going on about and adds in Shape and later talks about Rels' LS meta read and votes him. I'm not sure what caused him to move back to me over Rels kus I'm not caught up just yet, but I'll keep an eye out for it as I plan to get caught up next. For those who hate to read, Reasons to scumread Gig. - Weird progression on me. Scum read on me develops after Rit starts pushing me, drops the read after we talk about something else, then says everyone is null and shortly after is back on me for the same thing Rit was talking about in the first place. -Multiple times says he's got only Null and Town reads. Mafia tend to have a hard time finding reasons to scumread other players whereas town tends to jump on things that bug them. -Scumreads all come from other people. He mentions a "lean" on Koshi for a meta he has no experience with (obviously talking about the meta read on Koshi early on), his readon me comes from Rit, the scumread on Rels was from Koshi, and I think (I haven't checked this one) the Shape read comes from Onegu/Sukrit I think Gig is probably Mafia based on this. ##Vote: GiygaS | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 02:39 Koshi wrote: At this point Onegu is simply mafia. I do not think he can be this fucking bad. That is a read that will never change. fucking 100% mafia. I towntelled pretty much 100% atm and he still is going on about how I am mafia. Pretty insane. Even if I am not yet 100% town. Going on about how I am mafia when there are WAY more possible candidates out there is just unbelievable unlikely. Seriously? I didn't react enough because I already knew it was Onegu??????????????????? And I somehow wanted to prevent people to know it was Onegu because if it was Onegu people would believe his read on me and think I am truly mafia? This is too fucking stupid even for Onegu. He is mafia. ##unvote ##vote Onegu Now I am pretty sure TT is also mafia btw, and somehow I think he should be lynched. But if anybody believes the idiocy that Onegu just wrote there..... Holy fuck. This can only come from mafia. Seriously. What a fucking far fetched case. This is really only possible coming from Mafia. Town is simply not that retarded. Idk, this is kinda overblown. Like Onegu's play this game is pretty solid, and him wondering why you had such a mild reaction to him being reveled is fair. No way do you actually believe him questioning that makes him mafia. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 02:40 Shapelog wrote: Btw Sukrits post about me and Scum Team QT made me remember my far fetch theory about Ritoky. Fair fetch Theroy: (Spoilers) + Show Spoiler + Ok so Ritoky has been defending me all game and calling me confirmed town is weird. I know i am town, but i do not think i have posted anything that makes me confirmed town. And all he does and says derps to defend me. When TT retakes his town read on me, Rit retakes his read on TT. He seems hellbent on defending me. With only reasoning being "oh hes derping thats town, Next level stuff." IDK maybe he likes me. OR maybe he is scum. He knows i'm town if he is mafia and make it seem like mafia defending mafia. Then i'll get lynch for the consent defense and flip town, it will bring him tons of town cred. I know this is far fetch but it makes sense. Why else would he be defending me so hard? Why read into my dumbness? I see our tinfoil is set to the same frequency sir. What do you make of the fact that Rit only cares about me rethinking my read on you, but doesn't really bother with anyone else who isn't sure about you, or even scumreads you? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 03:00 Koshi wrote: Fuck that shit. I am going to calm down and read. I really think Onegu should just be lynched for being the dumbest fucker alive who appears to also be mafia but seriously. I felt really good about my TT, GB, Kush and Rels list earlier. Good, kus I think Onegu is town and you and he are simply always rubbing each other wrong. I saw you posts about Rels (he's on my list of filters to check), but can you expand on your GB and Kush reads a little? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 03:29 Shapelog wrote: I love how i decided to go up against everyone who is saying I am town. I do too actually, I can't recall if I said it yet or not but you've made it into my townpile. I think the only reason I really took a step back was kus earlier on I was mixing you and Sukrit up and when I looked at filters to get my reads straight there was a fair few things in yours that made me uneasy. Hell even if I wasn't fairly convinced you were town by now I'd want to keep you in the game kus you are pretty active and I've liked a lot of your posts. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 03:45 Sukrit wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 03:42 Koshi wrote: You are a fucking joke. But it is ok. I am going to go with my gut and think you are town. Which is actually something insane for me to do. Because there is really no fucking way you are town and think I am mafia. But let's entertain the idea. I should be dead before enough people listen to your "serious" playing anyway. ##unvote ##vote TickTock Nope one of us die today. It will be me and I am 1000000000000000000000000% fucking ok with that because you give me a headache. I cant believe I used to enjoy playing with you. Guys why can't you two play nice? Lets not lynch between you 2 so we actually have a solid chance to lynch mafia today. I get that you 2 have a rocky history, but having to read about this feud in two games now is pretty tireing. Also, for the record I think you both tend to have good reads (though Koshi can be really unpredictable) so maybe you can try and put aside your hate for each other and look at what you agree on? ... Fuck that's me isn't it? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 04:20 Vivax wrote: I have no brain power for this game today,ill sheep Koshi Super late to the party, eh? Why Koshi? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 05:20 Rels wrote: I think Damdred is scum. Damdred is not invested in the game, which is already a big indicator. Damdred usually plays D1 by finding townreads, and lynching the one not in his town list. Here I have the distinct impression he tried to replicate that but failed. He has a couple of easy townreads that are not mostly based on nothing: Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 08:39 Damdred wrote: On December 14 2015 08:29 LightningStrike wrote: On December 14 2015 08:20 Damdred wrote: On December 14 2015 08:14 LightningStrike wrote: On December 14 2015 08:12 Damdred wrote: Hi I'm a Miller ls, how do I play this? Miller's aren't aware......... Are you mafia? My master plan ruined thanks to you ls. You caught me. Good. Now can you tell me who else is mafia with you? You obviously! Though shape is a good chance at town Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 05:07 Damdred wrote: Games not to bad I have a few ok town reads so far I'll post more when I get home. Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 07:15 Damdred wrote: On December 15 2015 06:08 LightningStrike wrote: Sorry I been conserving my posts a little bit more as I had 1 page of posts already so I trying to limit myself a little bit now. But Koshi pretty much town for me atm. Also Damdred if you are here can you give me your thoughts on TT or other The smurf guy please? I'm a bit behind tbh but my initial gut was town on Tt other idk yet Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 09:59 Damdred wrote: For the record ls is town this game, tone/actions and how he does the game totally point to it. I'll go to war over this read. His only posts that are a little big are about how to read Koshi, which is something completely unrelated to scumhunting: Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 09:48 Damdred wrote: It's honestly be the most helpful to everyone if you basically ignored koshi for the first 24 and see what kind of smart things he says and then make a decision going into,the lynch. If you keep badgering him about low posting you will just have a horrendous amount of non information. Tt I think ls is town should I get my head checked? Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 10:30 Damdred wrote: Let me tell you why you are totally wrong in how you are approaching koshi. 1) you say that koshi is going to be super lazy and you are content voting him because that's his scum meta. In actuality you are right about his meta but dead wrong in your interpretation of what koshi said. If you read koshis post he clearly states he's going to focus on building cases and finding mafia. A clearly different thing especially since generally cases take a decent bit of effort which scum koshi lacks. 2) you say my post is terrible because you read koshi on his d1. Though you correct yourself by saying I said 24 hours. In actuality I a aid we shouldn't bother koshi so that we can see what he comes up with. Since you know he said he would focus on cases and finding scum instead of spamming the thread. ....like I said give koshi space and some time see what he comes up with. Finally, there is no list post that Damdred uses for finding scums by POE with his townreads, especially on D1. For comparaison, here are the kind of posts I expected from Damdred (from Really Small Mafia II and Dark Tournament Mafia in which he flipped town). Really Small Mafia II, 12 hours into D1: Show nested quote + On December 12 2015 20:15 Damdred wrote: On December 12 2015 18:50 raynpelikoneet wrote: On December 12 2015 15:18 Damdred wrote: Eh screw it I'm awake so I'll post. Rs/Art go after Darth in what amounts to there opening post and follow up post. While I don't think its out of the scope of what they could do as scum going after dp so fast is something I don't really consider either of them to do. It seems to me its more motivated at this instance coming from town trying to catch someone on a meta irregularity that they feel. It isn't quite the gorcha moment to total town read but it makes sense and fives me somewhat town feelings motive wise. yes, this makes sense to me aswell. I think your read on Greymist is not really based on good reasoning Damdred. I believe in this game there are zero players who can be considered either alignment based on the tone of the posts, as we are all experienced enough to fake it. I think it's as possible that Greymist started the game joking with you as scum than it is that he did it as town. I'd probably agree with the part on my greymist post. I'm not hard town reading him at this point. like it sort of looks like this Damdred Rayn probably town Rsoultin/art Darth liking them greymist ? Marv Rels Dark Tournament, 25 hours into D1: Show nested quote + On December 02 2015 09:36 Damdred wrote: Disinformation Eels Damdred Shining Palmar Leans Trfel Fid (falling) Ls Honestly it's notso bad so far even though I've read 0 filters. I think Damdred is scum. ##Unvote ##Vote Damdred Rels you really use meta reads way too much. I do agree Damdred has dropped off a fair bit... idk he still seems more involved than he was in SoW2. Maybe I'll give a look into him if I have time, but I've seen nothing to actually make me suspect him. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 05:36 Rels wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 05:32 Shapelog wrote: Oh yeah wasn't he suppose to drop a bomb or something? even wrote him down in my notes as Null until bomb. Maybe he ment a real bomb. But i am not watching the news for it. Yep that's true. When I was scum with Damdred in sotw he posted several times he was going to do stuff and didn't. Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 08:44 Damdred wrote: Ls why should I not vote you ^^. Will be home to read and bomb soon Thing #1 that was not done. Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 01:29 Damdred wrote: Ok so I fell asleep and just woke up. give me three filters to read and I'll find acum if there is between them! Besides ls, koshi they are hard town reads atm. Thing #2 that was not done. Humm I did forget about this.. and @ Koshi, check Damdred's scum game in SoW2, he was playing in multiple games and did the lurker thing as scum. Not sure he would do that again so soon but he was playing in another game when this one started... But then that's weird kus he was more active then... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 05:40 Koshi wrote: 1) The post on Kush that is serious / jokey 2) The townread on Shape, into retraction, into townread again because ritoky says so 3) The scumread on ritoky is based on "having the same feeling like with GB last game", but GB was town? dafuq? 4) Now he is really trowing all eggs in the ritoky is mafia basket. 5) early game he had too many weak townreads and found nothing scummy, or didn't jump on anything. jsut some points I quickly recall 1) What was wrong with it? I didn't like his opening as he was talking about a lot of different things, making excuses, and throws out a vote out of nowhere. I found his "reasons" for voting Rit funny though. 2) I don't give a shit about Rit's read (other than it's weird it's so strong), I thought Shape might be town, reread and saw some stuff that made me pause, and based on his responses and continued posting decided I was overreacting to NAI stuff. 3) More of a null/scum lean than a real scumread. His reads are a little weird and some tinfoil thoughts make sense for him being mafia but I'd want to see his responses to my questions before I get more into that read. 4) Total BS, I'm not at all sure Rit is mafia here, he could well be town tunneled on me just like GB was last game. It's the reads stuff that is making me wonder. 5) So? I've been playing more to the style of finding town first then figuring out mafia from the remaining pool of players. I've also had hardly any time to play since this game started and all almost all my posts till today were made while at work on mobile. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 05:47 Koshi wrote: TickTock, Last game you proved that you are able to tunnel like a motherfucker and that you can find mafia treats in the game very easily. Why are you so lackluster here? I am reading this case, I already read it twice, and there is not the same conviction coming from it like you had last game with GB. Not at all. Any reason for that? (18 left) Being tunneled on Town all of last game kinda makes me want to try and tone that down some. Honestly the biggest difference is that this game seems to have a lot more going on than the last game and I'm not very sure on my scumreads atm. I feel pretty good about my townreads though. I don't remember how much time I sunk into last D1 but I think it was easily twice as much time as I have now. Reading filters in isolation is also not the way I prefer to make my reads but that's what I got out of reading Gig's. It also really sucks having Tube and Vivax only joining the game now as I'd prefer to have a better sense of all the players in this game, but I'm not sure there's much of anything to go on for those 2. Rels is kinda in this boat as well, but mostly just kus i haven't read him very closly yet. My initial gut read on him was that he wasn't trying to bust out the tryhard mode I see him use as mafia a lot and that would make him town. His last case on Damdred feels more like something I'd see from scum!Rels though, so I should relook at him. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 05:54 Koshi wrote: It literally cannot be solid unless you think I am mafia, and you agree you are mafia. He didn't say anything else. Some stuff about shape as well. (15 left) I am going to vote you and see what happens. I will reread you filter if you flip town. I think there are too many reasons for you to be mafia. And I also think that you don't have enough votes for the amount of people saying you are mafia. Not the best reason but you got like 3 votes or something. I'm not talking about his reads, I mean the way he is posting, talking about stuff, and pushing people. "Play" encompasses a lot more than reads. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 06:02 ritoky wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 05:00 Tictock wrote: Oops forgot I wanted to bring up this post real quick then I'm done talking about Rit for the moment. On December 15 2015 13:56 ritoky wrote: too many people don't have an opinion on who is mafia. too many null reads. everyone should call someone mafia in their next post and stop wasting time pussyfooting. the time for your pointless shitty information gathering questions is past; form some opinions and stop being less useful than me. shape is town kush is probably town not interested in lynching koshi not interested in lynching damdred not interested in lynching rels no girls in the game so dunno LS alignment tt is probably mafia gb is underwhelming and should be a potential vote gig does the whole not delivering on promises shit every1 else is nai or unremarkable ##vote: glowingbear i am voting on you to piss you off so that you can shit town on me and then i can lynch tt at the eod. please stop being worse than me, cuz if you're worse than me you're probably mafia. Rit can you talk to me more about your bolded reads here? Kush has made a few okish posts since his open, but what has he done to warrant a townread like this? Why are you saying you need girls to read LS? is this a joke I'm missing, kus it seems really werid to me. Why have you given Rels a free pass but not GB? I don't really recall anything noteworthy from either of them so why is Rels a no lynch but GB a pressure vote? kush - had the tr on me at the right time, had the gb read at the right time, told koochi to go fuck himself. LS - historically women on these forums read him with near 100% accuracy. it isn't a joke or an exaggeration. rels - i coached rels and in doing so i developed a method of reading him, it doesn't work until day 2 or later so i am confident in my ability to discern his alignment late game. Ok w/e about the LS thing, I kinda get you on Rels, but the Kush stuff doesn't make much sense to me, well expect the part about Koshi. This "the right time" feels like shit to me, how do you know the right time? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 06:21 ritoky wrote: why rit is mafia and gig is mafia case before reading and analyzing thread? Stuff on you was what I was thinking about before I got home, put it down kus it was fairly fresh. Gig was kus Rels asked me to look into him, so it didn't start out a case but thats where I ended up after diving his filter. Gotta pick somewhere to start when I got home, and those were the 2 things on my mind. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 06:36 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 19:24 ritoky wrote: if you want me to write the why tt is potentially mafia book it would basically be: he tr shape for good reason (i thought) at proper time and when it was popular, then backed out of it for a bad/no reason when it was popular, was awkward, then has basically snap conceded/fucked off in the face of me wanting to lynch him. . Yay i'm popular lol. But really, TT didn't IMO pull out at a popular time. In fact, he the first person to pull out of a Town read. Giyga khan, LS, Damdred, Surkit all did it after his post about me. Not defending TT here, just don't understand how this is was the Popular time. Thank you for posting this Shape, I remember reading this earlier and though the same thing but it slipped my mind. I'm pretty sure everyone was reading Shape as town when I made that post. I also really think it's shitty to call me mafia because I went "Oh wait, maybe I was too fast to read this guy as town, here's what I'm noticing..." But apparently tunneling me kus of my Null reads is the thing to do now. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 06:45 Koshi wrote: Yeah what about we shennanies on Kush? Humm, maybe. I kinda like his "come fight me attitude" but then again that doesn't mean much since he's never really around does it? What was making you read Gig as town Koshi? (I think you said that earlier) His vote on me was pretty opportunistic and his progression on it was weird, along with parroting most of not all his scumreads. I know you didn't like my "case" (it wasn't but w/e) on him, so what did you like about him? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 06:50 ritoky wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 06:49 Tictock wrote: On December 16 2015 06:02 ritoky wrote: On December 16 2015 05:00 Tictock wrote: Oops forgot I wanted to bring up this post real quick then I'm done talking about Rit for the moment. On December 15 2015 13:56 ritoky wrote: too many people don't have an opinion on who is mafia. too many null reads. everyone should call someone mafia in their next post and stop wasting time pussyfooting. the time for your pointless shitty information gathering questions is past; form some opinions and stop being less useful than me. shape is town kush is probably town not interested in lynching koshi not interested in lynching damdred not interested in lynching rels no girls in the game so dunno LS alignment tt is probably mafia gb is underwhelming and should be a potential vote gig does the whole not delivering on promises shit every1 else is nai or unremarkable ##vote: glowingbear i am voting on you to piss you off so that you can shit town on me and then i can lynch tt at the eod. please stop being worse than me, cuz if you're worse than me you're probably mafia. Rit can you talk to me more about your bolded reads here? Kush has made a few okish posts since his open, but what has he done to warrant a townread like this? Why are you saying you need girls to read LS? is this a joke I'm missing, kus it seems really werid to me. Why have you given Rels a free pass but not GB? I don't really recall anything noteworthy from either of them so why is Rels a no lynch but GB a pressure vote? kush - had the tr on me at the right time, had the gb read at the right time, told koochi to go fuck himself. LS - historically women on these forums read him with near 100% accuracy. it isn't a joke or an exaggeration. rels - i coached rels and in doing so i developed a method of reading him, it doesn't work until day 2 or later so i am confident in my ability to discern his alignment late game. Ok w/e about the LS thing, I kinda get you on Rels, but the Kush stuff doesn't make much sense to me, well expect the part about Koshi. This "the right time" feels like shit to me, how do you know the right time? the right time is when i think the exact same thing in my brain at that time. Ah ok, so it's just a mindmeld thing? Is that a reliable metric for you? People are usually never on the same page as me so I rarely get moments like that. What did you think of what I was pointing out about Gig since I know you saw my post about him? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 06:56 ritoky wrote: idk...that read flip on shape and those 3 posts are pretty fucking awful and probably make you scum....but then you come back and decide to swim up the river of heavy resistance rather than least resistance...then you base half your game on omgusing an obv town....i really have no clue what you're doing if you're town. If the bolded is referring to you I think you are overstating your townyness. I think I'm taking my OMGUS into account properly here... I hope. Besides my read on you has more to do with the way you are reading Shape than me... ehh maybe 60/40. Why don't we talk about someone other than me for a second though? Like imagine for a moment that I wasn't around and was probably going to be modkilled. Who would you be your backup? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 06:59 Damdred wrote: He's buddying obvious town when usually he would be nit picking everyone and super paranoid of *obvious town*. he's also trying to use more bullshit reasons and instead of trying to push what he thinks he is taking the path of least resistance. ie instead of pushing me jumped on kush. idk if kush is scum granted but its suspicious of rels. Humm this is actually a decent point. Game is going fast enough that I'm barely keeping up but I'll take the time to look over Rels in just a min. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 07:14 ritoky wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 07:08 Tictock wrote: On December 16 2015 06:50 ritoky wrote: On December 16 2015 06:49 Tictock wrote: On December 16 2015 06:02 ritoky wrote: On December 16 2015 05:00 Tictock wrote: Oops forgot I wanted to bring up this post real quick then I'm done talking about Rit for the moment. On December 15 2015 13:56 ritoky wrote: too many people don't have an opinion on who is mafia. too many null reads. everyone should call someone mafia in their next post and stop wasting time pussyfooting. the time for your pointless shitty information gathering questions is past; form some opinions and stop being less useful than me. shape is town kush is probably town not interested in lynching koshi not interested in lynching damdred not interested in lynching rels no girls in the game so dunno LS alignment tt is probably mafia gb is underwhelming and should be a potential vote gig does the whole not delivering on promises shit every1 else is nai or unremarkable ##vote: glowingbear i am voting on you to piss you off so that you can shit town on me and then i can lynch tt at the eod. please stop being worse than me, cuz if you're worse than me you're probably mafia. Rit can you talk to me more about your bolded reads here? Kush has made a few okish posts since his open, but what has he done to warrant a townread like this? Why are you saying you need girls to read LS? is this a joke I'm missing, kus it seems really werid to me. Why have you given Rels a free pass but not GB? I don't really recall anything noteworthy from either of them so why is Rels a no lynch but GB a pressure vote? kush - had the tr on me at the right time, had the gb read at the right time, told koochi to go fuck himself. LS - historically women on these forums read him with near 100% accuracy. it isn't a joke or an exaggeration. rels - i coached rels and in doing so i developed a method of reading him, it doesn't work until day 2 or later so i am confident in my ability to discern his alignment late game. Ok w/e about the LS thing, I kinda get you on Rels, but the Kush stuff doesn't make much sense to me, well expect the part about Koshi. This "the right time" feels like shit to me, how do you know the right time? the right time is when i think the exact same thing in my brain at that time. Ah ok, so it's just a mindmeld thing? Is that a reliable metric for you? People are usually never on the same page as me so I rarely get moments like that. What did you think of what I was pointing out about Gig since I know you saw my post about him? if it happens more than once it usually means the person is above 80% chance to be town, reliable enough for me to not vote them d1. imo gig is completely underwhelming and i remember nothing about him off the top of my head other than he said he was gonna do shit and didn't. Thats not really what I was asking, what about these points? For those who hate to read, Reasons to scumread Gig. - Weird progression on me. Scum read on me develops after Rit starts pushing me, drops the read after we talk about something else, then says everyone is null and shortly after is back on me for the same thing Rit was talking about in the first place. -Multiple times says he's got only Null and Town reads. Mafia tend to have a hard time finding reasons to scumread other players whereas town tends to jump on things that bug them. -Scumreads all come from other people. He mentions a "lean" on Koshi for a meta he has no experience with (obviously talking about the meta read on Koshi early on), his readon me comes from Rit, the scumread on Rels was from Koshi, and I think (I haven't checked this one) the Shape read comes from Onegu/Sukrit | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 07:20 Rels wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 07:19 Tictock wrote: On December 16 2015 06:59 Damdred wrote: He's buddying obvious town when usually he would be nit picking everyone and super paranoid of *obvious town*. he's also trying to use more bullshit reasons and instead of trying to push what he thinks he is taking the path of least resistance. ie instead of pushing me jumped on kush. idk if kush is scum granted but its suspicious of rels. Humm this is actually a decent point. Game is going fast enough that I'm barely keeping up but I'll take the time to look over Rels in just a min. How is it scum indicative when I thought deadline was in 10 minutes and nobody wanted to vote Damdred ? Ok that does make sense, I didn't know you were confused about the deadline. Also yea, I don't think we should lynch Damdred. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 07:25 ritoky wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 07:17 Tictock wrote: On December 16 2015 06:56 ritoky wrote: idk...that read flip on shape and those 3 posts are pretty fucking awful and probably make you scum....but then you come back and decide to swim up the river of heavy resistance rather than least resistance...then you base half your game on omgusing an obv town....i really have no clue what you're doing if you're town. If the bolded is referring to you I think you are overstating your townyness. I think I'm taking my OMGUS into account properly here... I hope. Besides my read on you has more to do with the way you are reading Shape than me... ehh maybe 60/40. Why don't we talk about someone other than me for a second though? Like imagine for a moment that I wasn't around and was probably going to be modkilled. Who would you be your backup? i mean i haven't even voted on you, i am voting on gb; so it is clear what my alternative is. and i am not overstating my towniness, i claimed vt. basically why i keep talking about you is i am trying to figure out if you're just mafia or you're going to be "that guy" for me this game. "that guy" refers to the person in the game who i have a burning desire to lynch every phase and must forcibly talk myself out of lynching every phase. this is a very important distinction that could impede my progress of solving this game. outside of you who i want to lynch and gb who i am voting on cuz i expect better from, i have no particular desire of lynch targets. i don't want to lynch koochi, shape, damdred, kush, rels; everyone else i won't be hurt if they disappear. I thought your GB vote was purely for pressure, ok noted. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 22:58 Rels wrote: sukrit seems to be Onegu ?? From this profile, he has a post in Carnaval that suggests he's an Onegu smurf: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/485712-carnaval-do-brasil-mafia?page=46#917 But his posting style doesn't match up at aaaaaall. Lol for as bad a post this seemed like at the time it's amazing Rels hit the nail right on the head here. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
He kind parroted Rit about me, but other than that he's trying to get his head around the game. On December 15 2015 19:14 Rels wrote: TT is a good lynch too. He could be scum. He's not invested in finding scums, contrary to what I'm used from him. He repeats multiple times he doesn't have much time to play. This is kinda a shit post about me though since I stated pre-game that I was going to be heavily constrained with my time. Idk other than that I'm tempted to just roll with my initial gut read that Rels is town. Good to keep an eye on how he's making cases and pushing them though. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Last chance for you guys to join me on Gig though... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
or just sheep koshi... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 07:47 Koshi wrote: I FUCKING HATE MODKILLS DUE TO NOT VOTING? WHY IS IT A FUCKING RULE? WHY IS IT IMPORTANT THAT YOU VOTE? WHY WOULD YOU AS HOST RUIN THE BALANCE OF YOUR OWN GAME BECAUSE SOMEBODY HAS A FUCKING ISSUE AND CAN'T VOTE????????????????? NOT VOTING DOES FUCKING NOTHING..................................................................... LET TOWN SOLVE IT FFS AND GO FOR A BAN AFTER THE GAME.. What is this about... it can't be about you and Damdred is around (I think)... so? TMI? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I fail at reading, I thought it was LS kus of the caps, lol. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 07:52 LightningStrike wrote: I honestly rather kill kush over GB atm just because Kush is normally useless as both alignments. GB wasn't ver yuseful as Town last game either... Idk I'm wavering here I think I'm gunna vote GB... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 07:56 GlowingBear wrote: BTW the fact that TT is wasting his vote is pretty suspicious. Also, just so you guys know: I suddenly thought that Shapelog is Mafia because he started scumreading me for inactivity, but he followed my last game very closely (as he keeps saying how Koshi normally plays based on our last game) and for that reason should completely understand this is within under my town play. I've played exactly like this when I've landed on my new job. Now he sees Koshi is playing kinda differently and calls him out in the beginning of the game. But now never talks about him. He is town for him now, it seems. You can add up to that that he was ok with lynching either me or Kush, when we both were going against other and the probability of being Mafia is low. You can argue that he is not doing associative reads but you can see that he does that kind of thing for his early posts, where he sets a Mafia team right away. I've been trying to get people onto Gig but nobody wants to join me or tell me why they think he;s town. Now I guess I vote you kus of this and kus you've not done anything noteworthy this game | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Also I apologize for my reaction to Koshi's post I totally misread who was posting. I'm not sure I should explain exactly what I was thinking tonight either... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 08:08 Damdred wrote: Tt why did you apologize to me for hammering GB especially when your vote was no where anyway? Not for hammering GB, because I would have switched to Vivax if there was enough people around. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 08:07 LightningStrike wrote: What you mean what happened? You hammered GB............ I said WELL that happened... Rit is right though my vote wouldn't have mattered if not for Damdred's switch to Vivax. The idea was solid... the execution was bad. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 08:12 Damdred wrote: My shenanigan doesn't hammer GB kush is still leading the vote when I switch. I'll take the blame but if myself, koshi, tt, GB switch vivax has a real shot at being lynched Nah you can blame me, I was prob voting GB anyways but that last post of his sealed the deal for me. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
At least you got a nice job now? Maybe we'll learn this is your new town meta | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Will be around later tonight, but FYI tomorrow is another Shit day for me. I open one job, work my new job in the afternoon, then go back and close for my first job.... so F my life. After that I should be back to a normal schedule. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 08:20 ritoky wrote: if you wanna claim mason with LS then just do it already damdred. Ok yea this explains my tinfoil about Damdred/LS I'd forgotten until after EoD that Masons (or Harlequin and Columbine) were a thing in this game, wasn't going to give scum ideas about roles... but if Rit's gunna come out and say it... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Town Shapelog Damdred Koshi Probably Town Sukrit Rels LightningStrike kushm4sta Null/Unsure Tubesock ritoky Scum Vivax GiygaS | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I also hope Kush is able to give this game some effort now that he's got some time. Tube is totally null to me, I almost forgot he was in this game. I think Rit should be my first reread but my initial feeling is that his EoD lacked the bluster of some of his earlier posts and I think he's overreacting to Damdred's shenanigans, especially when GB was one of his scumreads. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 10:24 Shapelog wrote: Why i'm i talking to myself? I pulling a Koshi here. Heck Not even a Koshi, More like a lazy koshi. Why i'm I even concerned if I am talking to myself. Maybe it's because i have like 12 posts left (11ish after this.) Idk. Should do what i said I do and finish Notes and crap. You reminded me to check my filter and realized I'm a bit closer to 5 pgs than I thought I would be. I still feel the need to question why you bothered to hit post on this one after realizing you were so close to your limit. but now I feel like i need to make better use of my own post... Looked over Tubes filter and I get the sense he's read through the game in a rush or skimmed it and tried to push out what thoughts he could. Since he was apparently traveling at the start of the game I think I'll give him more time to go over things. Vivax looks really weird, he drops in, sheeps Koshi, but pokes at LS about something that he probably never read? Doesn't make sense. I'm looking at Onegu's filter and I'm amazed he doesn't post like this more. It's almost like reading another person even though I see hints of his usual trolling and whatnot. I can honestly see why he would feel the need to make a smurf just to avoid getting lynched for meta. This post feels off to me though. On December 16 2015 07:37 Sukrit wrote: Would prefer the TT lynch. To be honest if he flips scum I will 100% read you town. And if he flips town then I will keep looking at you. I need to reread something but like 2 pages ago it was like he was scum reading you and in the space of a few posts town reading you. So TT seems like a good lynch. I don't see why my flip has anything to do with Koshi, and nothing Onegu says here has anything to do with Kus. I'd also really like to see what he was talking about with my read on Koshi (+ Show Spoiler + which now that I think about it I never did really explain. Kinda 2 parts, his activity and posting are exactly like last game after starting out saying he was going to try to tone it down. Tells me he is getting engaged with the game and can't help himself. I also thought it was really towny how Koshi made a case on Rels while pushing GB, hard to see scum pushing multiple strong players at once. Just seems like Onegu is avoiding the question here, which is odd because later says this about Kush On December 16 2015 07:54 Sukrit wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 07:52 LightningStrike wrote: On December 16 2015 07:52 Sukrit wrote: LS Kush is a terrible lynch. Why is it a bad lynch? Because this is how he looks as town. Seems like he's just deflecting away from Kush kus he wasn't trying to get LS onto me just tells him Kush is a bad lynch. His opinion of GB was also pretty weak, just said he liked his reads. I've got more to do but going to save it till tomorrow, I should be able to put in some time if not a lot. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 16 2015 20:53 kushm4sta wrote: Wow you guys should have lynched me. what gives This is a really weird post. You were pushing for GB pretty much all day after your initial vote on Rit and now that he flips town this is your response? You kinda did this earlier too, On December 14 2015 23:22 kushm4sta wrote: Did a quick control-f for my name. No, Koshi, I will not be useless. This level of activity looks like it will be quite manageable for me to keep up with. Yes, GB,I do deserve your vote at this point in time. I hope to put some time into this game at lunch. All I can say now is ritoky is obviously town, which is funny because I'm currently voting him. Then the rest of your filter is almost all about GB. On December 15 2015 02:51 kushm4sta wrote: K I read everything mostly. Gb is a scummy. He's nitpicking/joking around/ being lazy. Before you say I'm lazier, no. Gigyas, a little concerned with his overserious tone and his post that looked more like summary than analysis. I'll quote it below. On December 15 2015 02:56 kushm4sta wrote: On second thought after rereading his filter I'm not so sure I want to put gigas on my scum list yet. I will wait to see what his scumreads look like. Gb, I'll vote for him when I get a chance. Unless he does something townie. This read on Gig is pretty flippant as well, I'd like to hear what Kush thinks of Gig now. More pushing GB. On December 15 2015 10:31 kushm4sta wrote: Why are we not lynching GB? im confused. On December 15 2015 21:48 kushm4sta wrote: I see no reason not to vote gb. Dunno when flip is but I will try to do some stuff at lunch So Kush spends pretty much all D1 talking about GB, only other real read I see is a TR on Rit. His response after EoD is total shit and doesn't match up with any of his play thus far. Starting to think about a team of Gig/Kush/+1. I haven't forgotten about rereading Rit, I'll prob look at him in my next post. Might not get to that till closer to EoN, but I will get it done. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 17 2015 02:26 kushm4sta wrote: Hi tt I will read gigas. Um I said you should have lynched me? Cause then ivwoildnt have to worry about this game anymore 'll Humm, I can understand that feeling, but thats not really what your other post implied... Let me see what you get on Gig, and your other reads as well. Right now I'd preffer to lynch Vivax tomorrow over anyone else, so you've got some time to do your thing. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
He makes some solid points and shows some clear thinking, but then other times he talks about stuff like he's got some magic mind-meld read on people. The real issue I have with the mind meld stuff is it only works for Rit (as in will never change other people's minds because it's not based on something tangible) and we just have to take his work on those reads. Similarly I think it's kinda shit that he claims "Only girls have a 100% read on LS" which sounds kinda like he's just leaving himself room to change his read on LS. I'm also finding Rit's EoD very lackluster. He was around and responding to some of my posts but other than that he only posts these 2 posts to push his own reads. On December 16 2015 07:33 ritoky wrote: Show nested quote + On December 16 2015 07:29 Shapelog wrote: Well something came up so i won't be here till 8 ish. ##Vote:Kush Voting kush due to lurking and guess what hes lurking. Meta read though, just best right now for me. kush is a bad vote imo On December 16 2015 07:35 ritoky wrote: the fact that the main proponent of kush's lynch (koochi) isn't even voting on kush and he has accumulated more votes than tt or gb did at any point disturbs me greatly. it probably means more likely mafia between gb and tt. It looked like Kush was going to be the lynch right up until I voted and Damdred tried to Shenannie, but this was all Rit did to try and get the lynches he wanted (Myself or GB). It's also pretty shit then how Rit attacks Damdred after EoD for getting GB lynched since GB was his preffered lynch. On December 16 2015 08:10 ritoky wrote: wtf was that damdred? a shennanie with 3 minutes left that you very quickly see and probably knew ahead of time wasn't happening and it hammers a town? wat? On December 16 2015 08:11 ritoky wrote: tt did not hammer gb, damdred did. tt's vote is irrelevant due to kush reaching votes first. without damdred's unvote it is irrelevant. Just feels out of place given Rit wanted to flip GB. Also I must have missed this before, but I'm confused about Rit's read on Kush. His reads post comes first but this was the post I missed: On December 15 2015 19:24 ritoky wrote: if you want me to write the why is kush potentially mafia book it would basically be: he makes good reads that are definitive at the proper time too frequently and probably is a result of extra information. i currently have a lack of desire to go down that rabbit hole cuz he called me town and too right thus scum isn't usually a good day 1 lunchable. also he did a game winning impression of me that i loved. So Kush is potentially mafia, but Rit doesn't want to go down that rabbit hole due to Kush townreading him... I have no idea what the last bit is referring to. It's like he's leaving room for Kush to be mafia but gives a handwavy explanation why he doesn't want to push that. Feels really off especially since Rit goes off to defend Kush pretty hard at EoD. Here we see Rit has Kush as his 2nd most town after Shape On December 15 2015 13:56 ritoky wrote: too many people don't have an opinion on who is mafia. too many null reads. everyone should call someone mafia in their next post and stop wasting time pussyfooting. the time for your pointless shitty information gathering questions is past; form some opinions and stop being less useful than me. shape is town kush is probably town not interested in lynching koshi not interested in lynching damdred not interested in lynching rels no girls in the game so dunno LS alignment tt is probably mafia gb is underwhelming and should be a potential vote gig does the whole not delivering on promises shit every1 else is nai or unremarkable ##vote: glowingbear i am voting on you to piss you off so that you can shit town on me and then i can lynch tt at the eod. please stop being worse than me, cuz if you're worse than me you're probably mafia. He even explains this read to me and defends it when Rels is asking about it kush - had the tr on me at the right time, had the gb read at the right time, told koochi to go fuck himself. On December 15 2015 19:35 ritoky wrote: Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 19:31 Rels wrote: On December 15 2015 19:24 ritoky wrote: if you want me to write the why is kush potentially mafia book it would basically be: he makes good reads that are definitive at the proper time too frequently and probably is a result of extra information. i currently have a lack of desire to go down that rabbit hole cuz he called me town and too right thus scum isn't usually a good day 1 lunchable. also he did a game winning impression of me that i loved. The only townread he posted was on you being obviously town, what do you mean he's right "too frequently" ? Do you think his reason for townreading you ("his long post where he sounds paranoid") was bad ? hey rels, i wanna sell you a brand new car for only $500. + Show Spoiler + there's a catch that's the read. let that blow your mind for an hour while i sleep for 40 minutes and get woken up again cuz babies don't like changes in their local environment and the oddly strong smell of lavender. On December 15 2015 19:45 ritoky wrote: Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 19:38 Rels wrote: On December 15 2015 19:35 ritoky wrote: On December 15 2015 19:31 Rels wrote: On December 15 2015 19:24 ritoky wrote: if you want me to write the why is kush potentially mafia book it would basically be: he makes good reads that are definitive at the proper time too frequently and probably is a result of extra information. i currently have a lack of desire to go down that rabbit hole cuz he called me town and too right thus scum isn't usually a good day 1 lunchable. also he did a game winning impression of me that i loved. The only townread he posted was on you being obviously town, what do you mean he's right "too frequently" ? Do you think his reason for townreading you ("his long post where he sounds paranoid") was bad ? hey rels, i wanna sell you a brand new car for only $500. + Show Spoiler + there's a catch that's the read. let that blow your mind for an hour while i sleep for 40 minutes and get woken up again cuz babies don't like changes in their local environment and the oddly strong smell of lavender. I don't understand one "he makes good reads that are definitive at the proper time too frequently" can refer to only one read ? gb, me, gigays, response to koochi. plz click filter b4 needling about pointless things. I've already discussed the weird townread on Shape, and I saw shape make a big tinfoil case on Rit regarding it (need to read that better, only had time to skim it) so that is another point to consider here. On the other hand Rit's push on me had some good explanations even if it's just making a big deal of me reevaluating my thoughts, and the way that he was interacting with me near EoD feels pretty geniune. The first part looks very towny to me, especially the bolded: On December 14 2015 18:14 ritoky wrote: reasons: shape is town cuz he went derpies. mafia doesn't go derpies over a missed joke and mafia doesn't go derpies while not reading the setup/roles. shape went derpies over those things thus town. i thought tt made same read as me, thus he is town. he then retracted his read so clearly he was not inside my brain lobe and is no longer town. his retracted read gives a null read that is even-handed. it is horse shit. it treats shape's alignment less than 12 hours into the game as some dynamic puzzle or something. it just feels like forced fabricated gray goo; plus there's no point to it other than maybe he realized he is tring someone he can ml. you said you liked 1 post, do you really need that much explanation to downgrade to null? overexplainers anonymous released demographics recently and turns out 70% of members are mafia. his questions don't feel like they are headed to conclusions his response to kush is awkward; it feels like he wants to make a joke but wants to be srs. too considered of a response. he pings lurkers, statistics have something to say about this and the propensity of it leading to mafia. + Show Spoiler + I still don't get why everyone blows up at me for thinking about NAI or null things out loud, but I guess I should learn to change that up. Last game GB and Vivax tunneled me the shit out of me D1 for a very similar post, here it is so you can compare for yourself. On November 25 2015 09:04 Tictock wrote: Show nested quote + On November 25 2015 08:48 sicklucker wrote: On November 25 2015 08:46 Chromatically wrote: On November 25 2015 08:43 sicklucker wrote: On November 25 2015 08:09 Chromatically wrote: I'm more interested in if he thinks FF is mafia for that? ya probably. Hes afraid he will be outed and coming clean will gain him town cred. Theres no way ff smurfed to reveal himself the 80% of the time he rolled town. It makes no sense... Espiecally since I have never seen him get mafia in like 15 games with him... lynch ff for sanity Hmm, I had the opposite reaction. Why would he be afraid of being outed as a smurf? Ok so ff has a very high perecentage of rolling town. Town is like 80% of the players. Why would he make a smurf when hes only getting mafia like 23% of the time or whatever. Especially when he historically never gets mafia anyway.. lol.. Hmm? You might have a point here, especially revealing so early before he could even see the affects of smurfing. FF tends to play fairly lazily the first few days and picks it up later. Maybe he rolled mafia and was worried people would push him early on? Course all of this is assuming it's actually FF and not someone trying to mind game us early... that's pretty tinfoily though and would be a pretty silly play. Gunna put this down as slightly suspect but possibly NAI for now. He talks about his read on me again here: On December 15 2015 19:24 ritoky wrote: if you want me to write the why tt is potentially mafia book it would basically be: he tr shape for good reason (i thought) at proper time and when it was popular, then backed out of it for a bad/no reason when it was popular, was awkward, then has basically snap conceded/fucked off in the face of me wanting to lynch him. The bolded line is not true iirc. I think Shape pointed this out at some point as well, but I was one of the first people to dislike Shapes early posting and the shit about "Snap conceded/fucked off" is obviously laughable now. So in this post Rit is inventing reasons to scum read me. While lining up one of his own townreads as a potential scum and is pushing a now confirmed townie. I didn't even realize when I started anylizing that post how fucking shit it was. But now that I've looked over #393 pretty carefully I see Rit is pushing 3 mislynchs there while inventing reasons to push them. I've seen Rit play rather strongly as mafia before in the Newbie game I ran, he is rather good at it. Look this shit over though I think Rit is a soild chance at scum here. Which brings me up to 3-4 scum reads now in Gig/Rit/Vivax/ and maybe Kush. I think I need to get back to solidifying my townreads because right now I think if we lynch out these people we win the game. According to OP I can donate my posts If a decent majority vote yes, I'm looking at 5 pages/filter per cycle, post donations (per Ver) up to 15 posts allowed per player. Filters allow us to keep track of this as has done past games. This is the last of my time today as I have to head to my 2nd job soon. So I'm giving the rest of my posts to Shape. ##Donate 15 posts to Shapelog | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Which brings me up to 3-4 scum reads now in Gig/Rit/Vivax/ and one of Kush. Is not exactly where my reads are, Kush/Onegu/Tube are all more null than scum right now. I'll do an updated list when I have time tonight. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 17 2015 07:32 Shapelog wrote: Vivax. Your new name is Vobby. After Dobby the house elf from Harry potter for your unending will to serve your master Koshius In the quest to kill the Scum Eatters! Damm I want to make a drawing now showing GiygaS Khan as Khan, Vobby and Koshius, and me, Shapanders. Might kickstart this. I'm so fucking glad I gave you more posts, lmao. And you should totally do this | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 17 2015 08:01 Blazinghand wrote: [/center]ritoky, a chocolate bar (Miller), had been chewed up by rats. Dammit, well so much for that last big post I made. I should really learn my lesson and lay off the tinfoil... Humm, I'm tempted to say that was was to promote WIFOM on myself and Damdred. I was kinda expecting a shot on Koshi since almost everyone reads him as town. Funny thing is I did shoot Rit N1 in my only scum game, uhh dam what was it called again... oh yea Holy Guardians. Humm... Nope... I'm not going to tinfoil this time. + Show Spoiler + I probably still will Anyways, I disagree with Koshi. Vivax needs to play the game or GTFO. ##Vote: Vivax | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 17 2015 08:46 kushm4sta wrote: So that's got to look good for me right? A townie saved me. Rit's vote had very little to do with influencing how EoD1 turned out. So him flipping town doesn't mean anything about you. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I tried to read it but I've worked a split shift at one job today (opened at 4am, then was back from 5-8pm) and worked at my 2nd job in between my brain is fried. I'll save it for tomorrow and try to make sense of the broken quotes. I'll give EoD another read tomorrow and then take a look at all these cases about Rels and from Rels. Thankfully I have some days off coming up so I'll have plenty of time this phase. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 17 2015 13:03 Tubesock wrote: @Tictock - I get the policy vote. I mean it's kinda not since 2 full days of nothing is lurking at a new level. But with Ritoky flipping town, does that mean your scum team is me/GiygaS/Vivax? To the world, doing a crew change today so while I'm not working I'm going to be in an out for the next few hours. You are still Null kus I didn't feel like there was enough content from you yet to try and make a read (or at least nothing jumped out at me from what I'd read up to today). I'll try to take a closer look at your posts tomorrow when my brain is not fried. My vote on Vivax is slightly more than policy, but right now I'll call it pressure as Vivax posting more should help us read him better as either alignment. (I mentioned my reason for scum reading him sometime during Night, if anyone wants to dig that up). Gig hasn't done or said anything to really change my read, I'm more than happy to reevaluate sometime later though. Kush is on my radar as well, but I'm kinda waffeling on him. Rels and Damdred are worth rereading sometime here as well. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 17 2015 13:26 Shapelog wrote: What WoT btw? WoT = Wall o' Text I haven't seen anyone post something that huge in a long time. Though if you get time (and you seem to have a bit on your hands) you should check my mega posts from my... 2nd? I think? Newbie game here. I tunneled the shit out of a town!Plotspot who managed to RB the mafia kill target 3/4 nights and I was convinced was fakeclaiming ( I was Masons with Breske that game). I did 3 mega posts that I prob spent like 3-4 hours putting together showing how my tinfoil fit perfectly. I was dead wrong >.< Sorry I'm not posting anything helpful, just responding to stuff. I'm gunna call it a night. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 06:39 kushm4sta wrote: tubesock i just realized you put my in a position of hard defending damdred when my townread of him really isn't super strong. Especially him asking for 3 filters isn't really that townie. Also I am rethinking his case on rels, now that I myself have read rels and don't really agree. Kush who is your top scum right now? D1 you were very quick to vote and pushed GB while ignoring a lot of the game. Today I see you going around giving out townreads. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I saw Koshi and Shape saying his reads are too convienent. As in they either flow with thread sentiment or are OMGUS based. Am I missing something or is that it? Sorry I should just reread the cases myself, but Rels hasn't really pinged my radar too much besides some of the meta cases. I'll review the stuff between Rels and Tube as I dont have any read on Tube yet besides him seeming more egaged today. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 17 2015 13:44 GiygaS wrote: Gonna back off shape for time being after his recent activity. Still don't have him as scum but he's not my first choice (still tt in my head but I'll have to go over filter tomorrow to see why everyone else has changed their mind on him, his cases EoD1 didn't seem all that great) Are these your only reads still? And are you backing off Shape just based on his activity or was it something more specific? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 07:48 Shapelog wrote: Wow its amazing what happens if you type something, make a sidenote, and then end up typing it again. "and the fact every time we mention it, he would...." is the correct thought process It's cool I could understand the general flow of your post. The nicknames are getting a bit ridiculous and hard to follow though... Anyways, that is a bit unusual from Rels but it doesn't make him confirmed scum like Koshi was saying. I mean I've had a tendency to let OMGUS influence my reads (see Rit) more than I should so that in itself is fairly NAI. Still I'll devote some time to looking that stuff over tongiht. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I like some of the pushes and questions he asks early on (several of them were questions I had reading through the game as well). I kinda gave him a pass based on some of this early activity and the fact that he wasn't really trying to buddy anyone or lead the thread like I've seen him do as scum. His first list post seems odd to me, like it's a pile of unfounded townreads. On December 16 2015 05:26 Rels wrote: Reading the thread I had these as town Town LS Shape sukrit Maybe town Koshi ritoky I would lynch TT Damdred or TS right now. giygas wasn't as bad as I thought. The others I have no idea atm. LS is his top town based off the meta that LS never uses Caps as scum. This is the first time Rels mentions Shape and Sukrit(Onegu). The Koshi read is a bit odd too here, because Rels last post to Koshi was this On December 15 2015 19:07 Rels wrote: Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 19:04 Koshi wrote: I haven no clue on how good Damdred can read LS. I also don't give a fuck about it. He can be wrong. 1) Weak that you lose your suspicion of LS due to 1 capslock sentence. But I can see it possible coming from town Rels after waking up. 2) I really don't see how it makes him mafia. GaygiS Khan never claimed he is certain you are mafia, he admits it is a bit of a pressure vote as well. You are/ were not a bad place to put a pressure vote on. I liked the play. Well you should appreciate the pressure back when all he had to show for rereading the game and filters was one case that was wrong. Or you're scum with him. After that Rels is more focused on Me and Damdred, and then suddenly Koshi is probably town? I suppose Rels never actually accused Koshi of being scum, just implied he might be, but I can see a tr like this coming from a scum!Rels wanting Koshi to back off. Rit is probably the read that makes the most sense here since Rels has been agreeing with his case on me and Rels questioned Rit on a few points. It's interesting then that Rit ends up last on this list then. A post like this is pretty meaningless, since it's just a list of people with no reasons, besides those I can assume. It's also a nice post to make as scum since it makes it look like you are trying to get townreads but unfounded reads like these are really easy to flip later on. It's also really Ironic that Rels made this post after scumreading Damdred for doing the same thing. On December 16 2015 05:20 Rels wrote: I think Damdred is scum. Damdred is not invested in the game, which is already a big indicator. Damdred usually plays D1 by finding townreads, and lynching the one not in his town list. Here I have the distinct impression he tried to replicate that but failed. He has a couple of easy townreads that are not mostly based on nothing: Overall though I feel like Rels was rather involved with EoD. On December 16 2015 06:03 Rels wrote: ritoky a word on Damdred please ? This is actually an interesting post because if Rels is scum he knows that Rit is town here, which if Rels is pushing a town!Damdred might be a risky move. Rit and Damdred used to be known for having a strong Soul read on each other, Rit even mentioned it himself. So if scum!Rels were trying to push a ML here he probably wouldn't want to get Rit's input. This probably sounds like a load of WIFOM, but I think it's actually somewhat solid. I also don't think it makes any sense for Rels and Damdred to both be scum here, there was no reason for Rels to make a case on Damdred after asking this: On December 16 2015 05:00 Rels wrote: yo I'm there, we shoudl consolidate. Why are people voting for people ? TT I know why and I agree. GB are the things on the others ? Also Rels voted for Kush and it looked very likely that Kush was going to be lynched, if we are going down the road of scum!Damdred voted Vivax to protect Kush then there is absolutly no way that Rels is scum with him. So 100% Rels and Damdred are never scum together this game This gets me to Rel's response to Tube's case. This post might be huge but for clarity here are the posts I'm reffering too: Tube's Post#719 with his Rels read + Show Spoiler + Rel's Response(#724) to the case + Show Spoiler + The first part is about Rel's LS read, which I agree is a weak read. However, the way Tube talks about Rels backing off from the fight feels wrong. There wasn't a fight at all, LS posted all caps in response to Damdred and Rels used the meta read that LS never does that as mafia to tr him there. Now I think that's a bad reason to think LS is town, I mean how hard is it to hold the SHIFT key or tap Caps Lock and go "WTF?!? WHY YOU DO THAT!?!?!?"? I think it was Kush who pointed out that scum!Rels prob wouldn't flip LS to town so easly, and give up on mislynching him. While that is a decent line of thinking I can also see Scum!Rels make the meta read on LS, then see the caps and think "Shit now meta points to town" and quickly flip his read. Humm I think I see what Tube was getting at with this LS read, but I don't think this makes Rels scum. Tube making the point about Rels catching Onegu smurfing is definitly off though. Even if Tube is sitting there scratching his head about how Rels did that it makes far less sense that Rels would out his partners smurf than Rels took the time to search games. The rest of Tubes case I can understand. Rels early case on LS was pretty shit, his early reads on me and gig were largely based on other's cases or OMGUS. I also agree that if Kush flips mafia then Rels is town as his vote was too early to be a bus when he could have easily tried to push back to me or onto GB. I'm not so sure that Kush flipping town makes Rels more likely to be mafia. I agree with Rels there that if D1 lynch was Town v Town then mafia are not likely to have been very involved. Continueing to look at the exchanges between Tube and Rels here. Tube's response (#747) to Rels starts off talking about the Caps Lock stuff. The caps lock reasons are pure teasing you. What you are saying is that I am also solely TRing Koshi because he had 1 post near EOD that was all caps lock. That's silly. I am most definitely NOT TRing LS because he had half a post that was caps. But I did want to check it. First I saw he didn't use it as scum but then I wondered if he did as town. So, I checked that too. I still think it's a silly reason so I made fun of you for it. For the record I TR LS for his comfortable tone and he has a bigger filter than I think mafiaLS would. I may have stated before but for LS I don't pay too much attention until D2.5/3 because then he is OBVIOUS. His caps lock statement was NAI. Even though he hasn't done it in his 4 scum games, I think he's entirely capable of it. So it's NAI, but apparently for you it overcomes a SHOCKING difference. The bolded line I 100% agree with however the first part of this kinda feels like Tube is backtracking a little on his point there. Though if Tube is scum here I'm not sure why he would decide to start a fight with Rels of all players, especially when Tube thinks Rels will not backdown easily. I disagree that Rels was uninvolved in D1 lynch though and him making a case on Damdred is a decent sign of that. I think Tube is focusing more on Rels vote on Kush: On December 16 2015 06:48 Rels wrote: Whatever OK to lynch kush. I don't think GB is likely to flip scum. ##Unvote ##Vote kushm4sta Which is a pretty flippant vote but it also sounds a little frustrated that nobody will listen. Maybe I just sympathize here kus my push on Gig was just as ineffective. Looking at the Stuff between Rels and Koshi (and especially since I've proven to myself that a Damdred/Rels team is never a thing here) I can totally understand Rel's frustration. What Koshi is pushing here really makes no sense. As for Rels himself... well I actually do see him possibly being scum this game. I pointed out theres some contradictions in his case on Damdred, but I also think it's interesting Rels didn't reffernce Season of the Witch 2 since his case is largely based on meta. SotW2 had Rels and Damdred as scum and Damdred was playing a rather inactive game there, so if Rels thinks Damdred is doing the same thing here I would think he should want to pull up meta from that game on Damdred. The stuff about his reads besides Damdred being based on thread sentiment or OMGUS is true. I think Damdred pointed out that town!Rels likes to dog people about questions, maybe everyone has just done a good job responding to him this game but I haven't see him doing that here. I'm also used to Rels making more cases based on non-meta stuff, but I have seen him falling into these kinds of reads more and more. Still I can't seem to let go of a gut feeling that Rels is town here due how he's been interacting with people and not trying to set himself up to look good. Honestly I think I'd like to give Rels more time to try and Read him a little better. Having said that I have to admit there are some decent points put against him, if I had to pick between Rels and Damdred I think I would prefer Rels. I'd still rather lynch Vivax or Gig before either of them. I know Gig says he's busy for a couple more days due to finals but I can't help but feel like it's an excuse since he's basically said he has no reads besides thinking I'm scum for stuff Rit said. Since I seem to be one of the minority concerned about Gig I suppose I'm ok giving him another day. Still if he pulls a Scott here I might get somewhat unbearable later. Actually I'm getting more flashbacks to last game with people's activity dropping off a little more today, hopefully that's not a trend. I've enjoyed the pace we've had thus far. Sorry let me wrap up this mega-post by saying I think I need to filter dive Tube next. Based on my last catching up read of the game I like how much he's been putting into the game today and him pushing on Rels as opposed to an afk Vivax or less active Gig or Kush (hell Onegu and to a less extent Damdred actually fall into this category today) seems fairly towny to me. Still a couple of things Rels pointed out clicked with me so I should investigate further. Right now my gut is telling me Rels vs Tube is town v town, but I could see one of them being mafia here. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I still feel better lynching Vivax today. Playing around Modkills is shit, and based on the fact that Vivax came in EoD1 to sheep Koshi and make a couple of "content" posts I don't think there's any reason to think he wont do the same today. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 10:29 Damdred wrote: Yeah koshi is just deranged and can't come up with a real answer. The correct answer is town do weird things all of the time because shenanigans or failed ones happen all of the time. Town don't care about the light mafia do for the most part. And koshi uses the it was important for town progression that gb or kush was lynched, that's beyond stupid since one of then was lynched. Please lynch me,this phase Damdred why are you pulling a Moosy with all this "lynch me plz" crap? I didn't think you were the type of person to roll over like this. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 10:46 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 10:38 Shapelog wrote: I mean maybe to buy town cred idk, that like the only thing i can think of right now. expanding. Like he could of gave me the posts because he knew i was going to talk about Rik? Then maybe shot Rik? Doubt it but going to wait before i jump to conclusions. Might make a scum/town case against/for him. I gave you posts kus I wasn't going to be able to use them and you were the only person to have maxed out their posting. On December 18 2015 10:57 GiygaS wrote: Don't think about it man, the situation is completely WIFOM. You're better off spending time looking at other things, otherwise you'll just go in circles. This is fairly accurate, but tbh I would probably do that as either alignment. Gigas gets a little towncred here for not trying to push this to further his scumread on me. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
So expect varying quility of posts incoming | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Sucks he joined the game late. He's had both a fixation on Rels and Caps Locks all game. On December 15 2015 15:45 Tubesock wrote: I didn't notice the time change. I think LightningStrike kinda falls into the Chezinu Rule (weird posters get attacked by mafia since they are so easy to lynch). I really didn't like how he came in scummed LS and bailed. Koshi has good points on him too. Plus, maybe he will spew townbows. ##Vote: Rels But I don't really agree with Chez rule tbh, but maybe. Rels instant meta case on LS was super early and a few people had voted LS like right off the bat. If you do use Chez rule this game with a cheztitute of LS, Shape broke it first. So yea. Also a little proud of "cheztitute" I'm also not a fan of Tube throwing his vote away D1, but he also wasn't around EoD. I would say he shoulda pushed Rels more if his vote was gunna stay there, but that's exactly what Tube has done today so thats cool. The stuff I saw in Rels filter about Tube didn't convince me and nothing is jumping out in my own read here. I don't really agree with his push on Rels, but he has pointed out a few things I didn't catch. Gunna stick with my gut read from before that Tube and Rels are both town. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 17 2015 13:08 Sukrit wrote: I will have free time in a bit and read everything. Ritoky is a really random kill imo. Onegu where have you been all day? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 15:43 Tubesock wrote: I don't think we gain anything from lynching Vivax today. If he's town it's "well he lurked like crazy!" if he's mafia it'll be "mafia had to bus!" and then more posts about feels and some bickering but we have no more information than we had the day before. I also like the idea of forcing him to post and vote every cycle or be modkilled with the punishment associated with it. If he's town we don't have a mlynch. If he's mafia then they have to think about when he might be cop checked or followed so we can waste a power maybe. Ok, mostly it's so he can face a ban. Because not playing at all like this is bullshit. (Sorry if you're sick or hurt or something) Let's band together and pledge to lynch him Day 4 (or something) if he can avoid modkill that long. And I want to lynch Rels. Ehh... idk if I agree about this tbh. However, I will admit that putting a pressure vote on someone who isn't here is stupid, besides I think plenty of people are ok with sheannies onto him. ##Unvote I'm not voting Rels though. I'm not even sure I want to lynch Gig anymore. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 14 2015 08:09 Koshi wrote: I ll keep my filter low this game. Just going to focus on cases and finding mafia. Not making excuses but my game might be trash. We will see. But I will not be buddied. disclaimer: don't expect too much though. Will probably still be pretty low content stuff. Koshi now with an 8 page filter... Lol On December 16 2015 07:59 Koshi wrote: Vivax is impossble and fucking no information in there if he flips town. What the fuck are you doing Damdred. You fucker. Koshi why do you keep siding with Vivax based on nothing? I know you did this last game as town, but there he at least went bonkers when I pushed him. What has he done to deserve you defending him like you have this game? Also you've ebeen pretty sure Rels and Damred are mafia together today, but I think I showed why thats not possible in my big wall back there. What do you think about them now? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 14:52 Damdred wrote: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 14:02 Tictock wrote: Humm, so reading through Rels filter again he's been fairly aggressive this game. I like some of the pushes and questions he asks early on (several of them were questions I had reading through the game as well). I kinda gave him a pass based on some of this early activity and the fact that he wasn't really trying to buddy anyone or lead the thread like I've seen him do as scum. His first list post seems odd to me, like it's a pile of unfounded townreads. On December 16 2015 05:26 Rels wrote: Reading the thread I had these as town Town LS Shape sukrit Maybe town Koshi ritoky I would lynch TT Damdred or TS right now. giygas wasn't as bad as I thought. The others I have no idea atm. LS is his top town based off the meta that LS never uses Caps as scum. This is the first time Rels mentions Shape and Sukrit(Onegu). The Koshi read is a bit odd too here, because Rels last post to Koshi was this On December 15 2015 19:07 Rels wrote: On December 15 2015 19:04 Koshi wrote: I haven no clue on how good Damdred can read LS. I also don't give a fuck about it. He can be wrong. 1) Weak that you lose your suspicion of LS due to 1 capslock sentence. But I can see it possible coming from town Rels after waking up. 2) I really don't see how it makes him mafia. GaygiS Khan never claimed he is certain you are mafia, he admits it is a bit of a pressure vote as well. You are/ were not a bad place to put a pressure vote on. I liked the play. Well you should appreciate the pressure back when all he had to show for rereading the game and filters was one case that was wrong. Or you're scum with him. After that Rels is more focused on Me and Damdred, and then suddenly Koshi is probably town? I suppose Rels never actually accused Koshi of being scum, just implied he might be, but I can see a tr like this coming from a scum!Rels wanting Koshi to back off. Rit is probably the read that makes the most sense here since Rels has been agreeing with his case on me and Rels questioned Rit on a few points. It's interesting then that Rit ends up last on this list then. A post like this is pretty meaningless, since it's just a list of people with no reasons, besides those I can assume. It's also a nice post to make as scum since it makes it look like you are trying to get townreads but unfounded reads like these are really easy to flip later on. It's also really Ironic that Rels made this post after scumreading Damdred for doing the same thing. On December 16 2015 05:20 Rels wrote: I think Damdred is scum. Damdred is not invested in the game, which is already a big indicator. Damdred usually plays D1 by finding townreads, and lynching the one not in his town list. Here I have the distinct impression he tried to replicate that but failed. He has a couple of easy townreads that are not mostly based on nothing: Overall though I feel like Rels was rather involved with EoD. On December 16 2015 06:03 Rels wrote: ritoky a word on Damdred please ? This is actually an interesting post because if Rels is scum he knows that Rit is town here, which if Rels is pushing a town!Damdred might be a risky move. Rit and Damdred used to be known for having a strong Soul read on each other, Rit even mentioned it himself. So if scum!Rels were trying to push a ML here he probably wouldn't want to get Rit's input. This probably sounds like a load of WIFOM, but I think it's actually somewhat solid. I also don't think it makes any sense for Rels and Damdred to both be scum here, there was no reason for Rels to make a case on Damdred after asking this: On December 16 2015 05:00 Rels wrote: yo I'm there, we shoudl consolidate. Why are people voting for people ? TT I know why and I agree. GB are the things on the others ? Also Rels voted for Kush and it looked very likely that Kush was going to be lynched, if we are going down the road of scum!Damdred voted Vivax to protect Kush then there is absolutly no way that Rels is scum with him. So 100% Rels and Damdred are never scum together this game This gets me to Rel's response to Tube's case. This post might be huge but for clarity here are the posts I'm reffering too: Tube's Post#719 with his Rels read + Show Spoiler + Rel's Response(#724) to the case + Show Spoiler + The first part is about Rel's LS read, which I agree is a weak read. However, the way Tube talks about Rels backing off from the fight feels wrong. There wasn't a fight at all, LS posted all caps in response to Damdred and Rels used the meta read that LS never does that as mafia to tr him there. Now I think that's a bad reason to think LS is town, I mean how hard is it to hold the SHIFT key or tap Caps Lock and go "WTF?!? WHY YOU DO THAT!?!?!?"? I think it was Kush who pointed out that scum!Rels prob wouldn't flip LS to town so easly, and give up on mislynching him. While that is a decent line of thinking I can also see Scum!Rels make the meta read on LS, then see the caps and think "Shit now meta points to town" and quickly flip his read. Humm I think I see what Tube was getting at with this LS read, but I don't think this makes Rels scum. Tube making the point about Rels catching Onegu smurfing is definitly off though. Even if Tube is sitting there scratching his head about how Rels did that it makes far less sense that Rels would out his partners smurf than Rels took the time to search games. The rest of Tubes case I can understand. Rels early case on LS was pretty shit, his early reads on me and gig were largely based on other's cases or OMGUS. I also agree that if Kush flips mafia then Rels is town as his vote was too early to be a bus when he could have easily tried to push back to me or onto GB. I'm not so sure that Kush flipping town makes Rels more likely to be mafia. I agree with Rels there that if D1 lynch was Town v Town then mafia are not likely to have been very involved. Continueing to look at the exchanges between Tube and Rels here. Tube's response (#747) to Rels starts off talking about the Caps Lock stuff. The caps lock reasons are pure teasing you. What you are saying is that I am also solely TRing Koshi because he had 1 post near EOD that was all caps lock. That's silly. I am most definitely NOT TRing LS because he had half a post that was caps. But I did want to check it. First I saw he didn't use it as scum but then I wondered if he did as town. So, I checked that too. I still think it's a silly reason so I made fun of you for it. For the record I TR LS for his comfortable tone and he has a bigger filter than I think mafiaLS would. I may have stated before but for LS I don't pay too much attention until D2.5/3 because then he is OBVIOUS. His caps lock statement was NAI. Even though he hasn't done it in his 4 scum games, I think he's entirely capable of it. So it's NAI, but apparently for you it overcomes a SHOCKING difference. The bolded line I 100% agree with however the first part of this kinda feels like Tube is backtracking a little on his point there. Though if Tube is scum here I'm not sure why he would decide to start a fight with Rels of all players, especially when Tube thinks Rels will not backdown easily. I disagree that Rels was uninvolved in D1 lynch though and him making a case on Damdred is a decent sign of that. I think Tube is focusing more on Rels vote on Kush: On December 16 2015 06:48 Rels wrote: Whatever OK to lynch kush. I don't think GB is likely to flip scum. ##Unvote ##Vote kushm4sta Which is a pretty flippant vote but it also sounds a little frustrated that nobody will listen. Maybe I just sympathize here kus my push on Gig was just as ineffective. Looking at the Stuff between Rels and Koshi (and especially since I've proven to myself that a Damdred/Rels team is never a thing here) I can totally understand Rel's frustration. What Koshi is pushing here really makes no sense. As for Rels himself... well I actually do see him possibly being scum this game. I pointed out theres some contradictions in his case on Damdred, but I also think it's interesting Rels didn't reffernce Season of the Witch 2 since his case is largely based on meta. SotW2 had Rels and Damdred as scum and Damdred was playing a rather inactive game there, so if Rels thinks Damdred is doing the same thing here I would think he should want to pull up meta from that game on Damdred. The stuff about his reads besides Damdred being based on thread sentiment or OMGUS is true. I think Damdred pointed out that town!Rels likes to dog people about questions, maybe everyone has just done a good job responding to him this game but I haven't see him doing that here. I'm also used to Rels making more cases based on non-meta stuff, but I have seen him falling into these kinds of reads more and more. Still I can't seem to let go of a gut feeling that Rels is town here due how he's been interacting with people and not trying to set himself up to look good. Honestly I think I'd like to give Rels more time to try and Read him a little better. Having said that I have to admit there are some decent points put against him, if I had to pick between Rels and Damdred I think I would prefer Rels. I'd still rather lynch Vivax or Gig before either of them. I know Gig says he's busy for a couple more days due to finals but I can't help but feel like it's an excuse since he's basically said he has no reads besides thinking I'm scum for stuff Rit said. Since I seem to be one of the minority concerned about Gig I suppose I'm ok giving him another day. Still if he pulls a Scott here I might get somewhat unbearable later. Actually I'm getting more flashbacks to last game with people's activity dropping off a little more today, hopefully that's not a trend. I've enjoyed the pace we've had thus far. Sorry let me wrap up this mega-post by saying I think I need to filter dive Tube next. Based on my last catching up read of the game I like how much he's been putting into the game today and him pushing on Rels as opposed to an afk Vivax or less active Gig or Kush (hell Onegu and to a less extent Damdred actually fall into this category today) seems fairly towny to me. Still a couple of things Rels pointed out clicked with me so I should investigate further. Right now my gut is telling me Rels vs Tube is town v town, but I could see one of them being mafia here. I hate posts like this most the time they come from scum meh Some of the time they come from Town This is a weak post Damdred. Does this post make you think I'm scum or not? What about it does? Kus you seem to imply that. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 18:02 Tubesock wrote: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 17:56 Tictock wrote: On December 18 2015 15:43 Tubesock wrote: I don't think we gain anything from lynching Vivax today. If he's town it's "well he lurked like crazy!" if he's mafia it'll be "mafia had to bus!" and then more posts about feels and some bickering but we have no more information than we had the day before. I also like the idea of forcing him to post and vote every cycle or be modkilled with the punishment associated with it. If he's town we don't have a mlynch. If he's mafia then they have to think about when he might be cop checked or followed so we can waste a power maybe. Ok, mostly it's so he can face a ban. Because not playing at all like this is bullshit. (Sorry if you're sick or hurt or something) Let's band together and pledge to lynch him Day 4 (or something) if he can avoid modkill that long. And I want to lynch Rels. Ehh... idk if I agree about this tbh. However, I will admit that putting a pressure vote on someone who isn't here is stupid, besides I think plenty of people are ok with sheannies onto him. ##Unvote I'm not voting Rels though. I'm not even sure I want to lynch Gig anymore. What changed your mind about GiygaS? Does that mean Damdred or Kush4masta is on the table? On December 18 2015 14:30 Tictock wrote: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 10:46 Shapelog wrote: On December 18 2015 10:38 Shapelog wrote: I mean maybe to buy town cred idk, that like the only thing i can think of right now. expanding. Like he could of gave me the posts because he knew i was going to talk about Rik? Then maybe shot Rik? Doubt it but going to wait before i jump to conclusions. Might make a scum/town case against/for him. I gave you posts kus I wasn't going to be able to use them and you were the only person to have maxed out their posting. Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 10:57 GiygaS wrote: Don't think about it man, the situation is completely WIFOM. You're better off spending time looking at other things, otherwise you'll just go in circles. This is fairly accurate, but tbh I would probably do that as either alignment. Gigas gets a little towncred here for not trying to push this to further his scumread on me. I'm also tempted to give him the leeway he's asking for Finals. Idk, I am a little paranoid he's pulling what Scott did last game as scum with just a bit more activity, but he's been fairly open about his thoughts. So at least giving him more time will produce more content. Idk wtf Damdred is doing today. Not having much time is one thing but I'm not really seeing very good posts from him either with his cries to lynch him when Koshi pushes. Kush seems to be making an effort today. There's the couple of weird things I bugged him about but I've like his responses. Him making townreads is actually a good thing, I just wanted to see how he reacted to me pointing out the shift in behavior. Bah Idk, Damdred might be an ok lynch. Onegu suddenly dropping off after his D1 is weird but idk if that's alignment indicative. It sucks this is 2 games in a row with multiple inactive people. I mean this game is better by a landslide thanMansion was but I was hoping we'd keep the pace from D1 going. I can't believe that there isn't mafia in the lurkers at this point. Especially since I kinda think Kush is town and D1 was all town wagons. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Think thats a sign to call it a nigh. I'll be around for EoD. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Apparently drunk me forgot to use the voting thread to Unvote. Fixed. Catching up now. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 20:05 Sukrit wrote: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 05:51 Tubesock wrote: On December 16 2015 07:51 Sukrit wrote: Kush is a terrible lynch. I agree with GB's reads so I dont really want to lynch him. At this point it is TT for me. ##unvote ##Vote: Ticktock On December 16 2015 13:48 Sukrit wrote: On December 16 2015 04:18 Koshi wrote: Onegu. Let's be honest here. I read you filter. It is filled with randomness and koshi accusation. I see 1 read on TT, and I see some Shape pressure. The Shape thing is not bad, I don't think he is mafia, but the pressure is not horrible. Anyway. I promise to not go off on you in this game anymore. And I will my VERY BEST to help you solve this game. The best help I can give you is to stop focusing on me. I am not mafia. You can still push me as much as you want, but I will not reply to it too much, I will just explain myself, but if you want your filter to look good endgame, you really should stop. Last game I tried to tilt you. And I deserve some of what I got here because of it. This game I am not trolling, I am not trying to make you upset. And I will continue to not troll this game. I am not ready to drop my scummy read on you. But I am not really interested in lynching you tomorrow either. I prolly should have voted kush I would have rather lost him than GB but meh. Vivax was maybe the best lynch option and was put up way to late. In the past I have enjoyed playing with you koshi and hope to still enjoy playing with you in the future but comeon. I am not giving up my shape read. Onegu gut read! Can you talk about the underline. Why did you oppose the Kush lynch during it, never say anything about not wanting to lynch GB and then say you would have rather lost Kush? Seems like you were there throughout it. Also, has the gut read changed on Shape? Will post here. Not my big post. Kush is never a good day one lynch. Basically you will never figure him out and it is 26% or what ever the percentage is for rolling scum this game what 3/13. I thought GB was town as all of his reads completely matched mine. I had a town read on GB. And if I had to choose between GB still being in the game or kush I would take GB as he is more likely to figure the game out and actually get the scum lynched where kush no offense has the same problem I do. We cant get people lynched even when we figure the game out. And yes I still really dont like shape. I think he has plenty of free time and typeing walls of text isnt hard for him/her. He is rsoultin I am sure. Rsoultin=Scum Shape=Scum I really don't think this is true. This seems like a really bad assumption to make. Onegu I'm really not following your thinking here at all. You say Shape is Rsoul, thus is mafia and I think shape is a rsoultin smurf and I have stopped reading her posts... Like you have no proof, aren't trying to show why this is true, but are immediately using this smurf idea to tunnel and ignore Shape. You are doing kinda the same thing with Koshi. Koshi proven wrong and still doesnt back off... Could get on the koshi is mafia train. Wait I have been on it for a while. I kinda get this, and it's true Koshi isn't making a lot of sense, but can you explain your thinking a bit better? Like what differentiates town!Koshi from scum!Koshi? Koshi's play looks a lot like his Town game from Mansion, but tbh I've never looked at his scum games. I agree with some of your stream of thoughts post, but it's looking to me like you are forcing yourself to stay tunneled on Shape and Koshi with these half-assed reasons that you don't try to backup. I know you and Koshi will probably tunnel each other regardless of alignment (+ Show Spoiler [tinfoil] + In fact, I could actually see Koshi and Onegu shit fight each other as scum just to shit up the thread and keep in line with expectations. Then plz lynch me. I dont have the clout to lynch you. If people didnt know I was onegu still then maybe I could have gotten you lynched. You are scum and you are going to mislynch me and that is fine would prefer if it was today. Your read on me has going I am 100% scum to I am town and to help you figure the game out back to I am mafia. Your read progression makes zero sense and you have no reason to scum read me other than the fact that I have figured you out. Like Koshi did the same shit as town last game, why wouldn't he do it now? You could probably flip the bolded around too because you seem to always push Koshi. Idk, last game I felt like Onegu was pushing Koshi's buttons just kus he could. This is feeling more like Onegu is just pushing Koshi kus he feels like he should and is inventing reasons to tunnel Shape. I still need to finish my catchup, but I'm thinking Onegu is a solid lynch based off these shit reasons to tunnel people. Funny thing though, I kinda agree about Koshi he's not making much sense today pushing a team of Rels/Damdred/Kush and wanting to lynch Rels who is the least likely member of that team. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 21:39 GiygaS wrote: Can you give more reasoning for wanting to lunch koshi beyond his changed thoughts? His thought process change is completely believable imo based on you two's history/his full on tilt mode yesterday. Noted that you had the exact same reaction to that post as I did. Maybe I've been wrong about Gigas. Between continuing to post after making excuses that he wont have time, and showing that he's thinking through things without rushing to conclusions, I'm gunna move him to a null/townlean. Would still like more developed Reads from ya Gig. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 21:57 Sukrit wrote: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 21:39 GiygaS wrote: Can you give more reasoning for wanting to lunch koshi beyond his changed thoughts? His thought process change is completely believable imo based on you two's history/his full on tilt mode yesterday. How is his thought process believable. He goes from holy shit onegu is scum because of that case kill with fire. To Onegu is town I will do my very best to help figure the game out with him. Back to onegu is scum for the same reason. No reasons changed. Which Koshi did all of last game as Town... so? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 22:13 Koshi wrote: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 18:01 Tictock wrote: On December 14 2015 08:09 Koshi wrote: I ll keep my filter low this game. Just going to focus on cases and finding mafia. Not making excuses but my game might be trash. We will see. But I will not be buddied. disclaimer: don't expect too much though. Will probably still be pretty low content stuff. Koshi now with an 8 page filter... Lol On December 16 2015 07:59 Koshi wrote: Vivax is impossble and fucking no information in there if he flips town. What the fuck are you doing Damdred. You fucker. Koshi why do you keep siding with Vivax based on nothing? I know you did this last game as town, but there he at least went bonkers when I pushed him. What has he done to deserve you defending him like you have this game? Also you've ebeen pretty sure Rels and Damred are mafia together today, but I think I showed why thats not possible in my big wall back there. What do you think about them now? Vivax could be mafia. But he also could be town. Remember how in last game I actually found that GB could not be mafia because of the fefe fiter? And that Chrom was most likely mafia from the fefe filter? Retarded as I am, I didn't follow that information, BUT, that kind of information is HUGE. Also, I think there is a very good chance Damdred flips mafia, Vivax is like 60% due to PoE. Damdred is 60% due to PoE and I got brilliant reasons. So then why are you LYNCHING RELS!?!?! I can see a possible team of Damdred/Kush +1 from the way EoD went. Even though I wasn't voting between the wagons yet I had said I would likely vote GB, so there is a slim chance that scum!Damdred saw that as a chance to save his teammate!Kush and tried to shenannies to put GB in the lead after my vote. It's a little far fetched, but I could see it happening. There is a few other things that actually support this, such as Rit's NK, and the change in behavior from both Damdred and Kush (kush getting more active, Damdred sinking more into the shadows). Rels makes no sense though. Your saing Rels decided to bus both his teammates D1, I don't buy it. Rels has a history of finding alternative lynches and protecting his teammates. I guess maybe he could purposefully make that change to his meta but it seems like such poor mafia play... I don't buy it, not from Rels. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 22:33 Koshi wrote: I hope you are town Onegu. I would enjoy actually seeing you play a game as town. Then you can realize how hard actually playing is. I do not believe rsoultin is so insanely crazy to play as Shape is doing. Totally different stuff. Damdred is mafia. +85% Rels is maybe mafia. But he actually also has pushed the people I think most likely are mafia. Maybe Rels is their powerrole, but I am not going to go into WIFOM lane and I prefer not to lynch Rels atm. Even though the cases on him are believable. Vivax could very well be mafia. But he is not worth lynching in this stage of the game for me. Maybe somebody can shoot him? Kush is looking less and less mafia. But I think he still can be. I cannot shake the feeling he was saved EoD1. I do not think he is mafia with Rels though. Onegu..................................................... I don't know. I just can't read him it seems. You people decide on him. I would lynch him. TT. The reason why TT is mafia: He hasn't solved the game in his mind yet. Or isn't pushing for the solution of the game. I know he does that as town. Just like I do it, I want people to follow my solution. TT normally does the same. But dnu if I want to lynch. Tubesock. I don't think he is mafia. But he is like... the most possible after all these others? others are town Why I don't want to lynch Rels yet: - Rels is being scumread by TT (and Tubesock) and voted Kush, while Kush was saved by TT and Damdred. Somewhere it could be that Rels/TT/Kush are mafia... and then TT saved Kush while Damdred was being pants on head. But because TT is more townie than Damdred, and because EoD1 I think it is way more likely Damdred is mafia. Also general posting of TT >>>> Damdred. all in all... I know I haven't solved the game 100% certain yet. And all my uncertainties kinda push a Rels lynch.... So... I kinda push against that now. Another good reason why Onegu is mafia, he already said a couple times this: If we lynch this guy and he flips this alignment then Koshi is this alignment. You need to fill in names and alignments but I remember him saying: if we lynch TT and TT is scum, koshi is town. if we lynch Rels and Rels is town, we lynch Koshi. And these sentences make me VERY WARY of Onegu................ WTF. Again Koshi is saying he is very sure Damdred is mafia, and here even says he's uncertain about Rels. But he's still voting Rels!?! | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 23:29 Koshi wrote: Yeah. For me there is a very good possibility that Kush/Rels/Damdred are mafia together and that Damded did a yolo play to save Kush. There is something unholy about them. Thats it, this makes no sense. I've brought up plenty of evidence as to why this team can't be possible and Koshi keeps pushing it anyways. He's super certain about Damdred, and is voting Rels. This is a new level of nonsense from Koshi, I don't buy it. ##Vote: Koshi | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 18 2015 23:38 Tubesock wrote: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 23:29 Koshi wrote: Yeah. For me there is a very good possibility that Kush/Rels/Damdred are mafia together and that Damded did a yolo play to save Kush. There is something unholy about them. I think TT ruined their play. If TT stayed on GiygaS then Kush dies. Rels looks great for pushing him earlier. Damdred looks good because the only correct answer is town does shenanies at the end. This doesn't make a lot of sense, why would they bus a teammate like this? Why would Rels bus both teammates. The team is not fucking Rels/Damdred/Kush! Like maybe the stuff I said about how Damdred saw I was planning to vote GB and saw me suggest Vivax so tried to shennanie Vivax to save Kush. That's risky though kus if I had voted Vivax with Damdred then Kush gets lynched anyways. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 02:46 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 01:20 kushm4sta wrote: Here's some tinfoily stuff. On December 17 2015 09:36 Shapelog wrote: Plus killing the person who is defending you seems like only a thing i do. ritoky defended shape. Do not think my actively is actually any alignment indicating for me. Would of been the same activeness roughly if I rolled mafia. Except maybe a bit thought out and better fleshed posts since i had a team to relay things. But then i prob. post dumb, dull, crap time to time because they weren't on lol. what if shape is giving himself away here just as a little wink to himself I really, really, really, really, want to this to be true. Btw you also enter the Tinfoil club with me and TT. Main reason i posted all "I would do this as mafia" so when i play another game and i am not as active you people will lynch me and see that focusing on meta is a secondary reasoning to lynch someone. Bit caught up now. Do not think Vobby is the best lynch today. A Rels or even a Damred flip would be more telling. This sounds like BS, I doubt you'd say that just to go "Gotcha! See meta is shit" after the end of another game... Besides you've been using meta all over the place this game. Though to be fair you've been doing a decent job of not basing a read solely based off of that. This prob doesn't mean anything though kus Self-meta is meh. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 02:51 Koshi wrote: ##unvote ##vote Rels Hmm The big posts from TT looks good enough to follow. I don't think it is scummy at all Kush. Pretty well written. Except you clearly didn't read it kus I was still thinking Rels could be town after that. And I've been showing how Rels doesn't fit in a Damdred/Kush team in that post. So... no dice. I think we lynch koshi and pat Onegu on the back when he flips scum, yes? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 03:52 Damdred wrote: Man I'm being a shitter this game but its ok, the games pretty boring and not many are doing work so I don't feel as bad. idk who I'm voting for maybe no one. Ugh, this play is starting to remind me of what you did in SotW Damdred. Check my questions to ya, who do you want to lynch? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 03:57 Damdred wrote: All today has been basically is stupid play trying to figure out teams when you haven't even flipped one of uscum. Rels while he isn't the model of towniness looks town to me who's only spent maybe a hour or two in the game.... But meh id rather get lynched todya over rels shrug. ...and shit like this isn't helping. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 05:38 Onegu wrote: Fuck I forgot no trolling ignore my previous post. Koshi I have played serious games you were in some of them, then some asshole pissed me off in the game I put the most effort in my mafia life. So I decided it was more important to enjoy myself. Can you try to post on Sukrit plz? If only for filter reasons? Or maybe Mods can add a filter for Onegu's account to the OP since he outed himself? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:04 Koshi wrote: lael y u ignore all posts I give in which I say why rels is mafia? What did I ignore? I don't see anything you've posted other than the XtoY w/e OMGUS voting stuff. Your reasoning on Rels being mafia with Damdred and Kush is so bad, you constantly say you think Damdred is mafia, but you keep focusing on Rels. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:04 GiygaS wrote: TT, any updates on that first part of the game where you quoted LS? Nah, I need to look him over again at some point but I don't think he's scum. I noted that post in case he dropped off. Opening post "Lets lynch scum" into inactivity would have been a scum tell imo, but that's not what LS did. I've only played with LS once or twice before but his posting feels natural and unrestrained, also I don't see any signs he's pushing an agenda. He's not scum. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:11 Koshi wrote: Like.. You don't think Rels is mafia anymore? Entire game you call Rels mafia, and now that I vote Rels over Damdred. I am mafia? Uhh Rels has been a townlean for me all game... Who is bullshitting? I'll do a list post when I get done, right now I'm torn between you and Damdred. I kinda think there has to be scum between you two, right now you are making less sense and Damdred isn't taking the easy option of jumping on Rels, so it's prob you. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:28 GiygaS wrote: Weird timeline thing with rels: - He makes meta case on LS - I make a post about it - He reads through the thread (the infamous caps post), then makes post saying LS is town - OMGUS' on me Ugh, I've been so fucking wishywashy with this, but I'm going to vote Rels ##Vote Rels I'd like to check this, which posts are you referring to? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:32 Damdred wrote: What was the question I missed it wasn't on the last page of your filter that I saw. Lets start with who do you think is scum and who do you want to lynch? We've only got ~ an hour left. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
- Insists Damdred is Mafia, wants to vote Rels who made a case on Damdred D1 - Keeps pushing a team that makes no sense, based only on Damdred's shenannies EoD1 - Very defensive of AFK Vivax for no reason - Shit fighting with Onegu just kus it's Onegu and always pushing him as mafia (like you've got 5 mafia in your lists and seem to want to push them all equally) I think the biggest things here are you ignoring that Rels/Damdred is never a thing, and you keep saying Damdred is scum but push Rels. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Town: 10 Shapelog 13 LightningStrike Prob Town 1 GiygaS 4 Tubesock 3 Rels 8 kushm4sta Null/Unsure 7 Sukrit (more of a scum lean) 9 Damdred Scum 2 Koshi 6 Vivax I think a team of Koshi/Vivax + Onegu fits, but really I'm just thinking Koshi/Vivax is very likely atm. Koshi is never mafia with Damdred here. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:53 Tictock wrote: Koshi is never mafia with Damdred here. Actually maybe this isn't true, it would explain why Koshi is so sure Damdred in scum but is pushing Rels over him. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:57 Sukrit wrote: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 06:53 Tictock wrote: Quick List post Not in Order Town: 10 Shapelog 13 LightningStrike Prob Town 1 GiygaS 4 Tubesock 3 Rels 8 kushm4sta Null/Unsure 7 Sukrit (more of a scum lean) 9 Damdred Scum 2 Koshi 6 Vivax I think a team of Koshi/Vivax + Onegu fits, but really I'm just thinking Koshi/Vivax is very likely atm. Koshi is never mafia with Damdred here. So I bus koshi hard from the start... Given how I've seen you two play before? It's not impossible that you'd both roll scum and tunnel the shit out of each other. Your shape read is really shit btw. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:58 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 06:56 Tubesock wrote: On December 19 2015 06:47 Tictock wrote: I'll get to it Koshi, but here is why I think you are mafia and why people should be voting for you. - Insists Damdred is Mafia, wants to vote Rels who made a case on Damdred D1 - Keeps pushing a team that makes no sense, based only on Damdred's shenannies EoD1 - Very defensive of AFK Vivax for no reason - Shit fighting with Onegu just kus it's Onegu and always pushing him as mafia (like you've got 5 mafia in your lists and seem to want to push them all equally) I think the biggest things here are you ignoring that Rels/Damdred is never a thing, and you keep saying Damdred is scum but push Rels. This isn't true. I already know TT's incoming question, Can you Explain? Also yeah, lately even Koshius is sus. about his house elf friend Vobby. Still null/idk read him i think. Yep. What do you think isn't true? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 07:01 Sukrit wrote: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 06:59 Tictock wrote: On December 19 2015 06:57 Sukrit wrote: On December 19 2015 06:53 Tictock wrote: Quick List post Not in Order Town: 10 Shapelog 13 LightningStrike Prob Town 1 GiygaS 4 Tubesock 3 Rels 8 kushm4sta Null/Unsure 7 Sukrit (more of a scum lean) 9 Damdred Scum 2 Koshi 6 Vivax I think a team of Koshi/Vivax + Onegu fits, but really I'm just thinking Koshi/Vivax is very likely atm. Koshi is never mafia with Damdred here. So I bus koshi hard from the start... Given how I've seen you two play before? It's not impossible that you'd both roll scum and tunnel the shit out of each other. Your shape read is really shit btw. He is scum. I sense you have given up your high effort game. WIFOM makes me think this could be because you think we will scum read you for being active now that we know it's you. Which tells me you care more about how we view you than how the game is progressing. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:45 GiygaS wrote: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 06:41 Tictock wrote: On December 19 2015 06:28 GiygaS wrote: Weird timeline thing with rels: - He makes meta case on LS - I make a post about it - He reads through the thread (the infamous caps post), then makes post saying LS is town - OMGUS' on me Ugh, I've been so fucking wishywashy with this, but I'm going to vote Rels ##Vote Rels I'd like to check this, which posts are you referring to? #269 Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 08:05 Rels wrote: I stayed up for posting this. I thought the deadline was 1 hour earlier. Here is LS filter from the game I just played, in which he was town: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/498635-dark-tournament-mini-mafia?user=LightningStrike Here is his filter from this game: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/499399-tl-mafia-lxxiii-the-nutcracker?user=LightningStrike It's a schocking difference. LS as town in dark tournament mafia posted reads, questionned stuff and overall looked to solve the game. In this game, he had NO game-related post until I asked him for a list of reads. I think this guy is scum. ##Vote LightningStrike #357 Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 15:35 GiygaS wrote: Still looking over everyone, but I'm sort of stuck on rels. Like I just don't understand his play coming from an experienced player (at least I presume he is based on posts). Like in addition to the things Koshi already said about him, his question seemed to go towards this weird meta-lynch on LS. Like look at this post: On December 15 2015 08:05 Rels wrote: I stayed up for posting this. I thought the deadline was 1 hour earlier. Here is LS filter from the game I just played, in which he was town: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/498635-dark-tournament-mini-mafia?user=LightningStrike Here is his filter from this game: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/499399-tl-mafia-lxxiii-the-nutcracker?user=LightningStrike It's a schocking difference. LS as town in dark tournament mafia posted reads, questionned stuff and overall looked to solve the game. In this game, he had NO game-related post until I asked him for a list of reads. I think this guy is scum. ##Vote LightningStrike There's 9 hours between this post and LS replying to his list. In these 9 hours, LS is pretty on top of things, his content isn't isolated to this list that was requested, and they're pretty relevant to the game. I don't think LS is particularly townie, but this is a pretty bullshit case on him. It just feels like rels posted a weird question and then wanted to attach meaning to it so he put up this weird argument that doesn't even make sense. He even ignored that already noted scummy post from LS (the one where he's talking about conserving posts for the filter), the dude he's talking about. #369 Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 18:03 Rels wrote: On December 15 2015 09:48 LightningStrike wrote: On December 15 2015 08:44 Damdred wrote: Ls why should I not vote you ^^. Will be home to read and bomb soon JESUS CHRIST I TOWN THIS GAME TOO THATS WHY. .....LIKE YOU JUST PLAYED WITH ME WHEN I HAD A TERRIBLE DAY 1. Anyways just got done with my last final and will read what I missed after that post. Fuck he's probably town ##Unvote 373 Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 18:14 Rels wrote: On December 15 2015 15:35 GiygaS wrote: Still looking over everyone, but I'm sort of stuck on rels. Like I just don't understand his play coming from an experienced player (at least I presume he is based on posts). Like in addition to the things Koshi already said about him, his question seemed to go towards this weird meta-lynch on LS. Like look at this post: On December 15 2015 08:05 Rels wrote: I stayed up for posting this. I thought the deadline was 1 hour earlier. Here is LS filter from the game I just played, in which he was town: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/498635-dark-tournament-mini-mafia?user=LightningStrike Here is his filter from this game: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/499399-tl-mafia-lxxiii-the-nutcracker?user=LightningStrike It's a schocking difference. LS as town in dark tournament mafia posted reads, questionned stuff and overall looked to solve the game. In this game, he had NO game-related post until I asked him for a list of reads. I think this guy is scum. ##Vote LightningStrike There's 9 hours between this post and LS replying to his list. In these 9 hours, LS is pretty on top of things, his content isn't isolated to this list that was requested, and they're pretty relevant to the game. I don't think LS is particularly townie, but this is a pretty bullshit case on him. It just feels like rels posted a weird question and then wanted to attach meaning to it so he put up this weird argument that doesn't even make sense. He even ignored that already noted scummy post from LS (the one where he's talking about conserving posts for the filter), the dude he's talking about. Here is the content LS produced between my question and my accution in those 9 hours, excluding the posts that answer to me: On December 15 2015 06:08 LightningStrike wrote: Sorry I been conserving my posts a little bit more as I had 1 page of posts already so I trying to limit myself a little bit now. But Koshi pretty much town for me atm. Also Damdred if you are here can you give me your thoughts on TT or other The smurf guy please? On December 15 2015 07:54 LightningStrike wrote: On December 15 2015 07:52 ritoky wrote: On December 15 2015 06:08 LightningStrike wrote: Sorry I been conserving my posts a little bit more as I had 1 page of posts already so I trying to limit myself a little bit now. But Koshi pretty much town for me atm. Also Damdred if you are here can you give me your thoughts on TT or other The smurf guy please? this is a very bad post. clearly reading the thread, clearly hyper aware of the post limit, has a motive for not posting frequently; yet in his hello senpai post he elects to give no content of his own and simply defers all content to damdred. i noticed you, even if no one else did. I gave a read in that post plus asking Damdred about you? On December 15 2015 07:58 LightningStrike wrote: On December 15 2015 07:56 ritoky wrote: On December 15 2015 07:54 LightningStrike wrote: On December 15 2015 07:52 ritoky wrote: On December 15 2015 06:08 LightningStrike wrote: Sorry I been conserving my posts a little bit more as I had 1 page of posts already so I trying to limit myself a little bit now. But Koshi pretty much town for me atm. Also Damdred if you are here can you give me your thoughts on TT or other The smurf guy please? this is a very bad post. clearly reading the thread, clearly hyper aware of the post limit, has a motive for not posting frequently; yet in his hello senpai post he elects to give no content of his own and simply defers all content to damdred. i noticed you, even if no one else did. I gave a read in that post plus asking Damdred about you? you gave a 0 content town read on the guy spamming the thread who is probably never getting lynched on day 1 and whom the person who's opinion you're deferring to said he is never lynching day 1. it is the easiest read to just make offhand. I had him null leaning town and was giving a update on my read on him....................... On December 15 2015 08:03 LightningStrike wrote: FYI I just finished a game+ Show Spoiler + I won as VT You dirty liar. ##Vote GiygaS Oh ok, I had seen this. I thought you meant you had seen LS's Caps post and thought he was town, then Rels attacked you for it but had the same read. Which would be pretty scummy, but thats not what happened here. Rels was pushing you here kus you said there was no posts from LS between his meta case and meta-unvote. Then showed that there was and called you a liar. Like sure maybe thats scum!Rels throwing OMGUS onto you, but I can easily see town!Rels doing the exact same thing. In both cases (LS and Gigas) Rels eventually backed down and gave them townreads. Assuming you two are both town this would mean scum!Rels is giving up 2 potential mislynches in you two. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 07:43 LightningStrike wrote: Is this a tinfoil hat party? If so I brought mine here: Lmao. I need both the things that guy has. Maybe 3 things if you count the priceless expression on his face. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 07:43 Shapelog wrote: Vobby still is a no show btw.... @damred, personally i think the info from Rels flip is better for all the reasoning you just said and them some. @everyone Going to restrict my posting for EOD. (11 page filter lol. 11-6 or 7 = 5/4 pages of filter today) Unless i see something big that i have to point out. Saying this so you guys do not think i am being inactive. ##Donate 10 posts to Shape For the WIFOM ^.^ | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 07:45 Damdred wrote: But yeah a Rels lynch even if I disagree (I have nothing better) is more information for the game. What have you done with the Towndred I know? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Time for potential shenannies. I'm actually slightly feeling Damdred over Vivax right now, but idk. Actually tbh I'm comfortable over here on the Koshi wagon. Plenty of room, and there is cookies! | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 07:52 Damdred wrote: Well a small part of me Tt wants to be right d1 when I wasn't totally rolled into,the ground from work. And the logical part of me knows that after some sleep I can try to put the pieces together tomorrow either way. But I'm just tired and aggravated from the holiday season which is horrible,in all food industries What does this mean. You want to lynch Vivax? Or does this mean you want to lynch Kush kus he was your target D1 before the shenannies... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 07:53 Koshi wrote: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 07:52 Tictock wrote: 10 min to go. Time for potential shenannies. I'm actually slightly feeling Damdred over Vivax right now, but idk. Actually tbh I'm comfortable over here on the Koshi wagon. Plenty of room, and there is cookies! I hope you are mafia. You don't wanna shenannie Damdred here? Fine, but if you are wrong about Rels I'm coming after you pretty hard Koshi. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I still prefer Koshi over Damdred. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 07:56 Koshi wrote: tt you are dropping so fucking fast to mafia category. Pretty sick. Holy fuck you make an entire case on the person you are going to shoot???? How fucking hardtry is that? OMGUS is a mafia trait right? Kus thats what you've been arguing about Rels, but now your doing it to me... | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I know I said I was coming after Koshi hard, but tbh Damdred looks really bad off of that. Like it's shit play as mafia too, but it's really shit as town that he voted onto Rels when he said he thought it was a bad lynch. I'm gunna take a break and reread that EoD later tonight. It's actually more likely someone who just jumped on Rels for no real reason is mafia than Koshi being mafia and leading a mislynch all day for such bad reasons. I'll see what I think when I reread. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 08:07 Koshi wrote: yeah knew it in the end. too many people were making completely retarded cases on me based on this and the fact I didn't lynch Damdred. gg. Tomorrow you can ml me. I will vote Damdred and then afk out the game. might be last ml. But I don't make any more posts in this game. The town will have to know I am town. If they don't. It's ok. If you are Town here Koshi you won't do this. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 08:11 Koshi wrote: Damdred/TT/Vivax gg wp Yea kus I'm fucking mafia here bussing all my teammates. You are the fucking king of Nonsense Koshi. And why the hell are you only talking in terms of Teams when we haven't lynched mafia yet? Gah, it's like you want me to tunnel you. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Humm your PoE list isn't bad. Bleh idk you are making it really hard to read you this game. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
##Donte 5 posts to Koshi Fight me bro. No more handouts from me. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 05:49 GiygaS wrote: Some things that irk me about Koshi: - General confidence early game about townreads - He goes from sure on me being scum (for a very bizarre reason but still very sure) to very confident I'm town because I backed off of two things, said I don't have any scumreads and gave him links to my previous game. He later states that he got a townread on me because it doesn't seem I'm on a team for the above reasons but ehhh. - He's getting on Damdred for his EoD1 move, but hasn't brought up TT at all in that respect. He also simultaneously thinks kush is town, which is said so many times doesn't matter. Let's go over his reasons why Damdred did what he did from a mafia perspective (thoughts in bold): Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 10:30 Koshi wrote: 1) pretend to care about the lynch This could equally be town or mafia. 2) put suspicion on saved person. This is possible, but he would have to think that this puts a ton of suspicion on himself as well. 3) save teammate But you think kush is town. His move wouldn't have even saved kush unless TT hammered 4) wifom in every shape or form So it's a null read 5) yolo plays to look town So it's a null read 5 different reasons why mafia could do it. There are kore and some can be split up further. I am sleeping 0229 Everybody who townreads damdred is a bad player. So his move is either a null read or he's going for a very high-risk low-reward play at EoD. - Calls GB town because he seems like a carefree town. Then swaps after drunk posts from GB that don't mean anything (these were only the only posts between tr->sr from GB). - Reason he moved from TT to GB: because TT was posting (not backing off his scum tell), and GB was a liability. This seems like a bs reason abandon his TT lynch. During this swap, he moved GB to scum read, but he voted GB not because he had a scumread, but because GB was a liability. - Had TT as a town read the next day because "There is no fucking way mafia!TT decided to be so active before the lynch and then made that ritoky is mafia case right before they shot ritoky." Later on the page he admits this is a wifom null read, and has very good reasons to scumread TT. So then why did he list him as town? - points sukrit/onegu already brought up Going to read through tt and then ls next. When I was reading through kush he seemed to bring up some good points. I don't like the Rels case at all right now, seems mostly based on Shape tinfoil team theories and general misinformation. This is actually a really good post from Gigas, I hadn't even thought about the point he's making (In bold) about Damdred's vote D1 implicating him. My vote D1 got GB lynched over Kush, Damdred's vote opened that up for possibility. If Kush is mafia here both of us did things to save him right at EoD. From Koshi's perspective there should be no real difference in what we did as the results were the same. I must resort to tinfoil how this might make sense: + Show Spoiler [tinfoil] + Rit started attacking Damdred for his shenannies right away after EoD, and Rit is know to have a "Soul read" on Damdred that is peculiarly accurate. So Rit being killed N1strongly implicates Damdred here, however it also implicates me as well since I was Rit's main scum read. Now town!Koshi might look at Rit being killed and go "Well clearly Damdred benifits greatly from that shot, so he must be scum" but he should also be thinking the same thing about me, at least to some extent. Humm maybe this is Koshi's "Great reason to still scumread TT" that is mentioned in the same post Gig makes. Still this worries me as I feel like the Rit kill was made just to push WIFOM on Damdred and I. So pushing this logic (which is tempting, but is still just WIFOM) does seem to benefit scum behavior more than town. Still the thing that bugs me most about Koshi's play last phase wasn't his read on Damdred, it was how Koshi kept calling Damdred 85% guarenteed scum, or w/e, but it was how he basically only pushed Rels. (+ Show Spoiler [Damdred Vote] + Yea sure Koshi voted Damdred at first, but he swapped to Rels at the drop of a hat. On December 17 2015 18:31 Koshi wrote: )##unvote ##vote Rels Die in a fire. Damdred is mafia with you. But you are way likelier to be mafia. I should read this Damdred pressure on you btw. I missed it. I also missed you calling him mafia like the little omgusucker that you are. Shape. Please stop mistyping GaygiS Khan his name. He will be mad. + Show Spoiler + ![]() | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 05:01 Damdred wrote: And when I flip town what then koshi? And hopefully rels does to I still don't understand why Damdred has just given up this game. He was pretty sure Rels was Town but still voted Rels? Like I'm trying to look at how EoD went and why people voted the way they did. Koshi's reads made it clear he should be voting Damdred, but he pushes Rels. Damdred is pretty sure Rels is town, says he wants people to lynch him, votes Rels. Ok actually it was 7 people on Rels, but there is a strong chance 2/3 mafia were on the Rels wagon here and these 2 are the first people I've looked at and they already look like they have to be the mafia here... I'm a little unsure that scum!Koshi would drive a mislynch like this all day because he know this will make him look bad. Then again his reasoning is even more all over the place than I'm used too. I started to run the tinfoil of Koshi and Damdred as a team, but that is actually never a thing. It only makes sense if they are playing a super bad/desperate scum game and I don't think they would. At most there is 1 mafia between them. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
My list post from EoD is mostly accurate. If I get killed use that and whatever else I get down before I have to go as a sorta last will. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 06:11 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 06:07 Tictock wrote: On December 18 2015 23:38 Tubesock wrote: On December 18 2015 23:29 Koshi wrote: Yeah. For me there is a very good possibility that Kush/Rels/Damdred are mafia together and that Damded did a yolo play to save Kush. There is something unholy about them. I think TT ruined their play. If TT stayed on GiygaS then Kush dies. Rels looks great for pushing him earlier. Damdred looks good because the only correct answer is town does shenanies at the end. This doesn't make a lot of sense, why would they bus a teammate like this? Why would Rels bus both teammates. The team is not fucking Rels/Damdred/Kush! Like maybe the stuff I said about how Damdred saw I was planning to vote GB and saw me suggest Vivax so tried to shennanie Vivax to save Kush. That's risky though kus if I had voted Vivax with Damdred then Kush gets lynched anyways. Comptely agree because i been saying Damred and Rels team has been impossible/highly unlikely since EoD. Thought Koshius was going to learn. I think our Lynch options today are: Rels Kouhius and Oengu. prob. in that order, but i might being bias on Rels. Idk i still think Kubrels is best lynch. Koshius lynch also reveals a lot of info as well if he flips scum. But if he is town, we kinda have a iffy situation where we can not afford to screw up. On December 19 2015 06:15 Shapelog wrote: idk acutrally about Koshius come to think about it. One part of me wants to lynch him because of shits, giggles, and because he is being irrational to the point of ripping my hair out. The other side says Rels flip info outweighs Koshius flip info. Could be wrong about the info flip. Has Kubrels really posted anything yet? other than at koshius for voting him over damdred or something. Last thing i remember from him. I'm not sure I like Shape's attitude about EoD at all. He's agreeing with me that Damdred/Rels are never a thing. He thinks Rels's flip is the best flip for information, but But if he is town, we kinda have a iffy situation where we can not afford to screw up. Which is kinda true about anyone flipping town, we don't get any real information until we flip mafia. I'm not sure what he means by this "situation where we cannot afford to screw up" I think we lynch Vivax who has basically claimed scum imo tomorrow, then we have 2 more lynches to find the rest. Idk if I have time to look over Shapes filter to see exactly why he was scumreading Rels, but I kinda feel like it was due to Koshi and Tube's cases. Posts like the ones I've quoted here just feel like he's fence sitting, but I know he's made other decent ones. Not convinced this is scummy, but worth noting. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 19 2015 05:11 Shapelog wrote: Ok i gone through his filter. 1st thing i want to bring up is his Rit town read. Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 14:01 kushm4sta wrote: hello dear friends. I was not expecting this game to start so quickly. The number of potential signups made me think this was a large game and that it would start nearer to christmas. Should I ask for replacement? hmm no I think I would rather just piss everyone off with my minimal activity. I'm going to placeholder on ritoky because i see his name up there and I recall him posting pics of miley cyrus. Show nested quote + On December 14 2015 23:22 kushm4sta wrote: Did a quick control-f for my name. No, Koshi, I will not be useless. This level of activity looks like it will be quite manageable for me to keep up with. Yes, GB,I do deserve your vote at this point in time. I hope to put some time into this game at lunch. All I can say now is ritoky is obviously town, which is funny because I'm currently voting him. Show nested quote + On December 15 2015 04:16 kushm4sta wrote: On December 15 2015 04:06 Sukrit wrote: Can you tell me why ritoky is townie kush? I have him completely null is there something you are seeing that I am not? his long post where he sounds paranoid On December 15 2015 03:38 GlowingBear wrote: On December 15 2015 02:56 kushm4sta wrote: On second thought after rereading his filter I'm not so sure I want to put gigas on my scum list yet. I will wait to see what his scumreads look like. Gb, I'll vote for him when I get a chance. Unless he does something townie. After re reading a 1 page filter? Wow that seems a lot to rethink huh I don't what you mean here. What is scummy about what I said precisely? I find his town read awkward. Like his main point for it was because Rik sounded paraiod in is post (which he didn't seem to me.) It is almost like he was trying to find a reason to town read him. Show nested quote + On December 17 2015 08:46 kushm4sta wrote: So that's got to look good for me right? A townie saved me. And then says "The person i was town reading died, that good right?". It's weird IMO. Rational Shapelog says this is a coincidence, but irrational shapelog says this is mafia indicate. And that Surkitengo and Kush planed to kill Rik from day one. Second point, Him and GiygaS khan: Show nested quote + On December 17 2015 02:46 kushm4sta wrote: On December 15 2015 02:58 GiygaS wrote: I'll reread tt filter and see, but all I have is null or town reads on everyone, except a tiny lean on Koshi from meta that I haven't even experienced. ![]() This read on koshi makes me think he's town. It is a very specific type of read. Very nuanced. Scum don't have nuanced reads like that. Show nested quote + On December 17 2015 02:57 kushm4sta wrote: Current scum reads are on tt (again, I really don't like that list of townread retraction with NAI stuff) and shape (holy shit that random asslist in to weird sukrit fos). Might get some more/less post-filters, but we'll see. His scumreads look believable and so does his case on rels. Not saying they are right or wrong but they look like townie reads So he is town reading GiygaS Khan. Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 19:53 kushm4sta wrote: Really not impressed with that exam schedule post. I'm sure it's true but the pressure want even on him. Scummy because he wants to take advantage of an irl excuse to its fullest. He could have just said I have exams. Onegu no one wants your steam of consciousness. That does not help find scum. Then calling his RL reasoning scum sus. He goes against all his defense for GiygaS Khan and calls him scummy. I feel this is a townie post. I can't really explain why, But run the case where they are a team. Why even post this? For town cred and bring sus. on a team mate. Heck lets look through this in the eyes of a kush as mafia and GiygaS as town, why go against one the people your town reading and bring sus. onto your self? To try to get a mislynch when everyone is set on either Rels or Vobby? Thats why i think this is a townie post, because it makes in a mafia shoes IMO. Point 3: me Scum->town->Town with chance of mafia What do i mean? Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 01:20 kushm4sta wrote: Here's some tinfoily stuff. On December 17 2015 09:36 Shapelog wrote: Plus killing the person who is defending you seems like only a thing i do. ritoky defended shape. Do not think my actively is actually any alignment indicating for me. Would of been the same activeness roughly if I rolled mafia. Except maybe a bit thought out and better fleshed posts since i had a team to relay things. But then i prob. post dumb, dull, crap time to time because they weren't on lol. what if shape is giving himself away here just as a little wink to himself Again, why would mafia go after someone else at this point. Plus i am a sucker for tinfoil ![]() So in conclusion, Kush is prob. town but as scummy posts. His conclusion is rahter mixed, prob town but with scummy posts? Looking at Kush's vote D2. On December 19 2015 01:21 kushm4sta wrote: gonna placeholder vivax bbl at lynch On December 19 2015 02:39 kushm4sta wrote: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 02:36 Koshi wrote: On December 17 2015 10:33 Tubesock wrote: On December 17 2015 10:12 Shapelog wrote: On December 17 2015 09:58 Tubesock wrote: On December 17 2015 09:45 Shapelog wrote: On December 17 2015 09:36 Tubesock wrote: On December 17 2015 08:02 Shapelog wrote: Welp, That happen. That's funny shit. I'm going to admit I don't really understand much of your big list post. Why do LS and Damdred have to be on the same team? Why can't they be budding the other? You seem to tie them together but you have Damdred more towny than LS. I feel the opposite. I think LS has added more thought to the game. The only thing Damdred did I think is towny is scum Rels and that's probably just because Rels cased him. Can you more explain your town read on Damdred? The rest of your associative reads, seems they all preclude that every shitfight 2 players have here are town vs mafia. I read this post and thought you don't think town fights town. That's not true is it? I'm starting to rethink my position on damdred. Earlier on in the EoD, i posted it didn't make much sense if he was mafia and the wagons were both town to do it. Why draw the attention onto himself? But i'm starting to see what Koshius and other people are saying about him. I will look at him in Dark tournament and compare his town game from that to here. And no town does fight town time to time (Should know from TT and Vobby wagons from Haunted mansion). Thanks for bringing this up. I ponder about it with kush. Like it can see it from both sides of the flip. Idk, i just posted that I won't be tunneling the mafia vs town stuff on him for the time being, You been quiet btw. Go any ideas about anything? list, scums teams, anything? My last list post I posted before going to bed 10 hours ago is essentially unchanged. Rels is now lower. Ritoky I should put in green but to be funny I'd keep him lower than Koshi because he didn't use Caps Lock or even held his shift key like a real baller. So uh apparently you missed my last couple of posts. Yeah i did miss it. Just looked into your filter and found #719 (your list). I remember seeing the case about you made against Rels now. I didn't really paid attention once it got to the town/mafia meta Rels part, since i'm not the one who should make/back up a meta case. And decided to come back to it later and keep pushing/tunneling. Will add Rels filter from dark tournament also to my read list tonight. I read the post now, But i going to reread what he said during the time he called you scum. My town/mafiaRels isn't really all that about meta. I mean it IS but it's not like necessarily Rels specific. Hard to explain. I've seen Rels in like 3 games. He was try hard and forceful in all, both as mafia and town. I respect his play, I think he's a strong player. It's not a meta read where it's like "Well, X person uses 15 smiley faces per paragraph, and this game she's doing 5" It's more like mafia Rels doesn't HAVE to go after it all the time. But town Rels basically does. In any case, disregard the meta bit. Do you think he's solving the game or attacking easy targets or only people who look at him? We can argue the semantics if Damdred is an easy target or not later. I'm even willing to concede Damdred is no easy target. My point still stands. Do you like this read Kush? Is it legit? I don't know about rels. There Tube is using shit meta. I don't think it's a Scummy read tho On December 19 2015 02:44 kushm4sta wrote: Rels Damdred ls Gigas vivax are all on my maybe list On December 19 2015 02:54 kushm4sta wrote: Yah I'm going over rels filter again now. I think I could lynch him. Is pretty poor reasoning. And that's a pretty long maybe list for all the townreading he was doing earlier on... Kush might well be Mafia here. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Tube put some effort into that lynch, he's kinda like Koshi but with less weird stuff going on. LS and Gigas were rather unispired voted. Gig only had Rels as a scumread (from D1 even), LS just hopped on. Both poor votes if town, but I kinda feel like it's NAI for these 2 players. I think that's everyone on the Rels wagon. Koshi, Damdred, and Kush are the ones who look the worst to me on it. Sorry I gotta run. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 20 2015 09:43 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 20 2015 09:36 LightningStrike wrote: anyone that is a vig or had the present you need to claim now. A. We do not have a vig as non of the roles in blue are vigs. B. If person was town with the present of the gun they would almost 100% of the time kill Vobby. This is why Mafia had the Gun This 100%. I know I would have shot Vobb... Vivax if I had had the chance. Even after that looking into Kush's poor reasoning vote onto Rels. This pretty much clears Damdred too based on his D1 vote, I don't think mafia would try to start shenannies when it's town v town like that. I think Vivax is the obvious lynch today. However the day is still young and I think Koshi has a really strong chance at being mafia with Vivax. So ##Vote: Koshi | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 20 2015 08:03 Half the Sky wrote: [/center]Toy soldiers Koshi and kushm4sta (Town Vanilla), had been torn to pieces. Oh wow n/m I fail at reading, just saw Kush when I glanced at this first. ... Uhh, well then this is shit for us then. 5/3 Sorry Koshi. >.< | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
4 Tubesock 6 Vivax 7 Sukrit 9 Damdred 10 Shapelog 12 Tictock 13 LightningStrike Ok I should prob just go to bed kus I think I had a drink too many, but here is where we are at. I double checked this time. Vivax is the obv lynch, and I think the chances of Damdred being mafia are incredibly slim based off his D1. The rest of you all I need to reread when I'm actually able to focus properly, kus this is Triple MyLo now. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Can we please lynch Vivax and give us another day to process? I don't believe there is anyway for Vivax to not be mafia here, and even if I am scum here I would probably be busing Vivax, so we lynch him and flips mafia (hopefully the RB like TS says). Town has chance to save and gain a ML. If that happens, go ahead and lynch me. If not then D4 will be interesting because I'm not mafia here and I have no intention of being the lynch that looses us the game. I normally don't really push my meta reads, but Vivax is so obviously scum based on his meta. I cohosted a game where he rolled scum was was literally too afraid to post anything because he thinks he is obvious as scum. As town he is engaged and drops opinions, like look at his posting D1 where he defers all responsibility to Koshi but then makes a couple of "Hey look I'm doing things" posts which actually don't do anything. Especially the question he asks to LS, it would suggest that he read the game, but if he read the game he would already have know the answer to that question. Check his meta yourself if you don't believe me. Shape can you explain to me your thought process with your 1 shot tracking? Why did you hold it N1? What made you think I was being targeted N2 and decide to track me? I'd also like Tube to answer the question that Damdred asked as well, because Vivax is an odd target to check when he looks so scummy, and it seems like you could gather more info from checking others. It's also the easiest claim in the world for Mafia to make here. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 20 2015 16:32 Shapelog wrote: Well Comrades! TT is one sly motherfucker or one really really really really unlucky miller. Hes Scum! He visted Kush last night. And yes, i am claiming the blue role of Fritz Stahlbaum, I am a one-time tracker (since mechanics state a role can be one-shot two shot or mutishot). It is funny how i got this piece of info btw. I misunderstood my role haha. I thought i see who Vists the person i was TRACKING not the other way around. You can thank that misunderstanding when TT flips mafia 1st reason why he is scum over unlucky Miller: Probability Math! the greatest weakness of guess who games! Let us obverse the natural and non-natural (human mafia influence.) Natural: lets say the set up of the game was like this: 2-3 blue roles, 3 vt, 2-3 millers, 2-3 wanders, 3 scum. Best chance TT gets miller is 3/13 Chance of visting Kush last night 1/9 Natural chance (random shot basically) of mafia killing kush the same night: 1/9 3 * 1 * 1 = 3 13 * 9 * 9 = 1053 So a natural chance of all that happening is 3/1053 or 1/351 or .28 % Of ever happening! But, I can hear you say (or TT at least) what about human mafia? They are surly not ever going to randomly shot someone! that be unreasonable! and that is true.... But there is way we can roughly calculate the non-natural chance that mafia would shot Kush last night. Patterns. So far 2/3 of the night kills by mafia have been second hand town members. What do i mean by second hand? townies who have lack luster mafia cases and slash or low content. Only Koshi has broken this rule. So we can calcule with this pattern who is mafia target last night: TS: heck no with that Rels case does he fit in. (might be mafia...) Giygas Khan: No, he did that big case on me, and a few smaller, but good scum cases/posts analyzes. Damred: not a single real case past D1, and that wasn't even big. +1 (might be mafia) TT: Doesn't matter, hes mafia, he would be shooting, so subtract one from the bottom. But if we are calling him a miller, then no Kush: Check +1 Koshi: Nope..... Mafia probuly killed him for town cred (more on that later) Lets say mafia already knew they were going to kill him so we will exclude him to give TT the best chance here. Me: Hell no, I been their biggest advocate (again later on) Surkit: Yes, but i think he is mafia along with TT. LS: pretty meh, not enough to be out of this logic : +1 Vobby: checkish +1, if i was scum, might as well lynch him and get cred at this point though. So for the sake of it (and since everyone else is calling him mafia I put him with the mafia team for this) So 3/6 or 1/2 of the people were up to be shot by mafia last night. 3 * 1 * 1 = 3 13 * 9 * 2 = 234 So 3/234 or 1/78 or 1.2 % chance of it happening. 1.2% vs a .28 % for innocent miller to be caught going to a dead person's home. Awful chances of miller aren't they? So if he is mafia it is a 98.8% non natural chance and a 99.72 natural chance that he was visiting for mafia business. Go ahead and fight me if you think he was just visiting Kush for a drink on the night he died. Go ahead, i got math. 2nd reasoning: TT has done nothing that makes sense as mafia. I bet you read that and went "What?" how can you claim someone is mafia when they done nothing that makes sense. I think i told Damred best why when he posted this: Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 08:53 Damdred wrote: Let me make it clear why I think Rels is town from that exchange specifically. 1) Mafia as a whole have a great sense of wanting to keep good apperances in thread. This comes from muddying pushing somewhat easy lunches avoiding hot topics. Most of this comes from not wanting to disturb waters and draw attention. Show nested quote + On December 18 2015 09:20 Shapelog wrote: On December 18 2015 08:53 Damdred wrote: Let me make it clear why I think Rels is town from that exchange specifically. 1) Mafia as a whole have a great sense of wanting to keep good apperances in thread. This comes from muddying pushing somewhat easy lunches avoiding hot topics. Most of this comes from not wanting to disturb waters and draw attention. 1. So your saying "typically, mafia is more quiet then town and meh pushs easy targets." Ok, that makes sense. But how does that factor in. Can't Anyone decide not to follow the mafia's golden rule? How does that really make sense? just because 75% of people follow a logic makes the 25% all the more deadly. Idk, maybe it is because when i gotten mafia/scum in RL mafia games i play exactly the same. 1st off my biggest issue with this and TT is that it is hard for him to "Trend waters" as Damred claim mafia should do. Is that that is Exactly why everyone scum read TT at the beginning! Just like koshi, if he doesn't live up to his "town play" he is auto scum in people eyes. So he has to do these big reads and cases. Hes got to put up the show, to be believe as town. And that's it. It is like something known as security theater, it is not actual security, it is just a show of security like behavior and actions that makes everyone feel safe. That is what he is doing here. Lets go threw the list: Rik case: So TT enters the game after much inactiveness, (maybe planned) and comes in and has a magically same theory i had about Rik. About his hard ass town read on me. Everyone wrote it off as tinfoil basically, except him. Tell me, why in the world would mafia come into the game, see people are questioning he's side, and instead of posting a bunch of stuff and posting. He just jumps on this. He could easily saw my theory and jump on. You can how this actually HELPS a mafia. Let me run it again, nearing end of D1, before wagons really from. TT sees votes on him, realizes that no one paid attention to his Rik post for the most part, and is discussing lynching him. Makes a relative rushed post, and gets into a conversation with Riks. Everyone points out his post is rushed, so he does something unexcepting, he votes for Giyga Khan. At that point, he wasn't even really talked about in the terms of being scum. Well then people scum read him for wasting his vote. I can image at this point he was desperate. He knew the two wagons were town and town. Damred (who maybe is his partner) does shenanigans and he has to vote one or the other to avoid sus. about him voting GiygaS Khan. And hammers GB because "well i am sus. might as well do something more sus. so i look town". Then to give him more cred, he goes off me going hard onto Rik. then kills Rik. Koshi Vote: pretty self explaining. Knew he would be town and that a fellow team mate had a gun. Maybe onegu is with him lol. Kush kill: So here we are. The info that got me writing this WoT in the first place. But why would the person kill the person he just scum reads? Duh for the cred. Show nested quote + On December 17 2015 08:46 kushm4sta wrote: So that's got to look good for me right? A townie saved me. It is different then from when Kush said he was more townie because Rik die. Remember how everyone thought this was a WIFOM move by mafia to cast sus. on me and kush? And everyone told Kush it was NAI? Kush didn't scum read Rik, in fact, he sided with rik. Compare this too: Show nested quote + On December 20 2015 06:01 Tictock wrote: So Shape posted this, which I think is rather good. On December 19 2015 05:11 Shapelog wrote: Ok i gone through his filter. 1st thing i want to bring up is his Rit town read. On December 14 2015 14:01 kushm4sta wrote: hello dear friends. I was not expecting this game to start so quickly. The number of potential signups made me think this was a large game and that it would start nearer to christmas. Should I ask for replacement? hmm no I think I would rather just piss everyone off with my minimal activity. I'm going to placeholder on ritoky because i see his name up there and I recall him posting pics of miley cyrus. On December 14 2015 23:22 kushm4sta wrote: Did a quick control-f for my name. No, Koshi, I will not be useless. This level of activity looks like it will be quite manageable for me to keep up with. Yes, GB,I do deserve your vote at this point in time. I hope to put some time into this game at lunch. All I can say now is ritoky is obviously town, which is funny because I'm currently voting him. On December 15 2015 04:16 kushm4sta wrote: On December 15 2015 04:06 Sukrit wrote: Can you tell me why ritoky is townie kush? I have him completely null is there something you are seeing that I am not? his long post where he sounds paranoid On December 15 2015 03:38 GlowingBear wrote: On December 15 2015 02:56 kushm4sta wrote: On second thought after rereading his filter I'm not so sure I want to put gigas on my scum list yet. I will wait to see what his scumreads look like. Gb, I'll vote for him when I get a chance. Unless he does something townie. After re reading a 1 page filter? Wow that seems a lot to rethink huh I don't what you mean here. What is scummy about what I said precisely? I find his town read awkward. Like his main point for it was because Rik sounded paraiod in is post (which he didn't seem to me.) It is almost like he was trying to find a reason to town read him. On December 17 2015 08:46 kushm4sta wrote: So that's got to look good for me right? A townie saved me. And then says "The person i was town reading died, that good right?". It's weird IMO. Rational Shapelog says this is a coincidence, but irrational shapelog says this is mafia indicate. And that Surkitengo and Kush planed to kill Rik from day one. Second point, Him and GiygaS khan: On December 17 2015 02:46 kushm4sta wrote: On December 15 2015 02:58 GiygaS wrote: I'll reread tt filter and see, but all I have is null or town reads on everyone, except a tiny lean on Koshi from meta that I haven't even experienced. ![]() This read on koshi makes me think he's town. It is a very specific type of read. Very nuanced. Scum don't have nuanced reads like that. On December 17 2015 02:57 kushm4sta wrote: Current scum reads are on tt (again, I really don't like that list of townread retraction with NAI stuff) and shape (holy shit that random asslist in to weird sukrit fos). Might get some more/less post-filters, but we'll see. His scumreads look believable and so does his case on rels. Not saying they are right or wrong but they look like townie reads So he is town reading GiygaS Khan. On December 18 2015 19:53 kushm4sta wrote: Really not impressed with that exam schedule post. I'm sure it's true but the pressure want even on him. Scummy because he wants to take advantage of an irl excuse to its fullest. He could have just said I have exams. Onegu no one wants your steam of consciousness. That does not help find scum. Then calling his RL reasoning scum sus. He goes against all his defense for GiygaS Khan and calls him scummy. I feel this is a townie post. I can't really explain why, But run the case where they are a team. Why even post this? For town cred and bring sus. on a team mate. Heck lets look through this in the eyes of a kush as mafia and GiygaS as town, why go against one the people your town reading and bring sus. onto your self? To try to get a mislynch when everyone is set on either Rels or Vobby? Thats why i think this is a townie post, because it makes in a mafia shoes IMO. Point 3: me Scum->town->Town with chance of mafia What do i mean? On December 19 2015 01:20 kushm4sta wrote: Here's some tinfoily stuff. On December 17 2015 09:36 Shapelog wrote: Plus killing the person who is defending you seems like only a thing i do. ritoky defended shape. Do not think my actively is actually any alignment indicating for me. Would of been the same activeness roughly if I rolled mafia. Except maybe a bit thought out and better fleshed posts since i had a team to relay things. But then i prob. post dumb, dull, crap time to time because they weren't on lol. what if shape is giving himself away here just as a little wink to himself Again, why would mafia go after someone else at this point. Plus i am a sucker for tinfoil ![]() So in conclusion, Kush is prob. town but as scummy posts. His conclusion is rahter mixed, prob town but with scummy posts? Looking at Kush's vote D2. On December 19 2015 01:21 kushm4sta wrote: gonna placeholder vivax bbl at lynch On December 19 2015 02:39 kushm4sta wrote: On December 19 2015 02:36 Koshi wrote: On December 17 2015 10:33 Tubesock wrote: On December 17 2015 10:12 Shapelog wrote: On December 17 2015 09:58 Tubesock wrote: On December 17 2015 09:45 Shapelog wrote: On December 17 2015 09:36 Tubesock wrote: On December 17 2015 08:02 Shapelog wrote: Welp, That happen. That's funny shit. I'm going to admit I don't really understand much of your big list post. Why do LS and Damdred have to be on the same team? Why can't they be budding the other? You seem to tie them together but you have Damdred more towny than LS. I feel the opposite. I think LS has added more thought to the game. The only thing Damdred did I think is towny is scum Rels and that's probably just because Rels cased him. Can you more explain your town read on Damdred? The rest of your associative reads, seems they all preclude that every shitfight 2 players have here are town vs mafia. I read this post and thought you don't think town fights town. That's not true is it? I'm starting to rethink my position on damdred. Earlier on in the EoD, i posted it didn't make much sense if he was mafia and the wagons were both town to do it. Why draw the attention onto himself? But i'm starting to see what Koshius and other people are saying about him. I will look at him in Dark tournament and compare his town game from that to here. And no town does fight town time to time (Should know from TT and Vobby wagons from Haunted mansion). Thanks for bringing this up. I ponder about it with kush. Like it can see it from both sides of the flip. Idk, i just posted that I won't be tunneling the mafia vs town stuff on him for the time being, You been quiet btw. Go any ideas about anything? list, scums teams, anything? My last list post I posted before going to bed 10 hours ago is essentially unchanged. Rels is now lower. Ritoky I should put in green but to be funny I'd keep him lower than Koshi because he didn't use Caps Lock or even held his shift key like a real baller. So uh apparently you missed my last couple of posts. Yeah i did miss it. Just looked into your filter and found #719 (your list). I remember seeing the case about you made against Rels now. I didn't really paid attention once it got to the town/mafia meta Rels part, since i'm not the one who should make/back up a meta case. And decided to come back to it later and keep pushing/tunneling. Will add Rels filter from dark tournament also to my read list tonight. I read the post now, But i going to reread what he said during the time he called you scum. My town/mafiaRels isn't really all that about meta. I mean it IS but it's not like necessarily Rels specific. Hard to explain. I've seen Rels in like 3 games. He was try hard and forceful in all, both as mafia and town. I respect his play, I think he's a strong player. It's not a meta read where it's like "Well, X person uses 15 smiley faces per paragraph, and this game she's doing 5" It's more like mafia Rels doesn't HAVE to go after it all the time. But town Rels basically does. In any case, disregard the meta bit. Do you think he's solving the game or attacking easy targets or only people who look at him? We can argue the semantics if Damdred is an easy target or not later. I'm even willing to concede Damdred is no easy target. My point still stands. Do you like this read Kush? Is it legit? I don't know about rels. There Tube is using shit meta. I don't think it's a Scummy read tho On December 19 2015 02:44 kushm4sta wrote: Rels Damdred ls Gigas vivax are all on my maybe list On December 19 2015 02:54 kushm4sta wrote: Yah I'm going over rels filter again now. I think I could lynch him. Is pretty poor reasoning. And that's a pretty long maybe list for all the townreading he was doing earlier on... Kush might well be Mafia here. Then Kush dies. The night TT calls him scum, magically he visits the place with at best a 1.2% chance roughly as a miller? And the night before, digs up my read on kush which practically said "This guy is town, but he does have a few scummys posts" which clearly implies that they aren't big enough to make me think he was mafia. Then pulls up irrelevant D2 garage filter from Kushs filter to call him scum. Why would he do this as mafia? Because that has been his entire plan from the beginning! And it work so good to, I mean if it wasn't for my stupid mistake i would of not even have knew. But everything makes sense now. But it is time to drive home the "mafia is being obvious mafia to try to seem town" claim. 3rd reason: His trouble, dumbtell posts. Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 08:14 Tictock wrote: On December 19 2015 08:11 Koshi wrote: Damdred/TT/Vivax gg wp Yea kus I'm fucking mafia here bussing all my teammates. You are the fucking king of Nonsense Koshi. And why the hell are you only talking in terms of Teams when we haven't lynched mafia yet? Gah, it's like you want me to tunnel you. Idk about Damdred (I don't think really he went hard after damdred tbh, more like "his play makes no sense! again") about about Vivax. Tell me why the hell mafia at this point shouldn't get rid of him if he is scum? Because he is a team mate? It is way to hard to defend his crap. It seems too good that mafia would just let one of their own get lynch without some plan. And guess what, the other two TT and ???? are doing just that, to get cred. Mafia will have too at this point either come out and lie about a role or just let him get lynch. But if Vivax is town (which according to TS could be a 50/50 right now bewteen mafia and town RB) then it is easy winnings right now. Keeping vivax alive as possible has been mafia key goal. No one except LS i think even glace at my post D2 when i keep bringing up Vobby. Why not keep town Vivax alive as long as possible. I still think he is scum, but honestly a coinflip right now (if what TS is saying is true, which for all i know could be mafia trying to influence voting) At our last lynch is super fucking dicey Dead Koshi post: Show nested quote + On December 20 2015 11:56 Tictock wrote: On December 20 2015 09:43 Shapelog wrote: On December 20 2015 09:36 LightningStrike wrote: anyone that is a vig or had the present you need to claim now. A. We do not have a vig as non of the roles in blue are vigs. B. If person was town with the present of the gun they would almost 100% of the time kill Vobby. This is why Mafia had the Gun This 100%. I know I would have shot Vobb... Vivax if I had had the chance. Even after that looking into Kush's poor reasoning vote onto Rels. This pretty much clears Damdred too based on his D1 vote, I don't think mafia would try to start shenannies when it's town v town like that. I think Vivax is the obvious lynch today. However the day is still young and I think Koshi has a really strong chance at being mafia with Vivax. So ##Vote: Koshi This is prob. NAI but is worth mentioning. Easy knowing that koshi is dieing to post this after day to basically be town. How does mafia forget who they are killing? Excellently, that is why he is mafia. Sees my post about vig and gun, Somehow misses the who conversation with LS about asking someone to claim up to who shot koshi (or maybe kush and TT had gun lol, no wait makes no sense) Skips Night flips and posts a koshi lynch. Because it seems townie. But this is his biggest dumbtell all game for the "obivous mafia being town" plan. Hell lets ponder if a town killed koshi last night. By his skimmyness alone, to not even look at who died. seems like a normal scum move. Wait....He HAD TO READ THE DAY CYCLE POST BECAUSE HE KNEW KUSH DIED! HOW IN THE HELL DID HE MISS KOSHI? Maybe skimming through to see if his night kill got healed! And you know what is funny? I FUCKING BROUGHT IT, SO DID EVERYONE ELSE! MAFIA TOO OBVIOUS? NO THAT IS IMPOSSIBLE. I mean give me your 1st reason that you ever thought of in this game that TT was town? Was it a town read? scum case? No, it was because it was posting like a mad man trying to get everyone to say "thats our boy" and it fucking work! Damm...... Conclusion: Which one do you feel more comfortable with? A almost 99% gaurtreed scum or a 50/50 scum? Pure probulbilty says that TT only has a 1.2 % of rolling town at this point. Vivax still has 50%! at this point. My money is on the 99% scum God i was so lucky ##Vote: TicTock I can not believe you betrayed me tinfoil buddy ![]() Also if TS is mafia he fucked you over baldly because of a present call. Also Thanking my dumbness and my misunderstanding of the role lol. 1) Ok so it looks like Gig already debunked some of the math you used here, but I really don't like how you claimed to have spent like 3-4 hours making this post and never bothered to check what the possible explanations might be here. Seems like Gigas read your case, did his own math and checked pretty much any possibility he could think of in less than an hour... Damdred came up with another possible explanation, and even as I take a quick glance at the OP it looks like there is also a candy that gives: - a visit to the person who gets nightkilled for one night So I have to then wonder if this case is actually town modivated, because it looks like you are pushing me with some heavy confirmation bias. If this is scum!Shape trying to make this claim and case to seal the deal here I have to applaud his effort as it's a solid play to try and end the game. I'm getting a little tinfoily here so I'll stop till I see Shapes response about using his tracking, but this is 2 days in a row where a strong push over Vivax has happened... 2) This is a really weird point and I'm not sure how to respond to it. You are sorta saying I'm to town to be town, or that I'm mafia here picking the perfect "I can't be mafia" plays. It just sounds like confirmation bias, tbh. 3) That was about the worst post I've ever made, and is a lesson for why you don't drink and post kids. I'll give you guys the backstory to yesturday, but what happened here was that my brain literally stopped working about halfway through that post and thought Koshi was still alive. I think I'd half recognized that 2 people had been killed (only way I would have responded to Shapes post about shooting Kush like I did) but then spaced that detail or just forgot Koshi was the 2nd kill. I def responded before I stopped to process the daypost there. So I said I had to go help a friend yesterday, the whole story there was that a buddy of mine had to put down the family dog last earlier this week and was rather broken up about it. Told me he hadn't been out of bed in 4 days. He's got a slew of issues including anxiety... I don't need to get into the details but I was worried about him. So another friend and I went over to try and get him out of the house and cheer him up. We ended up playing a few rounds of some drinking games and making a small party of out it, maybe not the best idea (I also worry my friend drinks too much) but it seemed to get the mood to lighten. So that's how I ended up getting home and posting what I did there. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 01:48 Shapelog wrote: Like everyone killed had a way for a mislynch the day they died. Me on Rit, TT had a Kush being scum case. Koshius was killed by them while having major sus.. But yet Vobby, who has been the easiest target for a mislynch is still alive? IS it because he only post to avoid modkill? Is it because mafia knows it sus. and it is the easiest target for a mislynch? Why not kill everyone that could provide town with info with a lynch? And yes, why waste the gun when they could of mislynch koshius or vobby today and shot and win tomorrow? Because they have the best mislynch! Vobby. Like the more and more i think about it. The more and more i can see vobby being bait for the mafia's fishing hook. And town being the fish. I mean... maybe, but then I'd have to accept that Vivax plays this terribly as town. I don't think he does. Or it's just that Vivax is mafia and they won't kill their teammate kus that'd be against mafia win con. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 02:19 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 21 2015 02:15 Damdred wrote: That's a difficult question. The easiest explanation is if you are a one shot blue role that is information based (ie cop or tracker) you use the power and then post your results get the extra information plus confirmed town d2 in the process. For example tracked onegu n1 no movement more likely he's town+your confirmed. Now it's an odd thing Couldn't technically I track GF who goes no where? Idk, I was like when i saw my role "Lets get some motherfucking mafia boys", I wouldn't be that smart enough to confirm myself like that ![]() Humm GF is untrackable, so you would get a null result, or "No movement" or something. That's actually something to consider, if mafia has a GF they use them to deliver KP 100% of the time right? I guess we don't know enough about the setup to assume mafia has a GF here though... Idk I think it's pretty likely, GF isn't a strong role and typical mafia setup on these forums for 13 players is Goon/RB/GF Though if I'm a wanderer (and there is at least 2 with a miller to boot) then I'm guessing there is either more candy floating around or another powerrole out there. If Tube is telling the truth that Vivax is RB (and if he is he has to be mafia, no way does he play like this as townRB) then we know there was the candy Tube got, the extra shot that mafia got, and a 1 shot tracker in Shape. Idk I feel like there is something missing to balance for town. On the other hand if Vivax is being the worst townRB of all time then I could see the balance being something like RB/1shot Tracker vs Goon/RB/GF with a Vig shot candy and Rolecheck candy floating around. Humm, that actually makes a fair bit of sense. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 02:31 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 21 2015 02:26 Tictock wrote: Well I must be whatever the hell low chance I'm wanderer, kus I didn't shoot or open any candy or w/e. I got a VT role PM. Can we please lynch Vivax and give us another day to process? I don't believe there is anyway for Vivax to not be mafia here, and even if I am scum here I would probably be busing Vivax, so we lynch him and flips mafia (hopefully the RB like TS says). Town has chance to save and gain a ML. If that happens, go ahead and lynch me. If not then D4 will be interesting because I'm not mafia here and I have no intention of being the lynch that looses us the game. I normally don't really push my meta reads, but Vivax is so obviously scum based on his meta. I cohosted a game where he rolled scum was was literally too afraid to post anything because he thinks he is obvious as scum. As town he is engaged and drops opinions, like look at his posting D1 where he defers all responsibility to Koshi but then makes a couple of "Hey look I'm doing things" posts which actually don't do anything. Especially the question he asks to LS, it would suggest that he read the game, but if he read the game he would already have know the answer to that question. Check his meta yourself if you don't believe me. Shape can you explain to me your thought process with your 1 shot tracking? Why did you hold it N1? What made you think I was being targeted N2 and decide to track me? I'd also like Tube to answer the question that Damdred asked as well, because Vivax is an odd target to check when he looks so scummy, and it seems like you could gather more info from checking others. It's also the easiest claim in the world for Mafia to make here. I already did.... In so many times......*sigh* I misunderstood the text. I though it worked like a watcher/lookout. So i thought i was watching you, but turns out I tracking. Reason why i hold it is explain a few posts up. Yea I saw it now, missed it while I was posting other stuff. I can understand you're "less doors" idea to hold the track, seems solid. But this still suggests to me that you thought I was getting vistied or NK'd. I didn't think you were so convinced I was town to assume mafia would put actions on me. Maybe I'm just getting confused by your EoN posts but you posted this in what looks like a drunken rant: On December 19 2015 13:09 Shapelog wrote: I HaTe Myyyyyy LifE. WaS TyPing Brillllenrt ResPond ON WhO WaAS ScUm. THeN PagE ReLoaD, LoSt It. Oh Wellllll, Justa PoSt ThE CaSe Torrrmoerrr. Don'T yOU DARE MR> TICKDLATOLK TO SKIP AHEAD! So you were already making this case during the Night? Or what is this referring to? Looking back over your posts in the night I suppose I was mistaken, it does look like you considered me the towniest person in the game at that point so it makes you would watch me to see if people came to visit. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I'm so sure that Vivax is the proper lynch here. Please don't get dragged into this WIFOM about Vivax being 50/50, because if you actually bother to look at his play you can easily tell that his chances of being scum are so much higher than that. Though the way that Shape is so dead set on me here is giving me the heebie geebies, and rechecking his posts from Night I think there is a solid chance that he was planning this post about me before the daypost. Shape Damdred is never mafia because of the only intelligant thing I posted last night, no way does he make a spectacle of himself trying shenannies D1 in a town v town. He is suggesting the smart play here, we lynch vivax and buy time to sort this out. ##Vote: Vivax | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Ummmm think i was asking you your options on todays lynch. [QUOTE]On December 19 2015 10:56 Shapelog wrote: [QUOTE]On December 19 2015 08:49 Tictock wrote: I thought about this randomly and decided it would be fun. ##Donte 5 posts to Koshi Fight me bro. No more handouts from me.[/QUOTE] NO MR.TickdeToak BAD BOY FIghtingxz. We Haved To Haive A coNverSation Aboutiy VoBBy. NoW do U! Wantve toh LYCNH! VoBby orKosushishshush? OR shouldwe be More ACcepTing Of otherirses And Likes ConSider Somesoenes Liek Oengus Or tHat KhaN!. IN FACT, I shalz DriVe and Get InFO On They So I can CharGe ThEm WiTH THE DEATHS OF RIKOTY. GOD I MISS THAT GUY! HE WAS SUCH A GOOD FAtherZs I Getz baCk toO yoU aFter The Drive. WAIT FOR ME MR. TIckDeToak![/QUOTE] [QUOTE]On December 19 2015 13:09 Shapelog wrote: I HaTe Myyyyyy LifE. WaS TyPing Brillllenrt ResPond ON WhO WaAS ScUm. THeN PagE ReLoaD, LoSt It. Oh Wellllll, Justa PoSt ThE CaSe Torrrmoerrr. Don'T yOU DARE MR> TICKDLATOLK TO SKIP AHEAD![/QUOTE] + Show Spoiler + As it clearly shows........ Lol what is clear about this post? You mention that you had a brilliant case on who was scum, but lost it. If it wasn't the one you posted on me today, who was it on? The fact that you mentioned my name makes me think you were writing it about me, but tbh I have no idea what you are saying to or about me here. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 03:37 Shapelog wrote: And no, how the hell would i be making my post if i didn't even get my Results yet -_- TT.....are you still drunk? P.S. i feel your friend. I have anxiety disorder (along with my list of mental problems.) And i lost my dog like 2 mouths ago ![]() Well that's kinda my point here, but idk maybe I'm just getting really confused by your posts there. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 03:41 Shapelog wrote: Like pretend i am mafia. Tell me how posting a tracker result makes any fucking sense? No one else is claiming crap? DId i just typed up BS and waited for 4 hours (till 2:30 am) to post it? Wtf TT? You lied about my case. You can make out at the time what i was talking to you about. About a vobby or a Koshi lynch. And that i would "drive their filters and press them with the charges of rik death." I am pretty sure you are scum, and pulled up the second one just to help your case. Well 1shot tracker isn't the strongest role, I'm not good at balance but I think you'd consider it like half a power role, which means if mafia has a RB then town likely has another .5 role, like Masons or Vet. Or it could be that more candy is present in the game. I'm not at all convinced you are scum fake claiming like this, but it is def not outside the realm of possibility. Just like it's not totally outside the realm of possibility that I'm a wanderer. If you are scum it would make sense to claim a semi-powerful role but leave room in case there are other claims, especially if you think your claim is good enough that it can close out the game for you. Honestly if I were scum I would have claimed that I shot Kush, or got a candy, or w/e the fuck I pleased to try and cover myself here. None of that is true though, so for me either you are lying or I am the 2nd wanderer in this game. If you are not scum here it actually means town probably has more roles or candy that might help us in this triple MyLo. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 03:46 Damdred wrote: Ok TT to be clear you are claiming you are not a pr at all and haven't used any presents/candy correct? Sh you 100% claim a track on Tt correct? No over explaining just yes or no from the both of you. Correct. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 04:03 GiygaS wrote: About to get on plane, gonna quickly post a list and vote. Town (in order) Shape Tube Scum (in order) Vivax Tt Null (in order of scumminess) Damdred LS Sukrit ##Vote Vivax What changed your mind on me? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 04:08 Damdred wrote: Tt do you think sh is town still? It's pretty likely that he is, but I can't ignore that he's pushing off of what looks to me like confirmed scum Vivax to mislynch me. Honestly I think your the only person I'd be willing to stake money on being town here atm. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 04:20 Shapelog wrote: Show nested quote + On December 21 2015 04:16 Tictock wrote: Like I disagree with Gig that a fakeclaim is high-risk low reward if the result of that claim is getting town to used their last lynch on town. If i was partners with vivax (which if i was, i would of snap about right now) This would make sense. Also i would be pretty ballz with a Track claim. And that's exactly what worries me here. Tube is right that you'd have to be like the most hopeful town in the world to think Vivax is a coinflip here. Idk, I have to head to work in just a min. I'll ponder stuff and be able to follow/respond to questions but that's about all I can do till I get back to my PC. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 21 2015 05:08 Damdred wrote: Simple fact is this is sort of difficult. Vivax more than likely is scum and scum team is going to by a for cred if he's town I'm really disappointed with him. But I've been shitty so I won't hold,it against him. However, Tt is most likely the next scum in this situation. I should explain. Look at how he handles the claim by sha, his response isn't fuck this guy is lying he is scum trying to get a mislymch. Instead it is, summit guys I guess as unlikely as it is I'm a wanderer and sh tracked me danger Secondly the chances of a wanderer going to the person who was hit with kp is extremely small. Let alone the fact we would have to accept 2 wanderer and one unaware Miller. Could 've extreme bad luck for town but it's damming. Kinda sad I was wrong about Tt this game though oh well. My response isn't "Fuck Shape is scum" because we only have one mislynch left and however unlikely it is that I'm wanderer and visited the NK it's still a possibility I need to consider here. + Show Spoiler + I was wondering a bit about the present that says "visit to the nightkill target" though, I wonder if it's possible that someone used that gift On me. Getting through Shape's filter is not something I can do at work or in the couple of hours, and I need to be pretty damed sure that he is scum before I'd want to lynch him over Vivax. (Responding to a different post, but on mobile, so deal with it) I tried to push Vivax yesterday but nobody was interested, when I suggested shenannies nobody was around. I didn't build a high profile case on Vivax kus the guy has a 6 post filter that says nothing... What is there to talk about there? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Like I get the low chance that wanderer has to wander into the NK. What makes you so sure about the number f wanderers though? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Pretty sure he hasn't posted today or at least not since Shapes claim. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I might make a mini case on Vivax just to remind everyone why he really should be the lynch today. I've been fine giving you posts Shape, but apparently that's a scummy thing when I do it so screw you. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Had a power outage in my area so power was off for the whole block for about 12 hours. Useing a little time at work to catchup but I got word that everything is back on at home so I'll be at it in about 30 min with more detailed posts. I've realized I was being niave about several things at the start of day but I'm still not sure that I want to conclude Shape is fakeclaiming here even if it's more likely than me being a 2nd wanderer. Just seems highly unlikely especially since there have been no other claims. I know who I want to lynch tomorrow, and I was working on a case, but lost some of it when the power went out. I'll get back to work on that when I get home, may not get it done till day though. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
For me it's these 3 people. Gigas: Slowly but surely this guy has been changing my mind since D1. He's been active despite posting excuses to not be and while he hasn't made a great deal of reads he's been careful about the reads he does have. It was his responses to Shapes case that really have me convinced he is town though. He pointed out the errors in Shapes math and was generally against the case, and even though he eventually changed his mind and now thinks I am scum he was not willing to lynch me over Vivax. Onegu (aka Sukrit): So obviously town, I really felt this D1 granted he's slacked off a bit since then I still think this is true. It's not exactly easy to read Onegu, but when he is town he generally does w/e the hell he wants until it is MyLo/LyLo and then he tries to bring his A game. His vote D2 on Koshi falls into the "doing what he wants" which is quite often poking at Koshi for reactions, but I think you can already see his reactions picking up again now that we are in LyLo. There's another reason why Onegu is lock town for me, but I'll get to that later. LS: Weakest of my townreads atm. His overall attitude has been carefree and relaxed. He voted for me rather quickly yesterday, but then what town doesn't put faith in an unCC'd blue claim like that? There are weaker reasons such as Meta to read LS as town here, but it's both his tone and lack of pushing a solid agenda that have me convinced. Never lynch these 3 people imo. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Tube made the claim that he got a candy and from it was able to rolecheck someone, for whatever reason he picked Vivax, and got the result that Vivax is RB. It's been brought up a few times, but this claim is literally the easiest thing to do as scum since he would already know Vivax's role. Still the question then becomes, why bother claiming then rather than simply pushing Vivax? If Tube were scum here and wanted to make a fakeclaim wouldn't he have chosen a differn't target to try and push scum onto and secure the win? Why prolong the game by outing a teammate rather than make a fakeclaim about a towny and try to get the mislynch? So initial conclusion about Tube: Possible scum, but unlikely. Shape has been a solid townread of mine all game. He is also the only person to have claimed blue, however his claim is that I visited Kush N2. Since I got a VT role PM there can only be 2 possibilities about Shape. 1) He is scum fakeclaiming 2) He is town, and the tracker and I either got screwed over by being one of multiple wanderers or possibly somehow was forced to visit the KP target by a candy. Given that he is unCC'd and that I've been pretty convinced Shape is town all game #2 was the initial conclusion I came to. Now that I've done my own checking about setup I see that this is the far less likely option and I was a fool to believe it so easily. So Shape is probably mafia. Damdred was another person I was townreading at the start of this cycle, but I'm now convinced that I've been even more naive about him than shape. I was giving him way too much credit for the D1 shenannie onto Vivax, it seems like something that scum would never bother to do, but then that also makes it a nice and easy thing as scum to look more towny. Besides if you look at Damdred's D2 you will notice he hardly even bothers to mention Vivax even though he is very wishy washy about the lynch on Rels. Damdred has been pretty hit and miss all game, but his play suddenly gets a lot more involved as soon as Shape makes his claim and is pushing me. Damdred is almost certainly mafia here. He is the one I've been making a case on and is my preferred lynch tomorrow. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I'm sure I'm never getting night killed this game, but I still thought I should share my reads before Daypost just in case. I'll be trying to pickup the pieces of my old case on Damdred, but might take the opportunity to reread and double check things a little before posting it (so don't expect it right after Daypost, sometime tonight though for sure). I look forward to a day full of people voting me, and possibly largely ignoring most of what I have to say. After all.. Tis the season! Happy Holidays everyone! | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
I was thinking about the candy and setup stuff a lot yesterday. Given that we only know of 2 candies being claimed I'm starting to wonder how many were held by the townies who got mislynched or NK'd at the start of the game. The extra KP for mafia N2 might not have been the only present they got, and it's also quite possible that town lost a fair few extra actions being carried by GB, Rit, Rels, Koshi, or Kush. This is ofc assuming that the candy is lost on death not RNG'd back into the game. I think we'd know if the latter were the case though. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 07:45 Damdred wrote: TT answer this question You never used any candy this game correct. I never got any candy, nor am I a role, nor was I gifted any night actions. As far as I am aware I am VT. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 07:47 Damdred wrote: Tt is scum I applaud the effort though Your certanty about me will only make me stronger! | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 07:52 Damdred wrote: Then why do you keep trying to put the idea out there someone used a candy on you when it's a lie. Because I don't know if it's possible to do that or not? I have no idea how they work besides what is posted in the OP. What makes you so sure you do know how the candies work? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 07:49 Shapelog wrote: TT and Onegu Because TT didn't even talked about The Dumbtell i been talking about all game. For both days. He usually has been jumping on my stuff and this was before i got drunk. Weird isn't it he doesn't jump on this? This one: Show nested quote + On December 19 2015 08:00 Sukrit wrote: On December 19 2015 07:59 Vivax wrote: On December 19 2015 07:58 Koshi wrote: On December 19 2015 07:58 Vivax wrote: Sukrit is mafia boys You are disgusting YOu will have to believe me You realize I am onegu right??? I said last night that i thought this was a dumbtell and neither Onegu or TT commented on it. And why would you as scum? someone who is everywhere on everyones list and even says "its is prob. Tinfoil", easy to slide under the Radar. I don't have a clue what you mean here. Who is dumbtelling? Why does either me or Onegu commenting about about this mean anything? | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 07:56 Damdred wrote: Because I asked hts and she told me Ah benefits of Scum QT I see. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
So now there is a confirmed blue in Gig, Shape claiming 1 shot tracker, and 2 candies having been opened. We also know Scum had a RB. Humm, gunna check some stuff about setup. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 08:10 LightningStrike wrote: oh it was giy. Well guys I got mafia here: Parity Cop here and here was my checks: Damdred-Koshi: Same Alignment. Koshi- Tictock: Different Alignment. Tictock you can now post baby seals ![]() ##Vote: Tictock ![]() NO! F my Life. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 08:19 Damdred wrote: Hey Tt I got a question for you. I might answer. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Nobody in their right mind tracks me N2 ^.^ Got so lucky. Btw Shape I didn't copy you on the Rit tinfoil, we each got there on our own. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 08:33 LightningStrike wrote: Show nested quote + On December 23 2015 08:16 Tictock wrote: On December 23 2015 08:10 LightningStrike wrote: oh it was giy. Well guys I got mafia here: Parity Cop here and here was my checks: Damdred-Koshi: Same Alignment. Koshi- Tictock: Different Alignment. Tictock you can now post baby seals ![]() ##Vote: Tictock ![]() NO! F my Life. Wrong animal dude ![]() ![]() Not for me, besides... This was all that's left of the seal | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
| ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
Good to know that even as I'm going down I can make plays to help my team ^.^ Still ofc I understand that it was going to be a long couple of cycles over the Holiday which is why I started thinking about conceding before we lynched Vivax. GG everyone. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 14:04 ritoky wrote: yeah we had a similar situation in the last game as mafia that you guys had, and me and palmar both advocated shooting palmar for credit, which led to our team winning. also read the obs qt cuz idk how anyone alive didn't know LS was blue since like...forever ago. Blue hunting is not something I'm very good at obv >.< Still, feel pretty good about how far we got. Only my 2nd game as scum ever too! And while I don't blame Vivax, I do wish he had put a little more effort into at least participating in Scum QT, we coulda made D3 a lot harder for town by playing off each other. As it was I saw no way around bussing him, which is why I tried to setup that possibility so early on. Pretty sure if it hadn't been for the checks I could have pushed Damdred pretty hard based on his play D2 and the way he ignored Vivax and voted for his townread Rels. Actually I still can't believe you guys lynched Rels there, lol I was sure you all would shenannie back to Vivax. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 14:11 ritoky wrote: why me over koshi btw? cuz i was just more right at the time? More fun WIFOM to spout out ^.^ Also yea Koshi was more all over the place and was even a possible mislynch. Not sure out kills N2 were the best tbh, but we were kinda still going for WIFOM onto Damdred. I also think it was silly for me to not try and claim the shot on Kush, I even set myself up to claim with that Kush read EoN, but I felt like there was no way town!Me would have shot Kush over Vivax. I prob coulda claimed that I opened a candy and it fizzeled though or w/e it would have done had it been the candy to make me visit the NK. Meh, I just wasn't into the idea of trying for a bunch of candy claims, but especially for being in 5/3 D3 I should try to make those plays. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 14:12 ritoky wrote: also sickest tt read early game; no town ever makes that read progression lol. Nah, pretty sure I woulda made that same exact post as town, or at least I woulda had the same rethinking of Shape as I did there. I legit had been mixing up Onegu's smurf and Shape on my initial read through and when I filter'd Shape those were my thoughts. Like literally the same thing happened last game with a post I made early on. I get picked on a lot for my early D1. I usually have a very different approach to the game D1 than I do later on, but throwing out whatever thoughts I have on Null reads is something I've done plenty of times as town. | ||
Tictock
United States6051 Posts
On December 23 2015 14:16 ritoky wrote: for tt from obs qt: not unreasonable thing to do, but he has been telegraphing this claim for a while. the way he only talked/buddied w/ damdred day 1 made it obv it was his n1 check. the way he opened day 2 saying "no matter what work with me today damdred"; plus he has been a peripheral player who hasn't tried to really engage the main points of the thread which is what he does as VT. so i doubt this is fake. shape's is probably more likely fake than LS. the real question is if he will consider godfather potential on damdred post-flip....or at least that's the question for me so i can be right :D but if you didn't notice the super early stuff that i did, this is when you shoulda known for sure: Show nested quote + On December 20 2015 09:36 LightningStrike wrote: BTW Damdred can you promise me something? Show nested quote + On December 20 2015 09:53 LightningStrike wrote: On December 20 2015 09:37 Damdred wrote: Maybe? Can you work with me this entire day phase? he is basically hard claiming a parity check in which he knows damdred is town or thinks damdred is the town of the differents right here. he snap needs to die. Yea, I have played like 1 game with LS. There is no way I can read into his posts that much, besides he had a very similar attitude about Damdred D1, just seemed to me like they play together a lot and have a repore. | ||
| ||
![]() StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 Counter-Strike Other Games Organizations Other Games StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War
StarCraft 2 • Hupsaiya StarCraft: Brood War![]() • Light_VIP ![]() • practicex ![]() • AfreecaTV YouTube • intothetv ![]() • Kozan • IndyKCrew ![]() • LaughNgamezSOOP • Migwel ![]() • sooper7s League of Legends Other Games |
The PondCast
WardiTV Spring Champion…
Tenacious Turtle Tussle
BSL
Online Event
Clem vs Nice
SHIN vs Classic
Replay Cast
Clem vs Dark
ByuN vs herO
OSC
Online Event
Creator vs GuMiho
Percival vs Dark
ByuN vs Zoun
Lemon vs Ryung
WardiTV Spring Champion…
SC Evo League
[ Show More ] Replay Cast
SOOP
Online Event
WardiTV Spring Champion…
Online Event
BSL
Sparkling Tuna Cup
WardiTV Spring Champion…
Online Event
BSL
Afreeca Starleague
Soulkey vs Scan
Barracks vs Light
Wardi Open
Monday Night Weeklies
PiGosaur Monday
Afreeca Starleague
Sharp vs Speed
Jaedong vs BeSt
Online Event
Dark vs Bunny
Cure vs Zoun
Replay Cast
|
|