On August 21 2015 11:24 ritoky wrote: i am town aligned, but i can't control who i vote for each phase. the mods literally rng it and send it to me at the start of the phase and it is mandatory that i vote for that individual. while fidei was an okay vote this past phase i am just gonna go ahead and claim this now in the event that i am alive and forced to vote on a town read of mine tomorrow.
This is simultaneously both the most horrible and hilarious thing I have read this game. You played it into the RP rather well. Not sure best way to deal with it, prob just claim your RNG vote right away I guess.
So finally had a chance to catch up on EoD.
I really disliked the way that Wave, Damdred, and Rels were pushing people back onto the ruxx wagon. Wave is the only one of the 3 that I don't have a read on but Damdred and Rels have been looking pretty scummy to me already so now I'm fairly certain those reads were right. Damdred especially since he said he was dropping his RP to play more seriously then does basically nothing but one post saying to get back on ruxx, also twice now has he made internet excuses but he generally plays via phone posts anyways.
I'm gunna let me read on Fidei take a backseat for now. I still think he's likely mafia (felt my points on him were decent as well) but a large part of the game seems to be reading him town so maybe I've just let myself get confirmation bias.
Mixed feelings on Chez, I have no experience with the personality he rolled this game so thats hindering my ability to understand some of his posts. I'm also confused why he told me to "get with the cool kids" but then said I was the #1 cool kid I think, maybe... pretty sure I'm missing the point there kus I'm definitely not the coolest kid on the block. I'm ok with him staying in the game though, agree with HtS that he's a decent cop check or summin.
On August 22 2015 03:34 Rels wrote: Hts I cannot see the mafia motivation behind it but you are not reading what I post Never said ruxxar roleplaying ls was a reason to vote him, but you assumed I did Never said you reconsidered, but you assumed I did
This is a terrible post from Rels, seems to me like he's soft pushing scum on her.
Honestly I dislike the whole interaction between Rels and HtS around the time of this post. Rels claimed to hard townread HtS in his first post and sheeped her vote everywich way. But in this interaction he is just poking at her and never tries to talk about her reads besides him.
On August 22 2015 04:05 Tubesock wrote: Breshke was early on ruXxar and never left even though most his posts were about the nonRNG. He wasn't getting much of answers from Ritoky. My question is why didn't he change the vote for more pressure on Ritoky? He kept going for quite awhile so he obviously wanted an answer. But didn't care enough to change the vote from ruXxar. Or talk more about Fidei who he was also scumming at the time.
He very well could have been waiting to see if others with influence taking up the charge on Ritoky. He was in a position to lynch Fidei if sentiment went more that way and was easily able to shed off Fidei as well.
I actually kinda like this reasoning on Breshek, not sure it's correct but it is a decent reason to scum read Bre I think.
I had wanted to ask HtS about this:
On August 22 2015 04:01 Half the Sky wrote: Tubesock and Rels, if they are not shot definitely need to be the next lynches. That last post of his (the former) was bad.
Tube, talk to us about EoD or something way the hell more contested than that.
This being "That last post"
On August 22 2015 03:37 Tubesock wrote: Hi.
I think Geript is town. The games I read/played in with him that he was mafia he would instigate eimotional responses from the more veteraln players at the same time breadcrumbing reasons for his surviving NK's. He's done none of that here.
I believe Damdreds 3rd party thing, but that's due host wifom.
I don't see anything wrong with that post. The meta read on geript is w/e, the attempt to use meta on geript is fine since he's not RPing I just can't judge the validity of it.
Also I'm thinking the same thing, a Chez role being 3p makes perfect sense.
If anyone has insight into why this post is bad I'd appreciate it.
In fact better explanations are in order for why Tube is mafia, I'm leaning town on him atm. Though mostly for tone.
On August 21 2015 23:47 Lord Tolkien wrote: Anyone opposed to this?
##Shoot Yamato77
Yes. Damdred and Chezinu are significantly better shots. Chezinu gives us information whether it was town-town or town-mafia wagons (3p essentially being town-town). Yamato is a lower probability shot than a number of others.
This. I haven't seen anything convincing to say that Chezinu's last-minute spurt of activity was alignment indicative, and before that his filter was trash-tier. I've also no confidence whatsoever that he will actually look to contribute to the game.
Also, if he is mafia, then we confirm a bunch of town.
From a totally selfish and non-game-winning perspective I'd rather you shoot Kelsier, whose only purpose seems to genuinely hinder town and generally be rude to people. But in terms of shooting lurkers, I think Chez is the better choice.
KSC, can you explain this to me?
I thought I understood it at first, but now I'm not sure.
On August 22 2015 04:05 Tubesock wrote: Breshke was early on ruXxar and never left even though most his posts were about the nonRNG. He wasn't getting much of answers from Ritoky. My question is why didn't he change the vote for more pressure on Ritoky? He kept going for quite awhile so he obviously wanted an answer. But didn't care enough to change the vote from ruXxar. Or talk more about Fidei who he was also scumming at the time.
He very well could have been waiting to see if others with influence taking up the charge on Ritoky. He was in a position to lynch Fidei if sentiment went more that way and was easily able to shed off Fidei as well.
I actually kinda like this reasoning on Breshek, not sure it's correct but it is a decent reason to scum read Bre I think.
I had wanted to ask HtS about this:
On August 22 2015 04:01 Half the Sky wrote: Tubesock and Rels, if they are not shot definitely need to be the next lynches. That last post of his (the former) was bad.
Tube, talk to us about EoD or something way the hell more contested than that.
This being "That last post"
On August 22 2015 03:37 Tubesock wrote: Hi.
I think Geript is town. The games I read/played in with him that he was mafia he would instigate eimotional responses from the more veteraln players at the same time breadcrumbing reasons for his surviving NK's. He's done none of that here.
I believe Damdreds 3rd party thing, but that's due host wifom.
I don't see anything wrong with that post. The meta read on geript is w/e, the attempt to use meta on geript is fine since he's not RPing I just can't judge the validity of it.
Also I'm thinking the same thing, a Chez role being 3p makes perfect sense.
If anyone has insight into why this post is bad I'd appreciate it.
In fact better explanations are in order for why Tube is mafia, I'm leaning town on him atm. Though mostly for tone.
On August 21 2015 23:47 Lord Tolkien wrote: Anyone opposed to this?
##Shoot Yamato77
Yes. Damdred and Chezinu are significantly better shots. Chezinu gives us information whether it was town-town or town-mafia wagons (3p essentially being town-town). Yamato is a lower probability shot than a number of others.
This. I haven't seen anything convincing to say that Chezinu's last-minute spurt of activity was alignment indicative, and before that his filter was trash-tier. I've also no confidence whatsoever that he will actually look to contribute to the game.
Also, if he is mafia, then we confirm a bunch of town.
From a totally selfish and non-game-winning perspective I'd rather you shoot Kelsier, whose only purpose seems to genuinely hinder town and generally be rude to people. But in terms of shooting lurkers, I think Chez is the better choice.
KSC, can you explain this to me?
I thought I understood it at first, but now I'm not sure.
At least your random vote makes your life easy. You vote who you have too, read through their filter to get a solid read on them, make that case, then can focus on the little one since your hands are tied past that.
Any other attention/reads you give us I consider a bonus!
On August 21 2015 23:47 Lord Tolkien wrote: Anyone opposed to this?
##Shoot Yamato77
Yes. Damdred and Chezinu are significantly better shots. Chezinu gives us information whether it was town-town or town-mafia wagons (3p essentially being town-town). Yamato is a lower probability shot than a number of others.
This. I haven't seen anything convincing to say that Chezinu's last-minute spurt of activity was alignment indicative, and before that his filter was trash-tier. I've also no confidence whatsoever that he will actually look to contribute to the game.
Also, if he is mafia, then we confirm a bunch of town.
From a totally selfish and non-game-winning perspective I'd rather you shoot Kelsier, whose only purpose seems to genuinely hinder town and generally be rude to people. But in terms of shooting lurkers, I think Chez is the better choice.
KSC, can you explain this to me?
I thought I understood it at first, but now I'm not sure.
r u srs?
Compared to you?
10,000%
At least, def over 9000
well i wanted to roleplay and have fun this game
but fide decided that wasn't how this game was going to go down... so I did it anyway because fuck that guy amirite
but he still got mad and sponged the fun out of the game
geript is cool though...for a geript doe
Yea, I'm pretty sure your town as well.
Carry on, have some fun, done let the serious ppl get you down.
On August 22 2015 08:06 geript wrote: There's literally zero reason to not lynch ritoky. There's literally zero reason to believe ritoky. There's zero way that can be his role. If it is then the game is irrelevant because that should never ever be a role in any game. Like the basic rules of fucking mafia is that you always get to control your own vote. Like there are roles that can alter votes (stealing votes, doubling votes, vote rigging, pardoning etc). But even those are generally exceptionally bad form in themed games. On top of that we've seen 3 roles flip and they're all normal. There's no reason to expect super not normal roles. Bottom line ritoky is lying and should be lynched.
I mean... you were warned.
On August 06 2015 05:26 Onegu wrote: Disclaimer Part 1: This game is not meant to be played super serious. I will do my best with the balance team to make it balanced. That being said I am trying to theme it well more than balance it well. I would enjoy it if you guys played serious but played to enjoy yourselves more.
Disclaimer Part 2: If you have been a active player in the last 2 years there is a high probability you will be a role in this game. If you dont like it I dont really care I am onegu and you all love me and I am sure will forgive me. If you have a really big problem that you might be a role in this game PM me and I might take you out as a role.
Disclaimer Part 3: This will be a completely closed setup. Nothing will be notified unless absolutely necessary.
Disclaimer Part 4: This is a Onegu hosted game. Expect a hiccup hosting wise, because I am Onegu. Dont bitch about it if/when it happens. I will modkill you so hard ask Koshi. This being said I will do my best to make sure there are no hiccups but no promises.
On August 22 2015 08:15 geript wrote: No. I refuse to accept that BH or anyone else would approve that shit or that Onegu is that much of a fucking retard to include shit like that without those roles having some other form of kp or a huge power level. No on is dumb enough to disallow town the ability to control their own vote.
Seriously. Ask yourself if you have a 'standard' role. Named vt, cop, medic, mason, get, banisher, RBer, PGO, etc. if you do and 3 flips do then odds are all the roles are standard or mostly standard. So bullshit.
People defending said bullshit are liars or mafia.
Your assuming too much I think.
What is there are only 3 mafia?
What is these roles are in fact mafia-aligned?
Like this game has DISCLAIMERS saying it may not be 100% balances and is setup for funsies and theme.
There are tons of ways to try and balance around abnormally functioning roles. Though I do agree that it makes the most sense that there should be a counter-balance to such terrible voting restrictions within the roles themselves.
On August 22 2015 08:06 geript wrote: There's literally zero reason to not lynch ritoky. There's literally zero reason to believe ritoky. There's zero way that can be his role. If it is then the game is irrelevant because that should never ever be a role in any game. Like the basic rules of fucking mafia is that you always get to control your own vote. Like there are roles that can alter votes (stealing votes, doubling votes, vote rigging, pardoning etc). But even those are generally exceptionally bad form in themed games. On top of that we've seen 3 roles flip and they're all normal. There's no reason to expect super not normal roles. Bottom line ritoky is lying and should be lynched.
my role states i cant vote anyone who other people are voting
On August 22 2015 08:06 geript wrote: There's literally zero reason to not lynch ritoky. There's literally zero reason to believe ritoky. There's zero way that can be his role. If it is then the game is irrelevant because that should never ever be a role in any game. Like the basic rules of fucking mafia is that you always get to control your own vote. Like there are roles that can alter votes (stealing votes, doubling votes, vote rigging, pardoning etc). But even those are generally exceptionally bad form in themed games. On top of that we've seen 3 roles flip and they're all normal. There's no reason to expect super not normal roles. Bottom line ritoky is lying and should be lynched.
my role states i cant vote anyone who other people are voting
so i believe his roile
Wow ok I rescind my claim that my role is silly.
You guys have some silly roles.
On August 22 2015 08:05 JudgeJudy wrote:
On August 22 2015 08:01 ritoky wrote:
On August 22 2015 07:58 Fecalfeast wrote: omg really ritoky? Your role is worse than mine then. You're a non-foctor today since you rng'd town
can you respond to some of what i found in your filter. and also give a list of at least scum reads? town reads are okay too.
On August 22 2015 04:24 JudgeJudy wrote:
On August 21 2015 06:56 Fecalfeast wrote: wait chezinu claims mafia and gives up then votes to save himself after saying he wanted to vote himself?
##unvote ##vote chezinu
On August 21 2015 06:59 Fecalfeast wrote: OK chez isn';t mafia but idk the rux wagon is scummy yolo
##unvote ##vote waveofshadow
Fecal, what made you turn away from the chez lynch? He didn't have any posts between these two posts above.
This one too.
I can't have my vote on the person who gets lynched or bad stuff happens to me so I was afraid that if chezinu was town, scum would snipe him last second and I would die
judgejudy probably actually town, chezinu probably scum, I would kill tubesock. Damdred I haven't noticed while rereading this day but he's probably still scum.
KelsierSC is probably scum too
my role is town aligned
if i give up my ability to vote on majority cases i can check alignments
Nevermind, I didn't see this. Shutting up till I've read.
Honestly atm, I'm tempted to believe all the restriction/role related stuff being claimed atm.
The only one that stands out...
Is ritoky's.
All of them are rather silly and makes their votes NAI, however rit's is the only one that is a pure hindrance without anything else attached. The other roles seem to be more situational/conditional and have some leeway.
My own role has a nifty little trick, but it's unlikely that I will get to use it since it's rather conditional.
So right now I'm thinking Rit is either lying to us about something or is mafia.
Ignoring it and dismissing it are two different things, especially when the notion was brought up by geript as being important.
Idk, looking back now you admitted that we will prob have to lynch you sometime later on down the line so I can't seriously entertain the notion of you being mafia.
On August 22 2015 08:06 geript wrote: There's literally zero reason to not lynch ritoky. There's literally zero reason to believe ritoky. There's zero way that can be his role. If it is then the game is irrelevant because that should never ever be a role in any game. Like the basic rules of fucking mafia is that you always get to control your own vote. Like there are roles that can alter votes (stealing votes, doubling votes, vote rigging, pardoning etc). But even those are generally exceptionally bad form in themed games. On top of that we've seen 3 roles flip and they're all normal. There's no reason to expect super not normal roles. Bottom line ritoky is lying and should be lynched.
my role states i cant vote anyone who other people are voting
EPT![[image loading]](http://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0065/2742/products/fun-sponge_large.jpg?v=1374268282)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/ZVFeE.gif)
