Campus Mafia (New/Newish Players Welcome) - Page 23

On November 04 2014 23:21 Elvis! wrote:



I don't think you even read what I'm writing.



You say I call Superbia out.
In the very post you quote me on I say I don't read him as scum since it's not him distracting people.
I always stayed with my opinion of not calling Superbia scum. No flip-flop happened.
Straight up lies.

When exactly do I flip-flop on you? I can see why you didn't qoute me on it because there is nothing.
Trolling can be different and trolling on the second page is a bit different than what you're doing. If you want me to further elaborate on that I can.
Again straight up lies.

I don't even wanna start on how IRL mafia barely relates to a lot of things in forum mafia. Also I just don't see the connection here.

Sooooo you define town solely on people who are "detecting my sketchy play".
Yes, detecting sketchy play and thus hunting scum is what town does.
But there has been sketchy play by quite some people - especially by straight up lying.
So because you tunnel me, any scummy play by people who aren't me is irrelevant to you apparently.
Why don't you define town by them being useful in catching scum. They can and are supposed to question everyone's play including mine, but you can't define town by them tunneling on the same guy as you .

I especially dislike you sheeping Lightning here.
Saying his play is scummy but you rate him null because of what reason? Because his partner would tell him to not post something stupid? Why didn't you tell him then, since for me you two are scum here.
This is one of the weirdest sheeping going on I have seen in a while and with that a major scumslip .

Please other people give intel on who of these two to lynch first. Atm I'm on
##Vote Serejai

As a note on Superbia:
His disputed post just seems so trolly, wanna see if he actually pulls through (which would be retarded as fuck - I'm not used to Superbia doing stuff that stupid), so I'll not go on the wagon yet.
If he actually does that shit, holy moly he's gon get lynched

@sentinel he's trolling on like the second page of the thread.
Stop trying to make reasonable posts in the first pages happen. Its not gonna happen.
Surely trolly behaviour is typically scum, because scum want to distract from something with it. Is he distracting from something?
As long as he doesn't go full retard and fulfill his promise, I don't read him town/scum for that.
His reaction is all that counts.

Talking about this Lightning guy.
So he begins with a vote on superbia.
...
I don't even...
Like how can you vote someone without giving reasoning.

Ok, he later on gives reasoning after being asked multiple times, as he says "I have read chelsea's posts (and I wanna look town so I agree with the guy who people think is townie)"

Then he's like, "wait a second, chelsea pulled his vote back. Time to pull mine back as well so I fit in again and don't look suspicious. Being mafai is so easy".

Then he sees people going on about Immortal.
Now guess what happens next.
He calls someone fishy without reasoning what exactly is meant, why it is fishy, why that appears scummy or anything of importance.
Generally, I am yet to see him post his own opinion that isn't basically copy-pasted from someone (especially chelsea), rephrased or wishy-washy (referring to his recent post on Immortal being "fishy").

I am yet to see his posts exceed 4 lines, and even those 4 lines don't ever have content. He just rephrases stuff and basically reposts others, and I'm yet to see anything productive from him.
He doesn't even remotely try hunting scum
For now, if he doesn't drastically change his playstyle or someone more definitive arrises, I view him as a mafia lurker.

##Vote LightningStrike

On November 04 2014 22:16 Serejai wrote:
Either Sentinel is scum or Elvis+Fecal are scum.

Still leaning Elvis because of how much he contradicts himself.

Starts off calling out Superbia because "Surely trolly behaviour is typically scum".

Then once Sentinel says the same thing, Elvis suddenly flip-flops and says "so posting something trolly on the second page makes someone scummy... Okay I guess." in sarcasm and proceeds to call Sentinel scum.

I come into the game with a troll post as well and, once again, Elvis does a complete flip-flip and suddenly trolling = obvious scum again.

Don't know how you guys play online mafia but this is pretty cut and dry mafia play for IRL games.

I would put Bresh, Grack, and Sentinel as town at the moment because they're the only ones that seem to notice some of the sketchy posting by Elvis. Lightning is null to me; he may post scummy but surely if he were mafia his teammates would step in and help improve his posting - unless they are intentionally trying to throw him under the bus. If Lightning gets lynched and turns town we should probably look at the people who were pushing for him (coincidentally Elvis is at the top of that list).

On November 04 2014 05:46 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
So let's look at his returning post:


I wait for you to make an argument and see who, if anyone, sheeps it or incorporates it into their case on me. Then I can poke holes in it appropriately, and I have a list of people who are trying to sneak by under the floorboards while you attract all the attention. Making reads based on people's reactions to events is much easier when you're involved in said events. It eliminates one of the variables.

On November 04 2014 05:46 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
We're pushing more for a reaction from you, if anything. Just as a way to get you to come out, shrug off any suspicion that doesn't belong, and then proceed as needed. It's the beginning of the day - any votes this early are most likely going to be changed as needed.

On November 05 2014 00:07 Superbia wrote:


So let me get this straight, you accepted precisely because of this reason? And you planned this within 5 minutes?



Why are you answering for FF? Why do you presume to know what his goal is? This only makes sense if you know FF's alignment.

On November 04 2014 23:42 LightningStrike wrote:

First you start off saying this .Then you quickly shifterd to this like 2 of your posts later
Saying his reaction is all that counts is fishy as someone trying to defend their fellow scum
Then when everyone was talking about Sentinel you quickly changed the target to me in this post
You got scum all over you now in my eyes due to those posts.

On November 04 2014 23:21 Elvis! wrote:

Sooooo you define town solely on people who are "detecting my sketchy play".
Yes, detecting sketchy play and thus hunting scum is what town does.
But there has been sketchy play by quite some people - especially by straight up lying.
So because you tunnel me, any scummy play by people who aren't me is irrelevant to you apparently.
Why don't you define town by them being useful in catching scum. They can and are supposed to question everyone's play including mine, but you can't define town by them tunneling on the same guy as you .

On November 05 2014 00:28 Superbia wrote:
Does grack usually traffic cop as town d1? Anyone know?