|
On October 24 2014 06:39 DrParnassus wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:19 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:17 DrParnassus wrote:And no, I can't give any reasons why any of the people in that list are scummy because it's a PoE list. A few things have caught my eye so far but now isn't a useful time to talk about them. On October 24 2014 06:15 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:13 DrParnassus wrote:
5. Fecalfeast
6. batsnacks
7. Elvis!
8. GlowingBear
10. Holyflare
13. raynpelikoneet
That's where I think the mafia are. Deep down in my heart of hearts I want to remove HF from that list but the quality of his scumplay makes it hard to write him off so soon. Great. Does this mean you are caught up? -> Reasoning would be dope. Yeah, just caught up. And no to the request for reasoning, see the beginning of this post. "It isn't a useful time to talk about them" - really? When is a useful time to do that then? Not right now Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:19 justanothertownie wrote:
If it is a PoE list there still have to be reasons why other people are NOT on this list. Go. 1. Alakaslam His posts are all pretty harmless and some are real attempts to start some kinda of discussion. I know scum slam likes to hide behind an impenetrable wall of wifom and he's not doing that here. He's trying to help. 2. Damdred Show nested quote +On October 23 2014 22:51 Damdred wrote:On October 23 2014 22:22 StorrZerg wrote:On October 23 2014 22:20 Damdred wrote:
Generally I don't like cluttering up the thread with my townreads as I like scum hunting rather then townhunting. If people want my read on a specific person besides slam im happy to give it though.
Storr in the first fantasy game you said tunneling is not part of your town meta you just scum hunt basically. But you say its a joke now since its what happened last game with lian however your tone feels a bit off. And you do feel a bit forced and insincere yeah lets not have discussion day 1. so who be that town read Why does it have to be giving town reads=discussion on day 1? I think the correlation isn't their necessarily whats important is asking questions and actually talking not throwing out "oh hey this person is town". That doesn't work for the way I like to play I have my note pad with my town notes in it on people otherwise I talk to people in the thread and question and scum read people. Its pretty obvious who my town read is....not sure why you even have to ask. I think the bottom response is townie. Storr is questioning him by asking damdred to clarify his town read. Damdred refuses to answer, saying that Storr should be able to figure that out for themselves. I'd expect mafia to be more cooperative than that while under interrogation as they don't want to cause any drama. But Damdred welcomes the drama. 3. liancourt HF's post about lian was good. I read his posts about preferring direct conversation as genuine. I think there's been some stuff said about his meta though so I'll have to check on that later 4. StorrZerg I'm with kush in that I initially thought there was something off about him but over time I became unable to focus on his posts and somehow that colored him green in my head. But since then he's posted a lot most of it looks like a real attempt to find mafia. 9. kushm4sta I think I'm exempt from having to explain this read so I'm not gonna waste time going into it unless ends up as a lynch or something 11. IAmRobik Everything about the way he's playing reminds me of the town robik that is sometimes so difficult to cooperate with. (Possibly intentionally) shitty opening and confidence in his reads are all town robik things. I don't know if things have changed but I'm pretty sure he hates playing scum and is scared to post as mafia, as he pointed out earlier.
That Storr read is awful. So awful.
Not being able to focus on someones posts is by no means a towntell for that person. And sure he posted a lot since he yelled at me when I accused him. And he made absolutely no sense while doing that.
|
On October 24 2014 06:42 Holyflare wrote:
my post about lian was good lol? that was supposed to be satirical
All the fluff was clearly a joke but the core of your post was that being casual is generally townie, which lian has been all game.
|
I think robik looks pretty solid. I like how he's posting; he's focused, not all caps, consolidated, no personal dramas, that stuff is what reminds me of hard to get along with robik. @DrParnassus what about robik this game seem hard to cooperate with? Could you quote an example? You did say -everything about the way he's playing- reminds you of that.
|
On October 24 2014 06:24 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:22 IAmRobik wrote:
JAT, I just went through lian's filter and you're wrong
He gave wishy washy reads on storr, calling him both scum and town in convoluted ways
He gave a really weak read on HF being town for "analyzing" the mafai post? DAFUQ
Calls Kush town as a joke and then responds to rayn saying that he doesn't see kush as town
Calls slam and bats townie for looking jolly.
I mean, if you consider these reads, yeah, he's totally given reads on 1/2 the players.
Calls kush 'town for now'
Calls fecal town for "not giving a rats ass"
Calls damdred town for being a "man with a plan"
Calls me town for being a "hardcore player" even though he doesn't agree with my reads
Makes it seem like Rayn and GB are his top scum saying "well rayn and gb aren't here"
Like, his posts are terrible. I never said he gave good or well reasoned reads. But he most definitely gave reads as you see. I still have a hard time seeing a new scum player post like he did earlier. You seemed to be of the same opinion. Does this not matter anymore?
Why are you assuming he is a new player
|
On October 24 2014 06:44 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:39 DrParnassus wrote:On October 24 2014 06:19 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:17 DrParnassus wrote:And no, I can't give any reasons why any of the people in that list are scummy because it's a PoE list. A few things have caught my eye so far but now isn't a useful time to talk about them. On October 24 2014 06:15 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:13 DrParnassus wrote:
5. Fecalfeast
6. batsnacks
7. Elvis!
8. GlowingBear
10. Holyflare
13. raynpelikoneet
That's where I think the mafia are. Deep down in my heart of hearts I want to remove HF from that list but the quality of his scumplay makes it hard to write him off so soon. Great. Does this mean you are caught up? -> Reasoning would be dope. Yeah, just caught up. And no to the request for reasoning, see the beginning of this post. "It isn't a useful time to talk about them" - really? When is a useful time to do that then? Not right now On October 24 2014 06:19 justanothertownie wrote:
If it is a PoE list there still have to be reasons why other people are NOT on this list. Go. 1. Alakaslam His posts are all pretty harmless and some are real attempts to start some kinda of discussion. I know scum slam likes to hide behind an impenetrable wall of wifom and he's not doing that here. He's trying to help. 2. Damdred On October 23 2014 22:51 Damdred wrote:On October 23 2014 22:22 StorrZerg wrote:On October 23 2014 22:20 Damdred wrote:
Generally I don't like cluttering up the thread with my townreads as I like scum hunting rather then townhunting. If people want my read on a specific person besides slam im happy to give it though.
Storr in the first fantasy game you said tunneling is not part of your town meta you just scum hunt basically. But you say its a joke now since its what happened last game with lian however your tone feels a bit off. And you do feel a bit forced and insincere yeah lets not have discussion day 1. so who be that town read Why does it have to be giving town reads=discussion on day 1? I think the correlation isn't their necessarily whats important is asking questions and actually talking not throwing out "oh hey this person is town". That doesn't work for the way I like to play I have my note pad with my town notes in it on people otherwise I talk to people in the thread and question and scum read people. Its pretty obvious who my town read is....not sure why you even have to ask. I think the bottom response is townie. Storr is questioning him by asking damdred to clarify his town read. Damdred refuses to answer, saying that Storr should be able to figure that out for themselves. I'd expect mafia to be more cooperative than that while under interrogation as they don't want to cause any drama. But Damdred welcomes the drama. 3. liancourt HF's post about lian was good. I read his posts about preferring direct conversation as genuine. I think there's been some stuff said about his meta though so I'll have to check on that later 4. StorrZerg I'm with kush in that I initially thought there was something off about him but over time I became unable to focus on his posts and somehow that colored him green in my head. But since then he's posted a lot most of it looks like a real attempt to find mafia. 9. kushm4sta I think I'm exempt from having to explain this read so I'm not gonna waste time going into it unless ends up as a lynch or something 11. IAmRobik Everything about the way he's playing reminds me of the town robik that is sometimes so difficult to cooperate with. (Possibly intentionally) shitty opening and confidence in his reads are all town robik things. I don't know if things have changed but I'm pretty sure he hates playing scum and is scared to post as mafia, as he pointed out earlier. That Storr read is awful. So awful. Not being able to focus on someones posts is by no means a towntell for that person. And sure he posted a lot since he yelled at me when I accused him. And he made absolutely no sense while doing that.
Of course it's awful but that was the progression of my read on him so I'm just being honest. And yes, most of his posts aren't very good or helpful. But despite tha,t it still looks like he's trying to help in the ways he knows how
|
On October 24 2014 06:50 StorrZerg wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:24 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:22 IAmRobik wrote:
JAT, I just went through lian's filter and you're wrong
He gave wishy washy reads on storr, calling him both scum and town in convoluted ways
He gave a really weak read on HF being town for "analyzing" the mafai post? DAFUQ
Calls Kush town as a joke and then responds to rayn saying that he doesn't see kush as town
Calls slam and bats townie for looking jolly.
I mean, if you consider these reads, yeah, he's totally given reads on 1/2 the players.
Calls kush 'town for now'
Calls fecal town for "not giving a rats ass"
Calls damdred town for being a "man with a plan"
Calls me town for being a "hardcore player" even though he doesn't agree with my reads
Makes it seem like Rayn and GB are his top scum saying "well rayn and gb aren't here"
Like, his posts are terrible. I never said he gave good or well reasoned reads. But he most definitely gave reads as you see. I still have a hard time seeing a new scum player post like he did earlier. You seemed to be of the same opinion. Does this not matter anymore? Why are you assuming he is a new player
Read the thread and then come back.
|
On October 24 2014 06:50 batsnacks wrote:
I think robik looks pretty solid. I like how he's posting; he's focused, not all caps, consolidated, no personal dramas, that stuff is what reminds me of hard to get along with robik. @DrParnassus what about robik this game seem hard to cooperate with? Could you quote an example? You did say -everything about the way he's playing- reminds you of that.
it's his attitude in general, his arrogance
|
|
|
On October 24 2014 06:39 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:38 IAmRobik wrote:On October 24 2014 06:33 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:28 IAmRobik wrote:On October 24 2014 06:24 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:22 IAmRobik wrote:
JAT, I just went through lian's filter and you're wrong
He gave wishy washy reads on storr, calling him both scum and town in convoluted ways
He gave a really weak read on HF being town for "analyzing" the mafai post? DAFUQ
Calls Kush town as a joke and then responds to rayn saying that he doesn't see kush as town
Calls slam and bats townie for looking jolly.
I mean, if you consider these reads, yeah, he's totally given reads on 1/2 the players.
Calls kush 'town for now'
Calls fecal town for "not giving a rats ass"
Calls damdred town for being a "man with a plan"
Calls me town for being a "hardcore player" even though he doesn't agree with my reads
Makes it seem like Rayn and GB are his top scum saying "well rayn and gb aren't here"
Like, his posts are terrible. I never said he gave good or well reasoned reads. But he most definitely gave reads as you see. I still have a hard time seeing a new scum player post like he did earlier. You seemed to be of the same opinion. Does this not matter anymore? Yeah, I mean. Whatever. I put his filter to "read all" and read about 2/3 of the way through and he had no reads, which is when I went and wrote the top sentence and then he actually started giving the bad reads starting from the slam & bats = town He has a certain few posts that I think are towny. These posts are, ironically, not game related. I have no good reason to call him town based off of his play though. And he claims to have played before, so calling him new scum is an incorrect assumption. Lastly, just based off of a meta read of the disparity between game 1 and game 2, it leads me to believe that he's more likely to have rolled scum than town. But alas, Pros and cons both ways. Not on my lynch list for today most like.y Can you quote me where he claimed that? That's news to me - I only know of his towngame here. And yes I also don't townread him for game related posts because most of them are pretty questionable. Apart from some posts on storr. From the other Fantasy Football Mafia game. On October 07 2014 04:59 liancourt wrote:On October 07 2014 04:54 Grackaroni wrote:On October 07 2014 04:52 liancourt wrote:On October 07 2014 04:36 Grackaroni wrote:
Lian are you a smurf?
BH wants to follow RNG but he will do what he can to convince other people to vote for OO. He doesn't care if people lynch OO for other reasons aside from RNG as long as it's OO that is lynched.
BH you said you don't have an opinion on Oats post's. Do you have an opinion on HF's posts attacking Oat's posts? Would there be any difference if I were a smurf or not? I think I told the mod what I am. Not particularly but I like trying to guess smurfs Your first post is a post I don't see a new player making. I am from somewhere else. So in a way I am new but not new. Take what you will. So guess the smurf game is over. How should a new player post? Hi i am new here lets be friends? Hmmm...
do you have any follow up to this besides hmm? has your opinion on lian changed?
|
On October 24 2014 06:52 DrParnassus wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:50 batsnacks wrote:
I think robik looks pretty solid. I like how he's posting; he's focused, not all caps, consolidated, no personal dramas, that stuff is what reminds me of hard to get along with robik. @DrParnassus what about robik this game seem hard to cooperate with? Could you quote an example? You did say -everything about the way he's playing- reminds you of that. it's his attitude in general, his arrogance
Is it arrogance or non-cooperativeness? Or is his arrogance making him hard to cooperate with?
I asked robik a question he apparently has already answered and he answered it again for me and didn't even call me dumb.
Are you sure you're not just biased because he said you were mafia?
|
On October 24 2014 06:55 StorrZerg wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:39 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:38 IAmRobik wrote:On October 24 2014 06:33 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:28 IAmRobik wrote:On October 24 2014 06:24 justanothertownie wrote:On October 24 2014 06:22 IAmRobik wrote:
JAT, I just went through lian's filter and you're wrong
He gave wishy washy reads on storr, calling him both scum and town in convoluted ways
He gave a really weak read on HF being town for "analyzing" the mafai post? DAFUQ
Calls Kush town as a joke and then responds to rayn saying that he doesn't see kush as town
Calls slam and bats townie for looking jolly.
I mean, if you consider these reads, yeah, he's totally given reads on 1/2 the players.
Calls kush 'town for now'
Calls fecal town for "not giving a rats ass"
Calls damdred town for being a "man with a plan"
Calls me town for being a "hardcore player" even though he doesn't agree with my reads
Makes it seem like Rayn and GB are his top scum saying "well rayn and gb aren't here"
Like, his posts are terrible. I never said he gave good or well reasoned reads. But he most definitely gave reads as you see. I still have a hard time seeing a new scum player post like he did earlier. You seemed to be of the same opinion. Does this not matter anymore? Yeah, I mean. Whatever. I put his filter to "read all" and read about 2/3 of the way through and he had no reads, which is when I went and wrote the top sentence and then he actually started giving the bad reads starting from the slam & bats = town He has a certain few posts that I think are towny. These posts are, ironically, not game related. I have no good reason to call him town based off of his play though. And he claims to have played before, so calling him new scum is an incorrect assumption. Lastly, just based off of a meta read of the disparity between game 1 and game 2, it leads me to believe that he's more likely to have rolled scum than town. But alas, Pros and cons both ways. Not on my lynch list for today most like.y Can you quote me where he claimed that? That's news to me - I only know of his towngame here. And yes I also don't townread him for game related posts because most of them are pretty questionable. Apart from some posts on storr. From the other Fantasy Football Mafia game. On October 07 2014 04:59 liancourt wrote:On October 07 2014 04:54 Grackaroni wrote:On October 07 2014 04:52 liancourt wrote:On October 07 2014 04:36 Grackaroni wrote:
Lian are you a smurf?
BH wants to follow RNG but he will do what he can to convince other people to vote for OO. He doesn't care if people lynch OO for other reasons aside from RNG as long as it's OO that is lynched.
BH you said you don't have an opinion on Oats post's. Do you have an opinion on HF's posts attacking Oat's posts? Would there be any difference if I were a smurf or not? I think I told the mod what I am. Not particularly but I like trying to guess smurfs Your first post is a post I don't see a new player making. I am from somewhere else. So in a way I am new but not new. Take what you will. So guess the smurf game is over. How should a new player post? Hi i am new here lets be friends? Hmmm... do you have any follow up to this besides hmm?
No.
|
On October 24 2014 06:50 batsnacks wrote:
I think robik looks pretty solid. I like how he's posting; he's focused, not all caps, consolidated, no personal dramas, that stuff is what reminds me of hard to get along with robik. @DrParnassus what about robik this game seem hard to cooperate with? Could you quote an example? You did say -everything about the way he's playing- reminds you of that.
i think when he gets personal its more town. and he has been caps locked all ready.
but i get your point that it can be hard to play with. just like playing with you!!!!!!!!!!!
how do you feel about jat
|
guys guys try to figure out my big ass post was it scum motivated? pro town? non productive? total fluff? oh and disregard point 8 it's not I'm trying to read you guys by making you analyze that post or anything...b-baka
|
On October 24 2014 06:58 liancourt wrote:
guys guys try to figure out my big ass post was it scum motivated? pro town? non productive? total fluff? oh and disregard point 8 it's not I'm trying to read you guys by making you analyze that post or anything...b-baka
good point ill bite
#vote liancourt
|
On October 24 2014 06:41 liancourt wrote:
6. I dont play with the normal mindset. My motivation while winning is a goal it isnt a primary goal to having fun while playing because you play to have fun. While i like to argue and debate i dont wanna call ppl names and swear at them. And getting called stupid while argueing with someone isnt my thing. I think i got called stupid a lot last game for being non productive but thats how i play. I ll take on any argument regardless of motivation whether it be pro town anti town because i enjoy the debating side of it.
I like this part of that post. I think everyone should read it twice.
GJ Liam
|
storr did you give lessons to robik? he's on the platform to tunneling my ass to kingdom cum.
|
no i take lessons from him (see again another way to buy into robik's pocket  )
|
On October 24 2014 06:56 batsnacks wrote:
Are you sure you're not just biased because he said you were mafia?
Might be, I did consider that. However I've used this read on robik before and I think it's always turned out correct.
Arrogance was probably not the right word, confidence is more what I was going for.
|
why are you funny this game? you are so mafai!
|
On October 24 2014 06:57 StorrZerg wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 06:50 batsnacks wrote:
I think robik looks pretty solid. I like how he's posting; he's focused, not all caps, consolidated, no personal dramas, that stuff is what reminds me of hard to get along with robik. @DrParnassus what about robik this game seem hard to cooperate with? Could you quote an example? You did say -everything about the way he's playing- reminds you of that. i think when he gets personal its more town. and he has been caps locked all ready. but i get your point that it can be hard to play with. just like playing with you!!!!!!!!!!! how do you feel about jat
jat seems like jat. I thought yours and his little tiff was boring.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
